Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Re dying without insurance, just found out today that one of the drugs I may need to take costs $10,000/month. Were I on Medicare (I'm not there yet) my share would be 33%, so $3,300/month for years or more.

A low income elderly person needing this drug would essentially be unable to buy it. Inadequate insurance coverage can indeed be a death sentence.
I hope you have good insurance to cover that.

These programs seem to be for people under the FPL, around $1200 a month. You wouldn't have to be poor at all to find a bill like the $3300 a month SG is talking about impossible much less the 10k a month.
 
The BBC says that nine republican (at least, that's presumably what they mean) senators have said they will not support the Senate bill, but that Trump is optmisitic that they'll "get over the line". They also report a survey by USA Today saying that only 12% of Americans support the bill. (Most don't know, rather than opposing it.) I wonder what the chances of the Senate passing some version of it are!

MSNBC (or maybe it was CNN) put on a montage this evening of a gazillion Trump claims that X will happen soon/in a couple weeks/etc. none of which ever happened.
 
Re dying without insurance, just found out today that one of the drugs I may need to take costs $10,000/month. Were I on Medicare (I'm not there yet) my share would be 33%, so $3,300/month for years or more.

A low income elderly person needing this drug would essentially be unable to buy it. Inadequate insurance coverage can indeed be a death sentence.

You might be illustrating another problem with our health-care system: Gouging by pharmaceutical companies. There's no reason why drug prices shouldn't be subject to some controls or limits. For reference, how much would that same drug cost the patient in Canada or Japan?

Also, don't most people on Medicare buy supplement or Advantage plans that include drug coverage? If you were on Medicare with the additional coverage, what would your costs be?
 
You might be illustrating another problem with our health-care system: Gouging by pharmaceutical companies. There's no reason why drug prices shouldn't be subject to some controls or limits. For reference, how much would that same drug cost the patient in Canada or Japan?

Also, don't most people on Medicare buy supplement or Advantage plans that include drug coverage? If you were on Medicare with the additional coverage, what would your costs be?

There is no doubt that Big Pharma price gouging is out of control. But the GOP controlled Congress is overly influenced by the Big Pharma lobby.

The Democrats are not innocent in this, but they are more likely to help end this crap than the GOP is at the moment. We need to stand up to this.

As for buying supplemental insurance, I'm not in that system yet so I don't know the details. It was my doctor that told me what I would be paying for said drugs as we discussed my options.
 
Last edited:
Frogs worrying about pact with scorpion.

One Republican congressional aide said that comment left some lawmakers worried that the president — who had no real ties to the GOP before running for the White House — could turn on them if a bill passes but the follow-up becomes politically damaging. The official insisted on anonymity in order to describe private discussions.
 
With indications that the AHCA may not be passable, Mitch McConnell is contemplating a change in strategy. Fix, not repeal, ACA.
With his bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act in deep trouble, Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader, raised an alternate possibility on Tuesday: Either Republicans come together, or he would have to work with Democrats to shore up the deteriorating health law. Link

Meantime in McConnell's home state, repeal of ACA could have a devastating impact. Yet many residents remain convinced, "Obamacare must go!"
Perhaps nowhere has the health care law had as powerful an impact as in Kentucky, where nearly one in three people now receive coverage through Medicaid, expanded under the legislation. Perhaps no region in Kentucky has benefited as much as Appalachia, the impoverished eastern part of the state, where in some counties more than 60 percent of people are covered by Medicaid.

And in few places are the political complexities of health care more glaring than in this poor state with crushing medical needs, substantially alleviated by the Affordable Care Act, but where Republican opposition to the law remains almost an article of faith. Link

Reporters talked with Kentucky residents who have gained preventive healthcare, including access to a primary care physician, for the first time under ACA, yet they remain opposed to ACA, convinced it must be repealed. Yet they don't always seem aware of what it would mean to them personally. One woman suffering with lupus, who only gained healthcare coverage through ACA, was surprised to learn that under AHCA she would probably lose that coverage. She was also surprised to learn McConnell, whom she voted for, is leading the charge to roll back coverage. It's very hard to understand how someone for whom medical coverage is so important could be so totally uninformed.

It's a tough problem politically because many voters use emotion, not reason, to make their political choices. As an example, I saw a post on Facebook written by a woman who is disabled. She needs a lot of treatment and is benefiting from Medicaid expansion under ACA. Yet she is opposed to ACA -- and voted for Donald Trump -- because she calls herself pro-life and says ACA pays for abortions. She wrote she would gladly give up her Medicaid coverage in exchange for ending abortion.

Reminds me of the unemployed coal miner who said he voted for Trump, knowing he might lose his healthcare coverage, because "I'll be getting my coal mining job back."

They may only get half of what they wish for but they don't seem to really understand that.
 
Premiums rose in first Bush term, long before Obamacare
screen-shot-2016-09-30-at-14201-pm.png
 
NPR just interviewed a senator who was talking about one of the proposed revisions lowering the proposed "uninsured" number from 21 million to 20 million.

He referred to this as a "step in the right direction".

A very small step, I imagine.

I suppose it's unfair to characterized the Republicans as heartless bastards who secretly wish the poor would simply crawl off and die... But it's getting harder not to.
 
NPR just interviewed a senator who was talking about one of the proposed revisions lowering the proposed "uninsured" number from 21 million to 20 million.

He referred to this as a "step in the right direction".

A very small step, I imagine.

I suppose it's unfair to characterized the Republicans as heartless bastards who secretly wish the poor would simply crawl off and die... But it's getting harder not to.

It seems that each revision seems to reduce the number who would lose insurance by 1 million. It was 24, then 23, 22, 21 and so on. It's difficult to trust this kind of thing. Presumably there is a number of additional uninsured (and hence a number of additional deaths) that is acceptable to the GOP :rolleyes:
 
NPR just interviewed a senator who was talking about one of the proposed revisions lowering the proposed "uninsured" number from 21 million to 20 million.

He referred to this as a "step in the right direction".

A very small step, I imagine.

I suppose it's unfair to characterized the Republicans as heartless bastards who secretly wish the poor would simply crawl off and die... But it's getting harder not to.

Well Ryan has talked about his college days of dreaming about gutting medicaid. He can finally do something about it and get so many nursing homes to discharge their patients to the street.
 
NPR just interviewed a senator who was talking about one of the proposed revisions lowering the proposed "uninsured" number from 21 million to 20 million.

He referred to this as a "step in the right direction".

A very small step, I imagine.

I suppose it's unfair to characterized the Republicans as heartless bastards who secretly wish the poor would simply crawl off and die... But it's getting harder not to.

They can leave it as is and the uninsured numbered will go down, as the uninsured start to die off.
 
It seems that each revision seems to reduce the number who would lose insurance by 1 million. It was 24, then 23, 22, 21 and so on. It's difficult to trust this kind of thing. Presumably there is a number of additional uninsured (and hence a number of additional deaths) that is acceptable to the GOP :rolleyes:

And based on current uninsured levels, I guess we can say that Democrats were ok with a certain number of deaths?
 
And based on current uninsured levels, I guess we can say that Democrats were ok with a certain number of deaths?

Only if you can show that it was the Democrats who were most influential in constraining coverage and Medicare expansion and not the GOP. ;)
 
Note the ACA framing change today from Mnuchin:

The ACA was a tax on the economy, led to slow growth. So now the rich people are the economy. :rolleyes:
 
And based on current uninsured levels, I guess we can say that Democrats were ok with a certain number of deaths?

The Republicans (generally) want to make changes to the law that will result in more deaths, and they have the power to do this.

The Democrats (generally) want to make changes to the law that would result in fewer deaths, and they do not have to power to do this.

So no, you cannot say that based on the level of uninsured now. It would be the Fallacy Fallacy to say that your conclusion was false though. Everyone is 'ok' with a certain number of deaths because it's impossible to anything about a 'certain number' of deaths; it's also impossible to make a perfect system so anyone looking at it rationally is also 'ok' with a certain number of hypothetically preventable deaths. In other words, your conclusion is trivially true, as it it is true yet meaningless.

The cost/benefit for these additional deaths show the GOP and it's hanger-ons to be craven though. Additional tax cuts to the groups already doing very well that have no way to bring benefits to the public at large for thousands of additional deaths? Yes, not really another rational way to put it.
 
I hope you have good insurance to cover that.


These programs seem to be for people under the FPL, around $1200 a month. You wouldn't have to be poor at all to find a bill like the $3300 a month SG is talking about impossible much less the 10k a month.

SG's scenario leaves a lot of questions open.

Most Medicare drug coverage uses copays instead of coinsurance. PDPs are highly subsidized privatecoverage, and while it's true that there are some with coinsurance, most prefer copays because they're more palatable and attractive to people on fixed incomes. The 33% figure she has quoted seems unlikely.

Additionally, Medicare Part D has an out of pocket maximum, currently at $4950. Technically, the patient would still pay 5% above that, so it's not a true max, but very few people exceed that level.

So unless SG is giving us a scenario where the patient is paying full fare and doesn't have Part D coverage, it's exceedingly unlikely and a misleading anecdote.

Don't get me wrong - the drug costs in the US are ridiculous. But they're ridiculous enough that no exaggeration is needed in order to make that point.
 
NPR just interviewed a senator who was talking about one of the proposed revisions lowering the proposed "uninsured" number from 21 million to 20 million.

He referred to this as a "step in the right direction".

A very small step, I imagine.

I suppose it's unfair to characterized the Republicans as heartless bastards who secretly wish the poor would simply crawl off and die... But it's getting harder not to.

As someone who has voted Republican on occasion, I sadly have to agree.
 
SG's scenario leaves a lot of questions open.

Most Medicare drug coverage uses copays instead of coinsurance. PDPs are highly subsidized privatecoverage, and while it's true that there are some with coinsurance, most prefer copays because they're more palatable and attractive to people on fixed incomes. The 33% figure she has quoted seems unlikely.

Additionally, Medicare Part D has an out of pocket maximum, currently at $4950. Technically, the patient would still pay 5% above that, so it's not a true max, but very few people exceed that level.

So unless SG is giving us a scenario where the patient is paying full fare and doesn't have Part D coverage, it's exceedingly unlikely and a misleading anecdote.

Don't get me wrong - the drug costs in the US are ridiculous. But they're ridiculous enough that no exaggeration is needed in order to make that point.


If only it were so simple.

Mrs. qg is on Medicare and has a supplemental Part D policy.

She only needs two drugs to manage her COPD, a Spiriva Handihaler, and a Ventolin inhaler. (Well ... three, counting the oxygen she is hooked up to 24/7) She pretty much has to have these two drugs, or all the supplemental O2 in the world won't keep her out of the emergency room.

Our Part D plan is one of the best bang-for-the-buck plans for those two drugs I can find, using all the different insurance calculators out there.

Just looking at the Spiriva alone, over a year. Jan. is full price, just about, because of the deductible. That's right at $500. Just for one month. After that we get a stretch of months which aren't unmanageably painful, right at $100 per. For a while.

Then, around the Fall of the year, their "donut hole" kicks in. Prices jump back up to around $300 per month or more. We don't get out of the "hole" before the end of the year, when it all starts over again.

That's just for one drug, not coincidentally, I suspect, one of the most commonly prescribed drugs for her condition. COPD patients are enough of a profit target for the pharmaceutical industry that several major news organizations have done specials on the price abuse.

For some of you this may not sound all that bad, But like I said, that's just one drug. And just one of hers.

We are both on fixed incomes. I'm on disability. I can't work at all. She's on SS. She can only get out of bed with great effort. We have a little back-up in the bank, but thanks to things like this it is evaporating rapidly.

We pay 20% of every doctor's appointment, every piece of medical equipment, every everything.

Our income from SS is sufficiently high (just barely)to keep us from being eligible for any other supplemental medical assistance. We just have to get by.

I skip my doctors' appointments whenever I think I can safely do so. Just to slow down the evaporation of our meager savings. I have more doctors than she does. More meds, too.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom