Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

If only it were so simple.

Mrs. qg is on Medicare and has a supplemental Part D policy.

She only needs two drugs to manage her COPD, a Spiriva Handihaler, and a Ventolin inhaler. (Well ... three, counting the oxygen she is hooked up to 24/7) She pretty much has to have these two drugs, or all the supplemental O2 in the world won't keep her out of the emergency room.

Our Part D plan is one of the best bang-for-the-buck plans for those two drugs I can find, using all the different insurance calculators out there.

Just looking at the Spiriva alone, over a year. Jan. is full price, just about, because of the deductible. That's right at $500. Just for one month. After that we get a stretch of months which aren't unmanageably painful, right at $100 per. For a while.

Then, around the Fall of the year, their "donut hole" kicks in. Prices jump back up to around $300 per month or more. We don't get out of the "hole" before the end of the year, when it all starts over again.

That's just for one drug, not coincidentally, I suspect, one of the most commonly prescribed drugs for her condition. COPD patients are enough of a profit target for the pharmaceutical industry that several major news organizations have done specials on the price abuse.

For some of you this may not sound all that bad, But like I said, that's just one drug. And just one of hers.

We are both on fixed incomes. I'm on disability. I can't work at all. She's on SS. She can only get out of bed with great effort. We have a little back-up in the bank, but thanks to things like this it is evaporating rapidly.

We pay 20% of every doctor's appointment, every piece of medical equipment, every everything.

Our income from SS is sufficiently high (just barely)to keep us from being eligible for any other supplemental medical assistance. We just have to get by.

I skip my doctors' appointments whenever I think I can safely do so. Just to slow down the evaporation of our meager savings. I have more doctors than she does. More meds, too.

I agree that it's not simple. And while not nearly as extreme, I understand your drug-cost-pain. The donut hole is shrinking (unless congress decides to make a hash of that too), and should be closed by 2020. I know that's little comfort now, but at least it's an acknowledged problem with Part D.
 
If only it were so simple.

Mrs. qg is on Medicare and has a supplemental Part D policy.

She only needs two drugs to manage her COPD, a Spiriva Handihaler, and a Ventolin inhaler. (Well ... three, counting the oxygen she is hooked up to 24/7) She pretty much has to have these two drugs, or all the supplemental O2 in the world won't keep her out of the emergency room.

Our Part D plan is one of the best bang-for-the-buck plans for those two drugs I can find, using all the different insurance calculators out there.

Just looking at the Spiriva alone, over a year. Jan. is full price, just about, because of the deductible. That's right at $500. Just for one month. After that we get a stretch of months which aren't unmanageably painful, right at $100 per. For a while.

Then, around the Fall of the year, their "donut hole" kicks in. Prices jump back up to around $300 per month or more. We don't get out of the "hole" before the end of the year, when it all starts over again.

That's just for one drug, not coincidentally, I suspect, one of the most commonly prescribed drugs for her condition. COPD patients are enough of a profit target for the pharmaceutical industry that several major news organizations have done specials on the price abuse.

For some of you this may not sound all that bad, But like I said, that's just one drug. And just one of hers.

We are both on fixed incomes. I'm on disability. I can't work at all. She's on SS. She can only get out of bed with great effort. We have a little back-up in the bank, but thanks to things like this it is evaporating rapidly.

We pay 20% of every doctor's appointment, every piece of medical equipment, every everything.

Our income from SS is sufficiently high (just barely)to keep us from being eligible for any other supplemental medical assistance. We just have to get by.

I skip my doctors' appointments whenever I think I can safely do so. Just to slow down the evaporation of our meager savings. I have more doctors than she does. More meds, too.
I have a 83 year old step mom who thinks she should do without her insulin when she reaches the donut hole because she can't afford it. It's been hard convincing her to accept financial help, insulin is just not optional.
 
I have a 83 year old step mom who thinks she should do without her insulin when she reaches the donut hole because she can't afford it. It's been hard convincing her to accept financial help, insulin is just not optional.

But that's the Republican plan. Living is optional. If you can't afford it, just get a job.
 
Trump's latest Tweet:
"If Republican Senators are unable to pass what they are working on now, they should immediately REPEAL, and then REPLACE at a later date!"

If there's a big enough gap, the people who die during that period will reduce the costs later.
 
I really wish that politicians would stop trying to design health systems. They don't know anything about how it works. It's almost guaranteed to be a disaster.

You want something better? Commission the NAIC and the AAA to come up with a solution. Then stick with it.
 
I really wish that politicians would stop trying to design health systems. They don't know anything about how it works. It's almost guaranteed to be a disaster.

You want something better? Commission the NAIC and the AAA to come up with a solution. Then stick with it.

Let the NAIC.....the Insurance Companies lobbying group....design a health system. That will work well.........
 
Let the NAIC.....the Insurance Companies lobbying group....design a health system. That will work well.........


If only there was some way to examine the various different alternatives in some sort of real wold situation. It's a shame no other country has ever designed a system that the US could learn from, really.
 
Let the NAIC.....the Insurance Companies lobbying group....design a health system. That will work well.........

NAIC = National Association of Insurance Commissioners. These are the regulators that oversee insurance companies. You should probably look up acronyms you're not familiar with before making assumptions. They're about as far from a lobbying group for insurance companies as you can get. These are elected officials in each state that monitor the activities of insurance companies on behalf of the citizens of that state.

The AAA is the American Academy of Actuaries. The provide ethical and practice oversight for all practicing actuaries in the US, govern the behavior of actuaries, and produce the standards of practice for that profession. Actuaries are responsible for making sure that the insurance products offered are appropriately priced and sustainable relative to the risk inherent in the pool, and that insurance companies hold sufficient reserves to meet the financial obligations of the policies they issue.

Those two organizations are pretty much the only ones with sufficient understanding of the current marketplace, the dynamics of insurance, and the impacts that changes to that marketplace (including UHC or single payer) will have. Anyone else is almost guaranteed to create as much havoc as progress.
 
Last edited:
I really wish that politicians would stop trying to design health systems. They don't know anything about how it works. It's almost guaranteed to be a disaster.

You want something better? Commission the NAIC and the AAA to come up with a solution. Then stick with it.

When the ACA was being designed they brought in lots of experts. It hasn't been a disaster despite the Republican claims that it has.

Ever hear of the National Academy of Medicine or as it was formerly called the institute of Medicine? It's the research arm of Congress for Medical issues. Just as the National Academy of Sciences is the research arm of Congress for scientific issues.

The current Senate and House health care bills are however entirely political. They didn't ask NAM to consult on this issue. If they could, they would tell the CBO to get lost as well. These bills were never intended to improve the health care system. The goal is to give rich people a big tax break and kill Obama's signature program.
 
Emily's Cat said:
American Association of Actuaries, Society of Actuaries, Blue Cross Blue Shield Association Actuarial Committee. Suggestions included:
  1. increasing the penalty for mandatory coverage,
  2. changing the subsidy to be age-adjusted to reduce the dramatic cliff experienced by older consumers when they hit 400%,
  3. changing the age scale to be 5:1 instead of 3:1 to allow for lower rates for younger people,
  4. removing the minimum FPL requirement for individual market that excluded people with incomes under 133%FPL and allow for less disruptive transitioning between Medicaid and Individual markets,
  5. revisions to the risk adjustment methodology to even out the disparate preference for older/sicker individuals over younger/healthier ones and create a more stable environment,
  6. creation of an invisible high risk pool to mitigate the impact from sicker than average new entrants
and a few others I don't recall.

To take these one-by-one:

No.1 - Weren't there a lot of Republicans opposed to any penalty? That the government shouldn't be forcing people to buy a product they didn't want? But the penalty was included and was scaled to increase over time and be income-based. This is from a PBS March 2014 news report:
In 2014, the penalty is the greater of a flat $95 per adult and $47.50 per child under age 18, up to a maximum of $285 per family, or 1 percent of your family’s modified adjusted gross income that is over the threshold the requires you to file a tax return. That threshold is $10,150 for an individual, $13,050 for a head of household and $20,300 for a married couple filing jointly.

Next year the penalty increases to $325 per adult or 2 percent of income, and in 2016 it will be the greater of $695 or 2.5 percent of income.

The $95 penalty has gotten a lot of press, but many people will be paying substantially more than that. A single person earning more than $19,650 would not qualify for the $95 penalty ($19,650 – $10,150 = $9,500 x 1% = $95). So the 1 percent penalty is the standard that will apply in most cases, say experts. For example, for a single person whose MAGI is $35,000, the penalty would be $249 ($35,000 – $10,150 = $24,850 x 1% = $249). Link
 
Emily's Cat said:
American Association of Actuaries, Society of Actuaries, Blue Cross Blue Shield Association Actuarial Committee. Suggestions included:

  1. increasing the penalty for mandatory coverage,
  2. changing the subsidy to be age-adjusted to reduce the dramatic cliff experienced by older consumers when they hit 400%,
  3. changing the age scale to be 5:1 instead of 3:1 to allow for lower rates for younger people,
  4. removing the minimum FPL requirement for individual market that excluded people with incomes under 133%FPL and allow for less disruptive transitioning between Medicaid and Individual markets,
  5. revisions to the risk adjustment methodology to even out the disparate preference for older/sicker individuals over younger/healthier ones and create a more stable environment,
  6. creation of an invisible high risk pool to mitigate the impact from sicker than average new entrants
and a few others I don't recall.

No.2, changing the subsidy to age-adjusted to avoid older consumers paying 400% of...the cost of the basic premium?

First of all what I'm seeing is the difference in costs -- between a 21-year-old and someone age 64 -- is actually about 300% or, as I find it more often expressed, 3x. This is a chart from ValuePenguin:



The ACA planners said this was done in order to allow insurers to consider age when determining premium cost. The reason for that seems obvious. However, individual states can set their own regulations. Most use the federal guidelines (above) but a few don't. New York and Vermont do not allow age to be a consideration in computing premium costs. Massachusetts does but only allows a 2x rise.

I can agree that seeing the premium cost more than double between age 40 and 60 seems extreme. I presume the thinking is, medical requirements rise with age and so does (normally) income. I would want to know the history though and without searching a news archive it is a little hard to find. What was the original proposal? Was it changed? ACA went through a long hearing process and was amended dozens of times in order to try and gain some Republican support. What was the Republican position vs. the Democrats?
 
No.2, changing the subsidy to age-adjusted to avoid older consumers paying 400% of...the cost of the basic premium?

ACA premium subsidies limit the cost of insurance based on family income. Limiting the annual premium of the second least expensive Silver plan to between 2% and 9% of family income for incomes between FPL and 400% of FPL respectively.

The problem is that the subsidy is eliminated when family income exceeds 400% of FPL. Without a subsidy, insurance premiums can be unaffordable (20% of income or higher) for older persons with incomes just over the subsidy cutoff. Because premiums depend on age it is seldom a problem for younger adults.

The Republican proposals adjust subsidies based on age, not income. It fixes the problem for those approaching 65 with incomes just over the current subsidy cutoff but makes insurance unaffordable for young families near the poverty line. It also ends up subsidizing wealth older Americans who can easily afford to pay the full premium.

A more reasonable solution would be to extend the subsidies past 400% of FPL. At these higher income levels the percentage of income going to insurance could also rise.
 
FPL meaning federal poverty level. Income for a family of four at 4x the FPL would be about $98,000. Link Not having employer-based healthcare coverage is a big part of the problem. A survey done last year by the Commonwealth Fund found:
Commonwealth also noted that higher-income Obamacare consumers are spending more on coverage, as a share of their income, than people who have job-based coverage. Link

But the message being replied to was not about income-based subsidies, it was about the way ACA lets premiums rise as one ages. Removing limits on income-based subsidies is not one of the points that was listed that actuaries recommended
 
Yes, the ACA allows premiums to rise with age. The big complaint at the time the bill was being passed was that they didn't allow them to rise enough. The ACA limits age based premium adjustments to a 3 to 1 ratio. The actual difference in medical costs based on age is 5 to 1 or higher.
 
The big complaint at the time the bill was being passed was that they didn't allow them to rise enough...

Complaint by whom? The post I was responding to said Congress was advised by the actuary industry that the rise was too steep. I think really to vet some of this one would have to go back and read news articles from 2009-2010.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom