Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

I don't think it's magic but I do believe that, generally speaking, less regulation/taxation means lower prices and more choice.

What do you base this belief on?

In my experience, going for the lower price has not always meant a lower cost. In many cases, quite the opposite.

So is the mere fact it is done in the name of "lower prices" an argument in favor of something? I mean shipping all of our manufacturing jobs abroad to exploit 3rd world labor sure has lowered prices, too.

To head off the army of strawmen that are surely coming my way, note that I did not say zero regulation/taxation. What we need is smarter policy.

Wonderful slogan.

That's the problem: Define effective regulation/taxation. Beyond hardcore Libertarians, you aren't going to find many people that want absolutely nothing.

Correct, certainly for those in power who use that slogan you just used. They don't want nothing, they want campaign war-chest contributions and a nice retirement gig on a few charitable boards. We get lower prices, maybe a funny aftertaste in the water, too.

Right. Rent-seeking is a problem in the business world in general. That's a problem we have to fight. ETA: A high-regulation atmosphere contributes to rent-seeking.

If the regulations protect an entrenched interest such that it can be that comfortable and complacent, sure.

Why wouldn't we want to have as small a government as possible? Do we need them to do everything?

Same straw man you claimed you just had to shield yourself from.

Wanting a government that is active and responsive to commercial abuses (as if the idea that people will do anything for a buck is so outlandish) is not the same as saying you "need them to do everything."

Sent from my SM-J327P using Tapatalk
 
Our exceptionalism keeps us from considering good ideas from other countries. This should be changed. Good beer does not have to served ice cold.
You guys are making some fabulous craft beers these days, and thanks to globalisation I can enjoy them right here in Cardiff. What an amazing world we live in.
 
Last edited:
Good news, sort of. The delay says they can't pass it. The delay might just be waiting for less attention on the issue so they can get it passed like the House did.
That can't be it. All the secrecy and short deadlines was about bouncing a measure through because they knew it would be toxic. The more time passes the worse it gets. This is them throwing their hands up and enjoying summer, because who knows what the political landscape will be like come fall? Who knew it would be like this in spring?
 
That sounds like a reason to expand or redraw the boundary lines. If people can't get insurance because of the county they live in, and in the next county over they can, that's a problem. This stuff isn't carved in stone; it can be revised. And maybe those customers would choose a longer drive to a specialist rather than no coverage at all.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining

In the United States, redlining is the practice of denying services, either directly or through selectively raising prices, to residents of certain areas based on the racial or ethnic composition of those areas.
That was deemed unacceptable enough to be made illegal. Perhaps it should be extended to economic class as well.
 
IRS Publication 974 covers the Premium Tax Credit. The income range is specified on page 4:



There are however other factors besides income that could make one ineligible for a Premium Tax Credit.

I was wrong in my earlier post, the Medicaid income cutoff is 138%, not 133%.
Here in Texas, we don't have expanded medicaid. If your income falls between 100% and 138% (?) you don't qualify for medicaid or Obamacare, basically just forget about having health insurance.
 
You guys are making some fabulous craft beers these days, and thanks to globalisation I can enjoy them right here in Cardiff. What an amazing world we live in.

It is a pretty good time to be alive. I hope we don't wreck all the things that make it so.
 
Fortunately my income is not low enough to fall into the hole, where you make too much for medicaid and not enough to qualify for Obamacare, but I know a number of artists who do. The limit is only 12k for an individual but that is deceiving, when you are self employed lots of things are expenses, even a large bit of mortgage, utilities, etc., so that by the time you get to net income there is not much left.
 
That sounds like a reason to expand or redraw the boundary lines. If people can't get insurance because of the county they live in, and in the next county over they can, that's a problem. This stuff isn't carved in stone; it can be revised. And maybe those customers would choose a longer drive to a specialist rather than no coverage at all.

Region boundaries can be altered to fix problems. Or the state can work harder to convince an insurance company to serve and underserved region. Assuming of course that the state is interested in making the ACA work instead of making Obamacare fail for political reasons.

A list of where the 42 counties are might tell us a lot about the cause of the problem.
 
Here in Texas, we don't have expanded medicaid. If your income falls between 100% and 138% (?) you don't qualify for medicaid or Obamacare, basically just forget about having health insurance.

The Kaiser subsidy calculator is probably the best place to explore options.

A 45 year old person living in Austin, Texas with income of 115% of FPL would qualify for an enhanced Silver plan with a 94% actuarial value for $23 a month. A Bronze plan would have a $0 monthly premium.

With an income below the FPL this person would be screwed because Texas didn't expand Medicaid.
 
Last edited:
What are people meaning when they say they "can't qualify for Obamacare?"

The ACA isn't a health coverage plan in and of itself.

If they mean they don't qualify for subsidies, that's a different matter.

Just one of many ways to subtly use language to make something that needs tweaking and adjusting into a condemnation of the entire system and that we simply have to abandon the whole thing.

Sent from my SM-J327P using Tapatalk
 
What are people meaning when they say they "can't qualify for Obamacare?"

The ACA isn't a health coverage plan in and of itself.

If they mean they don't qualify for subsidies, that's a different matter.

Just one of many ways to subtly use language to make something that needs tweaking and adjusting into a condemnation of the entire system and that we simply have to abandon the whole thing.

Sent from my SM-J327P using Tapatalk
Obamacare is almost synonymous with the subsidies. There are people who buy on the exchange who don't qualify for subsidies but they are in the minority.

ETA: I'm very much in favor of keeping the system.
ETA2: The biggest mistake I see was making medicaid expansion optional.
 
Last edited:
The Kaiser subsidy calculator is probably the best place to explore options.

A 45 year old person living in Austin, Texas with income of 115% of FPL would qualify for an enhanced Silver plan with a 94% actuarial value for $23 a month. A Bronze plan would have a $0 monthly premium.

With an income below the FPL this person would be screwed because Texas didn't expand Medicaid.
My bad, it's people who make below the FPL but not low enough to qualify for medicaid that are screwed then.
 
Trump wants the government to pay for peoples' healthcare, and that is where he and congressional republicans differ.
 
Obamacare is almost synonymous with the subsidies. There are people who buy on the exchange who don't qualify for subsidies but they are in the minority.

ETA: I'm very much in favor of keeping the system.
ETA2: The biggest mistake I see was making medicaid expansion optional.

I seem to recall that the feds had no real shot at forcing states to expand medicaid, and trying to do so would have lost in the Supreme Court.
 
Well it's not killing, so I guess we are fine then?

Sorry, wasn't sure if your statement was meant to be sarcastic or not.

I am assuming that you realize that kicking 22 million people off of insurance, and charging over 5 times more would result in a very large number of unnecessary deaths.

Based on the culmination of over 130 studies on the subject, the historical data shows that 1,300 people would die every year for every 1 million people without health insurance. In other words, the GOP "healthcare" plan would result in 28,600 unnecessary deaths every year for the 22 million uninsured.

Health Care Cuts Will Increase Odds Of Dying For The Uninsured, Medical Review Predicts



Pointlessly killing off Americans is bad enough, but what's worse is the blood money is not even going to really help any other Americans besides the super rich.

You can literally measure the number of people killed (mostly elderly, children, and the disadvantaged) that would be used to buy each new sports car from the extra money given to the super rich as a result of this bill.
 
Last edited:
To head off the army of strawmen that are surely coming my way, note that I did not say zero regulation/taxation...

Why wouldn't we want to have as small a government as possible?
Not zero, just 'as small as possible', huh?

Typical republican mantra.

"We tried cutting taxes and removing regulations, and things just got worse. So obviously we need more tax cuts and deregulation!"

"Eventually we will reach that magic spot where government is as small as possible but not quite zero, and everything will come up roses!".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom