Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

The stupid, idiotic, lying, horribly greedy Republicans have decided to delay the vote on their wonderful health care regulation which designed to provide tax breaks to the few rich people by removing health care for many of the people who are not rich.

https://www.yahoo.com/news/senate-republicans-suddenly-delay-health-care-vote-180243185.html

Senate Republicans suddenly delay health care vote

WASHINGTON — Senate Republican leaders abruptly decided to delay a vote on their plan to begin voting on a sweeping and controversial overhaul of the nation’s health care system.

...

McConnell had also repeatedly vowed to push through the bill before the end of the week. Sen. Roy Blunt, R-Mo., another member of Senate leadership, told reporters that the odds of passing the legislation would not get better with time.

But they apparently lacked the votes.

...
 
It's almost like we need some sort of universal system to ensure basic healthcare for everyone in an efficient manner. If only such a thing existed.
In the US it doesn't and it's naive to think we can just import something from elsewhere and it will just work.

I do get what you're saying though and there is a reasonable limit to what can be done.

But in this case the man already has ambulance services close enough to help, that African kid already has enough food, and that other kid had his cancer expenses covered. We're just going to take it away from them now so the ultra wealthy get a tax cut.

That is a good point and that's why it's so hard to take away benefits once you confer them. But I would not characterize deciding to take a benefit away as the same thing as causing someone to suffer. To continue the analogy, if it costs $5000/month to keep an ambulance close to this guy's ranch on the off-chance that he needs it, I think it's only fair to ask him to shoulder some of that load or decide that those $5000 could be more efficiently used elsewhere. If that African kid is fed but people in our own country are not, I don't think it's immoral to decide not to send money to Africa so that we can take care of problems here. Resources are limited and hard decisions have to be made.
 
In the US it doesn't and it's naive to think we can just import something from elsewhere and it will just work.



That is a good point and that's why it's so hard to take away benefits once you confer them. But I would not characterize deciding to take a benefit away as the same thing as causing someone to suffer. To continue the analogy, if it costs $5000/month to keep an ambulance close to this guy's ranch on the off-chance that he needs it, I think it's only fair to ask him to shoulder some of that load or decide that those $5000 could be more efficiently used elsewhere. If that African kid is fed but people in our own country are not, I don't think it's immoral to decide not to send money to Africa so that we can take care of problems here. Resources are limited and hard decisions have to be made.

That's the thing though. Resources are only limited because some people don't believe that it's important enough to make sure EVERYBODY has access to health care.

If the money was needed to fight ISIS for example, the resources would suddenly be there.
 
In the US it doesn't and it's naive to think we can just import something from elsewhere and it will just work.

You mean like the way some countries try to promote secular representational government in place that didn't previously have it. Stupid waste of time. If it isn't already there you can't just change it.
 
What are these organizations suggesting for AHCA, the current bill?

I don't believe they've had any insight into it. It's not like our "esteemed" congress-critters are soliciting advice from actual experts, you know.

ETA: There may be some interaction, but there isn't any public commentary from those organizations at the moment. So far as I know, they've all been on watch, waiting to see what the hell is going on.
 
Good news, sort of. The delay says they can't pass it. The delay might just be waiting for less attention on the issue so they can get it passed like the House did.
They're not getting it done before recess like the house did which is a problem with a bill so unpopular. Senators will hear from their constituents and it won't be an outcry of support to take healthcare away for tax cuts for the top 1%.

Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
 
You mean like the way some countries try to promote secular representational government in place that didn't previously have it. Stupid waste of time. If it isn't already there you can't just change it.
That's a strawman; I didn't say it's a stupid waste of time or that it couldn't be changed. You can change it, it's just not as easy as picking a system and importing it over.
 
Repubs are claiming that the ACA is dying because health insurance companies have withdrawn from 47 (or some other number) counties, meaning residents of those counties can't get individual coverage.

Why would insurers issue -- or be allowed to issue -- coverage by counties? Counties in the U.S. are arbitrary land areas that have nothing to do with population or anything else. Los Angeles County or Cook County (Chicago) have millions of people; rural counties in the Midwest or South might have a few hundred (at least one has fewer than 100). Why not just require insurers to offer identical policies throughout a state? How would that affect the insurance market?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/County_statistics_of_the_United_States

In the early days of hospitals, many hospitals were funded at the local level. In fact, most hospitals were county hospitals. Sometimes a particularly large county might have more than one hospital, depending on geography. Regulations for health insurance include a geographic access requirement, ensuring appropriate access to hospitals, facilities, labs, and doctors within the area that the insurance company is filing - that ends up being pretty close to county for everywhere outside of dense urban regions. So the requirements on the books are still based at the county level.
 
That's a strawman; I didn't say it's a stupid waste of time or that it couldn't be changed. You can change it, it's just not as easy as picking a system and importing it over.

Our exceptionalism keeps us from considering good ideas from other countries. This should be changed. Good beer does not have to served ice cold.
 
In the early days of hospitals, many hospitals were funded at the local level. In fact, most hospitals were county hospitals. Sometimes a particularly large county might have more than one hospital, depending on geography. Regulations for health insurance include a geographic access requirement, ensuring appropriate access to hospitals, facilities, labs, and doctors within the area that the insurance company is filing - that ends up being pretty close to county for everywhere outside of dense urban regions. So the requirements on the books are still based at the county level.

Gee, maybe it's time to change them. Both the ACA and the AHCA are massive federal bills. County lines shouldn't carry much weight.
 
The entire Republican Party has grown up on lies/propaganda and believe there is some magic solution involving tax cuts and deregulation that can make anything/everything better.

The problem is that this propaganda was never intended to be policy it was a way to get elected by promising voters they could have their cake and eat it too.
I don't think it is all 'propaganda'. People who become Republicans may actually believe that the 'magic solution' is real, not just a ruse to get voters.

While the idea that tax cuts and deregulation will make everything better is pure fantasy, it is a very believable fantasy - particularly for business people who see taxes and regulation as little more than impediments to efficient commerce. Of course that is not actually true, because without effective regulations (and the taxes to pay for them) business would be impossible.

The Republican hierarchy is full of crony capitalists who use selective regulations and tax manipulations to gain pecuniary advantage for themselves, but this hypocrisy doesn't necessarily mean they don't still believe in the fantasy of 'free' market solutions - they just don't think it applies to them (or they don't even realize the depths of their hypocrisy). And to be fair, Democrats are not immune to similar hypocrisy.

The current generation never got that memo and are continually shocked at the consequences of trying to implement policy based on it. Never fear though, they can always just blame Democrats for the failure of these policies!
It's not only the current generation of Republicans who believe(d) that taxes and regulation should be minimized as much as possible. It goes way way back to the founding of the United States and even before. The difference between conservatives and progressives is in whether we should continue to hold those beliefs dear.
 
I don't think it is all 'propaganda'. People who become Republicans may actually believe that the 'magic solution' is real, not just a ruse to get voters.
I don't think it's magic but I do believe that, generally speaking, less regulation/taxation means lower prices and more choice. To head off the army of strawmen that are surely coming my way, note that I did not say zero regulation/taxation. What we need is smarter policy.

While the idea that tax cuts and deregulation will make everything better is pure fantasy, it is a very believable fantasy - particularly for business people who see taxes and regulation as little more than impediments to efficient commerce. Of course that is not actually true, because without effective regulations (and the taxes to pay for them) business would be impossible.
That's the problem: Define effective regulation/taxation. Beyond hardcore Libertarians, you aren't going to find many people that want absolutely nothing.

The Republican hierarchy is full of crony capitalists who use selective regulations and tax manipulations to gain pecuniary advantage for themselves, but this hypocrisy doesn't necessarily mean they don't still believe in the fantasy of 'free' market solutions - they just don't think it applies to them (or they don't even realize the depths of their hypocrisy). And to be fair, Democrats are not immune to similar hypocrisy.
Right. Rent-seeking is a problem in the business world in general. That's a problem we have to fight. ETA: A high-regulation atmosphere contributes to rent-seeking.

It's not only the current generation of Republicans who believe(d) that taxes and regulation should be minimized as much as possible. It goes way way back to the founding of the United States and even before. The difference between conservatives and progressives is in whether we should continue to hold those beliefs dear.
Why wouldn't we want to have as small a government as possible? Do we need them to do everything?
 
Last edited:
I know people that are in this situation, between 100% and 133% so not eligible for Obamacare and can't get insurance, so this bit is an improvement. Can't say I hope the bill will pass though, I don't.

IRS Publication 974 covers the Premium Tax Credit. The income range is specified on page 4:

Your household income for 2016 is at least 100% but no more than 400% of the federal poverty line for your family size

There are however other factors besides income that could make one ineligible for a Premium Tax Credit.

I was wrong in my earlier post, the Medicaid income cutoff is 138%, not 133%.
 
Repubs are claiming that the ACA is dying because health insurance companies have withdrawn from 47 (or some other number) counties, meaning residents of those counties can't get individual coverage.

Why would insurers issue -- or be allowed to issue -- coverage by counties? Counties in the U.S. are arbitrary land areas that have nothing to do with population or anything else. Los Angeles County or Cook County (Chicago) have millions of people; rural counties in the Midwest or South might have a few hundred (at least one has fewer than 100). Why not just require insurers to offer identical policies throughout a state? How would that affect the insurance market?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/County_statistics_of_the_United_States

Medical costs vary a lot across the country and even within a single state. Under the ACA insurance premiums depend on where the user lives. This was implemented on a state by state basis by dividing the state into regions. Each region consists of one or more counties.

Using the existing county lines for boundaries makes a lot more sense than inventing a new arbitrary line because people already know their county.

The reason medical costs vary is the old story of supply and demand. An insurer setting up a provider network is required to have a full range of specialists. If the region only has one provider working in a specialty, they must sign up that provider and have no real leverage for negotiating reasonable fees. In a big urban area there are multiple providers for every specialty and negotiation over fees is a lot easier.
 
...
The reason medical costs vary is the old story of supply and demand. An insurer setting up a provider network is required to have a full range of specialists. If the region only has one provider working in a specialty, they must sign up that provider and have no real leverage for negotiating reasonable fees. ....

That sounds like a reason to expand or redraw the boundary lines. If people can't get insurance because of the county they live in, and in the next county over they can, that's a problem. This stuff isn't carved in stone; it can be revised. And maybe those customers would choose a longer drive to a specialist rather than no coverage at all.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom