Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Stop bringing morality and ethics into it. You don't do that in your own words, so stop using an argument that relies on morality and ethics.

It isn't related to ethics. Whether something is killing or not is merely a question of logic.

Whether the killing is right or wrong is the moral question, not if it is or is not killing.
 
Last edited:
KellyAnne says all those people who are going to lose their Medicaid coverage can just get jobs with insurance.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry...-always-find-jobs_us_594fce98e4b05c37bb770cb7

Since most are already employed, I'm sure they'll have no problem getting a second job that has the insurance coverage that the first job doesn't have.
I can imagine the job adverts, 15hr a week and we cover one kidney. Just need a few well chosen jobs and you'll be able to get 95% of your body covered.
 
This seems like literally choosing to kill poor people so that the ultra rich can pay less in taxes.

http://www.rollingstone.com/politic...pushing-bill-that-will-kill-thousands-w489867

But then there's that 26,500 figure – the conservative estimate of the number of Americans who would die every year under an Obamacare repeal plan like the one currently before the Senate. (Other studies put the number even higher.) We know this because of research conducted in the mid-2000s in Massachusetts, which was the first state to enact a program designed to insure everyone. After the program was fully implemented, researchers determined that for every 830 people who gained health insurance, there was one less death per year.

One fewer death. Sheesh, proofreading, folks!
 
How can that be a problem? It's a core principle of Capitalism!

I know you are being sarcastic, but it really isn’t. Adam Smith was vehemently opposed to the corporations of his day, specifically for this reason.

Milton Friedman conveniently and selectively presumed the corporate structure was just legal fiction and without any real supporting evidence said that corporate executives would work in the best interests of “the owners” that being the shareholders. Even if he’d presented an actual case or argument for this, it’s pretty clear at this point he was wrong.
 
Trump may be a turd but let's be fair - this wasn't actually his idea.

Truth is, Trump bought into the lies about 'Obamacare' and figured that with his business acumen he could do much better. So the idea was great, but the reality is sick.

The entire Republican Party has grown up on lies/propaganda and believe there is some magic solution involving tax cuts and deregulation that can make anything/everything better.

The problem is that this propaganda was never intended to be policy it was a way to get elected by promising voters they could have their cake and eat it too. The current generation never got that memo and are continually shocked at the consequences of trying to implement policy based on it. Never fear though, they can always just blame Democrats for the failure of these policies!
 
Well it's not killing, so I guess we are fine then?

You know what was meant, but yes technically it's more allowing people to die unnecessarily.

Like when the cook accidentally ends up on fire, and the rich guy with 3 mansions, 6 sports cars, and 100 million dollars doesn't use the fire extinguisher to save them because then they'd have to pay to refill it.
 
You know what was meant, but yes technically it's more allowing people to die unnecessarily.

Like when the cook accidentally ends up on fire, and the rich guy with 3 mansions, 6 sports cars, and 100 million dollars doesn't use the fire extinguisher to save them because then they'd have to pay to refill it.

I'm pretty sure the person meant killing.
 
You know what was meant, but yes technically it's more allowing people to die unnecessarily.

Like when the cook accidentally ends up on fire, and the rich guy with 3 mansions, 6 sports cars, and 100 million dollars doesn't use the fire extinguisher to save them because then they'd have to pay to refill it.

OK, that's a little more directly contributing to the cook's death, but I understand your point. The question is, how far can you take such logic?

If a man dies on his middle-of-nowhere ranch because the ambulance couldn't get to him on time because he was so far away, did "we" kill him because we refuse to pay to have ambulances within 2 minutes of every living person?

If a kid dies of starvation in Africa, did we kill that kid because we don't donate to the cause or insist that our government, the richest in the world, send enough aid to feed everyone?

If a neighborhood kid is dying of cancer and you don't buy the barbecue plate to contribute to his out-of-pocket costs, are you effectively killing him?

If you support having other people's taxes raised -but not your own- in order to pay for healthcare, aren't you, in effect, refusing to help pay to prevent all those deaths?
 
Repubs are claiming that the ACA is dying because health insurance companies have withdrawn from 47 (or some other number) counties, meaning residents of those counties can't get individual coverage.

Why would insurers issue -- or be allowed to issue -- coverage by counties? Counties in the U.S. are arbitrary land areas that have nothing to do with population or anything else. Los Angeles County or Cook County (Chicago) have millions of people; rural counties in the Midwest or South might have a few hundred (at least one has fewer than 100). Why not just require insurers to offer identical policies throughout a state? How would that affect the insurance market?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/County_statistics_of_the_United_States
 
Just because Trump promised up and down to repeal Obamacare and replace it with something that would provide more services for less costs and lower deductibles, that does not mean that Trump is a liar when he made all of those promises. After all, Trump was not actually under oath when he made these promises, therefore legally speaking Trump is not a liar.

But in all practicality, Trump is about the biggest liar in the world.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...964a7d55207_story.html?utm_term=.e5f871a42f1e

...

In a Washington Post interview before his inauguration, Trump distilled his vision for health care into a few visionary goals.

“We’re going to have insurance for everybody,” he said. “There was a philosophy in some circles that if you can’t pay for it, you don’t get it. That’s not going to happen with us.”

...

Trump said he was close to finishing a plan of his own that would have “lower numbers, much lower deductibles.”

...
 
OK, that's a little more directly contributing to the cook's death, but I understand your point. The question is, how far can you take such logic?

If a man dies on his middle-of-nowhere ranch because the ambulance couldn't get to him on time because he was so far away, did "we" kill him because we refuse to pay to have ambulances within 2 minutes of every living person?

If a kid dies of starvation in Africa, did we kill that kid because we don't donate to the cause or insist that our government, the richest in the world, send enough aid to feed everyone?

If a neighborhood kid is dying of cancer and you don't buy the barbecue plate to contribute to his out-of-pocket costs, are you effectively killing him?

If you support having other people's taxes raised -but not your own- in order to pay for healthcare, aren't you, in effect, refusing to help pay to prevent all those deaths?

It's almost like we need some sort of universal system to ensure basic healthcare for everyone in an efficient manner. If only such a thing existed.

I do get what you're saying though and there is a reasonable limit to what can be done.

But in this case the man already has ambulance services close enough to help, that African kid already has enough food, and that other kid had his cancer expenses covered. We're just going to take it away from them now so the ultra wealthy get a tax cut.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom