Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

I wouldn't be so sure of that. Companies are going to have to make up the lost revenue from the CSRs somewhere. If there aren't enough unsubsidized people buying plans in the market, where else are they going to find that revenue?

It really is unclear what will happen. Customers on the exchange will sign up for the plans, creating a legally binding contract between them and the insurance company. The insurance company will not get the CSR payments that make the plans profitable.

Seems to me that the insurance companies will be going to court to get this fixed.

They're not going to wait for a court decision that could take years (that they could lose) to address the revenue gap. Everyone is going to get screwed.

There are only two viable options for an insurer:
1) Raise all of the premiums across the board to the level necessary to produce within-carrier subsidization of those plans or
2) Exit the market altogether

Both of those options result in everyone in the individual market getting screwed.


ETA: There's always the extremely remote possibility that the states could fund the reimbursements through some other tax or fee based method, but it's hard to see how that could happen quickly enough to prevent massive disruption and loss of coverage.
 
Last edited:
Anyone have a link to the text of the EO issued by Obama, authorizing Federal reimbursement for the cost-sharing subsidies?

I'd like to read it.

Thanks.
 
Remember when the commander-in-ept said:

“We’re going to have insurance for everybody. There was a philosophy in some circles that if you can’t pay for it, you don’t get it. That’s not going to happen with us.”
 
It is crazy how much flak Trump is getting for something all three branches agreed was unconstitutional.
 
White house doesn't have the executive order posted. I found one from yesterday pertaining to ACA - extending access to associations and limited benefit plans... but I couldn't find anything about removing the subsidies. Maybe it's just not posted yet.

I don't know that there is a specific executive order about ending subsidies. But the official White House spokesperson said it. Not everything involves an executive order from the president. It could be the secretary of HHS.
 
It is crazy how much flak Trump is getting for something all three branches agreed was unconstitutional.

You do realize this will kill people, right?

Is being "correct" so much more important than saving lives?
 
A lot of people don't realize it but every day these job creators wake up wondering how they can spend more money on wages.

I've heard that lie. The media will try to spin anything. Right now they're trying to make it sound like a bunch of Democrat voters dying is bad.
 
I've heard that lie. The media will try to spin anything. Right now they're trying to make it sound like a bunch of Democrat voters dying is bad.

True, but many of them will be Republican voters. Still poor*, though.


*The ones affected will be after their medical bills, regardless of beforehand.
 
You do realize this will kill people, right?

Is being "correct" so much more important than saving lives?

When it comes to the Constitution, YES! Part of living in a constitutional republic is the idea that the rule of law rather than disobeying the Constitution when convenient protects us all.
 
When it comes to the Constitution, YES! Part of living in a constitutional republic is the idea that the rule of law rather than disobeying the Constitution when convenient protects us all.
I'm sure people facing financial ruin for being sick feel quite "protected" by the Constitution.
 
We'll add your name to the 'let people die' category.

I'm in the let people die category regardless of the Constitution. I don't believe government has a role in making things better. This is specifically about the expectation that elected government should violate the Constitution over healthcare.
 
It's a bit disingenuous to use the excuse that it's unconstitutional, when they've been making the payment for a good 8 months now, despite the ruling having been handed down last year.

In any case, instead of throwing the baby out with the bathwater, why not make congress do its actual job and appropriate the necessary funds? The judge did find that part of the law perfectly legal.
 
That isn't a ringing endorsement for shredding the Constitution.
Is this supposed to evoke some kind of emotional response related to damaging a piece of paper that overrides my concern for other human beings?

Sent from my SM-J327P using Tapatalk
 
One judge has ruled, and the case is under appeal. There is no reason other than malice not to maintain the status quo until the issue is resolved, probably by the Supreme Court.

Many of Trump's own advisers opposed his action.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...404234-b01d-11e7-be94-fabb0f1e9ffb_story.html

One federal judge is good enough. Not everything needs appeal to the supreme Court just because. Neither party in the suit has a problem with the ruling.

I read the article. None of the internal house opponents are described as disagreeing with the Constitutional issues. Keeping those payments going under that situation would be a violation of the oath of office.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom