Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

I don't know that there is a specific executive order about ending subsidies. But the official White House spokesperson said it. Not everything involves an executive order from the president. It could be the secretary of HHS.

I'll try to keep an eye out for something that confirms this. It's been being talked about for a couple of years now, and it has pretty massive impacts.
 
You do realize this will kill people, right?

Is being "correct" so much more important than saving lives?

It's not going to kill anyone.

And yes, actually, being just and legal IS more important than saving lives. Heck, it's feasible that some good samaritan could rob a bank and use all the money to pay the hospital bills of those in need. Still illegal, still unjust, still not excusable. It's feasible that the government could forcibly take ownership of everything in the US, and could confiscate the earnings of every citizen, then use that money to save lives. That doesn't make it okay.

The ends don't justify the means.
 
President Trump on Monday blasted ObamaCare, saying it is "dead" and "finished."

"ObamaCare is finished. It's dead. It's gone," Trump said during a Cabinet meeting.

"You shouldn't even mention it, it's gone. There is no such thing as ObamaCare anymore. It is a — and I said this years ago — it's a concept that couldn't have worked."

Trump added that in the law's "best days," it couldn't have worked.
The comments come after the White House announced last week that it would end key payments to insurers selling ObamaCare plans.

http://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/355658-trump-there-is-no-such-thing-as-obamacare-anymore

HAHAHAHAHA!!!
 
Trump's breathless excitement over exclaiming the death of Obamacare reinforces my belief that his almost singular policy is the erasure of Obama from the National consciousness. Recklessly. To the detriment of the country. To the detriment of himself. Our new Ahab.
 
What Trump is up to:
His main strategy is trying to prevent healthy people from entering the normal insurance market. The administration has all but stopped advertising the Obamacare insurance exchanges, which serve people who don’t already have coverage. Absent this outreach, people who desperately need insurance — the sick — will dominate sign-ups, and prices will soar. Imagine if the life insurance market were dominated by people who’d already turned 80.
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/15/opinion/columnists/how-to-fight-the-new-trumpcare.html

More:
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/12/...column-region&region=top-news&WT.nav=top-news
 

Okay, I'm gonna quibble. YEs, Trump is busy trying to destroy ACA. Yes, he's going about it in a reckless and negligent way with no consideration to the harm being done in the process...

But this quote is absurd. The advertising that is funded by the government has had very little impact on the market. And insurers advertise for open enrollment too. The government no longer funding this specific type of advertising is NOT going to destroy the market and leave only the sick signing up. Seriously, this is a ridiculous claim.

There's plenty of other things that can AND SHOULD be attacked with respect to the current administration's handling of ACA. This is a distraction from that.
 
Okay, I'm gonna quibble. YEs, Trump is busy trying to destroy ACA. Yes, he's going about it in a reckless and negligent way with no consideration to the harm being done in the process...

But this quote is absurd. The advertising that is funded by the government has had very little impact on the market. And insurers advertise for open enrollment too. The government no longer funding this specific type of advertising is NOT going to destroy the market and leave only the sick signing up. Seriously, this is a ridiculous claim.

There's plenty of other things that can AND SHOULD be attacked with respect to the current administration's handling of ACA. This is a distraction from that.


The story sets out many of those things. Maybe this is a more representative quote:
Last week, the administration took several steps to deprive people of health insurance. In doing so, it has both a short-term goal (have the federal government do less to help vulnerable citizens) and a long-term goal (sabotage Obamacare, so that Congress can more easily repeal the law).
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/15/opinion/columnists/how-to-fight-the-new-trumpcare.html

And this:
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/12/...column-region&region=top-news&WT.nav=top-news

But I think you're making a big mistake if you think advertising doesn't matter, especially in the face of dishonest political claims that "Obamacare is broken." Telling people who don't have insurance what's available and how to get it is about as basic as you can get, especially when there is an enrollment deadline. Watch any hour of prime-time TV and count how many minutes are paid advertising. You wanna claim it's not effective?
 
But I think you're making a big mistake if you think advertising doesn't matter, especially in the face of dishonest political claims that "Obamacare is broken." Telling people who don't have insurance what's available and how to get it is about as basic as you can get, especially when there is an enrollment deadline. Watch any hour of prime-time TV and count how many minutes are paid advertising. You wanna claim it's not effective?

I'm not saying that advertising doesn't matter. I'm saying that advertising paid for by the government is unnecessary.

Over the past several years, the government advertising has made no measurable difference in the volume of enrollments. The advertising was in a limited number of areas, and was quite expensive, and showed no actual increase in enrollments - it didn't generate lift. The insurers are advertising already, and will continue to do so - it's in their interests to bring in lower cost people, after all. The additional advertising in such a small footprint at such a large price is not a good use of funds.
 
This is a very good observation paired with an excellent kicker.


His single-minded obsession with dismantling the Affordable Care Act isn’t an impulse that stems from some deeply held right wing ideology, but from his primitive desire to brutalize Obama, the person, in the public square. He sees the steady progress he’s made rolling back Obama-era regulations and administrative action not as policy changes that will serve the public interest, or as legacy burnishing accomplishments in their own right, but as his most proximate means of needling a defenseless nemesis. Of owning Obama. Nay, of pwning him.

Perhaps Obama is highly insulted by all this pwnage. That’s the fantasy anyhow. But as in Moscow four years ago (allegedly) Trump hasn’t come around to the fact that the bed he’s befouling isn’t Obama’s anymore. It’s his. And, unfortunately, it’s ours, too.
 
I'm not saying that advertising doesn't matter. I'm saying that advertising paid for by the government is unnecessary.

Over the past several years, the government advertising has made no measurable difference in the volume of enrollments. The advertising was in a limited number of areas, and was quite expensive, and showed no actual increase in enrollments - it didn't generate lift. The insurers are advertising already, and will continue to do so - it's in their interests to bring in lower cost people, after all. The additional advertising in such a small footprint at such a large price is not a good use of funds.


What's your evidence that government ads don't matter? How much have the insurance companies actually paid for expensive private advertising? Here's where we stand now:
Here’s more cause for worry: The polling firm Hart Research Associates conducted a poll for Get America Covered and found that only 31 percent of customers insured through the ACA exchanges and 12 percent of the uninsured know when open enrollment starts. Worse, majorities of the insured (54 percent) and of the uninsured (59 percent) either believe Obamacare will be canceled in 2018 or say they’re unsure.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/blog...etence-will-not-save-us-from-his-malevolence/

If advertising is badly designed or misdirected, that's a separate issue that needs to be dealt with. But obviously, people need to know that health insurance is available and a deadline is looming. And Trump is doing everything he can to discourage them.
 
... But obviously, people need to know that health insurance is available and a deadline is looming. And Trump is doing everything he can to discourage them.

Including telling them that Obamacare is DEAD, whether or not you were expecting those cancelled subsidies. I don't think advertising would help now.
 
Including telling them that Obamacare is DEAD, whether or not you were expecting those cancelled subsidies. I don't think advertising would help now.
It's even worse, some of the ads that has been funded and released by the DHHS, involves horror stories of families whose lives are worse off because of ACA.

I'm not sure, but that has got to be the first time a department is actively trying to discourage US citizens from utilising their services. Imagine if the US Army ran recruiting ads along the line of "Be all that you can be after losing a limb or two".
 
Last edited:
Lying and not paying the bills was a big part of Trump's business model. Now he is making government work just like his business.
 
It ain't dead yet. Look on the bright side. Trump has declared ACA dead. When the inevitable "tweaks" to make it actually dead are sent to the Oval Office no one will be able to mention the subject because Trump declared ACA dead.


It will be like when the Allies stormed the Normandy beaches and no one wanted to wake Hitler! And, yes, I just compared Trump to Hitler.
 
I'm not so sure the total number of enrollees will go down. The number of new sign ups should, because of the slashed advertising budget and scarce facilitators, but anyone who is already enrolled doesn't have to do anything. You get an email from your insurance company telling you what next years premium will be and if you agree you take no action, it automatically rolls over. If you want to shop for a new policy (or if your insurance company withdraws from the market) you have to return to the Exchange, but this is something you are already familiar with, it's not that much trouble.

The usual frequent emails from the Exchange have already started, I don't suppose that will change, they're cheap to send.
 
I'm not so sure the total number of enrollees will go down. The number of new sign ups should, because of the slashed advertising budget and scarce facilitators, but anyone who is already enrolled doesn't have to do anything. You get an email from your insurance company telling you what next years premium will be and if you agree you take no action, it automatically rolls over. If you want to shop for a new policy (or if your insurance company withdraws from the market) you have to return to the Exchange, but this is something you are already familiar with, it's not that much trouble.

The usual frequent emails from the Exchange have already started, I don't suppose that will change, they're cheap to send.


According to this, current enrollees will be auto re-upped before they have a chance to change if they want:
Millions of Americans with insurance through the Affordable Care Act could find themselves locked into health plans they do not want for the coming year because of the Trump administration’s schedule for the enrollment season that starts in less than two weeks.
The complication arises when people who already have health plans under the law are automatically re-enrolled in the same plan. In the past, a few million consumers each year have been auto-
enrolled and then were sent government notices encouraging them to check whether they could find better or more affordable coverage.
This time, according to a federal document obtained by The Washington Post, the automatic enrollment will take place after it is too late to make any changes. Auto-enrollment will occur immediately after the last day of the ACA sign-up season, which the Trump administration has shortened, leaving the vast majority of such consumers stranded without any way to switch to a plan they might prefer.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...=.98482d9021c3
 
Last edited:

Okay, let's clear up some stuff with real information...

The shrinking open enrollment period is not new. It's been planned to shrink so that it is in alignment with Medicare open enrollment since the inception of ACA. In fact, in 2014, the enrollment period was artificially extended by an additional 2 months, and by 1 month in 2015. This year, after four years in practice, the enrollment period is down to 45 days. For comparison, Medicare Advantage has an enrollment period of 53 days.

Yes, there is likely to be a drop in enrollments this year. I wouldn't be at all surprised to see somewhere around a million people nationwide, although I don't give much credence to the loss being driven by Trump not extending the federal funding for advertising. The federal advertising was scheduled to sunset, by the terms of ACA. And it *should* be sunset in my opinion. The federally funded advertising was only operational in a handful of states, and was quite expensive. It also had minimal effect on actual enrollments in those states. The cost per acquisition was really high - a cost being borne by taxpayers.

The largest drivers of reduced enrollment, in my opinion, are due to two things: Reduced choice of insurers and increased prices. There were several counties in the US where no individual market options existed - there were no carriers at all. Additionally, there were many counties where there is only one carrier available, so there is no competition. Premiums for 2017 were expected to increase in a material way before Trump removed funding for the Cost Share Reduction (CSR) program... that removal has increased prices beyond what was already expected. Both of those are going to drive lower enrollment rates.

Regarding the other article...
The complication arises when people who already have health plans under the law are automatically re-enrolled in the same plan. In the past, a few million consumers each year have been auto-
enrolled and then were sent government notices encouraging them to check whether they could find better or more affordable coverage.

This time, according to a federal document obtained by The Washington Post, the automatic enrollment will take place after it is too late to make any changes.
This is pretty much just outright narrative. So let me clear this up.

Current members are sent a letter in OCTOBER telling them exactly what is going to happen to their coverage: the changes to coverage, cost shares, and premiums are all identified. The details of the plan that they will be auto-enrolled in are included. This is a federal requirement. I know this, because my team is responsible for generating the data used to populate those notices ;).

Additionally, although the mapping is generally done in advance, the mapped plans aren't effective until the January 1 anyway. They never have been.

So the chief complaint of this article seems to be that people have to 1) read their mail and 2) make a decision before open enrollment ends. Which is what they are supposed to be doing anyway.

It remains unclear whether consumers will be notified of when the automatic enrollment will take place
That right there ^^^ is blatant speculation for narrative emotional engineering. It's not a thing. I don't know why the author is "unclear" on the thing that every insurer is required to communicate to their policyholders, or that is easily available on the internet with only minimal googling skills, and that is actively being advertised by insurers all over the place. This isn't a black box. This author is busy fearmongering for no good reason.

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=health+insurance+open+enrollment
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom