Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

OTOH public opinion appears to veering towards it being the GOP's fault if they lose their healthcare
I certainly hope that that's the case.

Unfortunately, a large portion of the electorate (mainly the Trump supporters) are low information/ignorant/gullible. They may be foolish enough to think "better times are around the corner if only we let Trump do his thing". Or they may think "Obama set it up and Trump is trying oh so hard to fix it. The fact that its failing is because Obama did it wrong in the first place".

I remember seeing a poll that pointed out that 1/3rd of people didn't know Obamacare and the Affordable Care Act were the same thing. And roughly half of republicans thought subsidies wouldn't be affected without a replacement. I also remember seeing other studies that showed many people loved their state-centric health care but disliked Obamacare, not understanding that their state's health care was actually part of Obamacare.

http://fortune.com/2017/02/07/obamacare-affordable-care-act-repeal-poll/
 
It's always the Democrats fault. Always. If the Democrats hand't managed to pass the ACA, then the Republicans wouldn't have been forced to take away peoples Health Insurance.

See? Democrats fault.
Trump: I've been saying all along that Obamacare is a disaster. Today I proved it!
 
I certainly hope that that's the case.

Unfortunately, a large portion of the electorate (mainly the Trump supporters) are low information/ignorant/gullible. They may be foolish enough to think "better times are around the corner if only we let Trump do his thing". Or they may think "Obama set it up and Trump is trying oh so hard to fix it. The fact that its failing is because Obama did it wrong in the first place".

I remember seeing a poll that pointed out that 1/3rd of people didn't know Obamacare and the Affordable Care Act were the same thing. And roughly half of republicans thought subsidies wouldn't be affected without a replacement. I also remember seeing other studies that showed many people loved their state-centric health care but disliked Obamacare, not understanding that their state's health care was actually part of Obamacare.

http://fortune.com/2017/02/07/obamacare-affordable-care-act-repeal-poll/

Most Americans get health insurance from their employers. Only a small fraction buy individual policies from the exchange. They will not be directly affected by Trump's latest action.
 
Most Americans get health insurance from their employers. Only a small fraction buy individual policies from the exchange. They will not be directly affected by Trump's latest action.

This has been the problem with getting any real action on healthcare for the last 60 or so years. There will be no strong consensus until some critical mass of the voting public are without healthcare. Trump and Republicans are doing a good job of pushing us in that direction. I just don't know how many will suffer and how long Trump can keep the electorate divided.
 
Most Americans get health insurance from their employers. Only a small fraction buy individual policies from the exchange. They will not be directly affected by Trump's latest action.

Fewer Americans Getting Health Insurance From Employer
http://news.gallup.com/poll/160676/fewer-americans-getting-health-insurance-employer.aspx

Fewer Americans reported having employer-based health insurance in 2012 than did in 2008, 2009, and 2010, but at 44.5% it is unchanged from 2011. At the same time, more Americans continue to report having a government-based health plan -- Medicare, Medicaid, or military or veterans' benefits -- with the 25.6% who did so in 2012 up from 23.4% in 2008.
The percentage of Americans who say they get their coverage through "something else," which could mean they buy it for themselves, has been relatively unchanged over the years. Importantly, while more Americans remain uninsured than in the past, the percentage who are uninsured decreased slightly in 2012, after having risen each year previously going back to 2009.
 
Fewer Americans Getting Health Insurance From Employer
http://news.gallup.com/poll/160676/fewer-americans-getting-health-insurance-employer.aspx

The percentage of Americans who say they get their coverage through "something else," which could mean they buy it for themselves, has been relatively unchanged over the years. Importantly, while more Americans remain uninsured than in the past, the percentage who are uninsured decreased slightly in 2012, after having risen each year previously going back to 2009.

From your link:
Results are based on telephone interviews conducted as part of the Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index survey Jan. 1-Dec. 31, 2012, with a random sample of 353,563 adults, aged 18 and older, living in all 50 U.S. states and the District of Columbia, selected using random-digit-dial sampling.

Emphasis added. Note that this poll was done in 2012, five years ago and before the ACA exchanges opened.
 
And now potentially even bigger news than the executive order:

Trump will scrap critical Obamacare subsidy

So it's now official I take it.

So it is now officially Trumpcare from here forward as of these executive decisions. Ending the subsidy for insurance companies is huge.

Is he still going to try to claim that this is just Obamacare imploding on its own?

Of all the self-aggrandizing bordering-on-idiotic things Trump has done, this one leaves flabbergasted and actually angry. These are people's lives we're talking about. For some people affected by this, the administration might as well take them out to a public square and shoot them. It has exactly the same effect and is a lot more up-front about it.

What's it to going to take for the US populace to finally conclude their federal government is actively acting against their interests? A couple of people who have lost their health insurance to publicly immolate themselves?
 
Most of the press reports don't discuss how the Cost Sharing Reduction Payments work.

The exchanges make special versions of Silver plans available to families with incomes under 250% of the Federal Poverty Level. These have low or zero deductible, lower out of pocket maximums and lower copays than standard Silver plans. Trumps Executive order eliminates the Federal subsidies that make these plans possible.

More details can be found here:
The Effects of Ending the Affordable Care Act’s Cost-Sharing Reduction Payments.
 
Last edited:
Of all the self-aggrandizing bordering-on-idiotic things Trump has done, this one leaves flabbergasted and actually angry. These are people's lives we're talking about. For some people affected by this, the administration might as well take them out to a public square and shoot them. It has exactly the same effect and is a lot more up-front about it.

What's it to going to take for the US populace to finally conclude their federal government is actively acting against their interests? A couple of people who have lost their health insurance to publicly immolate themselves?

My bold. Trump's already boasted that he could do exactly that and not lose any support.
 
Most of the press reports don't discuss how the Cost Sharing Reduction Payments work.

The exchanges make special versions of Silver plans available to families with incomes under 250% of the Federal Poverty Level. These have low or zero deductible, lower out of pocket maximums and lower copays than standard Silver plans. Trumps Executive order eliminates the Federal subsidies that make these plans possible.

More details can be found here:
The Effects of Ending the Affordable Care Act’s Cost-Sharing Reduction Payments.

Oh, but he'll "help" them by going back to having cheaper plans available with worse coverage, and they can just hope that they don't have a medical problem that wipes them out. Make America Great Again.
 
Most of the press reports don't discuss how the Cost Sharing Reduction Payments work.

The exchanges make special versions of Silver plans available to families with incomes under 250% of the Federal Poverty Level. These have low or zero deductible, lower out of pocket maximums and lower copays than standard Silver plans. Trumps Executive order eliminates the Federal subsidies that make these plans possible.

Don't worry about it. Obamacare is collapsing (it has been collapsing since it was effectively enacted) and Trump is going to get those people who can't afford healthcare insurance great or even greatest healthcare the world has ever known insurance and cheap too.

Will it actually be cheap and great healthcare insurance? Highly unlikely. If Trump and Republicans had their way people could either get great healthcare insurance that's really expensive or they can get terrible junk health insurance that's really cheap doesn't really cower anything and might as well not really exist.

The basic idea is simply that you get what you pay for and if you can't afford to pay for you health needs then other people, most importantly the rich ones, shouldn't have to pay any taxes whatsoever to help pay for your healthcare.
 
Last edited:
The basic idea is simply that you get what you pay for and if you can't afford to pay for you health needs then other people, most importantly the rich ones, shouldn't have to pay any taxes whatsoever to help pay for your healthcare.

Yup, and in order to avoid admitting why they were obsessed with "repeal and replace," Republicans were forced to lie about what their bills would actually do. Now, they'll try the same tactic with "tax reform."
 
I posted this in the wrong thread, so here you go:

https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2017/10/12/presidential-executive-order-promoting-healthcare-choice-and-competition

If I'm reading this right, Trump has "ordered" HHS to "consider" doing some things?

Expanding access to associations isn't really a bad idea. The ACA small group market is super tiny, not affordable, and fraught with problems. Associations still have to cover the EHB, and still have to hit the minimum 60% AV that large employers are subject to... but they do get much better bargaining power.

Short Term benefits... mmm... There's a role for them, but it's still pretty much a bad idea. I mean, if you're healthy and you're only going to be without coverage for a short period of time (between jobs, for example), it's not necessarily bad to have access to limited benefits. But they're definitely not a replacement for comprehensive coverage. That bears close watching.

I have no objection to HRAs, and without some actual information on *what* Trump is thinking with respect to them, I have no opinion on this at all.
 
And now potentially even bigger news than the executive order:


Trump will scrap critical Obamacare subsidy

So it's now official I take it.

White house doesn't have the executive order posted. I found one from yesterday pertaining to ACA - extending access to associations and limited benefit plans... but I couldn't find anything about removing the subsidies. Maybe it's just not posted yet.
 
Most Americans get health insurance from their employers. Only a small fraction buy individual policies from the exchange. They will not be directly affected by Trump's latest action.

I wouldn't be so sure of that. Companies are going to have to make up the lost revenue from the CSRs somewhere. If there aren't enough unsubsidized people buying plans in the market, where else are they going to find that revenue?
 
I wouldn't be so sure of that. Companies are going to have to make up the lost revenue from the CSRs somewhere. If there aren't enough unsubsidized people buying plans in the market, where else are they going to find that revenue?

It really is unclear what will happen. Customers on the exchange will sign up for the plans, creating a legally binding contract between them and the insurance company. The insurance company will not get the CSR payments that make the plans profitable.

Seems to me that the insurance companies will be going to court to get this fixed.
 
It really is unclear what will happen. Customers on the exchange will sign up for the plans, creating a legally binding contract between them and the insurance company. The insurance company will not get the CSR payments that make the plans profitable.

Seems to me that the insurance companies will be going to court to get this fixed.

They're not going to wait for a court decision that could take years (that they could lose) to address the revenue gap. Everyone is going to get screwed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom