Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Okay, let's clear up some stuff with real information...

The shrinking open enrollment period is not new. It's been planned to shrink so that it is in alignment with Medicare open enrollment since the inception of ACA. In fact, in 2014, the enrollment period was artificially extended by an additional 2 months, and by 1 month in 2015. This year, after four years in practice, the enrollment period is down to 45 days. For comparison, Medicare Advantage has an enrollment period of 53 days.
......


According to the link, the enrollment period was shortened prematurely.
A narrowed enrollment window — from three months to 45 days — was planned by the Obama administration for the approximately three dozen states that rely on the federal insurance exchange. But the change was to have begun for 2019 coverage; instead, the Health and Human Services Department announced in April that it would take effect for the sign-up period starting Nov. 1.

With so much in flux, maintaining a longer enrollment period could only help people get coverage, and shortening it can only discourage people from signing up, which is Trump's goal, right? Is the goal to get consumers enrolled, or to shrink the program?
 
According to the link, the enrollment period was shortened prematurely.
The link seems to be incorrect, at least according to the law:
https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/155.410
(e)Annual open enrollment period.

(1) For the benefit year beginning on January 1, 2015, the annual open enrollment period begins on November 15, 2014, and extends through February 15, 2015.

(2) For the benefit years beginning on January 1, 2016 and January 1, 2017, the annual open enrollment period begins on November 1 of the calendar year preceding the benefit year, and extends through January 31 of the benefit year.

(3) For the benefit years beginning on or after January 1, 2018, the annual open enrollment period begins on November 1 and extends through December 15 of the calendar year preceding the benefit year.


With so much in flux, maintaining a longer enrollment period could only help people get coverage, and shortening it can only discourage people from signing up, which is Trump's goal, right? Is the goal to get consumers enrolled, or to shrink the program?
Meh. My observation has been that allowing open enrollment to extend into the effective year hasn't had any real effect on people's selections or decision-making. All it's done is encourage people to game the system.

I don't really care about Trump's goals. Most of his goals regarding ACA are stupid. But on the other hand, ACA is a pretty bad plan already. Accelerationism is idiotic... but ACA was never going to be long-term sustainable in its existing form anyway. So pretty much, it's going to suck.
 
.....
Meh. My observation has been that allowing open enrollment to extend into the effective year hasn't had any real effect on people's selections or decision-making. All it's done is encourage people to game the system.
....

How does anybody "game the system?" They buy insurance or they don't. They qualify for a subsidy or they don't. The ACA is intended to make health insurance available to the small percentage of the population that doesn't get it from their employer, or from Medicare, Medicaid or the VA. It should be obvious that people without jobs, often because they have medical problems, are generally less sophisticated and more vulnerable than the rest of us. Providing information and assistance in understanding their options is an important and legitimate function -- and Trump has dramatically cut those services:
In Indianapolis, the director of the state’s largest organization helping people find Affordable Care Act insurance had to lay off nine of 13 staff members last month because the federal government had just taken away more than 80 percent of the grant that paid for their work.

In Atlanta, festivalgoers at the annual Pride weekend in mid-October were mystified that members of Insure Georgia had a table set up, because they thought President Trump had gotten rid of the health-care law.

And across Ohio, residents starting to phone a call center for appointments with coaches to renew their coverage are being told that the service no longer exists and that, for help, they should go to a website, a hotline, an insurance broker, a county health department or — if all else fails — their member of Congress.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/nati...6288544af98_story.html?utm_term=.b6556458ec66

Note also that the original ACA plan was to expand Medicaid in every state, and for every state to establish its own insurance exchange. The states that did those things seem to have expanded coverage pretty successfully. If the ACA is hurting, it's largely because of the states that rejected it.
 
According to this, current enrollees will be auto re-upped before they have a chance to change if they want:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...=.98482d9021c3
Your link says the auto re-up will take place at the end of the enrollment season, which is Dec 15. I suppose someone could get caught out if they waited until the last second, and they somehow didn't know that they needed to shop for a new plan, if they wanted a new plan. I don't see it as a big factor though, at least not as big as Trump is hoping.
 
Your link says the auto re-up will take place at the end of the enrollment season, which is Dec 15. I suppose someone could get caught out if they waited until the last second, and they somehow didn't know that they needed to shop for a new plan, if they wanted a new plan. I don't see it as a big factor though, at least not as big as Trump is hoping.

I think the question is what are current enrollees being told? If they get a notice telling them "Your current coverage will be renewed automatically" vs. "Your current coverage will be renewed automatically unless you choose a different plan before Dec. 15. For information about all the plans available to you, go to...." the consumer gets a different picture. Information is everything, and it should be obvious that, even among people who are already covered, there has been a lot of confusion and misinformation.
 
Last edited:
How does anybody "game the system?"
By not paying for their insurance in December, and not signing up for their next year's insurance to start until February or March. People are required to have insurance... but only for 10 out of 12 months. So they take the risk for two months to avoid the premiums, skip in at the last minute for effective dates, and essentially get a full year's coverage. Because if anything goes wrong in December or January, they can just be "late" on their premium payments.

Note also that the original ACA plan was to expand Medicaid in every state, and for every state to establish its own insurance exchange. The states that did those things seem to have expanded coverage pretty successfully. If the ACA is hurting, it's largely because of the states that rejected it.

No, not really. Washington expanded Medicaid and built their own exchange, and there were several counties that were going to be without any coverage at all. The WA OIC negotiated with a handful of carriers to get them to pick up those counties, but I believe a bit under half the counties in WA have only one carrier, and all but around 5 or 6 have only two choices.

It's not just states that didn't expand Medicaid that are having a tough time of it.
 
By not paying for their insurance in December, and not signing up for their next year's insurance to start until February or March. People are required to have insurance... but only for 10 out of 12 months. So they take the risk for two months to avoid the premiums, skip in at the last minute for effective dates, and essentially get a full year's coverage. Because if anything goes wrong in December or January, they can just be "late" on their premium payments.

Who does that? What percentage of ACA consumers do that? And if that's a problem, how does is it solved by making it harder to get information?

....
No, not really. Washington expanded Medicaid and built their own exchange, and there were several counties that were going to be without any coverage at all. The WA OIC negotiated with a handful of carriers to get them to pick up those counties, but I believe a bit under half the counties in WA have only one carrier, and all but around 5 or 6 have only two choices.

It's not just states that didn't expand Medicaid that are having a tough time of it.

So before the ACA, what percentage of Washington residents did not have health coverage? And what is that percentage after it was fully implemented? If more people are covered, that's success, even if it's not perfection.

This county-based coverage has never made much sense and could be fixed administratively. If rural counties without a lot of customers could be left without carriers, the obvious solution is to create multi-county, regional or state-wide coverage groups. If the Republicans can promote selling insurance across state lines, with all the problems that would cause, it shouldn't be hard to get support for selling/buying across county lines.
 
Who does that? What percentage of ACA consumers do that? And if that's a problem, how does is it solved by making it harder to get information?
About 5% of the policyholders in my company, last year. It was worse in prior years.

Presence or lack of information has nothing to do with this though. This is due to the length of the open enrollment period.

So before the ACA, what percentage of Washington residents did not have health coverage? And what is that percentage after it was fully implemented? If more people are covered, that's success, even if it's not perfection.
In WA, the size of the individual market has been pretty even at about 450K the whole time I've been involved... which is going on about 12 years now. ACA didn't increase the individual market. What changes in the uninsured market occurred were a result of expanded Medicaid... which is not affected by the lack of advertising, nor by the shortened open enrollment period.

The same can't necessarily be assumed for other states. WA already had fairly stringent community rating rules, with minimal ability for insurers to deny coverage, so the shift to ACA didn't have as much of an impact as it did elsewhere.

This county-based coverage has never made much sense and could be fixed administratively. If rural counties without a lot of customers could be left without carriers, the obvious solution is to create multi-county, regional or state-wide coverage groups. If the Republicans can promote selling insurance across state lines, with all the problems that would cause, it shouldn't be hard to get support for selling/buying across county lines.
Great idea. Now all you have to do is convince the hospitals that have monopoly power in those rural counties to bring their prices down to a reasonable level...

Let me know when you've sorted that, would you?
 
I think the question is what are current enrollees being told? If they get a notice telling them "Your current coverage will be renewed automatically" vs. "Your current coverage will be renewed automatically unless you choose a different plan before Dec. 15. For information about all the plans available to you, go to...." the consumer gets a different picture. Information is everything, and it should be obvious that, even among people who are already covered, there has been a lot of confusion and misinformation.
I'm a current enrollee. Like EC says, they send you a packet with all the info. Also there is a constant bombardment of emails, I don't know if it will be the same this year, but I have gotten two already. They encourage you to shop for another policy, and tell you that your old policy will auto-up if you don't. Also you get communications from your insurance company.

Yes there has been confusion, and Trump is doing his best to sabotage the ACA, but I'm confident that by the time open enrollment starts on Wednesday few if any current enrollees will be unaware of their options. New enrollees are a different matter, I'm sure a number of them think that Obamacare is dead. Not.
 
.....
Great idea. Now all you have to do is convince the hospitals that have monopoly power in those rural counties to bring their prices down to a reasonable level...

Let me know when you've sorted that, would you?

Why should they have monopoly power? Wouldn't expanding the coverage area to give consumers more choices reduce that monopoly power? Could they maintain unreasonable prices if consumers could get a better deal by traveling to other providers a little farther away?
 
Why should they have monopoly power? Wouldn't expanding the coverage area to give consumers more choices reduce that monopoly power? Could they maintain unreasonable prices if consumers could get a better deal by traveling to other providers a little farther away?

Most rural areas only have one hospital to choose from. How much choice do you really think there is when the next closest hospital is 40 miles away, and you need surgery? Let alone for an emergency.

Honestly, the only people who have any sort of real 'choice' of hospitals and other major facilities are those who live in densely populated urban areas, and maybe some sprawl-filled suburbs.
 
Last edited:
Most rural areas only have one hospital to choose from. How much choice do you really think there is when the next closest hospital is 40 miles away, and you need surgery? Let alone for an emergency.
.....

If it's elective surgery, maybe 40 miles or more isn't too far to travel for better service and/or a better price. People travel from all over the world to the Mayo Clinic, the Cleveland Clinic etc. At least expanding the coverage area would give consumers the choice, and the very existence of that choice might have an impact on the local providers.

It might also create an incentive for some of those farther-away hospitals to create free-standing emergency rooms and clinics in rural areas to compete with the monopoly provider.
 
If it's elective surgery, maybe 40 miles or more isn't too far to travel for better service and/or a better price. People travel from all over the world to the Mayo Clinic, the Cleveland Clinic etc. At least expanding the coverage area would give consumers the choice, and the very existence of that choice might have an impact on the local providers.

It might also create an incentive for some of those farther-away hospitals to create free-standing emergency rooms and clinics in rural areas to compete with the monopoly provider.

I really think you're missing a key point here. Elective surgery, maybe, but that's stretching it. Even so, you've got to arrange for a significant amount more travel. Follow-up visits are going to pretty seriously interfere; instead of taking an hour or two off of work, you need to take a whole day. And of course, if you need an MRI or an X-ray, that's a whole day off work too.

I genuinely don't think you've given a lot of thought to how competition would work in health care.

How far are you willing to drive in order to get an X-ray? How much of a cost differential would you need to see in order to be willing to drive that far? How is that going to coordinate with your workday? What if you need someone to go with you?

Nah. We need to either nationalize the hospitals and make all doctors salaried... or the government needs to impose a quality-based fee structure on them.
 
....
Nah. We need to either nationalize the hospitals and make all doctors salaried... or the government needs to impose a quality-based fee structure on them.

Universal single-payer would be the goal, although a nationalized health care system like the UK is just one model, and maybe not the best. Meanwhile, it should be possible for state regulators to do something about unreasonable hospital fees in rural areas. And if the insurers say "We'll pay you the same rates we pay University Hospital in Big City, but no more," what are they going to do? Only take self-paying patients? Shut down? Is everybody really intimidated by rural providers? I ask again, why wouldn't better insurance coverage create an incentive for alternative providers to offer services?
 
Universal single-payer would be the goal, although a nationalized health care system like the UK is just one model, and maybe not the best. Meanwhile, it should be possible for state regulators to do something about unreasonable hospital fees in rural areas. And if the insurers say "We'll pay you the same rates we pay University Hospital in Big City, but no more," what are they going to do? Only take self-paying patients? Shut down? Is everybody really intimidated by rural providers? I ask again, why wouldn't better insurance coverage create an incentive for alternative providers to offer services?

State regulators don't regulate hospital fees. It's a bit of a gap.
 
State regulators don't regulate hospital fees. It's a bit of a gap.

They might not set fees ("you can charge this much") but I suspect that unusual behavior regarding fees, billing etc. could have an impact on whether a provider maintains and renews its license.
 
They might not set fees ("you can charge this much") but I suspect that unusual behavior regarding fees, billing etc. could have an impact on whether a provider maintains and renews its license.

Not to my knowledge, no. There is no legal requirement for providers to use reasonable pricing. Fraud might impact them, but high prices? Not really.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom