Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

It’s kind of stupid poker he is playing, thinking Democrats will play along and come up with Trumpcare. Every Trump or Republican plan will have tax deduction in place of subsidies. The American way!

But the game is up. Dems will not play, as they know Trump is a one term president.

http://www.politico.com/story/2017/10/13/trump-responds-ends-obamacare-subsidy-243743?lo=ap_a1

Trump thinks people will believe him that he's not to blame for sabotaging Obamacare. Unfortunately for him he's wrong and he will take flak for this.
 
How do you test for "the reason for the appeal is "I lost."" ?

A forum of legal experts across broad spectrum of politics with expertise in appeals reading the appeals documents combined with journalists bringing to the forum quotes on background from the parties involved in the appeal.

That is just a brainstorm though.
 
If it is illegal payments then it is Obamacare imploding on its own. You can't expect new management to carry on an illegal scheme.

The President isn’t a King or an Emperor. They do not have the authority to unilaterally decide what things should be legal and what shouldn’t.
 
The President isn’t a King or an Emperor. They do not have the authority to unilaterally decide what things should be legal and what shouldn’t.

A) they have a judge's decision to point to. All three branches of government is in agreement on this.

B) the president is the ultimate arbiter of what is Constitutional for the executive branch. departmentalism vs judicial supremcy.
 
Last edited:
Beyond the legal question, I'm wondering when people start losing their insurance, will they blame the Republicans/Trump or the Democrats?

On my good days I think they will make the Republicans responsible on my cynical days they will fall for Trump's BS that its the democrats fault.
 
Beyond the legal question, I'm wondering when people start losing their insurance, will they blame the Republicans/Trump or the Democrats?

On my good days I think they will make the Republicans responsible on my cynical days they will fall for Trump's BS that its the democrats fault.

It's always the Democrats fault. Always. If the Democrats hand't managed to pass the ACA, then the Republicans wouldn't have been forced to take away peoples Health Insurance.

See? Democrats fault.
 
It's always the Democrats fault. Always. If the Democrats hand't managed to pass the ACA, then the Republicans wouldn't have been forced to take away peoples Health Insurance.

See? Democrats fault.

According to the GOP of course it will be the Democrat's fault, for introducing the ACA in the first place, for not being compliant enough on repeal and replace and a million other things.

OTOH public opinion appears to veering towards it being the GOP's fault if they lose their healthcare
 
Which judge btw ?

"On May 12, 2016, Judge Rosemary Collyer of the federal district court for the District of Columbia decided that the Obama administration cannot constitutionally reimburse insurers for the costs they incur in fulfilling their obligation under the ACA to reduce cost sharing for marketplace enrollees with incomes below 250 percent of the poverty level. Judge Collyer found that Congress has not specifically appropriated money for this purpose."
 
"On May 12, 2016, Judge Rosemary Collyer of the federal district court for the District of Columbia decided that the Obama administration cannot constitutionally reimburse insurers for the costs they incur in fulfilling their obligation under the ACA to reduce cost sharing for marketplace enrollees with incomes below 250 percent of the poverty level. Judge Collyer found that Congress has not specifically appropriated money for this purpose."

Thank you, saved me a search.:thumbsup:
 
A) they have a judge's decision to point to. All three branches of government is in agreement on this.
That isn’t how the judicial system works. You don’t get to go searching for the one judge that agrees with you then insist that’s all that matters.
A) B) the president is the ultimate arbiter of what is Constitutional for the executive branch.
The role of interpreting the constitution belongs to the judiciary. Neither the executive branch nor the President is entitled to do so.
 
That isn’t how the judicial system works. You don’t get to go searching for the one judge that agrees with you then insist that’s all that matters.

The role of interpreting the constitution belongs to the judiciary. Neither the executive branch nor the President is entitled to do so.

It is the one judge the case went before. It was a suit by Congress against the president. You can't shop for a district in that situation.
 
Re: The ongoing court case involving subsidies to the ACA....

I have little patience for appeals that sound like the reason for the appeal is "I lost."
In that case how do you feel about the Trump administration appealing court rulings against his travel ban? Were those just set up because "I (meaning Trump) lost"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom