Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Workers comp is definitely a mess.
Not to play devil's advocate, but it's not exactly an apples to apples comparison with regular health insurance, because in some instances, employees have increased incentive to want to abuse it. Benefits of use include time off work, with pay, free drugs, etc.


These are benefits of many "regular (if there is such a thing) insurance policies as well. and no less easily abused when from those sources.

Worker's Comp is an insurance policy itself. Nothing more, nothing less.

If anything WC may be harder to get adequate compensation from. It is generally controlled by state legislatures, whose interests are generally aligned with the businesses who participate in the plan.

WC is just as liable to result in decreased care and compensation.

Underreporting of injuries is a significant problem in the workers' compensation system.[44] Workers, fearing retaliation from their employers, may avoid reporting injuries incurred on the job and instead seek treatment privately, bearing the cost themselves or passing these costs on to their health insurance provider – an element in the increasing cost of health insurance nationwide.[45]
I'm not sure how pervasive such abuse is, but in my (albeit limited) experience, abuse of this system can be significant.


If your experience is limited how do you know that the abuse can be significant?
 
Now instead of just killing me, they want to bankrupt me first and THEN kill me.

Nice.

....and then they would like to take any tax money saved as a result and instead of reducing the deficit and/or paying down the debt, they're going to give that money to people who need it most - multimillionaires :rolleyes:
 
Now instead of just killing me, they want to bankrupt me first and THEN kill me.

Nice.

Every time they go back to the drawing board it gets worse. I think it might have to do with the starting premise of their health care bills being obtaining tax cuts for rich. That doesn't seem like the right motivation to have when writing health care legislation.
 
Every time they go back to the drawing board it gets worse. I think it might have to do with the starting premise of their health care bills being obtaining tax cuts for rich. That doesn't seem like the right motivation to have when writing health care legislation.

Hopefully the Graham bill doesn't go very far.

I always thought the best way to get common sense healthcare for all is to do away with subsidized healthcare from employers. Make EVERYONE pay for healthcare and see how pissed off everyone gets.
 

That doesn't seem to be the case, but I haven't done a lot of research yet. It appears that the Graham-Cassidy bill would allow insurers to not cover costs related to *some* pre-existing conditions... but I don't know which conditions or in which situations at present. It does not seem to allow insurers to increase premiums for them.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/politics/cassidy-graham-explainer/?utm_term=.24d3205e7049
 
That doesn't seem to be the case, but I haven't done a lot of research yet. It appears that the Graham-Cassidy bill would allow insurers to not cover costs related to *some* pre-existing conditions... but I don't know which conditions or in which situations at present. It does not seem to allow insurers to increase premiums for them.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/politics/cassidy-graham-explainer/?utm_term=.24d3205e7049

Not sure which bill you are reading, but a "surcharge" as opposed to an increase in premiums is a distinction without a difference.
 
Has it ever been presented, in any way, by Republican congresspeople or any of their supporters, how these bills will actually be a good thing that we need/would want? I mean, we all know that the only reasons for these are to erase Obama from the history books and to give rich people tax cuts and not to actually improve normal people's lives, but how are they actually selling this? Or are they not even trying, giving us a giant "screw you"?
 
Has it ever been presented, in any way, by Republican congresspeople or any of their supporters, how these bills will actually be a good thing that we need/would want? I mean, we all know that the only reasons for these are to erase Obama from the history books and to give rich people tax cuts and not to actually improve normal people's lives, but how are they actually selling this? Or are they not even trying, giving us a giant "screw you"?

By promising to screw over minorities much worse.
 
Has it ever been presented, in any way, by Republican congresspeople or any of their supporters, how these bills will actually be a good thing that we need/would want? I mean, we all know that the only reasons for these are to erase Obama from the history books and to give rich people tax cuts and not to actually improve normal people's lives, but how are they actually selling this? Or are they not even trying, giving us a giant "screw you"?

I've actually asked the same type of question. When it comes to the healthcare legislation, I have to ask

1) What is the objective of the legislation, and
2) To what extent does this legislation achieve that objective?

During the campaign, the president claimed they were going to cover everyone and do it cheap. That sounds like goals to me, and I consider them reasonable goals, in fact.

Now, how does this legislation achieve that? Oh, wait....

Apparently, this bill does a terrible job of addressing the goal. Either that, or the goal is not what the president said...

The only goal is "repeal Obamacare." That's it. It has no other objective, and it doesn't matter how bad it is.
 
Not sure which bill you are reading, but a "surcharge" as opposed to an increase in premiums is a distinction without a difference.

I've re-read that article three times now. I'm not seeing any reference to surcharges related to pre-existing conditions in there anywhere. Can you give me a specific quote or reference?
 
This is a mess. The information available about this bill is really confused.

Anyway, an invisible high risk pool is actually a very good idea, provided it is set up and funded appropriately. It's something that was in serious consideration prior to ACA, and was proposed several times as a solution for when the federal reinsurance program sunset in 2016. The analysis I was involved in estimated the fees needed to administer the program as being around $3 PMPM for all covered lives in the state. The key is that the cost burden of very expensive illnesses would be spread throughout the entire state, not localized in the Individual pool. The individual pool has a higher incidence rate of severe conditions, because they frequently interfere with a person's ability to work (hence their ability to get employer-provided medical coverage).

Invisible high risk pools are just that - invisible. The covered individual doesn't even know that their costs are being pooled. They receive the same benefits, at the same cost, as any other person on that plan. The insurer cedes their premiums to the HRP, the HRP adds those premiums to the assessed fees collected from everyone else, and uses those fees to cover the cost of services delivered. The HRP reimburses the cost of services to the insurer. The person being funded this way has no idea it's even happening.

It would allow the premiums in the Individual market to be lower overall, as well as being more stable.

Of course, the devil is in the details. How the process is designed and administered can make or break it. As soon as I find some solid info on this bill, I'll give it a once-over.
 
I've re-read that article three times now. I'm not seeing any reference to surcharges related to pre-existing conditions in there anywhere. Can you give me a specific quote or reference?

The Post article was behind a paywall. Try this. I believed your previous post was saying the premiums wouldn't be different for pre-existing conditions.

https://www.americanprogress.org/is...lode-premiums-people-pre-existing-conditions/

ETA: Sorry, that article I believe was regarding the previous Republican plan. However, it appears the new one is worse than the one in April.
 
Last edited:
Has it ever been presented, in any way, by Republican congresspeople or any of their supporters, how these bills will actually be a good thing that we need/would want? I mean, we all know that the only reasons for these are to erase Obama from the history books and to give rich people tax cuts and not to actually improve normal people's lives, but how are they actually selling this? Or are they not even trying, giving us a giant "screw you"?

Their entire presentation is "Obamacare bad, repeal it." They don't need to present their base anything factual to convince them of this. Oh, and they can't present anything factual because facts do not support their case.
 
Vox asked nine Republican Senators supporting Graham-Cassidy how it will help patients. Not one of them could do it.

“They can do it with less money,” said Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-OK), who was unable to explain how or why.

Other Republican senators, meanwhile, fell back on political explanations for a bill that experts warn could result in millions losing their insurance. “If we do nothing, it has a tremendous impact on the 2018 elections,” said Sen. Pat Roberts (R-KS). “And whether or not Republicans still maintain control and we have the gavel.”

And then some members of the upper chamber acknowledged that the spending changes might have a big impact, but argued their home states would not be negatively impacted. “Four of our states are getting a disproportionate amount of money from health care now,” Sen. Richard Shelby (R-AL) said. The bill, he added, “wouldn’t cut Alabama.” (Numbers from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities suggest Alabama would receive more than $1 billion in additional funding under the bill, but most states would see big cuts.)

Also, I'm pretty sure Pat Robets hasn't seem Thelma and Louise recently or possibly at all.
 
Paul Krugman assesses the new proposal:
In reality, Graham-Cassidy is the opposite of moderate. It contains, in exaggerated and almost caricature form, all the elements that made previous Republican proposals so cruel and destructive. It would eliminate the individual mandate, undermine if not effectively eliminate protection for people with pre-existing conditions, and slash funding for subsidies and Medicaid. There are a few additional twists, but they’re all bad — notably, a funding formula that would penalize states that are actually successful in reducing the number of uninsured.
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/18/...region&WT.nav=opinion-c-col-right-region&_r=0
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom