Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Does this mean that if someone with regular health insurance goes to a doctor and says "I broke my arm, fix it," they will ask him if it happened on the job and turn him away if he says "yes," or that he will file a claim for his treatment that his insurer will reject, or what? I understand that the employer is responsible for injuries in the workplace, but isn't who pays a question to be fought out by the patient's insurance company vs. the employer's? How is the patient's treatment affected?

Yes. A primary care doctor will turn away patients that present for WC-related claims if the doc does not participate in the WC system. Regular health insurance does not pay for WC claims. You can bill them for it, but as soon as they find out it's related to WC, they recoup whatever they paid you and the doc has no recourse. At least in Texas, WC must be provided by the WC network*.

An ER, where they should go for a broken arm, will not turn them away because WC covers such ER care.

*We often get our regular patients who get hurt on the job. We do not participate in WC so we refer those patients to a specialized workers comp clinic. There are some rare companies who do not provide WC insurance and in those cases the company can pay us directly.
 
The stock market crashed on September 29, 2008 -- before Obama was elected, much less inaugurated.

And your point is?

House republicans were attacking the SCR payments in early 2016 - Forbes reported on it in April:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2016/01/14/why-the-house-lawsuit-over-cost-sharing-reductions-might-win-but-wont-kill-obamacare/#123498c569db

Courts ruled in favor of the Republican suit in May:
http://www.healthlawnext.com/2016/05/court-sides-house-representatives-aca-cost-sharing-subsidy-challenge/

Are you saying it's Trump's fault because what... he didn't oppose the thing that was in the works before election day?

Seriously, we've got plenty to blame Trump for. This isn't one of them. This is pretty squarely on the House GOP in 2016 and on the courts.
 
Welcome to the unregulated free market. Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times and in some cases it can render a market completely dysfunctional. Markets for health insurance are particularly susceptible, which is a big reason why multi-payer systems haven’t worked unless they are highly regulated and contain things like individual mandates to have insurance.

:confused: Workers Comp and Health Insurance are some of the most highly regulated markets in the US. And neither comes anywhere close to qualifying as a free market, regardless of the regulations.
 
How do you get that from “Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times”? This is an example of business doing what they always do and try to offload expenses to someone else. They will do so wherever and whenever they are allowed, which is why some marketplaces simply can’t function without heavy regulation.

I’m not sure how that’s confusing or difficult to understand unless you are being intentionally obtuse.

I'd guess he got it from:
Workers comp claims in the US are messy. They end up involving a lot of subrogation between WC and the injurer's medical insurance. And in many states, the employer is charged for those claims. The biggest problem with workers comp claims, imo, is that they're pretty much entirely run by lawyers trying to make sure it's someone else's fault.
Welcome to the unregulated free market. Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times and in some cases it can render a market completely dysfunctional. Markets for health insurance are particularly susceptible, which is a big reason why multi-payer systems haven’t worked unless they are highly regulated and contain things like individual mandates to have insurance.
 
Welcome to the unregulated free market. Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times and in some cases it can render a market completely dysfunctional. Markets for health insurance are particularly susceptible, which is a big reason why multi-payer systems haven’t worked unless they are highly regulated and contain things like individual mandates to have insurance.

I don't think Emily's Cat knows much about industrial insurance. Lawyers are rarely involved and it's the states that are the insurers, only the largest employers are self insured, the rest pay premiums to the state based on their claim history.

In a no-fault system, workers cannot sue the employer except in the most flagrant negligence cases, and at the same time, employers can only deny the claim under very limited circumstances such as proving the injury did not occur on the job.
 
Last edited:
Does this mean that if someone with regular health insurance goes to a doctor and says "I broke my arm, fix it," they will ask him if it happened on the job and turn him away if he says "yes," or that he will file a claim for his treatment that his insurer will reject, or what? I understand that the employer is responsible for injuries in the workplace, but isn't who pays a question to be fought out by the patient's insurance company vs. the employer's? How is the patient's treatment affected?

Generally, medical insurance will cover the immediate treatment, and will seek subrogation and recovery from the liable party. So if there is a worker's comp claim filed, the medical insurer will recover the cost of claims paid from the WC carrier. Similarly, if the injury occurred in an auto accident, the medical insurer will seek to recover the cost of claims from the auto insurer.

But there's often quite a bit of contention behind the scenes. WC acts on behalf of the employer, their incentive is to protect the finances of the employer and minimize inappropriate expenditures. The will take every feasible step to investigate whether a WC claim is fully justified and the proper liability of the employer. It can get very messy.

In contrast, the medical and auto insurance are both acting on behalf of the covered life, so subrogation between auto and medical is often less invasive. Not always, but often.
 
This is just the old "blame the worker who got hurt" crap. See above - a "perk" of workman's comp is that it is an opportunity to skip work and get paid for it?

Yeah, you get to skip work. but you have to get hurt on the job! So worth it for a vacation, right?

Workers are injured on the job. It's not a *********** vacation.
 
There isn't any increased incentive to abuse it even though I listed 3 additional incentives to abuse it?

time off work, with pay, free drugs, etc.

Drug seeking is just as prevalent outside of the industrial insurance system. Time off work with sick leave or vacation pay doesn't require an on the job injury.

The two systems are very different, though, not saying they aren't. But there are more than a few false statements about industrial insurance in this thread that shouldn't go unchallenged.
 
This is just the old "blame the worker who got hurt" crap. See above - a "perk" of workman's comp is that it is an opportunity to skip work and get paid for it?

Yeah, you get to skip work. but you have to get hurt on the job! So worth it for a vacation, right?

Workers are injured on the job. It's not a *********** vacation.

Again, Emily's Cat doesn't know what s/he's talking about. Rather than paying a medical bill and seeking reimbursement from the state, an insurer will simply reject the claim, referring the injured employee to file for WC benefits instead.
 
Generally, medical insurance will cover the immediate treatment, and will seek subrogation and recovery from the liable party. So if there is a worker's comp claim filed, the medical insurer will recover the cost of claims paid from the WC carrier. Similarly, if the injury occurred in an auto accident, the medical insurer will seek to recover the cost of claims from the auto insurer.

But there's often quite a bit of contention behind the scenes. WC acts on behalf of the employer, their incentive is to protect the finances of the employer and minimize inappropriate expenditures. The will take every feasible step to investigate whether a WC claim is fully justified and the proper liability of the employer. It can get very messy.

In contrast, the medical and auto insurance are both acting on behalf of the covered life, so subrogation between auto and medical is often less invasive. Not always, but often.
At some point did a committee sit down and create the most complicated and Kafkaesque system for healthcare provision possible in this universe?
 
Again, Emily's Cat doesn't know what s/he's talking about. Rather than paying a medical bill and seeking reimbursement from the state, an insurer will simply reject the claim, referring the injured employee to file for WC benefits instead.

Not always. We've had patients who don't tell us that they got hurt at work, the insurance pays as usual and then later we get asked for a recoupment. For Medicare/Medicaid and several other insurers, Third Party Recovery is a thing - they don't recoup from us; sometimes they seek recovery from the WC insurance or employer.

It all depends on several factors and there is no consistency. Thanks, government! ;)
 
I don't think Emily's Cat knows much about industrial insurance. Lawyers are rarely involved and it's the states that are the insurers, only the largest employers are self insured, the rest pay premiums to the state based on their claim history.
The States are not always the insurer. In Texas, the State is just the regulatory agency and there are private WC insurers that provide mandated benefits. We have many small businesses that do not carry WC insurance and are self-insured -our clinic included.
 
At some point did a committee sit down and create the most complicated and Kafkaesque system for healthcare provision possible in this universe?

Sure... in the same way that committee sat down and created the most complicated and Kafkaesque system for internal organs. This is the outcome of evolution, albeit with economic and financial systems rather than with genetics.
 
Again, Emily's Cat doesn't know what s/he's talking about. Rather than paying a medical bill and seeking reimbursement from the state, an insurer will simply reject the claim, referring the injured employee to file for WC benefits instead.

And again, Skeptic Ginger, who can't do me the courtesy of addressing me directly, is expressing incomplete knowledge. If the claim is KNOWN to be a WC claim, the medical insurer will reject the claim and direct it to WC. But in many cases, the injury is treated BEFORE the WC case has been opened or has been determined to be a WC liability.

For a very large number of medical services, the provider is not going to deny care to the patient, regardless of who is liable for the damages. The medical insurer is not going to deny payment to the provider until AFTER the claim has already been determined to be the liability of WC. The health insurer will continue to pay the provider and provide coverage under the terms of their contract until such time as a WC case has been opened.

As soon as a WC claim is opened, THEN the health insurer will deny claims and direct the injured individual to file them with the WC carrier. The WC carrier holds the liability for injuries that occurred on the job.

Not surprisingly, Emily's Cat actually knows a whole lot about how health insurance and secondary payers, including subrogated recovery of third-party liability works.
 
Not always. We've had patients who don't tell us that they got hurt at work, the insurance pays as usual and then later we get asked for a recoupment. For Medicare/Medicaid and several other insurers, Third Party Recovery is a thing - they don't recoup from us; sometimes they seek recovery from the WC insurance or employer.

It all depends on several factors and there is no consistency. Thanks, government! ;)
But it's not the norm that EC mistakenly described it as.
 
The States are not always the insurer. In Texas, the State is just the regulatory agency and there are private WC insurers that provide mandated benefits.

So?

Are you defending his/her mistaken representation of the WC system with these nitpicks?

We have many small businesses that do not carry WC insurance and are self-insured -our clinic included.
How do your 'small businesses' afford to be self insured? What kind of state allows an underfunded insurer to cover on-the-job injuries? How would a small employer pay out a million dollar claim, say if someone was very seriously injured?

The TX WC system looks pretty standard.
Workers' compensation is a state-regulated insurance program that pays medical bills and replaces some lost wages for employees who are injured at work or who have work-related diseases or illnesses. It also protects covered employers from civil suit brought by the injured worker. The Texas Workers' Compensation Act states that recovery of Workers' Compensation benefits is a covered employee's or a legal beneficiary's exclusive remedy against the employer for a work-related injury sustained by the employee or the death of the employee.

In light of that, this makes no sense:
According to a 1996 survey by the Texas Research and Oversight Council on Workers' Compensation (ROC), approximately two-fifths of Texas employers do not carry Workers' Compensation coverage. Most large employers tend to carry it, while small employers may not. Overall, an estimated 80 percent of the Texas workforce is covered under the worker's compensation system.
Until you look at this:
Who is Not Covered

Workers employed by the federal government fall outside Texas law. Claims for these workers follow different procedures. Federal employees claims are processed by the U.S. Department of Labor, and personnel working on military bases claims are processed by the U.S. Department of Defense. Other categories of workers not covered under Texas law are:

Workers employed on offshore drilling rigs and ships, and those involved in loading or unloading sea vessels (covered under specific federal laws, and their claims are handled by commercial insurance carriers);
Domestic or incidental household workers; and
Family members working on their farms and ranches.
That is also standard. We were not discussing exempt employers.

Nor were we discussing non-WC covered injuries. TX looks like it's WC system is full of holes.
The workers least likely to be covered are those in retail trade and agriculture. Only about half the employers in these industries, according to a survey by the ROC, provide Workers' Compensation insurance for their employees.
That simply says TX refuses to protect workers.

This does make sense:
The second option, certified self-insurance, is open only to those private-sector employers who can meet financial and safety requirements. They must obtain a certificate to that effect from TWCC. An updated list of certified self-insured employers is published monthly on the TWCC Web site.


Bottom line, regardless of TX leaving a lot of injured workers out in the cold, EC's posts about industrial insurance was misinformed.
 
Bottom line, regardless of TX leaving a lot of injured workers out in the cold, EC's posts about industrial insurance was misinformed.

The hell? I didn't say anything about whether or not they carried WC insurance. I spoke to subrogation and the fact that in many cases, the claims are NOT denied by the medical carrier, but that the costs are subrogated once a WC case has been opened and liability has been determined.

Stop misrepresenting me without even bothering to read my posts.
 
Drug seeking is just as prevalent outside of the industrial insurance system.
Great.
But I didn't reference "drug seeking". I said "free drugs" were an incentive.

Time off work with sick leave or vacation pay doesn't require an on the job injury.

Nobody said they did.
But they certainly are benefits of workman's comp claims, and are not benefits of typical private health insurance claims.


The two systems are very different, though, not saying they aren't. But there are more than a few false statements about industrial insurance in this thread that shouldn't go unchallenged.

What are the false statements?
 
Great.
But I didn't reference "drug seeking". I said "free drugs" were an incentive.
So workers want free antibiotics or antacids? What other drugs do people seek because they are free?

Nobody said they did.
But they certainly are benefits of workman's comp claims, and are not benefits of typical private health insurance claims.
You seem to not be following your own train of thought.

lomiller: "There isn’t any increased incentive to abuse it,"
Pterodactyl: "... even though I listed 3 additional incentives to abuse it? ... time off work, with pay, free drugs, etc."​

I merely pointed out none of the three things on you list provided an increased incentive not also seen in non-worker's comp insurance systems.

I will say that some worker's comp claims can involve a number of issues in addition to the medical ones. A small percentage of work related injuries can be complicated by the employee's emotional issues with the job. But it's beyond the discussion in this thread.

What are the false statements?
This unsupported claim for one:
Emily's Cat said:
Workers comp claims in the US are messy. They end up involving a lot of subrogation between WC and the injurer's medical insurance. And in many states, the employer is charged for those claims. The biggest problem with workers comp claims, imo, is that they're pretty much entirely run by lawyers trying to make sure it's someone else's fault.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom