Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

I've actually asked the same type of question. When it comes to the healthcare legislation, I have to ask

1) What is the objective of the legislation, and
2) To what extent does this legislation achieve that objective?

During the campaign, the president claimed they were going to cover everyone and do it cheap. That sounds like goals to me, and I consider them reasonable goals, in fact.

You are making the basic mistake all of his supporters knew was a bad idea, listening to what he said. You can't expect what he does to have any relationship to what he said. You are supposed to take him seriously not believe a literal interpretation of anything that comes out of his mouth.
 
Vox asked nine Republican Senators supporting Graham-Cassidy how it will help patients. Not one of them could do it.

Also, I'm pretty sure Pat Robets hasn't seem Thelma and Louise recently or possibly at all.
Just to expand on the insanity of the Grassley quote in the Vox article:
Despite many evident shortcomings in a bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act health care law, Republicans have a responsibility to pass it, U.S. Sen. Chuck Grassley said Wednesday.

In a conference call with Iowa reporters, Grassley expressed support for the Graham-Cassidy health care reform proposal currently before the Senate, arguing that the GOP has pledged to repeal the law known as Obamacare and must seize any opportunity to do so.

“You know, I could maybe give you 10 reasons why this bill shouldn’t be considered,” Grassley said. “But Republicans campaigned on this so often that you have a responsibility to carry out what you said in the campaign. That’s pretty much as much of a reason as the substance of the bill.”
Chuck Grassley: Fulfilling campaign promise just as important as 'substance' of health bill

This is just headshakingly stupid. He's willing to pass a bad bill - and he readily admit it's a bad bill - just to be able to say they've finally repealed ACA. The kicker comes further down, when he also admits that Graham-Cassidy won't do jack about rising premiums and the limited choice of healthcare coverage available.
 
Just to expand on the insanity of the Grassley quote in the Vox article:

Chuck Grassley: Fulfilling campaign promise just as important as 'substance' of health bill

This is just headshakingly stupid. He's willing to pass a bad bill - and he readily admit it's a bad bill - just to be able to say they've finally repealed ACA. The kicker comes further down, when he also admits that Graham-Cassidy won't do jack about rising premiums and the limited choice of healthcare coverage available.

I'm pretty sure if the press keeps pushing one of them will snap and admit, "Look, I just don't want to primaried!"
 
I know I ask this every time, but does the most recent proposal finally include some provision to allow buying insurance across state lines?
 
Campaign promise based on lies that Obama care was bad and lies that they had a better replacement plan, yep, got to keep that campaign promise. :boggled:
 
Has it ever been presented, in any way, by Republican congresspeople or any of their supporters, how these bills will actually be a good thing that we need/would want? I mean, we all know that the only reasons for these are to erase Obama from the history books and to give rich people tax cuts and not to actually improve normal people's lives, but how are they actually selling this? Or are they not even trying, giving us a giant "screw you"?
Not as such. They merely believe the federal government should not be involved in health care. If old people were not voting, they would immediately take out Medicare as well. Some hedging words usually accompany these ideas: the states should take care of their people. (Yet state tax is so small it would never cover it).
 
I know I ask this every time, but does the most recent proposal finally include some provision to allow buying insurance across state lines?

Makes it effectively impossible. Under this bill, every state will have totally different rules. This is also why their claims of the bill covering pre-existing conditions are BS since those rules would be set by the states and not the Federal Government.
 
Makes it effectively impossible. Under this bill, every state will have totally different rules. This is also why their claims of the bill covering pre-existing conditions are BS since those rules would be set by the states and not the Federal Government.

Is it yet another case of weasel-wording. Leaving the detailed rules to the states doesn't preclude the states coming up with rules to compel insurance companies to cover pre-existing conditions so strictly speaking the answer to the question of "Does your plan cover pre-existing conditions ?" is "Yes" it also means that:

  • GOP legislators can claim credit for any positives - premiums rising less quickly for those is low risk pools
  • They can blame state legislatures for any negative effects - millions lising coverage, premiums soaring for those with pre-existing conditions
  • They can make good on campaign promises
  • They and their multi-millionaire buddies get a hefty tax cut

As Private Eye would say "Trebles all round !" :mad:
 
I just love how "flexibility" will, as if by magic, make publicly funded healthcare so much cheaper that cutting funding overall by more than 20% won't reduce healthcare insurance coverage.

Republicans really are the party of faith based policies. Maybe with the power of Jesus everything will work out okay.
 
Just to expand on the insanity of the Grassley quote in the Vox article:

Chuck Grassley: Fulfilling campaign promise just as important as 'substance' of health bill

This is just headshakingly stupid. He's willing to pass a bad bill - and he readily admit it's a bad bill - just to be able to say they've finally repealed ACA. The kicker comes further down, when he also admits that Graham-Cassidy won't do jack about rising premiums and the limited choice of healthcare coverage available.

American people must suffer pain and misery only so the Republicans can fulfill an election promise. It must happen. It has to happen. It's just the way America works.
 
The Post article was behind a paywall. Try this. I believed your previous post was saying the premiums wouldn't be different for pre-existing conditions.

https://www.americanprogress.org/is...lode-premiums-people-pre-existing-conditions/

ETA: Sorry, that article I believe was regarding the previous Republican plan. However, it appears the new one is worse than the one in April.

Follow some of the links in the article. Either the authors truly don't understand what they're reading, or they're misrepresenting it.

http://www.politico.com/f/?id=0000015b-8ab0-df96-a9db-dff115c30001

First off: I haven't evaluated the plan on the whole. I'm responding to the bits and pieces that are trickling through. I'm unlikely to have the time to evaluate the whole plan for a few weeks, which is probably useless for this discussion.

Now to my comments and observations. The article you linked to claims that insurers would be allowed to mark-up premiums for preexisting conditions. So far as I can tell, this is not the case. Community rating rules would remain in place, including coverage for preexisting conditions. States could apply for a waiver to portions of that rule only if they set up a state-level plan for covering the waived elements in a way that reduces costs across the board. That's where the invisible high risk pool comes into play. That would allow insurers to exclude costs related to those particular conditions or attributes from their rating pool, while still providing coverage to those people. The reason it's called an invisible high risk pool is because it's invisible to the covered individual - they have no idea that their costs have been ceded to the state pool.

The authors of the article you link to claim that invisible high risk pools won't do anything to lower costs, but they really don't seem to understand how they work. They describe the process in materially incorrect ways on multiple occasions.

Now, it's also quite possible that there are detailed elements of this pool design that I'm missing. But based on the information that the article links to, their conclusions are unfounded.
 
Every time they go back to the drawing board it gets worse.

Of course it does. They're trying to get the extremists to vote for it. Before they thought it was too mild. Hell, why make a bill at all? Remove Obamacare completely and let the law of the jungle determine everything.
 
American people must suffer pain and misery only so the Republicans can fulfill an election promise. It must happen. It has to happen. It's just the way America works.

Yeah they promised their big contributors tax cuts and they better deliver if they want to keep their cushy jobs.
 
Makes it effectively impossible. Under this bill, every state will have totally different rules. This is also why their claims of the bill covering pre-existing conditions are BS since those rules would be set by the states and not the Federal Government.

Don’t dismiss the possibility that Republicans want to allow purchase of insurance across state lines anyway thus allowing badly regulated states to sell cheap but worthless policies to everyone else whether they meet that States requirements or not. TBH this is what I’m assuming they have been angling for all along.
 
Don’t dismiss the possibility that Republicans want to allow purchase of insurance across state lines anyway thus allowing badly regulated states to sell cheap but worthless policies to everyone else whether they meet that States requirements or not. TBH this is what I’m assuming they have been angling for all along.

Wouldn't the policies have to come up to the standard of the state in which they are sold?
 
Don’t dismiss the possibility that Republicans want to allow purchase of insurance across state lines anyway thus allowing badly regulated states to sell cheap but worthless policies to everyone else whether they meet that States requirements or not. TBH this is what I’m assuming they have been angling for all along.

AKA "The credit card industry template"

Wouldn't the policies have to come up to the standard of the state in which they are sold?

No, see, even if you're in Washington, and the seller is in Texas, the agency can word the contract so the 'official sale' takes place in South Dakota to take advantage of the lax laws there. Oh, didn't read the fine print of a 20,000 page document before signing? Too bad for you, I guess.
 
Last edited:
The big R talking point today is that just four states get 99.99999% (or some other number) of Obamacare benefits. Gee, you don't suppose that's because a) they have the largest populations, and b) other states' R governors and legislatures intentionally tried to keep O'care from helping their citizens? I do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom