Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Suffering a workplace injury and seeking treatment for it changes the way otherwise sane people view you. I had a family member who was injured on the job and even the pharmacist was a dick about filling the prescriptions. Much less coworkers and management. Even though they saw the injury happen and had video of the injury happening. It was like they expect the employee to just suck it up and not complain.

Why? Where was this? In some small, one-factory towns, the employer is seen as the lifeblood of the community. But in a lot of places, I would think a workplace injury would reflect negatively on the employer. Were the employees afraid they would be affected somehow, or what? And was the pharmacist mad about a low reimbursement rate or something? Why would he even have an opinion?

The reputation is that workplace injuries are exaggerated and invented to get paid time off work, by lazy employees who goldbrick. The theory is that Employers are obsessed with safety and go out of their way to ensure employees are coddled, so all injuries are fraud.

Workers comp claims in the US are messy. They end up involving a lot of subrogation between WC and the injurer's medical insurance. And in many states, the employer is charged for those claims. The biggest problem with workers comp claims, imo, is that they're pretty much entirely run by lawyers trying to make sure it's someone else's fault. So even if you set aside the potential for fraud and the accusations thereof, you end up with really long drawn out legal proceedings involving the injured person as well as any witnesses and a host of other people employed by the company in question... all of whom pretty much get run through the wringer. What should be a straightforward proceeding rarely is.
 
The key question is- how much does enrolling these individuals contribute to the financial stability of the corresponding plans? I can easily imagine that a one time cost of $1545 per person can be readily made back as that person pays premiums over the following years. The actual figures will, of course, depend on the type of plan in which they enroll, if the individual is eligible for government subsidies, and what health costs they incur. So the investment in recruitment may pay back the cost, although I don't think we have to data to be certain.

Um... no, not really. If it could so easily be made back, trust me, we'd have a much larger marketing budget at my company. If they were managing to enroll a higher volume, that would be different. But these two companies have average about 800 enrollees in the 18 cities they're operating in. That's a really big price tag without sufficient return on investment.

Additionally, the government is funding these adds - and they aren't making anything at all on these enrollees. There is no ROI available at all. Even from a good will perspective, the math doesn't work out.

Hell, that's higher than the combined advertising and commission costs per enrollee for Medicare Advantage - and the premium level for MA is significantly higher than for the Individual market.
 
It wasn't Trumps threat. Defunding the Cost-Share Reduction payments have been up before congress since before the election last year. You could feasibly lay that fiasco at the feet of the GOP... but it's silly and disingenuous to blame that one on Trump.

Yea it isn't like he has any responsibilities or accountability for anything anyway so why bother? Just because it would happen under his watch doesn't mean he bears any responsibility for it.
 
Yea it isn't like he has any responsibilities or accountability for anything anyway so why bother? Just because it would happen under his watch doesn't mean he bears any responsibility for it.

Yeah, like when insurance companies expressed their concern about the uncertainty in the government support, all it would have taken is for Trump to reassure them that he wouldn't let it be a problem. I mean, it's not like he's the President or anything so doesn't have any influence on government.

Instead, he has continually said, "Let it die."

Nope, no responsibility there.
 
The stock market crashed on September 29, 2008 -- before Obama was elected, much less inaugurated.

If you put responsibility and blame on Trump for something then you can blame anything on Obama. That's just the way it is. It's called balance.
 
Workers comp claims in the US are messy. They end up involving a lot of subrogation between WC and the injurer's medical insurance. And in many states, the employer is charged for those claims. The biggest problem with workers comp claims, imo, is that they're pretty much entirely run by lawyers trying to make sure it's someone else's fault.

Welcome to the unregulated free market. Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times and in some cases it can render a market completely dysfunctional. Markets for health insurance are particularly susceptible, which is a big reason why multi-payer systems haven’t worked unless they are highly regulated and contain things like individual mandates to have insurance.
 
Welcome to the unregulated free market. Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times and in some cases it can render a market completely dysfunctional. Markets for health insurance are particularly susceptible, which is a big reason why multi-payer systems haven’t worked unless they are highly regulated and contain things like individual mandates to have insurance.

You are saying the WC market is an unregulated free market?
 
You are saying the WC market is an unregulated free market?

How do you get that from “Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times”? This is an example of business doing what they always do and try to offload expenses to someone else. They will do so wherever and whenever they are allowed, which is why some marketplaces simply can’t function without heavy regulation.

I’m not sure how that’s confusing or difficult to understand unless you are being intentionally obtuse.
 
Workers comp is definitely a mess.
Not to play devil's advocate, but it's not exactly an apples to apples comparison with regular health insurance, because in some instances, employees have increased incentive to want to abuse it. Benefits of use include time off work, with pay, free drugs, etc.

I'm not sure how pervasive such abuse is, but in my (albeit limited) experience, abuse of this system can be significant.
 
How do you get that from “Everyone is trying to offload all their expenses to everyone else at all times”? This is an example of business doing what they always do and try to offload expenses to someone else. They will do so wherever and whenever they are allowed, which is why some marketplaces simply can’t function without heavy regulation.

I’m not sure how that’s confusing or difficult to understand unless you are being intentionally obtuse.

Well, you said

Welcome to the unregulated free market.
in response to Emily's post about Worker's Comp. WC is decidedly not an unregulated free market so your arguments to that effect do not apply to WC.
 
Well, you said

in response to Emily's post about Worker's Comp. WC is decidedly not an unregulated free market so your arguments to that effect do not apply to WC.

So deliberately obtuse then…
 
Workers comp is definitely a mess.
Not to play devil's advocate, but it's not exactly an apples to apples comparison with regular health insurance, because in some instances, employees have increased incentive to want to abuse it. Benefits of use include time off work, with pay, free drugs, etc.

I'm not sure how pervasive such abuse is, but in my (albeit limited) experience, abuse of this system can be significant.

There isn’t any increased incentive to abuse it, the incentive for abuse in any multi-payer system is always there and it’s why multi-payer systems need to be highly regulated to function even marginally well.
 
There isn’t any increased incentive to abuse it, the incentive for abuse in any multi-payer system is always there and it’s why multi-payer systems need to be highly regulated to function even marginally well.

There isn't any increased incentive to abuse it even though I listed 3 additional incentives to abuse it?
 
So deliberately obtuse then…

No, it was a direct quote of you saying "welcome to the free market," when WC is clearly not a free market; it's the end result of government regulation. Because the government has placed liability for covering such injuries directly on the employer, regular medical insurance specifically carves out on-the-job injuries. This created the whole specialized WC market which is regulated by State laws creating a whole framework for how WC insurance works.

Now, it's possible I misunderstood what you were saying, but you are basically accusing me of dishonesty here and I don't think that's a fair assessment. You could certainly clarify what you meant instead of saying I'm being deliberately obtuse.
 
No, it was a direct quote of you saying "welcome to the free market," when WC is clearly not a free market; it's the end result of government regulation. Because the government has placed liability for covering such injuries directly on the employer, regular medical insurance specifically carves out on-the-job injuries. This created the whole specialized WC market which is regulated by State laws creating a whole framework for how WC insurance works.
......

Does this mean that if someone with regular health insurance goes to a doctor and says "I broke my arm, fix it," they will ask him if it happened on the job and turn him away if he says "yes," or that he will file a claim for his treatment that his insurer will reject, or what? I understand that the employer is responsible for injuries in the workplace, but isn't who pays a question to be fought out by the patient's insurance company vs. the employer's? How is the patient's treatment affected?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom