Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

And the truth comes out, this is all about millionaire and billionaire donors putting the squeeze on GOP legislators, repeal the ACA and give us our tax cut or no more donations for you.

The Nation, current: The GOP’s Latest Obamacare Repeal Push Isn’t Really About Health Care - It’s about how to finance tax cuts for the ultra-wealthy.
Why are Republicans pushing a health-care bill the entire health-care industry hates? Politicians repealing a program or regulation in order to enrich industry is a common Washington tale, but that’s not what’s happening here: The health-insurance lobby hates the Graham-Cassidy bill and is trying to kill it, and so are hospitals, doctors, and pretty much the rest of the American health-care system.

This mystery is easily solved when you realize the Graham-Cassidy bill isn’t really about health care. It is not meant to help the health-insurance industry, and certainly not designed to help patients, who will lose access to affordable coverage, particularly if they have a preexisting condition. Rather, Graham-Cassidy is an ideological crusade to reshape the federal budget and change who really benefits from federal spending. The health-care cuts are mainly a means to finance future massive tax cuts, and the wealthy donors who will benefit are the real constituency for this legislation.

This is not a new revelation or development.
Salon June: GOP donors threaten to withhold funds unless their agenda is passed
If Republican politicians aren't soon able to pass sufficiently conservative versions of healthcare and tax reform, more than a few right-leaning donors say they're going to stop cutting fundraising checks, according to the Associated Press.
"Get Obamacare repealed and replaced, get tax reform passed," Texas-based donor Doug Deason said, calling his donations a "Dallas piggy bank."

The Hill, last month: Republican donor sues GOP for fraud over ObamaCare repeal failure
A Republican donor in Virginia has filed a lawsuit against the national and Virginia Republican parties, accusing them of fraud and racketeering for raising millions of dollars in donations knowing they wouldn’t be able to repeal ObamaCare.

The Virginian-Pilot reports that Bob Heghmann, a retired attorney in Virginia Beach, filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court on Thursday. The suit blasts the Republican Party, saying it “has been engaged in a pattern of Racketeering which involves massive fraud perpetrated on Republican voters and contributors as well as some Independents and Democrats.”

The lawsuit’s defendants include the Republican National Committee (RNC) and the Republican Party of Virginia, as well as Virginia’s two members of the RNC and the chairman of the state Republican Party, John Whitbeck.

As part of his suit, Heghmann argues that the Republican Party does not hold the same protection that members of Congress have against being sued for failing to fulfill campaign promises. He wants the GOP to either threaten to withhold money from members of Congress if they don’t repeal ObamaCare, or return contributions to donors.
Should be interesting if it gets to the SCOTUS.

NY Mag, Aug: Top Trump Donor Wants to Take Out GOP’s Second-Most Vulnerable Senator
Apparently, one of the president’s billionaire backers feels the same way. Robert Mercer, a patron of right-wing “populism” who believes that cats’ lives are worth more than those of the poor, is contributing $300,000 to a super-PAC aligned with former state senator Kelli Ward, who hopes to knock off Flake in next year’s GOP primary on the strength of her devotion to Donald Trump.
Flake was toeing the GOP line on repeal and replace last night on Colbert.

NYT, March: Wealthy Would Get Billions in Tax Cuts Under Obamacare Repeal Plan
Two of the biggest tax cuts in Republican proposals to repeal the Affordable Care Act would deliver roughly $144 billion over the coming decade to those with incomes of $1 million or more, according to a congressional analysis.


That the right wing middle and lower classes are so easily sold on tax cuts to billionaires is unfortunate. You'd think they might figure out the 1% is controlling the government the right wing claims to be against.
 
Last edited:
The big R talking point today is that just four states get 99.99999% (or some other number) of Obamacare benefits. Gee, you don't suppose that's because a) they have the largest populations, and b) other states' R governors and legislatures intentionally tried to keep O'care from helping their citizens? I do.

It doesn't matter why they get more money. The only thing that matters is taking from Democrats and giving to Republicans. That's about as good of an argument you'd need.
 
AKA "The credit card industry template"



No, see, even if you're in Washington, and the seller is in Texas, the agency can word the contract so the 'official sale' takes place in South Dakota to take advantage of the lax laws there. Oh, didn't read the fine print of a 20,000 page document before signing? Too bad for you, I guess.

Yup, that's exactly what I think they are angling for with the whole "across state lines" thing.

Of course this is justified by “putting it in the States hands” even though it effectively does the exact opposite.
 
I really think he's doing mostly because he's not going to run again and he can serve as the scapegoat allowing other members of the party to protect themselves from being primaried.

I hope not, because if all other members of his party vote for it the bill will pass.

Now Flake I am sure will vote for it if it even comes up for a vote.

I don't trust Rand Paul at all. And I can't really think of a reason Murkowski and Collins haven't already come out against it.
 
...And I can't really think of a reason Murkowski and Collins haven't already come out against it.
Publicity and attention.

I don't trust Paul either.


Can you imagine the GOP glee when right wing states deny all services to the poor and the poor subsequently immigrate to blue states?
 
Yup, that's exactly what I think they are angling for with the whole "across state lines" thing.

Of course this is justified by “putting it in the States hands” even though it effectively does the exact opposite.

If the issue is uninsured Americans, those credit card laws do seem correlated with much easier access to credit cards than when I was young.
 
I really think he's doing mostly because he's not going to run again and he can serve as the scapegoat allowing other members of the party to protect themselves from being primaried.
Based on positions he's taken on other issues over the years, I doubt that's the case. When he championed comprehensive immigration reform, he was doing something unpopular with the aptly named GOP "base." Pushing for campaign finance reform also was not something the GOP cared much about, aside from overturning it.

He has an independent streak.
 
My Obamacare provider robot-called me twice this week. The callback number yielded a man who could not really explain why I was being called. Something about knowing what was covered and what wasn't? I told him I was in for the calendar year, as far as I knew, and he confirmed this. He was going to transfer me to another department, and I hung up.

I'm a totally captive audience. My choices last fall were the plan I have or a more expensive one from the same company. So I wonder what that was about. Seeing how much price increase I'd tolerate before going uninsured, maybe.
 
If the issue is uninsured Americans, those credit card laws do seem correlated with much easier access to credit cards than when I was young.

True. Along those lines, I think lots of consumers/voters would be pretty comfortable with cheaper, readily-acquired but sub-optimal insurance. As far as I'm aware, though, Republican politicians never really push their plans that way. Trump, in particular, made it out that insurance would be cheaper and better.
 
The American Academy of Actuaries does not think Graham-Cassidy would make insurance more affordable most places.

Unless the funds allocated in the proposal are used to create stable markets by maintaining a level playing field for insurers and achieving a balanced risk pool, GCHJ would likely lead to higher individual market premiums, lower enrollment, eroded protections for those with preexisting conditions, lower insurer participation, and more unstable markets than under current law.
 
I hope not, because if all other members of his party vote for it the bill will pass.

Now Flake I am sure will vote for it if it even comes up for a vote.

I don't trust Rand Paul at all. And I can't really think of a reason Murkowski and Collins haven't already come out against it.
I'm waiting, just hoping that someone else will commit to voting against it. I don't get the feeling that it will pass, but, it's not over until the fat lady sings.
 
I really think he's doing mostly because he's not going to run again and he can serve as the scapegoat allowing other members of the party to protect themselves from being primaried.

At some point, aren't even die-hard fans going to realize he's just too old for this?

ETA: Although, AK is a bit odd. The state has forced the fed's hand on more than one occasion in the past. I don' really understand it, but for a small population state, they sure can band together when they want to.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom