Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

I just note that the 26-or-under provision was an ACA innovation. Before that, insurance companies could cut children off at 21.

And one alternative under the old system was to rack up huge medical bills, then declare bankruptcy. That was one of the primary causes of bankruptcy under the old system. Of course, that person would never get insurance again, unless he found a job that provided it, and maybe not even then.
You're right, of course. I knew that but failed to account for it - and that has been pretty popular with parents IIRC.

Yes, bankruptcy is an option. I know a woman whose son racked up a *$3 million* medical bill after a freak accident and his parents were allowed to keep an apartment and working vehicle. After all this - their son died in another freak accident. The son by then was covered as an indigent, IIRC.
 
Sensible politics for the Democrats would see them having a new healthcare act that fixes the problems with the current legislation and give it to the Republicans and say "here is a plan with X votes in the bag". That would preempt the accusations it is the Democrats causing the problem.

I think at the present time it might be better for the Democrats in Congress to stay out of this mess. They undoubtedly do have some fixes in mind for the problems with ACA -- and even Obama conceded that ACA could use some overhauling -- but in the present climate it might be smarter for the Dems to stay quiet and keep their heads down. No matter what they say or do the Republicans will find a way to cast it as negative.

Trump repeatedly promised, boasted actually, to have a better healthcare plan, giving much better care than ACA at lower cost and that would "cover everyone." This is what he told the Washington Post in January:
“We’re going to have insurance for everybody,” Trump said. “There was a philosophy in some circles that if you can’t pay for it, you don’t get it. That’s not going to happen with us.” People covered under the law “can expect to have great health care. It will be in a much simplified form. Much less expensive and much better.” Link

He's certainly not saying that now. And this is the problem. He has consistently been, at best wrong and at worst dishonest, about the kind of replacement plan his administration would come up with. Yet when the contradictions between what Trump promised and what he is trying to deliver -- cover everybody versus 20 million people become uninsured -- his supporters go into denial/attack mode. This just doesn't seem like the time when reasonable bipartisan policy-making has much of a chance.
 
Last edited:
Watching a Stephen Colbert clip and he brought up the fact that the Republicans voted 60 times to repeal the ACA when Obama was in the White House. As soon as you have Republican President they can't muster the votes to get a repeal measure through. It seems like it was all just theatre to keep the tea-party crowd happy but their terrified of the prospect of an actual repeal.
Yup. It's easy enough to vote for something when you know you'll never have to face the repercussions. When you're actually making law that will effect your constituents, not so much.
 
Yup. It's easy enough to vote for something when you know you'll never have to face the repercussions. When you're actually making law that will effect your constituents, not so much.

Which is just what Paul Ryan and the House GOP voted to do, pass the buck to the Senate.

Now McConnell is pretending voting to move the bill forward isn't really committing to anything. Makes one worry though, what sleazy trick he has up his sleeve.
 
<snip>

There's nothing in the Constitution (as far as I'm aware) about Healthcare, so is there any statutory obligation to provide it?

<snip>


Part of your confusion stems from the fact that you are discussing two different things in the same sentence.

The Federal Government can take on just about any "statutory" obligation it chooses to. That's because it makes the statutes. :)

The Constitution provides the guidelines for the structure of the government, and describes a few things it must do and a few that it isn't allowed to do.
 
bYIG9n9.jpg

https://twitter.com/foxnewspoll/status/887797950440652800


2h0OIC7.png

https://twitter.com/foxnewspoll/status/887809529240588290
 
Except that "compromise" means that the Democrats should completely abandon their ideas and merely accept whatever the GOP wants.

Heck with Obamacare that's pretty much what they did and then the GOP moved their position significantly to the right. You cannot work with people who deal in such bad faith :mad:
 
Except that "compromise" means that the Democrats should completely abandon their ideas and merely accept whatever the GOP wants.

Heck with Obamacare that's pretty much what they did and then the GOP moved their position significantly to the right. You cannot work with people who deal in such bad faith :mad:

People don't think that Democrats should agree to gut Medicaid, for example. Nor will they. That is an exceptionally unpopular idea.

Rather they think Republicans should drop that idea.
 
I think at the present time it might be better for the Democrats in Congress to stay out of this mess. They undoubtedly do have some fixes in mind for the problems with ACA -- and even Obama conceded that ACA could use some overhauling -- but in the present climate it might be smarter for the Dems to stay quiet and keep their heads down. No matter what they say or do the Republicans will find a way to cast it as negative.
I agree. The GOP would welcome any distraction, for one thing, and for another "Never interrupt the enemy when they're making a mistake". A Dem plan would simply provide the GOP with something to unite against - the only kind of unity they seem capable of.
 
You're right, of course. I knew that but failed to account for it - and that has been pretty popular with parents IIRC.

Yes, bankruptcy is an option. I know a woman whose son racked up a *$3 million* medical bill after a freak accident and his parents were allowed to keep an apartment and working vehicle. After all this - their son died in another freak accident. The son by then was covered as an indigent, IIRC.

Why would the son's bills go to the parents?
 
I got paywalled on Bob's link but Googled up another one. This is Donnie describing how healthcare insurance works:
Because you are basically saying from the moment the insurance [starts], you’re 21 years old, you start working and you’re paying $12 a year for insurance, and by the time you’re 70, you get a nice plan.

Okay so the Donmeister doesn't understand how healthcare insurance works. This is what I liked that the Post writer added to the article:
The point of Obamacare was to increase the number of healthy people paying into insurance pools so that coverage for those with preexisting conditions could be expanded. An insurance program that only covers the very sick would either have to limit coverage or have expensive policies. A program that has healthier people paying in can help keep costs down for those who need it. Healthy people don’t always want to buy insurance, though, which is why Obamacare has a mandate: have insurance or pay a tax penalty.

The Republicans don't like making healthy people buy healthcare insurance in order to expand coverage for people with preexisting conditions. Or charging a cash penalty for healthy people who simply refuse to buy a healthcare policy. The problem is, as I've heard economists say, if you want to make health insurance affordable for everyone that's the only way it can work, other than a single payer system.

So the GOP has a problem. They are more or less publicly committed to maintaining expanded healthcare coverage but won't accept doing it the way ACA does and there is no other way other than a single payer. The fact they tried to go about this by forming a replacement bill in secret, so no one know would know how bad it was until it was too late...it's actually hard to believe anyone would do something like that. Even Republicans. ;)
 
Does Trump this that health insurance and life insurance are the same thing?

In all seriousness he really might be confusing aspects of the two. It fits with his apparently real surprise that fixing health care was a difficult and complicated thing and his frustration with the inability of Congress to come up with a good solution quickly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom