Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

All the while we hear the utterly dishonest proclamation that Trump and/or the GOP have a better plan with more coverage for less money. It's a bald-faced lie. And even that gets little push-back and rarely is it ever called what it really is, a lie.
To be fair, the story of the GOP's failure is a big one, perhaps historic. With that winding down for summer there'll be room for other aspects to be covered. Which the Russia story might well expand into, of course.

The unpopularity of Trumpcare suggests that the populace has a more reasonable appreciation of the ACA than the GOP is pushing at them.
 
To be fair, the story of the GOP's failure is a big one, perhaps historic. With that winding down for summer there'll be room for other aspects to be covered. Which the Russia story might well expand into, of course.

The unpopularity of Trumpcare suggests that the populace has a more reasonable appreciation of the ACA than the GOP is pushing at them.
:boggled:

What is unfair about calling the claim the GOP has a better plan a lie? I don't understand your sentence.

Trump himself said he had a better plan. Does anyone recall when the House went to draft a plan they actually thought Trump had one?

The cognitive dissonance in this era of Trumpantics is the best mind boggling, it's more mind boggling than any mind boggling ever.
 
They're not there, because ACA IS failing. The Medicaid piece is all fine and dandy, but the Individual market is imploding.


Is it?
We know because every measure of healthcare spending, access and cost has improved since the passage and implementation of the Affordable Care Act.
http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-obamacare-charts-20170104-story.html

Sure, the ACA needs improvements. Those counties without coverage, for example, could be revised by redrawing some borders to merge them with neighboring counties. The subsidies to insurers could be restored. But a return to pre-2009 conditions would be catastrophic.
 
They're not there, because ACA IS failing. The Medicaid piece is all fine and dandy, but the Individual market is imploding.

And why is that? From what I've read its because of the uncertainty created by the whole repeal and replace fiasco.
 
Stack on penalties to ensure that they can't afford either thing, and end up screwed no matter what! :thumbsup:

If there were some sort of a savings plan in place, that might make more sense. But there's not - it's not like the money being paid by young people today is going to cover their costs when they're old. This is straight up nothing but intergenerational subsidization. It's bankrupting* young people today with the promise that they'll get to bankrupt younger people at some unspecified point in the future.

*Yes, hyperbole. OMG!!! :eek:
Is it really bankrupting young people? I believe it's a 3 to 1 ratio, so they are still paying a third of what us old farts pay.
 
:boggled:

What is unfair about calling the claim the GOP has a better plan a lie? I don't understand your sentence.

Trump himself said he had a better plan. Does anyone recall when the House went to draft a plan they actually thought Trump had one?

The cognitive dissonance in this era of Trumpantics is the best mind boggling, it's more mind boggling than any mind boggling ever.

Republicans didn't think they needed a plan because they thought Hillary would win.

It doesn't help that it is literally impossible for the GOP to come up with a better plan.
 
:boggled:

What is unfair about calling the claim the GOP has a better plan a lie? I don't understand your sentence.
I was referring to the press coverage, which has concentrated on the GOP's long road to failure rather than their lies. I think we'll see more critique of the "Obamacare is failing" claim over the summer.
 
Is it?


Sure, the ACA needs improvements. Those counties without coverage, for example, could be revised by redrawing some borders to merge them with neighboring counties. The subsidies to insurers could be restored. But a return to pre-2009 conditions would be catastrophic.

This sums it up pretty well, I think :
"The Republican effort has been hobbled by a split between moderates concerned about Medicaid cuts and conservatives who want more radical changes. The party has also faced the stark, politically unpalatable possibility that the ACA is a genie that cannot be wished back into the bottle."
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news...mp-healthcare-bill-fail-republicans-obamacare

If Obamacare really was a disaster the GOP wouldn't have this problem.
 
They're not there, because ACA IS failing. The Medicaid piece is all fine and dandy, but the Individual market is imploding.
:rolleyes:

Care to back that up with a cite that isn't lacking devoid of supporting data and straight from the right-wing echo-chamber?

I have individual coverage and I assure you it is not imploding.

There are a few marketplaces where insurers have pulled out because they have no assurance the GOP isn't going to pull the rug out from under them in the area of subsidies.

WA Po: The Affordable Care Act is neither imploding nor collapsing
The individual marketplace is stabilizing: The most common motivation for claims of collapse is the individual market. Importantly, most Americans get coverage through their employer or the government (Medicare, Medicaid). The Kaiser Family Foundation notes that the “individual market is where just 7% of the U.S. population gets their insurance (and thus also represents a small share of most health insurers’ business),” but it also correctly notes that “the stability of the market and willingness of insurers to continue to participate is essential to the ACA’s success.”

The problem in this part of the market is that too many private insurers have pulled out of the exchanges, leaving some parts of the country with too few coverage options. However, this problem, initially caused by the insurers pricing coverage too low to maintain profitability, is improving. Metrics of their profitability that showed earlier deterioration, including medical loss ratios (the share of premiums insurers are paying out in claims) and profit margins, are correcting, thanks in part to premium increases for 2017. One careful analysis of major insurers finds that they “… have now largely recovered from initial underpricing for the ACA marketplaces, and their individual-market premiums are now generally in line with costs.”
 
Last edited:
When they say that they will just have to let the ACA fail, what they really mean is that they will sabotage the ACA so that if fails. Remember this, as they've already taken a few actions that have caused premiums to increase dramatically and insurers to pull out of a few markets.
I expect that their budget and tax policies will target key funds for the ACA to further degrade the ACA.

The classic strategy of the GOP is to make government programs fail and then say "see, government programs never work."
 
So flip flopping. You really think the republicans have lost enough control to let something that bad come up for a vote?


The problem is that they have gained enough control.

Their problem is that their voting block in the Senate isn't as obedient as they thought.

They have enough control that they thought that a handful of top ranked Senators can lock themselves into a room and churn out an outrageous bill that they thought would just be accepted blindly by their rank and file. Most of that rank and file had no more idea of what that bill contained than anyone else, and when they found out they weren't all willing to toe (or tow) the party line.

It only needed three who had the guts to tell their bosses "Hell, no" and stick to it.
 
Sensible politics for the Democrats would see them having a new healthcare act that fixes the problems with the current legislation and give it to the Republicans and say "here is a plan with X votes in the bag". That would preempt the accusations it is the Democrats causing the problem.
 
Sensible politics for the Democrats would see them having a new healthcare act that fixes the problems with the current legislation and give it to the Republicans and say "here is a plan with X votes in the bag". That would preempt the accusations it is the Democrats causing the problem.

I think that the Democrats should absolutely put forth a credible reform plan. If it was any good, I think that some of the more vocal Republicans would massively distort it - think "death panels" and the like - so the Democrats would have to put in extreme effort to not only sell the plan to the general public but also to make sure that the plan was accurately understood. Of course that's assuming that the Democrats' plan was actually any good.
Republicans wouldn't support a Democrat plan in any event, but voters might take notice.
 
It's not surprising that republicans were unable to repeal and replace obamacare simply because their motivations were based overwhelming upon false and misleading claims. Moreover, the real serious problems would've continued to exist.

In fact I'm amazed things went this far.
 
I think that the Democrats should absolutely put forth a credible reform plan. If it was any good, I think that some of the more vocal Republicans would massively distort it - think "death panels" and the like - so the Democrats would have to put in extreme effort to not only sell the plan to the general public but also to make sure that the plan was accurately understood. Of course that's assuming that the Democrats' plan was actually any good.
Republicans wouldn't support a Democrat plan in any event, but voters might take notice.

IMO the Democratic Party is going to have to develop some attractive policies and become very adept at communicating them if they're going to make the necessary headway in the 2018 elections.

Healthcare seems like an ideal policy area for them to start with. Despite the GOP's general incompetence at managing the economy (deficits invariably soar as they cut taxes and start wars) and the President's terrible financial history, the GOP seems to be more trusted on financial matters. OTOH I can see that the Democratic Party have opportunities with respect to healthcare, the environment, welfare and social matters.

I really do hope they manage to do this but I'm concerned that they will just rely on being "not Trump" or that anything they do suggest will be twisted out of all recognition by right wing pundits - and to prove that they are "balanced", left wing pundits and comedians will feel obligated to have a dig too :mad:
 
I was about to post that despite Trump's "not going to own it" pleadings, he sits in the big chair in the round-ish office, and it's his problem whether he likes it or not.

But then I got to thinking...is it?

There's nothing in the Constitution (as far as I'm aware) about Healthcare, so is there any statutory obligation to provide it? Not that I'm advocating stepping away from Healthcare in any way (if anything, I advocate a move in the opposite direction), but if it came down to it, who has ultimate responsibility?

Basic question I know, but I'm often surprised by how the US system works. When I thought it was obvious, it turns out not to be.
 
This is the thing that I find amusing. Why are they calling this "Trumpcare"?

It is the antiquated notion at least among republicans that the leadership is ultimately responsible for the outcomes of the actions of the whole. But as the republican party is the party of personal enrichment and personal irresponsibility you can't expect them to ever accept any responsibility for their actions. That was why it was so easy for them to vote against the ACA and vote to strip 30 million people of their healthcare when they knew they would never be held responsible for it. Now they might be and that terrifies them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom