Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

But politicians who know nothing at all about how insurance works, how to manage and mitigate risk, how to adapt to moral hazard and adverse selection, and how to ensure a solvent operation... should NOT be trying to design insurance. There's a reason there's an entire testing and oversight body for actuaries. It's actually complicated!

But no one knows that, I mean even the president didn't know that when he got elected, how are normal people supposed to grapple with such unknowable things when the most competent male politician in the US can't?
 
.....
So long as they wish to maintain some element of private insurance, they should be seeking expertise from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, The American Medical Association, and the American Academy of Actuaries to make sure that what they design is sustainable and actually works.
.....

What makes you think they didn't? The ACA was adapted from a functioning system that Massachusetts developed from proposals by conservative think tanks. Congress held close to a year of public hearings with extensive input from numerous sources. But part of the plan was that all states would expand Medicaid, and Congress -- which quickly became a Republican Congress -- would appropriate enough money to pay subsidies to customers and insurance companies. The ACA could have been successful if it had been supported and refined.
 
What makes you think they didn't? The ACA was adapted from a functioning system that Massachusetts developed from proposals by conservative think tanks. Congress held close to a year of public hearings with extensive input from numerous sources. But part of the plan was that all states would expand Medicaid, and Congress -- which quickly became a Republican Congress -- would appropriate enough money to pay subsidies to customers and insurance companies. The ACA could have been successful if it had been supported and refined.

But how is making it succeed going to win the republican party any victories, they were elected and took control of congress with the mandate to destroy obamacare, not fix the healthcare system. That is what they have been about for the past 8 years.
 
But how is making it succeed going to win the republican party any victories, they were elected and took control of congress with the mandate to destroy obamacare, not fix the healthcare system. That is what they have been about for the past 8 years.

The Republicans certainly want to kill it. I was just responding to the point that politicians need input from insurance companies etc. The people who designed the ACA did get it.
 
The Republicans certainly want to kill it. I was just responding to the point that politicians need input from insurance companies etc. The people who designed the ACA did get it.

But Emily has bought far to many of the republicans lies to ever accept facts like that.
 
More trouble for BCRA.

The Senate would likely need 60 votes to overcome Democratic opposition and pass key portions of the GOP health care bill under the chamber’s rules, a blow to both the plan’s policy and its political fortunes unless Senate Republicans are willing to break decades of precedent.

The Senate’s so-called “Byrd Rule” is designed to make sure that policies passed under “budget reconciliation” — which allows legislation to advance with only 51 votes instead of the usual 60 needed to get past a filibuster — directly affect the federal budget, either by decreasing spending or increasing revenue. (Vox has explained the Byrd Rule in great detail.)

The findings of the Senate parliamentarian, who evaluates whether policies included in bills meant to pass through reconciliation comply with the Senate rules, were posted online late Friday afternoon and sent out by Democratic ranking member Sen. Bernie Sanders’s office. A Senate Republican aide noted that the parliamentarian reviewed a draft version of the bill, and the legislation could still be changed.

They are a critical blow to Republicans’ hopes of repealing and replacing Obamacare. Their plan is already short on votes, but Friday’s news could make it even more difficult for Senate leaders to sway their holdouts.

:D
 

I knew that lots of stuff they had in there did not comply with the Byrd Rule. What I wonder is how Mitch McConnell didn't though. He's been a Senator for as long as the Byrd Rule has existed.

Republicans are going to have to choose between voting for a bill that would result in taxpayer money going to abortions or voting no. Couldn't have happened to more deserving people.

I like how Bernie Sanders waited until they wasted as much time as possible and then dropped this on the Friday before they vote.

There are some more that haven't been ruled on yet:

Waivers for State Innovation (Essential Health Benefits): This section amends Sec. 1332 of the ACA to allow states to waive age rating, essential health benefits, and pre-existing condition requirements so long as their proposal does not increase the federal deficit. (Sec.207)

Small Business Health Plans: This section would allow small businesses to establish “association health plans” that could be sold across state lines. For regulatory purposes, these plans would be treated as part of the large group market and thus would be exempt from many ACA requirements such as covering essential health benefits. (Sec. 139)

Change in Permissible Age Variation in Health Insurance Premium Rates (“Age Tax”): This section allows insurers to charge older Americans at least five times more than what they charge younger individuals. (Sec. 204)

Flexible Block Grant Option for States: This section allows states the option to receive a lump sum Medicaid “block grant” instead of the per capita cap payments. (Sec. 134)

https://www.budget.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Background on Byrd Rule decisions_7.21[1].pdf


And if McConnell tries to buy individual Senators with provisions for specific states it will be challenged and ruled to be against Senate rules.

BURLINGTON, Vt., July 21 – U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) issued the following statement Friday after the Senate parliamentarian determined that the "Buffalo Bailout," a provision of the Republican health care bill specifically targeting New York state, is in violation of Senate reconciliation rules:

"Today, the Senate parliamentarian made a determination that at least a dozen provisions in the disastrous Trump-McConnell “health care” bill are in violation of Senate rules and cannot be included in this bill without 60 votes. One of these provisions is the “Buffalo Bailout” that was inserted into this bill in order to secure the vote of a tiny-handful of Republican representatives from upstate New York. This is a very important ruling. What this ruling means is that side deals which benefit individual states will most likely be ruled in violation of Senate rules. As the ranking member of the Budget Committee, I will challenge any one of these state-specific provisions. We need legislation which improves the lives of people in all 50 states, not legislation which is geared to obtaining the vote of this or that Republican senator."

https://www.budget.senate.gov/ranki...-care-side-deals-benefiting-individual-states
 
Last edited:
This one doesn't get much discussion but it is an important issue. Tax breaks (AKA subsidies) for employer-provided healthcare plans.
One of the biggest tax exclusions in the U.S. is the exclusion that allows workers who get job-based (or "employer paid") health insurance coverage not to pay taxes on the value of those policies and employers to deduct the cost as a business expense. The exclusion costs the Treasury an estimated $246 billion annually, according to Congress’ Joint Committee on Taxation, dwarfing the second-largest break, the mortgage interest deduction, which costs an estimated $98 billion. Link

You would think some conservative Republican would have attacked this long ago. That someone like Newt Gingrich would have wondered, "If an employer wants to give his work force healthcare benefits, why does the government have to pay for it?"

They have grumbled about this in the past but now they're serious. It is the way the Republicans would replace the ACA subsidies.
Employer and business groups are shifting their lobbying efforts from repealing the Affordable Care Act's unpopular “Cadillac” tax to fighting GOP proposals to chip away at the tax break on employer-provided health insurance. Capping the tax break, they say, would cause employers to offer skimpier benefits, and some would stop offering coverage altogether. That would erode the employer-sponsored health insurance market, where 178 million Americans get their health coverage.

[D]rafts of the House Republican bill to repeal the ACA showed lawmakers plan to cap the tax breaks on employer-sponsored health insurance to pay for the replacement healthcare law. It would be the single source of revenue to pay for the new age-based tax credits that would replace the ACA's subsidies. Link

Of course there's a huge flaw in the plan. If the tax break, the deductible, is capped or eliminated, guess what a lot of employers will do? See below:

.
 

Attachments

  • Employer based healthcare plans.jpg
    Employer based healthcare plans.jpg
    43.3 KB · Views: 17
The horrible bill has some chance of passing (if it only needed 50 votes...see above for the senate rule mess) . If Cruz for instance stands for anything, this will be his only chance to repeal Obamacare. It does not repeal taxes, only cuts spending. What the Cruzes and libertarians have to think (to pass) is that this will be their only chance to repeal it. It will not be repealed after the 2018 elections. By voting NO, Cruz and pals vote for an opposition view that gets them nothing. They will never get much anything in this era. Trump may be toast befor 2018. Good luck with Pence "leading." He will be like Gerry Ford.
 
Last edited:
... Good luck with Pence "leading." He will be like Gerry Ford.

Except that Ford had integrity. When I watched Pence lie his way through his debate rather than defend Trump, I got a reading on Pence. He knows considerably more about the healthcare bill than Trump (as does nearly everyone), and he's still pretending it's what they promised -- he can't wait to cast a tie-breaker on this bait-and-switch scam. Pence does not have integrity; he's sold out his pseudo-Christian soul.
 
Except that Ford had integrity. When I watched Pence lie his way through his debate rather than defend Trump, I got a reading on Pence. He knows considerably more about the healthcare bill than Trump (as does nearly everyone), and he's still pretending it's what they promised -- he can't wait to cast a tie-breaker on this bait-and-switch scam. Pence does not have integrity; he's sold out his pseudo-Christian soul.

I agree. He kisses Trump's ass, and you know that has to be conscious fakery. He denies any meetings with Russians and that is suspect as is pretending not to know what was going on in the campaign he was part of. At a minimum he's voiced no concern over the Russian hacking and meddling.

Then you get to the ACA campaign lies of which Pence completely ignores including this charade that any bill which gets passed, regardless of what is in it is somehow a victory and the keeping of the campaign promise of better cheaper health care that will cover everyone.
 
This one doesn't get much discussion but it is an important issue. Tax breaks (AKA subsidies) for employer-provided healthcare plans.


You would think some conservative Republican would have attacked this long ago. That someone like Newt Gingrich would have wondered, "If an employer wants to give his work force healthcare benefits, why does the government have to pay for it?"

They have grumbled about this in the past but now they're serious. It is the way the Republicans would replace the ACA subsidies.


Of course there's a huge flaw in the plan. If the tax break, the deductible, is capped or eliminated, guess what a lot of employers will do? See below:

.
If you remember the Heritage Plan -you know, the one that everyone falsely thinks the Democratic Party used to craft the ACA as a compromise with the Republicans- then you will remember that eliminating the employer tax breaks on health insurance was a feature of that plan. As an individual mandate to buy healthcare was supposed to roll out, such a break would be unnecessary.
 
If you remember the Heritage Plan -you know, the one that everyone falsely thinks the Democratic Party used to craft the ACA as a compromise with the Republicans- then you will remember that eliminating the employer tax breaks on health insurance was a feature of that plan. As an individual mandate to buy healthcare was supposed to roll out, such a break would be unnecessary.

This part of the Heritage foundation plan wasn’t followed because it’s stupid. Employer provided healthcare works far better than the individual market because it has large mandatory risk pools that insurance companies can effectively price. Insurance companies can not effectively price policies in an individual market with opt out provisions and no pre-existing condition clauses.

This move breaks the part of the US system that does work instead of fixing the parts than don’t.
 
This part of the Heritage foundation plan wasn’t followed because it’s stupid. Employer provided healthcare works far better than the individual market because it has large mandatory risk pools that insurance companies can effectively price. Insurance companies can not effectively price policies in an individual market with opt out provisions and no pre-existing condition clauses.

This move breaks the part of the US system that does work instead of fixing the parts than don’t.

But it doesn't work in sense that it distorts the labor market and distorts the individual market.
 
I'm not too familiar with the Heritage Plan but at least at present the Republican plan envisions capping -- but not eliminating -- the tax credits corporations get for providing employee healthcare plans.

One issue is: why has it been okay for the federal government to supply tax credits to corporations that provide healthcare plans but not okay to provide tax credits to individuals who purchase their own healthcare plan?
 
But it doesn't work
It works better than the alternative being presented.
distorts the labor market
This would be an argument in favor of single payer healthcare but not a move an individual insurance market because the inefficiencies of the individual health insurance market are much greater than anything created by employer based insurance.
distorts the individual market.
Who cares? Short of government dictated risk pools with mandatory participation the individual market can’t function efficiently anyway.
 
But it doesn't work in sense that it distorts the labor market and distorts the individual market.

I know this goes against your philosophy.but sometimes (often in my view) it is essential to distort the free market to make the society work better for its members: to protect the sick and the poor, to help the middle class, and yes, to even assist businesses and enhance the financial strength and security of the society as a whole, including the wealthy. Despite attempts by conservatives to create lies, history repeatedly demonstrates that free markets are not magical and often lead to financial disasters and /or exploitation.

You may notice that much of the tax structure of the USA tax code is intended to distort the free market so as to achieve goals members of our society seek. Many of these are to support and aid the wealthy- the Republican attempts to change health care will enhance these. But please leave alone the few that seek to help the poor and middle class.
 
They seem to be planning to shuffle the abortion birth control funds/or lack of funds elsewhere. To avoid the 60 vote rule.

Doesn't their replacement for the mandate also fall under that rule?
 
One issue is: why has it been okay for the federal government to supply tax credits to corporations that provide healthcare plans but not okay to provide tax credits to individuals who purchase their own healthcare plan?

Like so many things in this discussion it was originally a Republican alternative to what Democrats wanted, which was a single payer government funded system.

It’s near impossible to create an efficient individual market without mandatory participation and definable risk pools. (Even then, countries that take this approach seem to have higher per capita healthcare costs, at least anecdotally) If you are not going to have a single payer system or a highly regulated individual market it makes sense to move as many people into the employer based system as possible because while not ideal it’s better than the alternative.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom