Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

But health insurance is confusing. Didn't you know that? :rolleyes:

I really wish politicians would stop trying to develop health insurance. None of them know what the heck they're doing. This idiot least of all.

Before the ACA doctors often had to call insurance company clerks with high school diplomas to get permission to treat a patient.

No, Congress didn't implement the ACA so it followed insurance company practice. Requiring anyone apply for insurance had to fill out a detailed medical questionnaire before they can even get an individual quote. Society wasn't well served by that absurd complication.
 
But health insurance is confusing. Didn't you know that? :rolleyes:

I really wish politicians would stop trying to develop health insurance. None of them know what the heck they're doing. This idiot least of all.

You think private insurance companies should be able to do whatever they want? Medicare and Medicaid were developed by politicians. Every country that has universal coverage got a system created by their politicians. The problem with the U.S. is that our right-wing politicians reject the core principle that everyone is entitled to basic health care, which in our country is paid for by insurance of one kind or another. The ACA is so complicated because so many conflicting interests had to be accommodated, as the Republicans have started to understand.
 
Interesting. I'd been assuming that Trump's promises about insurance back on the campaign trail were just shameless lies. It never occurred to me that he might be sincere but entirely divorced from reality. I wonder what he thinks Obamacare is.

I don't think he needs to know. It's Obama-something, so it's bad and he's against it.
 
Like with Bush Jr., not knowing **** is supposedly fine if you got knowledgeable people around you and have a willingness to educate yourself.
Trump has neither.
 
But health insurance is confusing. Didn't you know that? :rolleyes:

Clearly no one knew that before the election. Thank god we have the worlds best deal maker on this exerting all of his skills to improve the situation. Just like all those who voted for him wanted.
 
President Donnie has announced that now his "healthcare plan" is to let "Obamacare fail."
"We’ll let Obamacare fail, and then the Democrats are going to come to us.” Link

With, of course, some help from the Donmeister. Here's what he's doing already:
  1. Weaken enforcement of the individual mandate.
  2. Impose work requirements for Medicaid recipients.
  3. Fail to do advertising or outreach.

Here's what he plans:
  • Make tax credits for premiums less generous.
  • Defund subsidies that help people pay out-of-pocket costs.
  • Redefine essential health benefits.
 
But health insurance is confusing. Didn't you know that? :rolleyes:

I really wish politicians would stop trying to develop health insurance. None of them know what the heck they're doing. This idiot least of all.


Part of the problem, probably a very minor part, and one I've mentioned before, is that some people don't need insurance, they need healthcare:

From the article:

"for someone born with a heart condition, for example, there was no halcyon period in their 20s when they could pay into the system without needing more back in coverage"

In this instance you can't have any sort of conventional, individual 'insurance' here. No underwriter ever, without coercion, is going to insure a risk that's already happened.

What you can have is a risk pool, a collective insurance where all who pay in know that they're paying for the long term sick but accept that because we live in an interlinked society.

However, the greatest ever American has already spoken, so that can't happen:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b2/Reagan-LPcover.jpg
 
President Trumpmeister is committed to doing everything he can to get rid of Obamacare yet the strange reality is:
A new Washington Post/ABC News poll found voters prefer Obamacare to the Republican health bill by a 2-to-1 margin — 50 to 24 percent...Surveys find that Medicaid enrollees really like their coverage; they’re just as satisfied as people who get health insurance at work. Indeed, the Medicaid expansion has proven so popular, and so effective, that Senate Republicans from Medicaid-expanding states like Ohio and Nevada have been fighting to preserve it. Link


D'oh! Stupid people!
 

Attachments

  • Angry Donnie.jpg
    Angry Donnie.jpg
    28.2 KB · Views: 8
I think at the present time it might be better for the Democrats in Congress to stay out of this mess. They undoubtedly do have some fixes in mind for the problems with ACA -- and even Obama conceded that ACA could use some overhauling -- but in the present climate it might be smarter for the Dems to stay quiet and keep their heads down. No matter what they say or do the Republicans will find a way to cast it as negative.

Trump repeatedly promised, boasted actually, to have a better healthcare plan, giving much better care than ACA at lower cost and that would "cover everyone." This is what he told the Washington Post in January:


He's certainly not saying that now. And this is the problem. He has consistently been, at best wrong and at worst dishonest, about the kind of replacement plan his administration would come up with. Yet when the contradictions between what Trump promised and what he is trying to deliver -- cover everybody versus 20 million people become uninsured -- his supporters go into denial/attack mode. This just doesn't seem like the time when reasonable bipartisan policy-making has much of a chance.

The basic problem is that Republicans have an almost religious belief in the idea that less regulation is always better (As opposed to the more balanced approach of Democrats which has been to either increase or decrease government involvement as needed to reach an optimal solution.), so they assume they can always make things better and cheaper by cutting taxes and reducing regulations. The only people left on the Republican side of the isle fall into one of 2 categories, those who are shocked when this turns out not to be the case, and those who insist you just need to double down and somehow it will all work out eventually.

They all start out with the belief that things will automatically be better until they start to flesh out the policy, which inevitably brings the two into conflict. In the interest of party unity, they avoid trying to assemble real policy but they are now in a spot where they can’t avoid it. Sadly, the result of this internal conflict is likely to be that Republicans are likely to eject any party member who isn’t willing to double down on polices that all available facts say will fail and cause enormous damage.
 
The basic problem is that Republicans have an almost religious belief in the idea that less regulation is always better (As opposed to the more balanced approach of Democrats which has been to either increase or decrease government involvement as needed to reach an optimal solution.), so they assume they can always make things better and cheaper by cutting taxes and reducing regulations. The only people left on the Republican side of the isle fall into one of 2 categories, those who are shocked when this turns out not to be the case, and those who insist you just need to double down and somehow it will all work out eventually.

They all start out with the belief that things will automatically be better until they start to flesh out the policy, which inevitably brings the two into conflict. In the interest of party unity, they avoid trying to assemble real policy but they are now in a spot where they can’t avoid it. Sadly, the result of this internal conflict is likely to be that Republicans are likely to eject any party member who isn’t willing to double down on polices that all available facts say will fail and cause enormous damage.

The magic of the marketplace will solve all problems if we just get government out of the way. :D

That was almost exactly what Rush Limbaugh was saying about health insurance a couple days ago.

In reality the goal should be an efficient market. One where both buyer and seller fully understand the product or service and offers from different suppliers can be easily compared. The ACA exchanges are a good step in that direction.
 
Healthcare will never be a model market: if it's literally a question of life and limb, economic considerations go out of the window, and everyone knows it.
That's why it needs massive supervision and a good deal of regulations.
 
Healthcare will never be a model market: if it's literally a question of life and limb, economic considerations go out of the window, and everyone knows it.
That's why it needs massive supervision and a good deal of regulations.

Yup, there was no invisible hand smacking the **** out of Martin Shkreli.
 
In reality the goal should be an efficient market. One where both buyer and seller fully understand the product or service and offers from different suppliers can be easily compared.

Yup, and to take that a step farther, sometimes an efficient market requires less regulation and sometimes it requires more. The problem with US politics at the for the last 25 years Democrats have been aiming to find the right amount of regulation and right amount of taxation to make the market efficient while Republicans have simply argued for less in all cases at all times regardless of the consequences.

This has left the US with very few cases of over-regulation, many cases of under-regulation and a President+Congress with a near religious commitment to deregulating already under-regulated things and cutting taxes to levels below that required to pay for things Republicans want to spend on.
 
Before the ACA doctors often had to call insurance company clerks with high school diplomas to get permission to treat a patient.

No, Congress didn't implement the ACA so it followed insurance company practice. Requiring anyone apply for insurance had to fill out a detailed medical questionnaire before they can even get an individual quote. Society wasn't well served by that absurd complication.

You think private insurance companies should be able to do whatever they want? Medicare and Medicaid were developed by politicians. Every country that has universal coverage got a system created by their politicians. The problem with the U.S. is that our right-wing politicians reject the core principle that everyone is entitled to basic health care, which in our country is paid for by insurance of one kind or another. The ACA is so complicated because so many conflicting interests had to be accommodated, as the Republicans have started to understand.

You both read my post completely differently from what I intended. Allow me to clarify:

Having politicians design health insurance is like having politicians design automobiles. Sure, they might decide that everyone has a right to a car, and that every car should have airbags, and that quality brakes are a requirement... But that's significantly different from designing a car where the transmission, engine, and drive train all work together efficiently and effectively. Would you trust even your most favorite politician to design a car for you to drive? I sincerely hope you would not.

This is similar.

So long as they wish to maintain some element of private insurance, they should be seeking expertise from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, The American Medical Association, and the American Academy of Actuaries to make sure that what they design is sustainable and actually works.

That's not at all implying that insurance companies should be able to do whatever they want, nor is it implying that they should roll back to the market as it existed pre-ACA.

But politicians who know nothing at all about how insurance works, how to manage and mitigate risk, how to adapt to moral hazard and adverse selection, and how to ensure a solvent operation... should NOT be trying to design insurance. There's a reason there's an entire testing and oversight body for actuaries. It's actually complicated!
 
The magic of the marketplace will solve all problems if we just get government out of the way. :D

That was almost exactly what Rush Limbaugh was saying about health insurance a couple days ago.

In reality the goal should be an efficient market. One where both buyer and seller fully understand the product or service and offers from different suppliers can be easily compared. The ACA exchanges are a good step in that direction.

The problem is that health insurance (all insurance actually) is not, and has never been, a free market.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom