Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Is it?


Sure, the ACA needs improvements. Those counties without coverage, for example, could be revised by redrawing some borders to merge them with neighboring counties. The subsidies to insurers could be restored. But a return to pre-2009 conditions would be catastrophic.

Everyone was better off when there was no real individual market. They knew they couldn't afford to get sick and so they didn't. Now people think that they can be self employed and get health insurance, total crazy talk.
 
IMO the Democratic Party is going to have to develop some attractive policies and become very adept at communicating them if they're going to make the necessary headway in the 2018 elections.
I think they should develop said policies and sit on them. Say they have an alternative, say the alternative is much better than anything the GOP has, but give out absolutely no details for Fox to poison the well with, until the pendulum swings back and it can be presented for actual debate. Informed voters are already with them. Emotional voters won't be swayed by details anyway.

In other words, they should do the same thing the GOP did, only actually have a good plan and not half-ass it at the last minute when their bluff gets called.
 
I think they should develop said policies and sit on them. Say they have an alternative, say the alternative is much better than anything the GOP has, but give out absolutely no details for Fox to poison the well with, until the pendulum swings back and it can be presented for actual debate. Informed voters are already with them. Emotional voters won't be swayed by details anyway.

In other words, they should do the same thing the GOP did, only actually have a good plan and not half-ass it at the last minute when their bluff gets called.

Agree with everything but the bolded part. Fox will poison the well regardless of whether or not there are any details. That is their job, to act as a propaganda mill for conservatives. Hide the details and only their version will be available. Considering how nuts they got with Obamacare and its relatively open process, hoping they will behave when there are no facts to contradict their lies is a pipe dream.
 
Twitterer-in-chief: "The Republicans never discuss how good their healthcare bill is"

Perhaps because the good part is tax breaks for the rich?
 
Everyone was better off when there was no real individual market. They knew they couldn't afford to get sick and so they didn't. Now people think that they can be self employed and get health insurance, total crazy talk.
And if they did want to get sick, they made sure to get a job with insurance first!
55ca34807b1d696d07f9a8ebc5e8f2ab.jpg
 
And the hard-core right wing of the GOP have changed their talking point to "we were elected to repeal Obamacare".

Just drop 'replace' and pretend repeal is what you campaigned on all along. Pretend you never claimed to have a magical replacement plan. Pretend the public hates the ACA despite the fact 50% support it and that number is even higher if you ask about the ACA rather than Obamacare despite the fact they are one in the same.
 
The GOP agenda:

"we don't like this car, so we are going to drive it off a cliff and wait for the Democrats to make us a new one we like better."
 
And the hard-core right wing of the GOP have changed their talking point to "we were elected to repeal Obamacare".

Just drop 'replace' and pretend repeal is what you campaigned on all along. Pretend you never claimed to have a magical replacement plan. Pretend the public hates the ACA despite the fact 50% support it and that number is even higher if you ask about the ACA rather than Obamacare despite the fact they are one in the same.

one and the same. /pedant
 
Trump challenges senators to resurrect Obamacare repeal effort: ‘We’re close’

Hoping to avoid a humiliating political defeat, President Trump on Wednesday demanded that Republican senators resume their efforts to approve a plan to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act, insisting that lawmakers are “very close.”

https://www.washingtonpost.com/powe...no-name:homepage/story&utm_term=.5b6811843b60

So we're back to repeal and replace, evidently. Fool can't make up his minf
 
Trump now thinks he's a schoolmaster and can give the Senators detention?
He thinks he's the boss, and can demand that his underlings stay working late in order to make progress / punish them for their indolence.

I thoroughly approve of him bullying his own party. Maybe it will help some of them find their spine.
 
I sure would like to attend some of the Republican meetings that are going on right now in Washington, D.C.

The number of charges and counter-charges being thrown around that lot of stupid, idiotic, liars would be most amusing to watch.
 
As much as I dislike Trump,this "all Republicans are either evil or stupid or both' routine is getting annoying.
 
Yes, it is.

Wow, that is an interesting article. Most of it focuses on the change in the uninsured rate. But as I've said already, that is almost all coming from Medicaid expansions, not from the individual market. There's been no perceptible change in the non-Medicaid-eligible uninsured volume.

Beyond that, a lot of their stats are misleading. And there's a whole lot of knowledge lacking in it. A comparison of a 10 year period (2000-2010) versus a 5 year period in which the actual effect of ACA was only felt for 2 years is really misleading. Underlying cost trend has been steady since 2014 - when ACA actually took effect in the marketplace. It was highest in the early 2000s, and the health insurance industry was already taking massive steps to bring those costs down:
https://www.pwc.com/us/en/health-industries/health-research-institute/behind-the-numbers.html

Sure, the ACA needs improvements. Those counties without coverage, for example, could be revised by redrawing some borders to merge them with neighboring counties. The subsidies to insurers could be restored. But a return to pre-2009 conditions would be catastrophic.

A return to pre-ACA Medicaid would be catastrophic, definitely. A return to pre-ACA Individual market wuld be problematic for some, but for others would be a massive improvement. Either way, it's irrelevant. ACA is very slightly better than what we had before... but it's still not sustainable and it's still not successful.
 
There's nothing in the Constitution (as far as I'm aware) about Healthcare, so is there any statutory obligation to provide it?
No. Pre Obamacare, health care is not a right but a privilege.

Not that I'm advocating stepping away from Healthcare in any way (if anything, I advocate a move in the opposite direction), but if it came down to it, who has ultimate responsibility?
The individual.

Basic question I know, but I'm often surprised by how the US system works. When I thought it was obvious, it turns out not to be.
If you have a full-time job your employer probably offers membership in a pool for your immediate family (not free, but probably cheaper than individual plans). If you are 65 or older, you're eligible for Medicare. If you're 26 or younger you can qualify on your parents' plan (again, not free, but probably cheaper than an individual plan). If you're absolutely indigent, you probably qualify for Medicaid (for now).

Under a repeal and at least one Senate replacement bill, if you are under 65, working but not in a job with benefits, you're pretty much on your own. For example, if you have 2 part-time jobs there is no obligation for an employer to cover you. If you have an emergency you can show up at an ER and probably get treatment, but for anything major the hospital will start going after your assets. Once your assets are gone, you go bankrupt and may qualify for Medicaid.

That's my understanding of the old system.
 
Watching a Stephen Colbert clip and he brought up the fact that the Republicans voted 60 times to repeal the ACA when Obama was in the White House. As soon as you have Republican President they can't muster the votes to get a repeal measure through. It seems like it was all just theatre to keep the tea-party crowd happy but their terrified of the prospect of an actual repeal.
 
As much as I dislike Trump,this "all Republicans are either evil or stupid or both' routine is getting annoying.

It would help a lot if some of those smart, non-evil Republicans (and I know for a fact that they're out there) asserted themselves within the party a bit more and started getting more of their own kind in leadership positions. To relate it to the thread topic, healthcare reform seems like exactly the type of issue the lends itself to moderate reform. I remember Sen. Bill Cassidy making some noises that sounded coherent and non-diabolical. Don't think too many folks listened to him.
 
No. Pre Obamacare, health care is not a right but a privilege.

The individual.

If you have a full-time job your employer probably offers membership in a pool for your immediate family (not free, but probably cheaper than individual plans). If you are 65 or older, you're eligible for Medicare. If you're 26 or younger you can qualify on your parents' plan (again, not free, but probably cheaper than an individual plan). If you're absolutely indigent, you probably qualify for Medicaid (for now).

Under a repeal and at least one Senate replacement bill, if you are under 65, working but not in a job with benefits, you're pretty much on your own. For example, if you have 2 part-time jobs there is no obligation for an employer to cover you. If you have an emergency you can show up at an ER and probably get treatment, but for anything major the hospital will start going after your assets. Once your assets are gone, you go bankrupt and may qualify for Medicaid.

That's my understanding of the old system.

I just note that the 26-or-under provision was an ACA innovation. Before that, insurance companies could cut children off at 21.

And one alternative under the old system was to rack up huge medical bills, then declare bankruptcy. That was one of the primary causes of bankruptcy under the old system. Of course, that person would never get insurance again, unless he found a job that provided it, and maybe not even then.
 
Funny typo on CNN.com for a story on the CBO projection if the Repeal Only is passed.

CNN said:
The bill is modeled after the 2015 bill that passed both chambers of Congress, but was vetoed by then-President Obamacare. Nearly all of today's current Republican senators voted for the 2015 bill.

*bold added by me


Sure, let's just rename the President :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom