Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Schumer and Pelosi should tell them that if they want Democrats to even consider, that cutting Medicaid is off the table and that any bill must increased the number of people covered.
They can probably try that if the straight repeal fails, but will it? I'm waiting for some Republicans to commit to voting against a straight repeal, certainly the conservatives who didn't like repeal and replace because it didn't go far enough won't vote against a repeal.
 
Schumer and Pelosi should tell them that if they want Democrats to even consider, that cutting Medicaid is off the table and that any bill must increased the number of people covered.

And they can even justify it on the grounds that this is what the President promised.
 
They can probably try that if the straight repeal fails, but will it? I'm waiting for some Republicans to commit to voting against a straight repeal, certainly the conservatives who didn't like repeal and replace because it didn't go far enough won't vote against a repeal.

Collins and Capito are already no.

I would be shocked if they pass this
 
“I alone can fix it.”

~~ Donald Trump, speaking at the Republican national convention in July 2016.

“I’m not going to own it.”

~~President Trump, quoted by the AP, after the GOP effort to repeal Obamacare collapsed.

--------
 
Last edited:
I think a clear failure on healthcare is exactly the type of thing that can overshadow some of the other big wins of Trump's administration. Not clear how Republican voters will assign blame, but I'm pretty sure that Trump won't come out of it looking good.
 
c) ramp up the penalties to the the point that young people will be forced to buy coverage. Emphasize that, despite appearances, they themselves will actually get old some day, thus balancing the equation.

Stack on penalties to ensure that they can't afford either thing, and end up screwed no matter what! :thumbsup:

If there were some sort of a savings plan in place, that might make more sense. But there's not - it's not like the money being paid by young people today is going to cover their costs when they're old. This is straight up nothing but intergenerational subsidization. It's bankrupting* young people today with the promise that they'll get to bankrupt younger people at some unspecified point in the future.

*Yes, hyperbole. OMG!!! :eek:
 
Current version of the health care bill is officially dead:

New GOP health bill lacks the votes to pass



So what happens now? Any chance of some kind of bipartisan reform?



Why are you laughing?

It's a new low bar when my greatest hope is that nothing horrible makes it through. That's all. I'm not hoping for any improvements at this point, just hoping nobody makes it worse. Where are we at as a country when the best option is total gridlock in our government? :(
 
He thinks that if it's repealed the Democrats will forced to come to the table to craft a new bill on Republican terms. McCain on the other hand, if I'm understanding correctly, is talking about a bipartisan repeal and replace bill, which would put the Democrats in a stronger position.

I think you're being too complicated. Trump just wants it to be known as Trumpcare™* that's his only motivation.



*even if it were exactly the same as Obamacare.
 
It is metaphysically impossible for Republicans to come up with a healthcare plan that is better than Obamacare. Because to Republicans, the most important part of healthcare reform is tax cuts.
 
I get annoyed at how little push-back we are hearing from the Democrats.

For how many years now have we heard over and over that Obama Care has failed, is failing, whatever. It's been the GOP intense talking point for days. I have only heard a couple newscasters, mostly on MSNBC, push back and challenge the claim.

Where are all the Democratic talking heads telling us it is not failing or failed, whatever.

LA Times (column): Republicans call Obamacare a 'failure.' These 7 charts show they couldn't be more wrong

All the while we hear the utterly dishonest proclamation that Trump and/or the GOP have a better plan with more coverage for less money. It's a bald-faced lie. And even that gets little push-back and rarely is it ever called what it really is, a lie.
 
“I alone can fix it.”

~~ Donald Trump, speaking at the Republican national convention in July 2016.

“I’m not going to own it.”

~~President Trump, quoted by the AP, after the GOP effort to repeal Obamacare collapsed.

--------

This is the thing that I find amusing. Why are they calling this "Trumpcare"? He clearly has almost nothing to do with it. I'm sure his staff might be involved in some of it, but he has made it clear that it is up to congressional leadership to come up with something. Despite his claims that "we" are going to do it easy and cheap, he's left it up to someone else. It's kind of the opposite of leadership.

Obama led the way with the ACA. Yeah, Pelosi et all were involved and so on, but Obama led it, and everyone else followed. Meanwhile, Trump doesn't have a clue what is even in the friggin bill.
 
This is the thing that I find amusing. Why are they calling this "Trumpcare"? He clearly has almost nothing to do with it. I'm sure his staff might be involved in some of it, but he has made it clear that it is up to congressional leadership to come up with something. Despite his claims that "we" are going to do it easy and cheap, he's left it up to someone else. It's kind of the opposite of leadership.

Obama led the way with the ACA. Yeah, Pelosi et all were involved and so on, but Obama led it, and everyone else followed. Meanwhile, Trump doesn't have a clue what is even in the friggin bill.

Republicans naming the ACA Obamacare didn't have anything to do with how much work he did on it. It was propaganda. They correctly figured that people would like Obamacare less than the ACA.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom