Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Can you do a full repeal under budget reconciliation?

No, they can't repeal the regulations that way.

They did pass a "repeal" in 2015 using reconciliation gutted it as much as possible. But they were protected from the consequences of that because they knew for a fact that Obama would veto it.

Same bill would not pass now, almost certainly.
 
McCain calls for 'return to regular order' on ObamaCare repeal

Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) said Monday night Congress should “return to regular order” to craft a replacement for ObamaCare.

“One of the major problems with Obamacare was that it was written on a strict party-line basis and driven through Congress without a single Republican vote. As this law continues to crumble in Arizona and states across the country, we must not repeat the original mistakes that led to Obamacare’s failure,” he said in a statement from Arizona, where he is recovering from surgery.

“The Congress must now return to regular order, hold hearings, receive input from members of both parties, and heed the recommendations of our nation's governors so that we can produce a bill that finally provides Americans with access to quality and affordable health care.”

McCain’s statement comes after GOP Sens. Jerry Moran (Kan.) and Mike Lee (Utah) announced on Monday night they will not support taking up a bill repealing and replacing ObamaCare, effectively blocking the legislation.

Sounds like nothing will be done in the near future then. Effectively it may be left for the next congress. This year is more than halfway over already and next year is an election year. And they probably want to move on to other things like big tax cuts for the rich.
 
An there is a lie there, that Obamacare was passed without Republican input. The Democrats invited them, had hearings and implemented plenty of Republican amendments but the Republicans keep on telling lies about it.
 
I don't understand why the news media can't just come out and say it, the GOP cannot deliver on replacing the ACA because they've been lying about actually having a replacement all this time.

The media will report everything but like, 'can't get both the moderates and the far right in the party together'. That is not the problem. Or, 'they are trying to please the base'. That is also not the problem. Or, 'they had 7 years to get a plan together and didn't do it.' That last one is as far as the news media wants to go when it comes to stating the truth.

On the other side the news media has repeated the Democratic message, it's a tax cut and the GOP wants to get rid of the Medicaid expansion. But that still side-steps the one unstated fact:

The truth is, the GOP promised a magical health care bill and it has always been and continues to be a big lie. I wish the media would at least mention that truth.



As I post this I am reminded of the latest GOP talking point, the ACA only impacts 10% of the population. If that is the case, why all the fuss about the things the ACA mandated insurers cover?

Because the news media wants to treat it as a drama like house of cards far more than they want to report on the actual policies being discussed. So they focus on votes and not effects.
 
For me, I am amazed by the public spectacle of the GOP pressing forward with a plan that is overwhelmingly opposed and hated by the vast majority of the public, the medical community, the health insurance businesses, many or most State governors (including many Republicans), and, in fact, a singnificant number of GOP Senators (who have to be unhappily recruited one by one by threats or "brides"). A plan that will take away access to health insurance for 10s of millions and raise premiums on many of the ill and elderly. Doesn't the Republican leadership feel at least a bit embarrassed by their obvious desperation to pass this stinking heap of legislation that is going to be a disaster for so many, with the only possible goals to repudiate Obama and funding tax cuts to the wealthiest?

The problem is that they look bad no matter what happens. Now they look like they can not even get their own party to vote for their legislation, and can not carry through their promises to repeal Obamacare.
 
Realistically, I think expanding Medicare has virtually no chance to survive a Republican Congress. They're going in the opposite direction: they want to restrict Medicare eligibility.

Ryan does want to privatize it so that the governments contribution can be controlled.
 
McCain calls for 'return to regular order' on ObamaCare repeal



Sounds like nothing will be done in the near future then. Effectively it may be left for the next congress. This year is more than halfway over already and next year is an election year. And they probably want to move on to other things like big tax cuts for the rich.

Yet, if this had come up for a vote, McCain would have voted for it. I didn't hear him come out opposed. Typical. The guy is all talk but in the end is just a lap dog.
 
The GOP can't ditch all of its extremists in order to find common ground with Democrats: Paul Ryan is one of them, after all.
It would probably be easier to let the Democrats draft the reform, and see how many Republicans are willing to go along.

What would the point be, could it even get a vote in the house if Ryan was against it?
 
Not really. The risk corridors were always planned to sunset, as was the federal reinsurance. The mandate might have some impact, but it really hasn't been as big a driver of adoption as you might think. At max, it still ends up being equivalent to roughly 2 months of premium on a silver plan, depending where you are and the prevailing prices in that area.

The biggest death knells for ACA are:
  • It doesn't do anything about cost
  • large provider groups know insurers have geo-access requirements and have been unwilling to come down on price
  • Most of the new entrants to the marketplace are older and/or sicker than average, definitely higher cost than in the pre-ACA market
  • The youngest and healthiest can stay on their parent's group coverage for a fraction of the price until age 26
  • Essential benefits are extensive and significantly more coverage than previously available which forces prices up
  • How Actuarial Value is defined exacerbates adverse selection impacts

Those aren't any of the things that have been 'sabotaged'. Those are the basic underpinnings of the law.

The "Law" was a compromise that was forced on Obama.
It could be improved but the Republicans have no interest in doing that.
 
I see President Trump is calling for the ACA to be repealed without there being any kind of replacement of the horizon - I guess deliberately creating a burning bridge.

That sounds like the way to create a really crappy piece of legislation to me but what do I know.

It'll be interesting to see how it plays out if the GOP deliberately allows the ACA to fail. I hope they will be punished electorally, sadly I think they may not.
 
So what happens now? Any chance of some kind of bipartisan reform?



Why are you laughing?

If they were smart they would stay out of it entirely. There are no reforms Republicans are willing to support that will improve the existing law, and Democratic participation will end up being nothing more than a scapegoat for the failure of the process. Real forward movement can only come from the Republican based summing to terms with the flaws in their dogma or from a Democratic majority.
 
I see President Trump is calling for the ACA to be repealed without there being any kind of replacement of the horizon - I guess deliberately creating a burning bridge.

That sounds like the way to create a really crappy piece of legislation to me but what do I know.


Republicans passed that in 2015 (Obama vetoed) . The CBO said 32 million would lose insurance and premiums would double.

There is no way there are 50 Senators that would vote for that. Mitch McConnell is talking about bringing it up for a vote. Maybe just to show Trump how little support there is for that idea.


And Trump also blames all the Democrats (and a few Republicans) for the bill dying.

I think that the Democrats would love to be "blamed" for it not passing.
 
If they were smart they would stay out of it entirely. There are no reforms Republicans are willing to support that will improve the existing law, and Democratic participation will end up being nothing more than a scapegoat for the failure of the process. Real forward movement can only come from the Republican based summing to terms with the flaws in their dogma or from a Democratic majority.

The "disaster" that is ACA is the result of a Democratic Party attempt to compromise. As some great philosopher once said:

FortyThree said:
There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again
 
Republicans passed that in 2015 (Obama vetoed) . The CBO said 32 million would lose insurance and premiums would double.

There is no way there are 50 Senators that would vote for that. Mitch McConnell is talking about bringing it up for a vote. Maybe just to show Trump how little support there is for that idea.

They will change their vote? They thought it was a good idea recently what changed their mind?
 
They will change their vote? They thought it was a good idea recently what changed their mind?

What changed their minds is that now there is no Obama to veto it, so they would have to live with the consequences of it actually becoming law. Political theater vs reality.
 
What changed their minds is that now there is no Obama to veto it, so they would have to live with the consequences of it actually becoming law. Political theater vs reality.

So flip flopping. You really think the republicans have lost enough control to let something that bad come up for a vote?
 
I see President Trump is calling for the ACA to be repealed without there being any kind of replacement of the horizon - I guess deliberately creating a burning bridge.

That sounds like the way to create a really crappy piece of legislation to me but what do I know.

It'll be interesting to see how it plays out if the GOP deliberately allows the ACA to fail. I hope they will be punished electorally, sadly I think they may not.
He thinks that if it's repealed the Democrats will forced to come to the table to craft a new bill on Republican terms. McCain on the other hand, if I'm understanding correctly, is talking about a bipartisan repeal and replace bill, which would put the Democrats in a stronger position.
 
He thinks that if it's repealed the Democrats will forced to come to the table to craft a new bill on Republican terms. McCain on the other hand, if I'm understanding correctly, is talking about a bipartisan repeal and replace bill, which would put the Democrats in a stronger position.

Schumer and Pelosi should tell them that if they want Democrats to even consider, that cutting Medicaid is off the table and that any bill must increased the number of people covered.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom