Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

I don't understand why the news media can't just come out and say it, the GOP cannot deliver on replacing the ACA because they've been lying about actually having a replacement all this time.

The media will report everything but like, 'can't get both the moderates and the far right in the party together'. That is not the problem. Or, 'they are trying to please the base'. That is also not the problem. Or, 'they had 7 years to get a plan together and didn't do it.' That last one is as far as the news media wants to go when it comes to stating the truth.

On the other side the news media has repeated the Democratic message, it's a tax cut and the GOP wants to get rid of the Medicaid expansion. But that still side-steps the one unstated fact:

The truth is, the GOP promised a magical health care bill and it has always been and continues to be a big lie. I wish the media would at least mention that truth.



As I post this I am reminded of the latest GOP talking point, the ACA only impacts 10% of the population. If that is the case, why all the fuss about the things the ACA mandated insurers cover?
 
For me, I am amazed by the public spectacle of the GOP pressing forward with a plan that is overwhelmingly opposed and hated by the vast majority of the public, the medical community, the health insurance businesses, many or most State governors (including many Republicans), and, in fact, a singnificant number of GOP Senators (who have to be unhappily recruited one by one by threats or "brides"). A plan that will take away access to health insurance for 10s of millions and raise premiums on many of the ill and elderly. Doesn't the Republican leadership feel at least a bit embarrassed by their obvious desperation to pass this stinking heap of legislation that is going to be a disaster for so many, with the only possible goals to repudiate Obama and funding tax cuts to the wealthiest?
 
...Bronze plans would be cheaper by quite a bit, which would appease the young/healthy people who can't get decent coverage for the price they're paying. Gold plans would be more expensive, which would reflect the inherent adverse selection of richer plans...

But doesn't that run counter to one of the fundamentals of ACA? If you decrease the amount the younger people are paying, then you have to increase the amount older people are paying until their premiums begin to get prohibitively expensive. Which sounds pretty much like where we were pre-ACA.


Gradually lower the age of eligibility for Medicare. The benefits would also need to be modified as that age lowers, to ultimately include maternity and pediatrics among other services...

Realistically, I think expanding Medicare has virtually no chance to survive a Republican Congress. They're going in the opposite direction: they want to restrict Medicare eligibility.
 
But doesn't that run counter to one of the fundamentals of ACA? If you decrease the amount the younger people are paying, then you have to increase the amount older people are paying until their premiums begin to get prohibitively expensive. Which sounds pretty much like where we were pre-ACA.




Realistically, I think expanding Medicare has virtually no chance to survive a Republican Congress. They're going in the opposite direction: they want to restrict Medicare eligibility.


That's a pretty safe bet.

Anything which might actually improve healthcare access for Americans has virtually no chance to survive a Republican Congress.

I think this would be true even if the solution was 100% free of cost to the government.

It is unquestionably true if there is any additional cost at all.
 
For me, I am amazed by the public spectacle of the GOP pressing forward with a plan that is overwhelmingly opposed and hated by the vast majority of the public, the medical community, the health insurance businesses, many or most State governors (including many Republicans), and, in fact, a singnificant number of GOP Senators (who have to be unhappily recruited one by one by threats or "brides"). A plan that will take away access to health insurance for 10s of millions and raise premiums on many of the ill and elderly. Doesn't the Republican leadership feel at least a bit embarrassed by their obvious desperation to pass this stinking heap of legislation that is going to be a disaster for so many, with the only possible goals to repudiate Obama and funding tax cuts to the wealthiest?
I'm not sure the GOP "leadership" sees anything from a non-swamp perspective. The perceptions being reported back by Republican congress-critters whose July 4th break was ruined by the matter are a challenge to be managed. They are not something that needs to be taken account of in any other sense.

Obama was the porch-light which kept the GOP swarm together, but with that extinguished they revert to a disparate bunch of bugs heading into the night on their own peculiar pursuits.
 
Another opinion about ACA from Amy Davidson Sorkin, a staff writer at The New Yorker magazine:

One of Obamacare’s innovations was to expand Medicaid eligibility to include people slightly above the poverty level. The federal government now pays the states a percentage of what it costs them to care for eligible residents: if a state spends more, it gets more, within certain parameters...many middle-class families rely on the A.C.A.’s essential health benefits, which include substance-abuse treatment, to deal with dependency issues.

Before Obamacare, when people who had insurance developed a serious health condition, they often discovered that it wasn’t covered by their policy, or that there were so many co-payments, deductibles, mysterious charges, and caps—including lifetime caps—that their coverage amounted to little more than a discount coupon on something that remained unaffordable. People found themselves without coverage for hospitalization, prescription drugs, and pediatric and chronic-disease care. A key contribution of the Affordable Care Act was to define each of those services, and some others, as “essential health benefits”—services that a plan had to cover in order to call itself a plan.

McConnell, Speaker of the House Paul Ryan, and others have brushed off concerns from constituents who say that Obamacare has saved their lives by claiming that the program has already “collapsed.” This is not true; the exchanges are under pressure, largely because of the uncertainties that the Republicans have introduced, but the percentage of Americans who are uninsured has fallen from sixteen per cent to nine per cent. The rate of personal bankruptcy, often attributable to medical costs, has also fallen. Link
 
Kasich spokesman: Pence’s healthcare claims ‘false’
The false assertion:
“I know Gov. Kasich isn’t with us, but I suspect that he’s very troubled to know that in Ohio alone, nearly 60,000 disabled citizens are stuck on waiting lists, leaving them without the care they need for months or even years,” Pence said in a speech Friday at the National Governors Association summer meeting in Providence, R.I.

VP Pence made a fake news claim today and has been called on it by multiple sources including GOP governor Kasich.
Ohio Gov. John Kasich's (R) office has flatly rejected Vice President Pence's claim that nearly 60,000 disabled Ohioans are on waiting lists for Medicaid’s home and community-based services.

Not to mention all the GOP bill would so is make said waiting lists longer.
According to the Post, waiting lists for such Medicaid services are common and are typically longer in states that did not take ObamaCare's Medicaid expansion than in those that did.

Ohio was among a number of Republican-controlled states that took the ACA's Medicaid expansion, which dramatically expanded the number of people who qualify for the program.

Senate GOP leaders' healthcare bill – the Better Care Reconciliation Act – calls for deep cuts to Medicaid, prompting some more moderate Republican members to voice misgivings about the measure.


VP Pence spreading ‘fake news’ about Ohio
About a week after the White House spread misinformation about Ohio’s Medicaid program, Vice President Mike Pence falsely said Friday that 60,000 Ohioans are going without care because of the state’s Medicaid expansion.

That prompted Kasich’s press secretary, Jon Keeling, to tweet: “That’s what we call #fakenews.” Keeling included a link to The Dispatch’s Capital Insider column from last Sunday citing state Medicaid data to refute an article cited by the White House. In what “the West Wing is reading,” the inaccurate piece said that after expanding Medicaid, Ohio “rolled back eligibility for some 34,000 seniors and individuals with disabilities as a cost-cutting measure.”

Medicaid officials also said there was no truth to a separate claim about recipients of Ohio’s Medicaid expansion “being put ahead of 60,000 disabled Ohioans who rely on Medicaid but are currently on a waiting list.”...

Pence spokesman Marc Lotter said the vice president’s source was a Wall Street Journal editorial July 7 slamming Kasich, even questioning whether he was still a Republican because of his stance on Medicaid. The editorial said, “Nearly 60,000 disabled Ohioans are on waiting lists that last for months or years to receive supplemental state services.”

Those Ohioans, however, are on a list seeking Medicaid waivers, mostly for home- and community-based services for the developmentally disabled. The number of people who can be served via the waivers is restricted, according to the Americans with Disabilities Act Participatory Action Research Consortium. ...

But Kaiser itself analyzed the data and concluded “there does not appear to be a relationship between a state’s Medicaid expansion status and changes in its ... waiver waiting list.” Kaiser noted that about 40 percent did not qualify for a waiver when they signed up for one, while as many as 90 percent of those with certain types of disabilities already are getting some form of non-waiver Medicaid help.

The foundation also learned that waiting lists in non-expansion states are often longer than those in expansion states.
 
Why gradually? Many people have suggested lowering the age to 55, or even 50, and charging an appropriate, income-based premium for voluntary enrollees, which would drop to current levels when people reach 65. It would essentially be an age-based public option that would take care of people who lose their jobs at an age when it will be hard to find a new one, and also gives people an incentive to retire early if they can afford it and are just working to keep their benefits.

Gradually because if you drop it from 65 to 0 in one year, you'll wreck the economy. Phasing it in over the space of about 10 years seems reasonable. It might be feasible to do it faster, but the tax impact would be pretty intense, and you risk a lot of other disruption with unemployment etc. A planned phase in would make it more sustainable, and also more palatable.
 
But doesn't that run counter to one of the fundamentals of ACA? If you decrease the amount the younger people are paying, then you have to increase the amount older people are paying until their premiums begin to get prohibitively expensive. Which sounds pretty much like where we were pre-ACA.
Your choice - make it so expensive relative to use that young people don't buy coverage at all... or increase the amount old people are paying so it's more representative of their actual costs and offset with subsidies where appropriate.

Realistically, I think expanding Medicare has virtually no chance to survive a Republican Congress. They're going in the opposite direction: they want to restrict Medicare eligibility.
It doesn't have a chance of making it through ANY congress. It's not like it's a new idea.

Also, Medicare and Medicaid are completely separate programs, funded in completely separate ways. They don't really belong in the same sentence there - it's entirely possible to expand Medicare AND ALSO restrict Medicaid eligibility.
 
These numbers are staggering:

picture.php
 
Expand Medicare?
...It doesn't have a chance of making it through ANY congress. It's not like it's a new idea...


Then why'd you suggest it?

...Gradually lower the age of eligibility for Medicare. The benefits would also need to be modified as that age lowers, to ultimately include maternity and pediatrics among other services....
 
Your choice - make it so expensive relative to use that young people don't buy coverage at all... or increase the amount old people are paying so it's more representative of their actual costs and offset with subsidies where appropriate.
c) ramp up the penalties to the the point that young people will be forced to buy coverage. Emphasize that, despite appearances, they themselves will actually get old some day, thus balancing the equation.
 
Current version of the health care bill is officially dead:

New GOP health bill lacks the votes to pass

GOP Sens. Jerry Moran (Kansas) and Mike Lee (Utah) announced on Monday night they will not support taking up a bill repealing and replacing ObamaCare, effectively blocking the legislation.

Their decision means Republicans in the Senate are well short of having the support to pass their legislation, and raises serious questions about whether President Trump will reach his goal of ending ObamaCare.

Moran and Lee both said the bill failed to do enough to lower premiums.

"This closed-door process has yielded the [bill], which fails to repeal the Affordable Care Act or address healthcare’s rising costs. For the same reasons I could not support the previous version of this bill, I cannot support this one," Moran said in a statement.

Highlighting the challenges faced by Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), Lee argued the measure is not conservative enough, tugging in the opposite direction from moderates.
“In addition to not repealing all of the Obamacare taxes, it doesn’t go far enough in lowering premiums for middle class families; nor does it create enough free space from the most costly Obamacare regulations," the Utah Republican said in a statement.

Lee added on Twitter that he and Moran will not support proceeding to "this version" of the Senate GOP legislation, known as the Better Care Reconciliation Act.

Lee warned that a controversial amendment from Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) included in the bill does not go far enough. That amendment allows insurers to sell plans without ObamaCare's pre-existing condition protections if they also sell plans that have them.

So what happens now? Any chance of some kind of bipartisan reform?



Why are you laughing?
 
Current version of the health care bill is officially dead:

New GOP health bill lacks the votes to pass



So what happens now? Any chance of some kind of bipartisan reform?



Why are you laughing?

I think Democrats would be on board with attempting a bipartisan reform. Unfortunately, I think any invitation would not be sincere. I believe that the GOP would let the Democrats in, tell them what the GOP bill will be and then cry partisanship when the Democrats decline it because the GOP did not actually try to compromise at all. See past attempts for Democrats to compromise with Republicans for verification of this kind of behavior.
 
Current version of the health care bill is officially dead:

New GOP health bill lacks the votes to pass



So what happens now? Any chance of some kind of bipartisan reform?



Why are you laughing?

I really can't see any path for bipartisan reform here. The two parties' desires seem too sharply opposed. I'd really like to hear from some of the forum Republicans on this. Were any of you in favor of the bill? Did it meet the expectations you had when you voted last election?
 
I really can't see any path for bipartisan reform here. The two parties' desires seem too sharply opposed. I'd really like to hear from some of the forum Republicans on this. Were any of you in favor of the bill? Did it meet the expectations you had when you voted last election?

The GOP can't ditch all of its extremists in order to find common ground with Democrats: Paul Ryan is one of them, after all.
It would probably be easier to let the Democrats draft the reform, and see how many Republicans are willing to go along.
 
Democrats would not support any repeal. Obamacare can hang in there till single payer is passed. The gift to insurance companies will then end, as well as 20 dollar ibuprofen pills. And 20 dollar disposable exam pants.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom