I get really tired of everyone always trying to make every issue a political issue. Some problems in the world aren't innately political. I'm sure if you look hard enough and squint your eyes just right, you can make it out so that every issue has some correlation with whatever political indicator you've decided to use that day. But that doesn't make it the reality.
I don't care what your politics is. ACA is NOT a success. It is failing, and there doesn't look to be a solution in the works. The proposed solutions at the moment are WORSE, no question... but that still doesn't make ACA good. It's not. ACA as it stands right now is NOT sustainable.
Yeah, I don't think it's just the current regime. I don't think anyone in politics is willing to touch it. Despite objections to the contrary, most democrat politicians are beholden to corporate interests too.
President Donald Trump lamented that he'll be "very angry" if the Republican effort to repeal Obamaca collapses.
“I will be very angry about it and a lot of people will be very upset,” Trump said on the possibility of the bill to repeal Obamacare failing, adding, “but I’m sitting waiting for that bill to come to my desk. I hope they do it.”
...
“They’ve been promising it for years. They’ve been promising it ever since Obamacare which is failed,” Trump said. “It’s a failed experiment. It is totally gone. It’s out of business and we have to get this done.”
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is trying to win support from several moderate Republicans and key conservatives in the coming days. He announced Tuesday that the Senate would stay in session through the first two weeks of August, shortening the summer recess considerably.
“He’s got to pull it off. Mitch has to pull it off,” Trump said of the Kentucky Republican. “He’s working very hard. He’s got to pull it off."
The gaps are occurring in rural areas, regardless of the politics involved. The relationship at play that is providing your false correlation is that states with larger urban centers and fewer rural areas tend to lean more liberal. The percentage of people in areas without coverage is an effect of rurality rather than politics.
If they're right-wing because they're rural, that might explain their politics. But it's their politics that determine whether their state expands Medicaid and other programs, which in turn has plenty to do with who gets insurance. And there's no particular reason why states, which generally regulate insurance, can't establish coverage regions that would include more than one county, or would create markets that would tie rural counties to the nearest urban center. These problems are manageable, for people who actually want to manage them. The blue states do, the red states don't.
If they're right-wing because they're rural, that might explain their politics. But it's their politics that determine whether their state expands Medicaid and other programs, which in turn has plenty to do with who gets insurance. And there's no particular reason why states, which generally regulate insurance, can't establish coverage regions that would include more than one county, or would create markets that would tie rural counties to the nearest urban center. These problems are manageable, for people who actually want to manage them. The blue states do, the red states don't.
The politics may be part of it. But it isn't the whole story. There were a handful of blue states that did NOT expand Medicaid, and several red states that did. So clearly that's not the only issue.
I suspect that wealth is a much bigger piece of it - although wealth and politics are correlated. Wealthy people tend to be Democrats, poor people tend to be Republicans. I suspect it has a lot to do with how much money you have available to toss in to the community pot - especially when rural poor communities don't have access to many of those community benefits, like subsidized public housing, community health centers, community transit, etc.
Bear in mind that expanding Medicaid didn't all come from federal coffers - the states had to fund some of that as well. That means increased taxes in those states in some form or other. And the federal funds were essentially seed funds - at some point those funds disappear, and the states will need to be able to fund that expansion all on their own. Is it really surprising that several of the poorest states in the union didn't opt to increase their taxes and spending?
I get really tired of everyone always trying to make every issue a political issue. Some problems in the world aren't innately political. I'm sure if you look hard enough and squint your eyes just right, you can make it out so that every issue has some correlation with whatever political indicator you've decided to use that day. But that doesn't make it the reality.
I don't care what your politics is. ACA is NOT a success. It is failing, and there doesn't look to be a solution in the works. The proposed solutions at the moment are WORSE, no question... but that still doesn't make ACA good. It's not. ACA as it stands right now is NOT sustainable.
Perhaps it would be sustainable without the sabotage: cutting risk corridor supports to insurance companies, dumping the individual mandate . Maybe the Republicans will be forced into a compromise that fixes ACA rather than eliminates it.
Perhaps it would be sustainable without the sabotage: cutting risk corridor supports to insurance companies, dumping the individual mandate . Maybe the Republicans will be forced into a compromise that fixes ACA rather than eliminates it.
The politics may be part of it. But it isn't the whole story. There were a handful of blue states that did NOT expand Medicaid, and several red states that did. So clearly that's not the only issue.
The only states I see Hillary winning that did not expand it are Virginia, and Arizona. Those are not exactly hugely blue states. But I am sure West Virginia is excited about getting its medicaid cut. It was the predictable result of their voting and they are not stupid. The whole rhetoric was that you couldn;t take trump literally, so why would they think they could take him literally when he said there would be no medicaid cuts? These are not stupid people they knew what they were getting.
The only states I see Hillary winning that did not expand it are Virginia, and Arizona. Those are not exactly hugely blue states. But I am sure West Virginia is excited about getting its medicaid cut. It was the predictable result of their voting and they are not stupid. The whole rhetoric was that you couldn;t take trump literally, so why would they think they could take him literally when he said there would be no medicaid cuts? These are not stupid people they knew what they were getting.
A bit ironic, since that is a primary source of funding there for treatment for drug dependency and abuse, and one of the GOP's big clarion calls these days is the need to address the opioid abuse epidemic in areas like that.
A bit ironic, since that is a primary source of funding there for treatment for drug dependency and abuse, and one of the GOP's big clarion calls these days is the need to address the opioid abuse epidemic in areas like that.
Perhaps it would be sustainable without the sabotage: cutting risk corridor supports to insurance companies, dumping the individual mandate . Maybe the Republicans will be forced into a compromise that fixes ACA rather than eliminates it.
Not really. The risk corridors were always planned to sunset, as was the federal reinsurance. The mandate might have some impact, but it really hasn't been as big a driver of adoption as you might think. At max, it still ends up being equivalent to roughly 2 months of premium on a silver plan, depending where you are and the prevailing prices in that area.
The biggest death knells for ACA are:
It doesn't do anything about cost
large provider groups know insurers have geo-access requirements and have been unwilling to come down on price
Most of the new entrants to the marketplace are older and/or sicker than average, definitely higher cost than in the pre-ACA market
The youngest and healthiest can stay on their parent's group coverage for a fraction of the price until age 26
Essential benefits are extensive and significantly more coverage than previously available which forces prices up
How Actuarial Value is defined exacerbates adverse selection impacts
Those aren't any of the things that have been 'sabotaged'. Those are the basic underpinnings of the law.
The only states I see Hillary winning that did not expand it are Virginia, and Arizona. Those are not exactly hugely blue states. But I am sure West Virginia is excited about getting its medicaid cut. It was the predictable result of their voting and they are not stupid. The whole rhetoric was that you couldn;t take trump literally, so why would they think they could take him literally when he said there would be no medicaid cuts? These are not stupid people they knew what they were getting.
Those are all swing states, and that is what they get for putting all the republicans in their statehouses. But that for some reason doesn't count them as red states.
Not really. The risk corridors were always planned to sunset, as was the federal reinsurance. The mandate might have some impact, but it really hasn't been as big a driver of adoption as you might think. At max, it still ends up being equivalent to roughly 2 months of premium on a silver plan, depending where you are and the prevailing prices in that area.
The biggest death knells for ACA are:
It doesn't do anything about cost
large provider groups know insurers have geo-access requirements and have been unwilling to come down on price
Most of the new entrants to the marketplace are older and/or sicker than average, definitely higher cost than in the pre-ACA market
The youngest and healthiest can stay on their parent's group coverage for a fraction of the price until age 26
Essential benefits are extensive and significantly more coverage than previously available which forces prices up
How Actuarial Value is defined exacerbates adverse selection impacts
Those aren't any of the things that have been 'sabotaged'. Those are the basic underpinnings of the law.
Okay, assuming all these points, what would be the solution then? If we don't want to fix the ACA, and Trumps suggestions are obviously clueless, what does that leave? Back to the bad old days where poor people and people with preexisting conditions weren't covered?
Okay, assuming all these points, what would be the solution then? If we don't want to fix the ACA, and Trumps suggestions are obviously clueless, what does that leave? Back to the bad old days where poor people and people with preexisting conditions weren't covered?
1) Fix what we have now. IMO, we would accomplish a lot by doing two things. First, change how the AV requirements are applied with respect to cost. Second address the costs.
Changing the AV requirements is probably going to get really boring for everyone in this thread except me. So feel free to skip.
The current AV is defined as the percentage of incurred costs paid by the insurer. The premiums, are expected to reflect the percentage levels of the AVs. For example, Bronze is at 60%, and Gold is at 80%, so the premiums for Gold plans are expected to be one-third higher than for Bronze plans.
The problem is that the incurred costs for a bronze plan and a gold plan are very different. Bronze plan folks are on the whole healthier and have lower incurred costs. Gold plan folks are on the whole sicker and have higher incurred costs. So for example, the average incurred cost for a Bronze might be $300 PMPM and the average cost for Gold might be $500 PMPM. When we apply the AVs, we see that the Bronze AV ends up at 60% of $300 = $180, and the Gold AV ends up at $400. That means the insurer paid portion of a gold plan's incurred costs is actually 2.22 times the Bronze's.
If the prices were allowed to reflect the underlying incurred costs for each tier of coverage, then the prices in the market place would be more appropriate. Bronze plans would be cheaper by quite a bit, which would appease the young/healthy people who can't get decent coverage for the price they're paying. Gold plans would be more expensive, which would reflect the inherent adverse selection of richer plans.
2) Gradually lower the age of eligibility for Medicare. The benefits would also need to be modified as that age lowers, to ultimately include maternity and pediatrics among other services. This would also have the benefit of allowing a continued private insurance market, in the form of Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage. That should help to appease those opposed to universal care, while still providing reasonable coverage for everyone.
......
2) Gradually lower the age of eligibility for Medicare. The benefits would also need to be modified as that age lowers, to ultimately include maternity and pediatrics among other services. This would also have the benefit of allowing a continued private insurance market, in the form of Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage. That should help to appease those opposed to universal care, while still providing reasonable coverage for everyone.
Why gradually? Many people have suggested lowering the age to 55, or even 50, and charging an appropriate, income-based premium for voluntary enrollees, which would drop to current levels when people reach 65. It would essentially be an age-based public option that would take care of people who lose their jobs at an age when it will be hard to find a new one, and also gives people an incentive to retire early if they can afford it and are just working to keep their benefits.
1) Fix what we have now. IMO, we would accomplish a lot by doing two things. First, change how the AV requirements are applied with respect to cost. Second address the costs.
Changing the AV requirements is probably going to get really boring for everyone in this thread except me. So feel free to skip.
The current AV is defined as the percentage of incurred costs paid by the insurer. The premiums, are expected to reflect the percentage levels of the AVs. For example, Bronze is at 60%, and Gold is at 80%, so the premiums for Gold plans are expected to be one-third higher than for Bronze plans.
The problem is that the incurred costs for a bronze plan and a gold plan are very different. Bronze plan folks are on the whole healthier and have lower incurred costs. Gold plan folks are on the whole sicker and have higher incurred costs. So for example, the average incurred cost for a Bronze might be $300 PMPM and the average cost for Gold might be $500 PMPM. When we apply the AVs, we see that the Bronze AV ends up at 60% of $300 = $180, and the Gold AV ends up at $400. That means the insurer paid portion of a gold plan's incurred costs is actually 2.22 times the Bronze's.
If the prices were allowed to reflect the underlying incurred costs for each tier of coverage, then the prices in the market place would be more appropriate. Bronze plans would be cheaper by quite a bit, which would appease the young/healthy people who can't get decent coverage for the price they're paying. Gold plans would be more expensive, which would reflect the inherent adverse selection of richer plans.
2) Gradually lower the age of eligibility for Medicare. The benefits would also need to be modified as that age lowers, to ultimately include maternity and pediatrics among other services. This would also have the benefit of allowing a continued private insurance market, in the form of Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage. That should help to appease those opposed to universal care, while still providing reasonable coverage for everyone.
Sounds simple and from what I can tell, effective. And the people I know love their Medicare!
Chances of the Republicans in Congress instituting these ideas: zero.
Chances of the Republicans in Congress seeking instead to deceptively severely limit and eventually eliminate Medicare: 70%.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.