Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

It's seems as though your argument is based on trying to find anything and everything wrong with ACA while ignoring everything right.

It's funny because first Republicans whined about how the ACA was going to far and was another steppingstone towards full blown marxist-leninist totalitarianism. Now they are complaining that the ACA is a failure because it hasn't solved all of the problems and issues with the American healthcare system even-though nobody really expected, or even argued, that it was going to do so.

It's almost like they are arguing that ACA didn't go far enough in reforming the American healthcare system, which is a completely reasonable point to make considering that many of the problems it's facing now will only become worse over time unless something is done.
 
I shared my toddler's hospital bill on Twitter. First came supporters — then death threats.

The attacks became increasingly personal and increasingly violent. Strangers were telling me it would have been cheaper to make a new kid, as if anyone in the history of the world could ever replace this bright light of mine, the boy who loves animals and can’t keep himself from kissing babies and always wants to sleep with one arm wrapped around my neck.

I was offered a .22 bullet, although I’m still not sure whom he meant it for, me or my child. One man took me up on the challenge I’d posed in the thread and declared that my son just wasn’t worth keeping alive anymore. There was even a percentage of the comments dedicated to the belief that I was a foreigner or, worse, a terrorist, which is when I started asking news outlets to use my full name: Alison, not Ali, since people seemed unable to believe that I was, in fact, a white chick from New Jersey.

The worst were the ones who attacked on the genetic front. Heterotaxy has no known cause, but in our case it was due to a genetic glitch, a previously unknown fault in the code of my own humanity that I passed down to my son. I don’t think I’ll ever come to terms with the fact that it was me who slipped the poison into his DNA, with knowing that his children (if he ever has them) will stand in front of this same 50-50 firing squad. It’s been my own private heartbreak. Now strangers were tearing barely healed scabs off those old wounds and I was running out of hands to stanch the bleeding.
 
I think most Trump supporters voted for an improved health care system with better coverage and lower premiums.

That was what he promised them.

Giving the wealthy a big tax cut wasn't a prominent part of Republican campaign rhetoric.

You think they actually believed that rhetoric? It was like the wall all metaphor, this is what republicans have been clearly intending since the beginning. And those counties that don't have an individual market will be so much less of a problem when they lose all health care providers.
 
So Republicans main argument is that Premiums have risen after Obamacare was enacted, despite the fact that they would've risen even if it wasn't enacted? Or that Obamacare didn't insure everyone, even-though it wasn't supposed to, so it's better to just stop trying to give Americans healthcare and return poor Americans their hard-fought freedom of living without healthcare insurance?

I didn't expect intellectually dishonest talking points from Republicans at all.


"If you can't fix everything, then don't fix anything" is a common excuse used to avoid taking action. You see it with climate change as well. "Why should we bother reducing emissions? That other country isn't doing it, so the problem will still be there."
"Perfect is the enemy of good", used as an excuse for apathy.
 
You think they actually believed that rhetoric? It was like the wall all metaphor, this is what republicans have been clearly intending since the beginning. And those counties that don't have an individual market will be so much less of a problem when they lose all health care providers.

One of the other conflicts that Republicans have been engaged in surrounding healthcare is that they don't like the way Medicare and Medicaid funding is organized. At the moment, there are strings attached, the states need to follow rules to use the funds.

The fight has been to loosen the federal enforcement, and allow the states to implement as they see fit. Federal cash, no strings attached. The big debate when it was first implemented was that in order for hospitals to qualify for operational funding, they needed to desegregate.

A lot of the political inertia in the USA right now is on a trajectory toward restoring segregation, it's just that the advocates know better than to be overt about it. The main buzzword is "state rights"
 
You think they actually believed that rhetoric?

I think lots of Republican voters did. I believe that this is one of those issues where there's a significant difference between the goals of Republican office-holders and Republican voters. I'm not sure how many Republican voters are aware of that.
 
Elections are always a tradeoff for voters: voting for any candidate gives some of what they want, some of what they don't want. The interesting question is about what factors take priority.

For example, people want X and Y, are they willing to vote for a candidate that is Pro X but anti Y? Yes, if they value X more than Y.

In this scenario, it's possible that yes, voters want tax cuts for the rich, and also better healthcare. When it comes down to the crunch, they learned they could only pick one, and begrudgingly voted for tax cuts for the rich OVER better healthcare. (because they will be rich soon, all Americans are just temporarily indisposed future billionaires, and healthcare expenses will not be an issue anymore)

*Gumble* Voters aren't voting for this. Politicians are voting for it. I would suggest that their motivations, and their value rankings, may vary from those of the average american.
 
One of the other conflicts that Republicans have been engaged in surrounding healthcare is that they don't like the way Medicare and Medicaid funding is organized. At the moment, there are strings attached, the states need to follow rules to use the funds.
....

Let's note once again that Medicare and Medicaid are entirely separate programs. Medicare is paid for by a federal payroll tax that goes into federal trust funds. The states don't have anything to do with it.
https://www.medicare.gov/about-us/how-medicare-is-funded/medicare-funding.html
 
I think lots of Republican voters did. I believe that this is one of those issues where there's a significant difference between the goals of Republican office-holders and Republican voters. I'm not sure how many Republican voters are aware of that.

That is as dumb as thinking that he was going to build a wall. The wall was a metaphor after all. He should be taken serious and not literally after all.
 
*Gumble* Voters aren't voting for this. Politicians are voting for it. I would suggest that their motivations, and their value rankings, may vary from those of the average american.

I guarantee it, but, there's always going to be a disconnect, in a republic, so what are they up to, is a good question. Why do they think they will get re-elected, is the question. My fear is that they *are* well aligned, with consideration for prioritization and tradeoffs.

No candidate is not going to 100% align with every voter, and I hope voters understand that. There's no 'average american' because the Venn diagrams for the different values don't have great overlap. Maximizing a district's voter satisfaction is a Logistics and Game Theory exercise. If they guess right, they get re-elected.
 
Maybe, but I'm not convinced of that. I'm not sure that Trump supporters do accept that they have to pick only one of those two things. I think they think it's entirely possible that we could somehow have really great health insurance for everyone more cheaply than with Obamacare and still cut taxes a lot. Not sure how they think it would work, probably some form of trickle-down economics.

It IS possible to have great health insurance at lest cost to everyone and cut taxes some (not necessarily a lot)... if we would actually look at cost-side controls as part of the solution.
 
I was responding to your suggestion that the minimum FPL requirement (133%) for individual market eligibility be removed. Kaiser says almost all people with incomes below 138% of poverty are not eligible for subsidized Marketplace coverage so why is this important? How many people does this effect?
:confused: They're not eligible for marketplace coverage because they're below 138% poverty. There's a floor for the marketplace.

It mostly affects people who are near the line, who would end up fluctuating between Medicaid and Marketplace plans. In some cases, there are people who may lose Medicaid coverage in some months, but not have reasonable access to other Marketplace plans - this means they end up with a disruption in their coverage. Not a big deal if the person is healthy, maybe, but it can be a serious problem if it interrupts care in progress.

As was pointed out, you claim ACA to be a disaster based on 42 counties out of 3,007 having no coverage available (next year?) while ignoring the fact that millions of people have gained coverage thanks to ACA. It's seems as though your argument is based on trying to find anything and everything wrong with ACA while ignoring everything right.
Not *just* those 42 counties. There are hundreds more counties where there is only one carrier, so no competition at all. Most carriers have moved to very limited plan selections and closed networks. There are now fewer choices available than there were before. AND the cost keep going up. The millions who have gained coverage mostly gained it through expanded Medicaid, and that's facing cuts as well. I cant' recall off the top of my head, and my google-fu seems broken today, but I believe that a fairly large portion of the federal funding used to expand Medicaid is scheduled to sunset under ACA anyway. I'm not ignoring the things that went right... but those few things aren't sufficient to make it sustainable.

If the problem is a result of states varying in how they implement ACA that's not a federal problem.
It's a variation in whether or not they expanded Medicaid, and how they planned for changes in income throughout the year. ACA didn't address that at all. Some states took additional measures to plan for income changes and to make sure there's a reasonable coordination between Medicaid and Marketplace. ACA didn't make accommodation for that, so yes, it's a federal problem.

Are they red states?
The prevailing political persuasion of the state is irrelevant.
 
It IS possible to have great health insurance at lest cost to everyone and cut taxes some (not necessarily a lot)... if we would actually look at cost-side controls as part of the solution.

True. I wasn't really thinking of that since I don't consider it politically realistic, but it's entirely possible that some voters were expecting some version of that.
 
It IS possible to have great health insurance at lest cost to everyone and cut taxes some (not necessarily a lot)... if we would actually look at cost-side controls as part of the solution.

Cost side controls are not going to happen with the current regime in Washington.

American health care is full of vested interests with deep pockets. In this country money doesn't talk, it shouts. The needs of the average American get lost in the din.
 
It IS possible to have great health insurance at lest cost to everyone and cut taxes some (not necessarily a lot)... if we would actually look at cost-side controls as part of the solution.

But there is too much money involved for that. It would be hurting the wealthy insurance and drug companies far to much to be doable.
 
Cost side controls are not going to happen with the current regime in Washington.

American health care is full of vested interests with deep pockets. In this country money doesn't talk, it shouts. The needs of the average American get lost in the din.

OF course money is speech after all. They need to have unlimited anonymous money into politics to make it work.
 
.....
The prevailing political persuasion of the state is irrelevant.


Not necessarily. A different perspective:
....Or consider the problem of counties with only one (or no) insurer, meaning no competition. As one recent study points out, this is almost entirely a red-state problem. In states with G.O.P. governors, 21 percent of the population lives in such counties; in Democratic-governor states, less than 2 percent.

So Obamacare is, though nobody will believe it, a well-thought-out law that works where states want it to work. It could and should be made to work better, but Republicans show no interest in making that happen.
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/10/opinion/obamacare-repeal.html
 

The gaps are occurring in rural areas, regardless of the politics involved. The relationship at play that is providing your false correlation is that states with larger urban centers and fewer rural areas tend to lean more liberal. The percentage of people in areas without coverage is an effect of rurality rather than politics.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom