Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

I think most Trump supporters voted for an improved health care system with better coverage and lower premiums.

That was what he promised them.

Giving the wealthy a big tax cut wasn't a prominent part of Republican campaign rhetoric.

Elections are always a tradeoff for voters: voting for any candidate gives some of what they want, some of what they don't want. The interesting question is about what factors take priority.

For example, people want X and Y, are they willing to vote for a candidate that is Pro X but anti Y? Yes, if they value X more than Y.

In this scenario, it's possible that yes, voters want tax cuts for the rich, and also better healthcare. When it comes down to the crunch, they learned they could only pick one, and begrudgingly voted for tax cuts for the rich OVER better healthcare. (because they will be rich soon, all Americans are just temporarily indisposed future billionaires, and healthcare expenses will not be an issue anymore)
 
When it comes down to the crunch, they learned they could only pick one, and begrudgingly voted for tax cuts for the rich OVER better healthcare.

Maybe, but I'm not convinced of that. I'm not sure that Trump supporters do accept that they have to pick only one of those two things. I think they think it's entirely possible that we could somehow have really great health insurance for everyone more cheaply than with Obamacare and still cut taxes a lot. Not sure how they think it would work, probably some form of trickle-down economics.
 
Maybe, but I'm not convinced of that. I'm not sure that Trump supporters do accept that they have to pick only one of those two things. I think they think it's entirely possible that we could somehow have really great health insurance for everyone more cheaply than with Obamacare and still cut taxes a lot. Not sure how they think it would work, probably some form of trickle-down economics.

Yes, there's probably a significant segment that believe tax cuts for the rich will make everybody richer, and so therefore, health insurance will become more affordable for all through that process.

What I'm really alluding to is the present situation where the mutually exclusiveness of those two outcomes (lowering taxes for the rich is not compatible with expanding access to healthcare) is becoming clearer and clearer every day. People will fall back on their priorities.

This is the importance of wedge issues: it forces voters with many complex goals to boil their vote down to one issue that the Republicans can say they own. Pro life. Low taxes. Christian license. Everything else (jobs, healthcare, Russian assault on Western democracies) becomes subordinate when it comes time to pull the lever.
 
Yes, there's probably a significant segment that believe tax cuts for the rich will make everybody richer, and so therefore, health insurance will become more affordable for all through that process.

What I'm really alluding to is the present situation where the mutually exclusiveness of those two outcomes (lowering taxes for the rich is not compatible with expanding access to healthcare) is becoming clearer and clearer every day. People will fall back on their priorities.

This is the importance of wedge issues: it forces voters with many complex goals to boil their vote down to one issue that the Republicans can say they own. Pro life. Low taxes. Christian license. Everything else (jobs, healthcare, Russian assault on Western democracies) becomes subordinate when it comes time to pull the lever.

Just as an interesting example. I have a friend who quite correctly pointed out that the economy was the number one answer (84%) when Americans are asked "Among the following, which are important issues in this election?"

Where she went wrong, was misinterpreting the most common issue as the most important issue for 'voters'.

If people are asked to rank their answers, a different outcome emerges, and we start to see partisan clusters. Republicans think the economy is important. But they think sticking it to Obama is more important. So an economic trainwreck might still be acceptable, when it comes time to vote for a congresscritter in 2018.
 
Last edited:
It means both sides refuse to work with the other side!

I'll admit it, I'm a registered Democrat, but it's not both sides. It may appear that way to people on the other side of the pond, but... In practice it has worked differently:
Some Republicans are admitting they may have to move to a plan B: working with Democrats. Link

Note the above: "may have to?" Quite a different attitude than the other side has. :(
Congressional Democrats emerged from blistering losses in the election assessing the damage but pledging, at least for now, to try to find ways to work with President-elect Donald Trump. Link

Quite a bit different than the GOP reaction to the election of Barack Obama.
Before the health care fight, before the economic stimulus package, before President Obama even took office, Senator Mitch McConnell, the Republican minority leader, had a strategy for his party: use his extensive knowledge of Senate procedure to slow things down, take advantage of the difficulties Democrats would have in governing and deny Democrats any Republican support on big legislation. Link

As McConnell told the Republican House caucus before Obama was even sworn in: "If he's for it we're against it." :(
 
And in non-satirical news: Republican lawmakers buy health insurance stocks as they surge during Obamacare repeal effort.

Just as the House Republican bill to slash much of the Affordable Care Act moved forward, Rep. Mike Conaway, a Texas Republican and member of Speaker Paul Ryan’s leadership team, added a health insurance company to his portfolio.

An account owned by Conaway’s wife made two purchases of UnitedHealth stock, worth as much as $30,000, on March 24th, the day the legislation advanced*in the House Rules Committee, according to disclosures. The exact value of Conaway’s investment isn’t clear, given that congressional ethics forms only show a range of amounts, and Conaway’s office did not respond to a request for comment.

It was a savvy move. Health industry stocks, including insurance giants like UnitedHealth, have surged as Republicans move forward with their repeal effort, which rolls back broad taxes on health care firms while loosening consumer regulations which prevent insurance companies from denying coverage for medical treatment. UnitedHealth has gained nearly 7 percent in value since March 24.

He wasn’t the only one. As the health care system overhaul advanced last month on the other side of Capitol Hill, Republican Sen. James Inhofe of Oklahoma purchased between $50,000 to $100,000 in UnitedHealth stock.
 
I'm not really finding much about this and I'm really not too clear on what is meant anyway. I did find this on a Kaiser website from last year:


I don't understand what the recommendation is. Kaiser says almost all persons with income of 138% of the federal poverty level are not eligible for subsidized marketplace coverage. Why should the provision be changed?

Because eligibility for ACA subsidies is done on an annual basis, whereas eligibility for Medicaid is done on a monthly basis. There is a fair bit of variation in implementation by state, of course. But in many states, there's a disconnect. A person may be eligible for Medicaid one month, then ineligible... the next... but not reach the minimum threshold for ACA over the course of the entire year.

It's also complicated by ACA plans generally having annual accumulators (deductibles and out of pocket maximums). Adding/Dropping coverage resets those accumulators in most states.
 
So Republicans main argument is that Premiums have risen after Obamacare was enacted, despite the fact that they would've risen even if it wasn't enacted? Or that Obamacare didn't insure everyone, even-though it wasn't supposed to, so it's better to just stop trying to give Americans healthcare and return poor Americans their hard-fought freedom of living without healthcare insurance?

I didn't expect intellectually dishonest talking points from Republicans at all.

Krugman points this out as well:

How do Republicans argue against this success? You can get a good overview by looking at the Twitter feed of Tom Price, President Trump’s secretary of health and human services — a feed that is, in its own way, almost as horrifying as that of the tweeter in chief. Price points repeatedly to two misleading numbers.

First, he points to the fact that fewer people than expected have signed up on the exchanges — Obamacare’s insurance marketplaces — and portrays this as a sign of dire failure. But a lot of this shortfall is the result of good news: Fewer employers than predicted chose to drop coverage and shift their workers onto exchange plans. So exchange enrollment has come in below forecast, but it mostly consists of people who wouldn’t otherwise have been insured — and as I said, there have been large gains in overall coverage.

Second, he points to the 28 million U.S. residents who remain uninsured as if this were some huge, unanticipated failure. But nobody expected Obamacare to cover everyone; indeed, the Congressional Budget Office always projected that more than 20 million people would, for various reasons, be left out. And you have to wonder how Price can look himself in the mirror after condemning the A.C.A. for missing some people when his own party’s plans would vastly increase the number of uninsured.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/07/opinion/republican-healthcare-obamacare.html

Republicans can't argue against the ACA, or for their own piece of legislation, in good faith and have to lie or mislead in order to not come off as completely abhorrent. It's no wonder that so many Republicans and republican leaning people remain uninformed about what exactly the Republicans in congress are trying enact: the less they know the better.
 
Because eligibility for ACA subsidies is done on an annual basis, whereas eligibility for Medicaid is done on a monthly basis...A person may be eligible for Medicaid one month, then ineligible... the next... but not reach the minimum threshold for ACA over the course of the entire year. It's also complicated by ACA plans generally having annual accumulators (deductibles and out of pocket maximums). Adding/Dropping coverage resets those accumulators in most states.
I was responding to your suggestion that the minimum FPL requirement (133%) for individual market eligibility be removed. Kaiser says almost all people with incomes below 138% of poverty are not eligible for subsidized Marketplace coverage so why is this important? How many people does this effect?

As was pointed out, you claim ACA to be a disaster based on 42 counties out of 3,007 having no coverage available (next year?) while ignoring the fact that millions of people have gained coverage thanks to ACA. It's seems as though your argument is based on trying to find anything and everything wrong with ACA while ignoring everything right.

There is a fair bit of variation in implementation by state, of course. But in many states, there's a disconnect.
If the problem is a result of states varying in how they implement ACA that's not a federal problem. Are they red states?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom