Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

That's actually an argument that we should subsidize the high car insurance premiums paid by 19 year olds. At least I think we don't do that now, I do know their premiums are very high.

No, it's an argument that no one blinks at paying car, house and fire insurance. It's just that single payer medical insurance or government health insurance is a change in the norm for the US and it takes a great effort to make such a change.

We can see from the countries with single payer or national health insurance policies that ALL people benefit from such a system, it is more efficient.

My health insurance costs more than a young healthy person and my car insurance costs less. There is nothing wrong with that, within a reasonable range for everyone (people with DUIs excepted). I have no issue with a surcharge for smokers.

Obesity and drug addiction need careful scientific research before such surcharges are added to those policies but those details are beside the point.

The point is, get over the hurdle of people believing because some people need more medical care than others we can't change to single payer or national health insurance and regulation of the health care industry. Yes we can and we'll all be better off if we do. All the research results support that conclusion.

After that, the rest are just negotiable details.
 
Last edited:
When the ACA was being designed they brought in lots of experts. It hasn't been a disaster despite the Republican claims that it has.

Have you been paying attention to the number of carriers exiting markets, the counties with zero coverage available, and the rate hikes coming down for 2018? What does it take for you to see it as a disaster?
 
No.2, changing the subsidy to age-adjusted to avoid older consumers paying 400% of...the cost of the basic premium?

First of all what I'm seeing is the difference in costs -- between a 21-year-old and someone age 64 -- is actually about 300% or, as I find it more often expressed, 3x. This is a chart from ValuePenguin:

[qimg]http://i1336.photobucket.com/albums/o646/tommyguy0421/JREF/ACA%20Premium%20Costs%20Age_zpsiownzoj0.jpg[/qimg]

The ACA planners said this was done in order to allow insurers to consider age when determining premium cost. The reason for that seems obvious. However, individual states can set their own regulations. Most use the federal guidelines (above) but a few don't. New York and Vermont do not allow age to be a consideration in computing premium costs. Massachusetts does but only allows a 2x rise.

I can agree that seeing the premium cost more than double between age 40 and 60 seems extreme. I presume the thinking is, medical requirements rise with age and so does (normally) income. I would want to know the history though and without searching a news archive it is a little hard to find. What was the original proposal? Was it changed? ACA went through a long hearing process and was amended dozens of times in order to try and gain some Republican support. What was the Republican position vs. the Democrats?

The SUBSIDY produces a cliff. A 20 yo who moves from 399% of FPL to 401% of FPL sees only a very marginal difference in their premium costs due to the loss of the subsidy. A 60 yo moving in those same brackets sees a dramatic increase in their premiums once that subsidy is taken away. The subsidy is tied to a % of income, but the premiums aren't. What ends up happening is that a low-income older family gets a substantially large subsidy that disappears when they cross the line.
 
FPL meaning federal poverty level. Income for a family of four at 4x the FPL would be about $98,000. Link Not having employer-based healthcare coverage is a big part of the problem. A survey done last year by the Commonwealth Fund found:


But the message being replied to was not about income-based subsidies, it was about the way ACA lets premiums rise as one ages. Removing limits on income-based subsidies is not one of the points that was listed that actuaries recommended

I think you misunderstood.

Emily's Cat said:
American Association of Actuaries, Society of Actuaries, Blue Cross Blue Shield Association Actuarial Committee. Suggestions included:
  1. increasing the penalty for mandatory coverage,
  2. changing the subsidy to be age-adjusted to reduce the dramatic cliff experienced by older consumers when they hit 400%,
  3. changing the age scale to be 5:1 instead of 3:1 to allow for lower rates for younger people,
  4. removing the minimum FPL requirement for individual market that excluded people with incomes under 133%FPL and allow for less disruptive transitioning between Medicaid and Individual markets,
  5. revisions to the risk adjustment methodology to even out the disparate preference for older/sicker individuals over younger/healthier ones and create a more stable environment,
  6. creation of an invisible high risk pool to mitigate the impact from sicker than average new entrants
and a few others I don't recall.
 
The Trump healthcare proposes going to age-based subsidies rather than income. Here's the argument against it:

That's a bad argument. It isn't recommending that it be ONLY age-adjusted subsidies, but that it be both age and income adjusted. Thus a low income older person would receive a larger subsidy than a younger low income person... but high income person would receive no subsidy at all.
 
The fallacy is, young people don't need healthcare. ACA is aimed at providing people with primary care, the goal being to keep people healthy, not just provide treatment for people who are seriously ill. This is one of the reasons most medical associations are on board. The best path to good health is to start seeing a primary care physician when you are young. By the time you reach the age where you're at increased risk the doctor has a good history on you and they can often spot problems long before they become serious ones. In the long run, that's cheaper for everybody. Which was the whole idea behind ACA; but we don't see the forest for the trees.

Plus young people do need healthcare. They get sick, they break limbs, get pregnant etc.

Medical associations are on board because ACA requires all preventive care to be at no cost to the insured individual, which means people go to the doctor more, which means doctors make more money.

ETA: Also because more people covered is better overall.

ETA2: But NOT because ACA has some great goal to provide primary care. It doesn't. Primary care is in there, but primary care was already in everything in the individual market (aside from critical illness and short-term policies, neither of which were removed by ACA, and both of which are regulated differently as they aren't considered comprehensive medical coverage in the first place).
 
Last edited:
No, it's an argument that no one blinks at paying car, house and fire insurance.

All of which are risk adjusted. Car insurance varies by age, driving history, type of car, and location - the higher your risk of an accident, the higher your premium. House and fire are similar. They take into account the age the house was built, the location, the topology and terrain, the types of dangers in the area etc. Fire insurance in CA is much higher than in WA. Homeowners insurance in WA varies significantly depending on whether you're on a hillside or not.
 
Medical associations are on board because ACA requires all preventive care to be at no cost to the insured individual, which means people go to the doctor more, which means doctors make more money...

You're seriously arguing the only reason medical associations support ACA is so doctors can make more money?
 
You're seriously arguing the only reason medical associations support ACA is so doctors can make more money?

Did you just not read anything beyond that spot? Or did you just not understand the whole "and because more people covered is better overall" part? Or did that sentiment weaken your outrage? Some other reason for ignoring the part of my post that would prevent you from inserting that pesky "only" in there... like nobody else can read? :rolleyes:
 
[Dr. Jay Shannon, CEO of the Cook County Health & Hospital System] in his speech to a rally in front of Stroger Hospital, noted that the county has cut its subsidy to the health system by 75 percent in recent years, with payments dropping from $481 million in 2009 to a projected $115 million this year—"in large part due to the new revenues available as a result of implementation of the ACA."

Should the ACA be repealed without an adequate replacement, he said, "patients will go back to the days of choosing food for their families or the medications to stabilize their health. These are not choices that any human being should have to make, no less a human being living in the richest nation in the world." Link


The above is from an article in Crain's Chicago Business. On a PBS news report they interviewed low-income patients in Chicago with diabetes who have, for the first time, regular access to a primary care physician and their health has improved at the same time the cost of treating them has fallen. This is from the report:
The health law also shifted the business model for U.S. hospitals. It offered them financial incentives to move away from expensive E.R. visits to primary care and managing chronic conditions.

Before the Affordable Care Act, hospitals had little incentive to reduce E.R. visits, especially from Medicare patients who generate a lot of revenue. At the University of Chicago Medicine, an academic medical center, Dr. Kenneth Polonsky says that if those incentives are rescinded and patients forgo preventive care, they will clog up already strained emergency rooms. "We will go back to a very frustrating time, where people had limited options for health care because of inability to get health insurance." PBS link
 
Have you been paying attention to the number of carriers exiting markets, the counties with zero coverage available, and the rate hikes coming down for 2018? What does it take for you to see it as a disaster?

And fortunately with the new republican fixes those counties will have no health care providers so they won't need coverage.
 
4. removing the minimum FPL requirement for individual market that excluded people with incomes under 133%FPL and allow for less disruptive transitioning between Medicaid and Individual markets

I'm not really finding much about this and I'm really not too clear on what is meant anyway. I did find this on a Kaiser website from last year:
In states that decide to expand Medicaid, tax credit eligibility effectively ranges from 138% to 400% of the poverty level (because almost all people with incomes below 138% of poverty are eligible for Medicaid and therefore are not eligible for subsidized Marketplace coverage). Link

I don't understand what the recommendation is. Kaiser says almost all persons with income of 138% of the federal poverty level are not eligible for subsidized marketplace coverage. Why should the provision be changed?
 
Have you been paying attention to the number of carriers exiting markets, the counties with zero coverage available, and the rate hikes coming down for 2018? What does it take for you to see it as a disaster?

There are 3,007 counties in the US. 42 of them have no coverage available. This is a problem but far from a disaster.

Yes rate hikes are coming. Part of that is simply insurance companies hedging their bets in an uncertain regulatory environment. If they set premiums too high insurance companies may have to issue a refund due to the Medical Cost Ratio rule. If premiums are too low the company loses money.

The ACA program that allowed insurance companies to share the risk with the government has been defunded by Congress.

If we want to curtail costs, there are plenty of opportunities. But with the GOP in charge of Congress and an clueless idiot in the White House can anything be accomplished?
 
The SUBSIDY produces a cliff. A 20 yo who moves from 399% of FPL to 401% of FPL sees only a very marginal difference in their premium costs due to the loss of the subsidy. A 60 yo moving in those same brackets sees a dramatic increase in their premiums once that subsidy is taken away. The subsidy is tied to a % of income, but the premiums aren't. What ends up happening is that a low-income older family gets a substantially large subsidy that disappears when they cross the line.

An easy solution is to taper the subsides off and eliminate the cliff. But that isn't about to happen because the current debate isn't about fixing health care and insurance. It's about giving the wealth people of America a big *********** tax cut.
 
I'm not really finding much about this and I'm really not too clear on what is meant anyway. I did find this on a Kaiser website from last year:


I don't understand what the recommendation is. Kaiser says almost all persons with income of 138% of the federal poverty level are not eligible for subsidized marketplace coverage. Why should the provision be changed?

It could be that if you are eligible for Medicaid you are not eligible for subsidies. If your state didn't expand Medicaid and your income is over FPL you can get coverage from the exchange.
 
An easy solution is to taper the subsides off and eliminate the cliff. But that isn't about to happen because the current debate isn't about fixing health care and insurance. It's about giving the wealth people of America a big *********** tax cut.

That is what people voted for after all.
 
So Republicans main argument is that Premiums have risen after Obamacare was enacted, despite the fact that they would've risen even if it wasn't enacted? Or that Obamacare didn't insure everyone, even-though it wasn't supposed to, so it's better to just stop trying to give Americans healthcare and return poor Americans their hard-fought freedom of living without healthcare insurance?

I didn't expect intellectually dishonest talking points from Republicans at all.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom