Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

And, um, since when are you qualified to hold an opinion?
Since I was born with a working brain, and acquired the ability to read and to reason. You?

You think A&E are being punished -- my niece thinks she's being punished. Neither of you are necessarily in possession of all the facts.
A&E are clearly being punished. They are denied eternal life, and forced to labor instead of idle in idyllic paradise.

Dig deeper. In this case, there are something like 2000 years of theological writings on this particular subject.
2000 years of spin doctoring doesn't necessarily convert nonsense into sense. If you have encountered a compelling argument in your studies of theological writings, feel free to prop it up here.

Since when are indirect consequences not consequences?
They ARE consequences, but they're consequences of an act of will rather than a force of nature. In this case, god's act of will is to punish A&E for their disobedience.

By discovering the concept of bad stuff, unhappiness has entered the Garden of Eden, basically wrecking it. More importantly, disobedience has entered the garden of Eden, making it no longer safe for A&E to be there.
Nothing has changed about the garden. The only change has been in the minds of A&E: they have become ashamed to be naked. They have donned clothes. Problem solved.

Rather than reward their initiative, god chooses to punish them.

You don't have to accept the traditional narrative, but for Pete's sake at least learn the real version of it. There is a strong tendency on this forum for people to post the most ridiculously straw-man versions of quite sophisticated theological arguments and then laugh at them.
The "real version" I'm referencing is in the bible. If there is some problem in the translation, I apologize for not reading Greek. There is no sophisticated theological arguments in my edition, but again, if you have something you regard as convincing, bring it on.

Gumboot has it at least partly right -- banishment from the Garden was not punitive, but preventative (it even says so in the Book).
Yeah, and when I ground my kids, that's preventative -- it prevents them from going to the movies. It's still a punishment. In the case of Genesis, what is being prevented is eternal life, and effortless pleasure. Where I come from, we'd consider that a punishment, but maybe we're not as "sophisticated" as you doctor types.

One can accomplish the same thing by banishing the Tree of Life from the garden.

Where do you put it, then?
Well, if you put it on the moon, you wouldn't have had to worry about men getting their hands on it until the 1960s, at the earliest. If you put it on Pluto, it would probably be safe for awhile longer. Stick it in "a galaxy far, far away" and it would likely be safe forever. Would that be too unsophisticated?

And while we're on the subject of "where," tell me: where can I go on Google Earth to get a peek at that flaming sword that turns this way and that to prevent us from sneaking back in?

Given that unhappiness had (demonstrably) already entered the Garden when A&E were banished, it would no longer have been "Edenic" even if they were permitted to stay.
Sorry to voice another opinion, but I disagree that unhappiness had demonstrably already entered the garden. A&E weren't unhappy, they were just ashamed to be seen naked (and they'd already solved that problem). I'm not unhappy when I wear clothes, and I see no reason to assume that they were. Unless there is some other indication of unhappiness that my lack of sophistication has overlooked, I think your case is a little weak on evidence.
 
There wasn't any "unhappiness" in the Garden of Eden until God turned up and started giving out punishment. If anyone's responsible for ruining Eden it's him.
 
I think it's funny that people go to experts on things they can't really have "expertise" in to tell them what to "believe" and why and what it all means.
It may be funny, and if your only desire is amusement*, then that is fine. But since people do go to those experts, and they do find their explanations compelling, it is those explanations you should be concerned with debating, not the simpler explanations of Aunt Marge, because Margie may well go find out about the others.

Look, all I am saying is don't bring a knife to a gunfight. If you throw, say, the Epicurean Paradox in somebody's face, you better know your Leibniz.

*Not an unworthy goal.
 
Well, go figure. I don't debate woo anyhow. It's not my thing. It just allows the woo more opportunities to make up reasons to believe even more in their made up story, I think... It would be like trying to convince the serial killer groupies that the guy they have a crush on is not really a "nice guy" deep inside.

I think the "tree of knowledge" concept has problems all around no matter how it is explained away. But all woo can be retrofitted to makes some sort of sense with reality as we've seen many times on this forum. All woo has their apologetics to every reasoned argument. And it all rests eventually on faith... which is not a way to know anything anyhow.

I'm not sure anything would convince Aunt Marge... but why should I care what Aunt Marge believes or how she has justified the belief to herself? When I was a kid I wondered if there was any good reason for ME to believe this stuff. And as far as I can tell, everyone uses the Aunt Marge approach (courtier's reply) to justify the woo they've come to "believe in"... that isn't a reason for me to believe.

Given that, I find amusement a very achievable goal--whereas, changing the minds of the faithful using reason is too lofty a goal for this skeptic. I would want evidence that there is a good method, before I'd employ it. I think humor... and randi's method of fooling people to show they can be fooled may be the best-- but I'd have to see the statistics first. I don't think studying their theology is useful, but it might be.
 
drkitten said:
Er, wrong. The Fall was not a punishment, merely a consequence
...
Dig deeper. In this case, there are something like 2000 years of theological writings on this particular subject.
2,000 years of theogical writings? I admire the surgical precision of your citing.

OK, here are a couple of biggies:

Augie 'n' Tom said:
Aquinas, Summa Theologica 2:2:136 "On the contrary, Punishment corresponds to guilt. Now the woman was more grievously punished than the man, as appears from Genesis 3. Therefore she sinned more grievously than the man. "

Augustine, "City of God" XV:1 "Of the bliss of Paradise, of Paradise itself, and of the life of our first parents there, and of their sin and punishment, many have thought much, spoken much, written much. "

Augustine, "City of God" XIV:15 "Of the Justice of the Punishment with Which Our First Parents Were Visited for Their Disobedience"

Augustine, "City of God" XIV:17 "But when they were stripped of this grace, that their disobedience might be punished by fit retribution, there began in the movement of their bodily members a shameless novelty which made nakedness indecent: it at once made them observant and made them ashamed."

Please feel free to quote the theological writings that you claim support your own view.
 
Last edited:
This is what makes the New Testament intolerable! In the old one you were supposed to fear God, which made some kind of sense if you consider the kind of vindictive, paranoid psychopath you were dealing with. But now you even have to love him??!
Come on, drkitten! You cannot be serious!
Aren't you running out of straw by now?


What is supposed to be straw? That the God of the Old Testament is the god of fear??? No straw there, drkitten. That you don’t want to read what the Bible actually says is your problem!

”1 After these things God tested Abraham, and said to him, "Abraham!" And he said, "Here am I." 2 He said, "Take your son, your only son Isaac, whom you love, and go to the land of Mori'ah, and offer him there as a burnt offering upon one of the mountains of which I shall tell you." 3 So Abraham rose early in the morning, saddled his ass, and took two of his young men with him, and his son Isaac; and he cut the wood for the burnt offering, and arose and went to the place of which God had told him. 4 On the third day Abraham lifted up his eyes and saw the place afar off. 5 Then Abraham said to his young men, "Stay here with the ass; I and the lad will go yonder and worship, and come again to you." 6 And Abraham took the wood of the burnt offering, and laid it on Isaac his son; and he took in his hand the fire and the knife. So they went both of them together. 7 And Isaac said to his father Abraham, "My father!" And he said, "Here am I, my son." He said, "Behold, the fire and the wood; but where is the lamb for a burnt offering?" 8 Abraham said, "God will provide himself the lamb for a burnt offering, my son." So they went both of them together. 9 When they came to the place of which God had told him, Abraham built an altar there, and laid the wood in order, and bound Isaac his son, and laid him on the altar, upon the wood. 10 Then Abraham put forth his hand, and took the knife to slay his son. 11 But the angel of the LORD called to him from heaven, and said, "Abraham, Abraham!" And he said, "Here am I." 12 He said, "Do not lay your hand on the lad or do anything to him; for now I know that you fear God, seeing you have not withheld your son, your only son, from me." “
http://www.bibleontheweb.com/Bible.asp , p. 22

So he's the god of lies, of threats, of punishment, of fear, and of mean and stupid tests of the loyalty of his subjects.
 
Quick question...

If the only tree they were forbidden to eat from was the Tree of Knowledge, does this mean that they had already eaten from the Tree of Life? Or had they just not got around to it? Or was it very well hidden? Or, even, invisible if you hadn't eaten the forbidden fruit?
 
It's hard to tell:

“"Behold, the man has become like one of us, knowing good and evil; and now, lest he put forth his hand and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever" -- 23 therefore the LORD God sent him forth from the garden of Eden, to till the ground from which he was taken. 24 He drove out the man; and at the east of the garden of Eden he placed the cherubim, and a flaming sword which turned every way, to guard the way to the tree of life.”"

It did not seem to be a problem before they ate of the tree of knowledge, but it's hard to say why. If logic can be applied here, the questions seems connected with God having sentenced them to death: For this reason they are expelled from the garden of Eden, and the cherubim is ordered to prevent them from climbing the fence and going scrumping. So it probably wasn't very well hidden.
My guess is that their heavenly father did not prevent them from eating of the tree of life until they "had become like one of us, knowing good and evil". Until then they were supposed to live forever. It is fairly typical that a control freak like this feels threatened when his children grow up to become his equals. That is intolerable, that is something that he cannot possibly live with!
 
There wasn't any "unhappiness" in the Garden of Eden until God turned up and started giving out punishment. If anyone's responsible for ruining Eden it's him.

You're either wrong or playing semantic games; Adam and Eve were "ashamed" as soon as they ate the apple, looked at each other, and realized they were naked. If you think shame makes someone happy, you have a strange view of happiness.
 
It did not seem to be a problem before they ate of the tree of knowledge, but it's hard to say why. If logic can be applied here, the questions seems connected with God having sentenced them to death: For this reason they are expelled from the garden of Eden, and the cherubim is ordered to prevent them from climbing the fence and going scrumping. So it probably wasn't very well hidden.
My guess is that their heavenly father did not prevent them from eating of the tree of life until they "had become like one of us, knowing good and evil". Until then they were supposed to live forever. It is fairly typical that a control freak like this feels threatened when his children grow up to become his equals. That is intolerable, that is something that he cannot possibly live with!

Interesting. Also prompts the thought that the search for the Philosopher's Stone, which could also be used IIRC to prolong life indefinitely, may have been inspired by this part of the Bible? No doubt someone with a bit more historical knowledge can confirm/refute this?
 
Last edited:
Quick question...

If the only tree they were forbidden to eat from was the Tree of Knowledge, does this mean that they had already eaten from the Tree of Life? Or had they just not got around to it? Or was it very well hidden? Or, even, invisible if you hadn't eaten the forbidden fruit?


I'm wondering if it's the last one...

The Bible states that both the Tree of Life and Tree of Knowledge are at the centre of the garden, yet when Eve is talking to the serpent she says they cannot eat from the tree in the middle of the garden.

This implies to me that Eve is only aware of one tree in the centre of the garden. Also God clearly doesn't want them eating from the Tree of Life and becoming immortal, so sends them away, and seems to imply that it's the knowledge gained from the Tree of Knowledge that makes this a possibility.

So I'm inclined to think that only those who can perceive right and wrong can see the Tree of Life.

*shrugs*
 
You're either wrong or playing semantic games; Adam and Eve were "ashamed" as soon as they ate the apple, looked at each other, and realized they were naked. If you think shame makes someone happy, you have a strange view of happiness.


"not happy" and "unhappy" are not necessarily the same thing any more than "less than 5" and "negative 3" are necessarily the same thing.
 
"not happy" and "unhappy" are not necessarily the same thing any more than "less than 5" and "negative 3" are necessarily the same thing.

Yes. And "shame" is a feeling that goes all the way to "unhappy."
 
That is my point, it shows that christians believe their myths, they do not think them through, for if a being was create to be completely obedient to their god, why would it suddenly rebel. If their god is all power and all knowing, and Lucifer is suppose to be the smartest of all angels, then why rebel against a being that you know you cannot fight against much less win against. In any myth, there is grand holes of reason that the apologists of the religion cannot answer.

I can tell you the myth that I was taught. There were two covering cherubs of the throne of God, in heaven. One was Jesus and one was Lucifer. When God created the world, God proclaimed that all the beings of the universe should acknowledge Jesus as higher than all creation because he was not a created being. Jesus was the actual son of God. Lucifer did not see how Jesus was any better than him and decided he should be a god, himself, if Jesus was.
 
The implication from reading the Bible is that eating once from the Tree of Life ensures eternal life. The implication in the Bible is also that Adam and Eve had not yet eaten from it. We must, therefore, assume that they were mortal, in which case eating from the Tree of Knowledge did not result in suddenly being mortal, and thus God's statement that they would die if they ate from it is at best totally dishonest, and at worst an outright lie.
They end up dying, one way or another. I do not see it so much as a deception, but an omission of how it was going to be enforced. You are right in your assumption that without access to the tree of life, they would eventually die, showing they were not immortal.

Whether or not they had already eaten of it, seems irrelevant to me. My opinion is that consuming of the tree of life would be something that they would have had to do periodically. They may have not have, yet, as you assert because they had descendants who lived longer than them. I would think that if they had already consumed, they would have been longer lived than they were.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom