The shame isn't in asking a question which is naive. The shame comes in when one ignores well reasoned explanations as to why that question is naive.
Which is exactly my point.
But simply because there are old arguments explaining why the A&E story makes sense, doesn't mean those arguments are valid.
Yes. And I will cheerfully accept -- in fact, I do accept -- that that I can see flaws in those arguments; that I do not find them compelling. I am usually happy to discuss those flaws, precisely because there may be subtleties of reason that I'm not seeing, subtleties that negate the percieved flaws.
However, the problems with the arguments
for a sophisticated reading of Genesis doesn't render the naive arguments
against Genesis any less naive or wrong.
Or, as an alternate example, your "Why are there still monkeys" anti-evolution counter argument has been around for at least 100+ years. The fact that people still use it doesn't improve it's validity.
That's a good example, actually. There are a lot of bad arguments against evolution, and they're still trotted out, as though disproving evolution will somehow magically prove creationism. And creationists are very good at seizing upon genuine disagreements between evolutionary theorists as though that somehow renders the entire theory of evolution invalid.
Unfortunately, that still won't rescue their flawed arguments.
We've seen
exactly that on this thread, though.
"God banished Adam and Eve from the Garden
as a punishment!"
"No, He banished them from the Garden to prevent them from eating the Tree of Life. It wasn't a punishment, it was a preventative. It says so IN THE BOOK."
No further theological argumentation about the nature of the preventative will somehow make it into a punishment, no matter how you misquote.
Similarly, Danm suggested that "but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die" is a lie.
Is it? Again, theologians have looked at this, and, no, it isn't. Dying is a secondary consequence of the Fall; prior to the expulsion from the Garden, Adam and Eve had access to the Tree of Life and were permitted it (Genesis 2 states that EVERY fruit was available except one) and as a result could live forever. Once they were expelled, they no longer had access to it, and as a result were going to die. Telling people about important long-term secondary effects is hardly lying to them.
Aha, you ask. But
why did God have to expel them from the Garden in the first place? Well, it says in THE BOOK that he did so precisely to keep them from the Tree of Life. But is this necessarily a bad thing. Some theologians have speculated that this was precisely to provide them with another path to immortality and eternal bliss via living and dying; after they've brought unhappiness into this world, the only way to provide them with perfect happiness is in another one (giving them a chance to work off their sins via redemption). Allowing people to live forever in this (unhappy) world would be a cruel act indeed; instead, they are forced to move from this one to the next.
Of course, you don't have to buy that. And not all theologians do, although I find it a very pretty argument. A more central argument is simply that you're not God, and therefore are neither required nor expected to understand His motivations, any more than my niece is expected to understand histamines.
I don't ask that you
believe these stories. I simply ask that you
understand them. If you're trying to convert the believers, it really,
really helps if you don't present them with caricatures of their own beliefs. (Yes, this is a personal issue of mine. My sister is very deeply into a lunatic Jesus cult, along with the rest of my family, and she's dragging my mother down as well. I can't tell her why her beliefs are wrong unless I actually know what her beliefs are. This should be simple common sense, but it's astonishing how common sense actually isn't.)