Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

No, and that's part of the point. It's booby trapped. It's telling your kids not to eat the candy, lacing it with cyanide, and leaving it on a table next to the comfy chair in front of the TV. Then, you leave a babysitter in charge, who (in loco parentis) says "Go ahead, we won't tell your folks."


More correctly it's leaving a whole bunch of candy on the table, telling them the toffees in the middle are laced with cyanide (even though they aren't), and then leaving a babysitter in charge who says "You should eat that toffee, it's not really laced with cyanide".

Except of course your children understand right and wrong, and Adam and Eve didn't.

Any way you slice it God was stupid, stupid, stupid to allow the set up that occurred in the Garden of Eden. To blame Adam and Eve for his mistakes is totally unfair, but perfectly in keeping with the metaphor of the bad parent. I have a theory that the banishment from Eden is made up by God to make him sound all tough and bad ass - in reality Child Welfare took Adam and Eve off him and put them in a foster home after the Serpent made an anonymous phone call.
 
Really? Yeah, you're probably right. Maybe the new testament is Greek...
Doesn't matter, really, I don't read Hebrew either.


LOL, you're probably right about that too. I wonder if the cherubim drowned...


His sword's probably not flaming any more... ;)
 
More correctly it's leaving a whole bunch of candy on the table, telling them the toffees in the middle are laced with cyanide (even though they aren't), and then leaving a babysitter in charge who says "You should eat that toffee, it's not really laced with cyanide".

Except of course your children understand right and wrong, and Adam and Eve didn't.

Any way you slice it God was stupid, stupid, stupid to allow the set up that occurred in the Garden of Eden. To blame Adam and Eve for his mistakes is totally unfair, but perfectly in keeping with the metaphor of the bad parent. I have a theory that the banishment from Eden is made up by God to make him sound all tough and bad ass - in reality Child Welfare took Adam and Eve off him and put them in a foster home after the Serpent made an anonymous phone call.

Genesis is a creepy story, because if you raise questions about the story you are "biting from that tree of knowledge"--the very thing that f*ed up everything for Eve-- (!) So it's the creepy story that keeps on scaring people for all eternity. "Don't question gods orders, dammit-- just believe him-- look what happened to the last uppity woman who got too curious-- she ruined it for EVERYONE!"

What a heartwarming cautionary tale. I think even if theists don't consciously understand this message... they understand the implications of questioning the story... and so they don't. Instead, they don't think about it-- and they dash about trying to silence those who bring up the inconsistencies so as not to anger this weirdly inconsistent god.
 
drKitten is grasping at straws. Even if we accept the argument that unhappiness had been introduced into the Garden and forced God to evict Adam and Eve (which honestly doesn't hold up to scrutiny), why does it follow that they have to become mortal and toil hard all their lives? Why can't the all-powerful god create another Garden and stick them in there, or simply erase their memories of so-called unhappiness/possibility of shame and be done with it?

As was said, the Fall may have been a "consequence" but it was one born from God's will, not an uncontrollable force of nature. God didn't have to force them to pain and labour, he chose to.

And, um, since when are you qualified to hold an opinion?
How inanely rude. Who the hell do you think you are?

Dig deeper. In this case, there are something like 2000 years of theological writings on this particular subject.
Which are still as uncompelling and unconvincing as ever.
 
So, you still end up with the psycho God.

Yes, you do end up with the psycho god, but you have to look at the intentions (and the achievements) of the authors of the Jesus myths: They obviously did not like Psycho Dad, but probably were unable to simply reject him! (Look at the way (some) believers treat atheists today!)
So what do you do? You reinterpret him, you change him into the Jesus God of mercy, forgiveness and love thy neighbour. You have to admit that even though this is still religion, it is nevertheless a radical change! It may not be the change that we would prefer, but if I were able to choose and presented only with the two alternatives, I would definitely prefer my neighbours to be Jesus-God Xians rather than Psycho-God Xians.

The showdown is incomplete, of course, Psycho God is not dead, but he's been given a more humble position. The new god is a saviour rather than a punisher, no longer the god of fear.
He is still used by rulers (secular as well as religious) to discipline their subjects, but now at least it's more carrot than stick.
And the struggle between the different interpretations of God is still going on among believers who don't have the courage to reject the whole absurd thing once and for all.

It is sooooo much easier to be an atheist!
 
That is my point, it shows that christians believe their myths, they do not think them through, for if a being was create to be completely obedient to their god, why would it suddenly rebel. If their god is all power and all knowing, and Lucifer is suppose to be the smartest of all angels, then why rebel against a being that you know you cannot fight against much less win against. In any myth, there is grand holes of reason that the apologists of the religion cannot answer.

I think that this problem stems from the fact that the books of the Abrahamic faiths seem to suffer from bad copy-pasting from earlier religions.
 
Covering up a problem is not dealing with it. The problem is that after eating the fruit, it is now possible for A&E to feel unhappy --- the Garden is no longer Edenic, because they are no longer guaranteed blissful happiness in it.
But were they really happy before they are the fruit? Happiness is relative.


But wasn't imperfection already in Eden even before the snake talked to Eve?
 
...I would definitely prefer my neighbours to be Jesus-God Xians rather than Psycho-God Xians...
...The showdown is incomplete, of course,...
It is sooooo much easier to be an atheist!

I could give examples, from the Bible, of where Jesus is just as bad
but I guess I would be missing your point.
If you mean christianity, as in what people currently believe,
opposed to what was written about him, long ago,
there is progress towards a more loving and forgiving God.
Politically, I am Libertarian so if what you are doing does not harm others,
Why should we restrict other's lives.
The less people think it is their duty to judge me, the better.
 
Has it been pointed out to Christians yet that their religion blatantly tells them that knowledge is evil?

You haven't read the bible have you?

Proverbs 1:4
To give subtilty to the simple, to the young man knowledge and discretion.

Proverbs 1:7
The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge: but fools despise wisdom and instruction.

Proverbs 1:2
How long, ye simple ones, will ye love simplicity? and the scorners delight in their scorning, and fools hate knowledge?

Proverbs 2:3
Yea, if thou criest after knowledge, and liftest up thy voice for understanding;

Proverbs 2:6
For the LORD giveth wisdom: out of his mouth cometh knowledge and understanding.


Proverbs 8:10
Receive my instruction, and not silver; and knowledge rather than choice gold.

Proverbs 9:10
The fear of the LORD is the beginning of wisdom: and the knowledge of the holy is understanding.

Proverbs 10:14
Wise men lay up knowledge: but the mouth of the foolish is near destruction.

Proverbs 11:9
An hypocrite with his mouth destroyeth his neighbour: but through knowledge shall the just be delivered.

Proverbs 12:1
Whoso loveth instruction loveth knowledge: but he that hateth reproof is brutish.

Proverbs 13:16
Every prudent man dealeth with knowledge: but a fool layeth open his folly.

Proverbs 14:6
A scorner seeketh wisdom, and findeth it not: but knowledge is easy unto him that understandeth.

Proverbs 14:7
Go from the presence of a foolish man, when thou perceivest not in him the lips of knowledge.

Proverbs 14:18
The simple inherit folly: but the prudent are crowned with knowledge.

Proverbs 15:2
The tongue of the wise useth knowledge aright: but the mouth of fools poureth out foolishness.

Proverbs 15:7
The lips of the wise disperse knowledge: but the heart of the foolish doeth not so.

Proverbs 15:14
The heart of him that hath understanding seeketh knowledge: but the mouth of fools feedeth on foolishness.

Proverbs 17:27
He that hath knowledge spareth his words: and a man of understanding is of an excellent spirit.

Proverbs 18:15
The heart of the prudent getteth knowledge; and the ear of the wise seeketh knowledge.

Proverbs 19:2
Also, that the soul be without knowledge, it is not good; and he that hasteth with his feet sinneth.

Proverbs 19:25
Smite a scorner, and the simple will beware: and reprove one that hath understanding, and he will understand knowledge.

Proverbs 20:15
There is gold, and a multitude of rubies: but the lips of knowledge are a precious jewel.

Proverbs 21:11
When the scorner is punished, the simple is made wise: and when the wise is instructed, he receiveth knowledge.

Obviously the Bible classifies ignorance as a thought virus!






--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Last edited:
Radrook, its often with cults so that words get another meaning. We call this Fundie Redefinition. Words like; peace, wisdom and such get pretty twisted.
 
Radrook, its often with cults so that words get another meaning. We call this Fundie Redefinition. Words like; peace, wisdom and such get pretty twisted.



The first mindless knee jerk response in an effort to prevent a nose bleed if thinking is attempted. This fellow makes no point at all. Why? Because he doesn't have a leg to stand on. So he resorts to mindlessly seeking a rise. Which he will of course-via being included in my total ignore list in order to prevent any more verbal incontinence from splattering my screen.

In any case, I haven't gone to a bui;lding refered to as a church in 20 years. Haven't mentioned in my posts anything which the mainliners might consider cultish. In fact, haven't even stated anything vaguely resembling the term Fundie in my reply. All I did was quote scripture. Which of course is anathema to the godless which in turn inspires them to come up with anything that pops into the vacancy they call mind. Which explains why I don't engage these individuals iun any type of extended conversation. They don't deserve it.
 
Cool, biblical proverbs endorsing knowlegde.

How come science is rejected when it does not confirm biblical stories??
Like flood, shape of the earth, age of the earth, and astronomy.
 
How sad that Radrook is a slave to his indoctrination-- ever trying to prove to himself that his Jehovah Witness worldview is good and true and makes sense so that he can believe he will live happily ever after for "believing" and sharing the "good news". So much energy spent trying to convince himself of a rather twisted lie.

And that is why I think religion is child abuse.
 
Radrook, its often with cults so that words get another meaning. We call this Fundie Redefinition. Words like; peace, wisdom and such get pretty twisted.

Sounds like "freedom is where christ is" and then fast forward to theocracy.
 
I think the problem consists in the use of all-encompassing generalizations which leave the generalizer susceptible to easy refution via counterexamples. After all, it's well-known that a universal generalization is easily toppled by one counterexample. When these examples are suddenly presented, of course, panicking doesn't help. It merely demonstrates the indefensibility of the proposition. Instead, the use of premise qualifiers such as most, the majority, the minority, some, a few, would remedy the situation. However, that's where dramatic effect is lost and from the godless viewpoint, drama is far more important than accuracy or logic. So it's futile to expect a modification in premise positing I guess. Sigh!
 
Last edited:
How come science is rejected by SOME christians when it does not confirm biblical stories??
Like flood, shape of the earth, age of the earth, and astronomy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom