Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

EGarrett

Illuminator
Joined
Feb 24, 2004
Messages
3,086
Has it been pointed out to Christians yet that their religion blatantly tells them that knowledge is evil?

Between that concept and the idea that believing stuff without investigating it (faith) is a virtue...isn't that really, really strong evidence that Christianity is a thought virus? It seems obvious enough that even a Christian might have to consider it.
 
To be fair, the tree was knowledge of good and evil, which in my armchair theology saddled humanity with knowing the difference and therefore being responsible for their own actions.
 
Hang on a minute, if they weren't responsible for their own actions prior to eating of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, why was it bad of them to eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, since they weren't in control of their actions?
 
I guess because "the woman" had free will. After all, she chose to eat of the tree despite god's warning.
I....guess. The bible makes no sense to me anyway.
 
Hang on a minute, if they weren't responsible for their own actions prior to eating of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, why was it bad of them to eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, since they weren't in control of their actions?

Just because you're not responsible for your actions doesn't make them not have consequences. And just because you don't understand the consequences of your actions doesn't make you not responsible for them.

Ask any parent. You have to teach your children not to do a lot of stuff, without necessarily explaining why. "No, you can't have a peanut butter cookie (because you're allergic to peanuts). No, I'm not going to explain histamine reactions to you. Shut up and have a banana instead." But it's still bad for my peanut-allergic niece to eat the wrong cookie.
 
Hang on a minute, if they weren't responsible for their own actions prior to eating of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, why was it bad of them to eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, since they weren't in control of their actions?

It is a wonderful and beautiful allegory of the change of humanity from animal to something more, with the new ability to realize the consequences of their own actions, and not perform them in order to accomplish some more abstract goal.

The problem is when Bible literalism takes a (poop) all over it, completely missing it's real purpose*.

In other words, treated as such, it's fine. When you start to ask questions as to why God would do such a thing, knowing they would fail and be punished, and could hardly be held responsible for their actions, much less so severely, you run into problems.






* As an allegory of human development, not as a false parasetic meme by which some lazy people gain a living specializing in pretending to place a supervillain hero.
 
Just because you're not responsible for your actions doesn't make them not have consequences. And just because you don't understand the consequences of your actions doesn't make you not responsible for them.

Ask any parent. You have to teach your children not to do a lot of stuff, without necessarily explaining why. "No, you can't have a peanut butter cookie (because you're allergic to peanuts). No, I'm not going to explain histamine reactions to you. Shut up and have a banana instead." But it's still bad for my peanut-allergic niece to eat the wrong cookie.

Right... except that A&E were being punished for their actions, which they weren't responsible for. You don't punish your niece for eating peanuts, you get her to a doctor.
 
It is a wonderful and beautiful allegory of the change of humanity from animal to something more, with the new ability to realize the consequences of their own actions, and not perform them in order to accomplish some more abstract goal.

The problem is when Bible literalism takes a (poop) all over it, completely missing it's real purpose*.

In other words, treated as such, it's fine. When you start to ask questions as to why God would do such a thing, knowing they would fail and be punished, and could hardly be held responsible for their actions, much less so severely, you run into problems.






* As an allegory of human development, not as a false parasetic meme by which some lazy people gain a living specializing in pretending to place a supervillain hero.

If God didn't want me wondering what the hell was going on with the bible, he should have dictated it in a clearer manner or made me less inquisitive.
 
Right... except that A&E were being punished for their actions, which they weren't responsible for.

Er, wrong. The Fall was not a punishment, merely a consequence.

Even if my niece feels she's being punished (because she now has to get histamine shots, which she hates).
 
Last edited:
What is this tree in the midst of the Garden that God warned Adam against eating? Could Eden have been a special annex of Heaven, for the growing of fruit trees? Why would God plant such a thing, a tree of the knowledge of good and evil? Apparently it was not for the use of man. That leaves the angels but why would angels need to know about good and evil? Angels are the servants of God and know nothing except obedience. Man was created with free will and that left open the possibility of sin entering the world. If sin took hold on man, how would the angels deal with it, having no concept of evil? Conveniently, there is a tree of that knowledge, right in the middle of the garden where man lived. Lucifer could have been looking for something to give him the edge in his popularity competition with the Son of God. He may have allowed this word "Knowledge" to run in his mind until he finally gave that thought enough power to finally cause him to act on it.This knowledge is something better left alone, if possible. The knowledge in itself is not necessarily destructive to the recipient but if the purpose for obtaining that knowledge is different from its intended use, it easily could be destructive. Angels are not made like man and it would have taken a very long time to get to a really bad condition because it would have had to fight against a hard-wired mind dedicated to serving God. That same knowledge, only intended for angels dedicated to fighting evil, to the Human mind was devastating and immediately turned them to evil behavior. Only in man can evil have its full potential realized. Satan looks on in wonder at the depths of depravity that man is capable of and can only wish that he could be so evil. Satan was able to survive his dose of knowledge and does not die of natural causes, so he has had a lot of time to hone his skills in manipulating men to works of evil and time to hate men, more and more.
 
Er, wrong. The Fall was not a punishment, merely a consequence.

Even if my niece feels she's being punished (because she now has to get histamine shots, which she hates).

Sure, sure. The Creator of the Universe and Knower of Everything up against two innocents who do not even know the difference between Good and Evil. They were mislead by a talking snake and humanity was "consequently" punished for ever. At least the All Powerful One could have given them a hint, like, "Don't believe the snake".

How can anyone believe this crap? That's a rhetorical question; not a slam at any individual. :D
 
It's like Chief Wiggum on The Simpsons: "You know you're not supposed to go in there. What is your fascination with my Forbidden Closet of Mystery? "
 
Christians (and other superstitions) have long believed that there is good and evil knowledge, the archetype being the Tree of Good and Evil. Science opposes that view and has been castigated for ages in it's pursuit of those things "man was never meant to know". You even see it in the latter day in non-religious contexts; see the thread here named "When Machines Rule" (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=118895)in which it is implied that we shouldn't press AI too far because it will lead to our species' demise.

A good question for the forum (related to the OP, of course) is whether there really is any category of knowledge (religious or otherwise) that man should not pursue, and why?
 
To the woman he said,
"I will greatly increase your pains in childbearing;
with pain you will give birth to children.
Your desire will be for your husband,
and he will rule over you." 17 To Adam he said, "Because you listened to your wife and ate from the tree about which I commanded you, 'You must not eat of it,'
"Cursed is the ground because of you;
through painful toil you will eat of it
all the days of your life.
18 It will produce thorns and thistles for you,
and you will eat the plants of the field.
19 By the sweat of your brow
you will eat your food
until you return to the ground,
since from it you were taken;
for dust you are
and to dust you will return."



is not a punishment? Really?
 
It's like Chief Wiggum on The Simpsons: "You know you're not supposed to go in there. What is your fascination with my Forbidden Closet of Mystery? "

:D

God should have given his tree a better name. There was a play put on here a few years ago about that. Adam and Eve, as two happy children, are playing innocently around the Tree of Knowledge. God's voice comes from offstage:

God: Hello, Adam and Eve. This is God speaking.

A&E: Oh, hi God.

God: I created you and everything here for your benefit and enjoyment. You can do whatever you want, anything your hearts desire--except eat from the Tree of Knowledge.

A&E: Oh, okay. (They go back to playing.)

God: (clears throat) Um, just a reminder--you can do anything you want--except eat from the Tree of Knowledge.

A&E: Sure, whatever you say. (They go back to playing again)

God: Okay, just so we're clear on this. See that tree? Yeah, the one with the fruit hanging from it. I specifically forbid you to eat from that tree!
 
"Just because you're not responsible for your actions doesn't make them not have consequences. And just because you don't understand the consequences of your actions doesn't make you not responsible for them.

Ask any parent. You have to teach your children not to do a lot of stuff, without necessarily explaining why. "No, you can't have a peanut butter cookie (because you're allergic to peanuts). No, I'm not going to explain histamine reactions to you. Shut up and have a banana instead." But it's still bad for my peanut-allergic niece to eat the wrong cookie."drkitten

Sure the consequences may still be the child's, but what kind of parent would you be if you put a peanut butter cookie in the playpen of your peanut allergic toddler. warning or no warning I think you as a parent would bear the resposibility.
 
Last edited:
To the woman he said,
"I will greatly increase your pains in childbearing;
with pain you will give birth to children.
Your desire will be for your husband,
and he will rule over you." 17 To Adam he said, "Because you listened to your wife and ate from the tree about which I commanded you, 'You must not eat of it,'
"Cursed is the ground because of you;
through painful toil you will eat of it
all the days of your life.
18 It will produce thorns and thistles for you,
and you will eat the plants of the field.
19 By the sweat of your brow
you will eat your food
until you return to the ground,
since from it you were taken;
for dust you are
and to dust you will return."



is not a punishment? Really?

No. If you are an apologist, it is a consequence.

''A tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing'' Bill S.
 
I guess because "the woman" had free will. After all, she chose to eat of the tree despite god's warning.
I....guess. The bible makes no sense to me anyway.

While some people will say that this is a way of blaming women for all our troubles in the world. It could also show that women were smart enough to know not to listen to an imaginary character about what fruits not to eat.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom