Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

Will someone let me know if Radrook ever says something that makes sense to someone other than him? I can understand most people and some pretty detailed scientific literature-- but I can't understand woo. I think you can tell more by the questions the woo avoids than anything they actually say.
 
Will someone let me know if Radrook ever says something that makes sense to someone other than him? I can understand most people and some pretty detailed scientific literature-- but I can't understand woo. I think you can tell more by the questions the woo avoids than anything they actually say.
Well, he did just post something about sweeping generalisations that can be easily refuted by specific counterexamples, and I think he's pretty much right about that. Especially since the premise of the thread has long since been acknowledged to be more or less innacurate.
 
I think the problem consists in the use of all-encompassing generalizations which leave the generalizer susceptible to easy refution via counterexamples.
You mean all-encompassing generalizations like "the godless viewpoint"?

Instead, the use of premise qualifiers such as most, the majority, the minority, some, a few, would remedy the situation. However, that's where dramatic effect is lost and from the godless viewpoint, drama is far more important than accuracy or logic.
Guess not...
 
What is this tree in the midst of the Garden that God warned Adam against eating? Could Eden have been a special annex of Heaven, for the growing of fruit trees? Why would God plant such a thing, a tree of the knowledge of good and evil?

It doesn't really matter what it was for, just that God told Adam not to eat from the tree, and Adam told Eve not to eat from the tree. They didn't do God's will so they were punished.

Apparently it was not for the use of man. That leaves the angels but why would angels need to know about good and evil? Angels are the servants of God and know nothing except obedience.

Man was created with free will and that left open the possibility of sin entering the world. If sin took hold on man, how would the angels deal with it, having no concept of evil? Conveniently, there is a tree of that knowledge, right in the middle of the garden where man lived.

Um, Angels have free will too, how else do 1/3 of them fall away from God along with Lucifer? They all had free will, and some of them chose to disobey God. There were several angels who were locked up in the bottomless pit because they disobeyed God and went down to earth and mated with human women.

Go read the book of Enoch, it is filled with exploits of these fallen angels and their offspring the Nephilim.

Lucifer could have been looking for something to give him the edge in his popularity competition with the Son of God. He may have allowed this word "Knowledge" to run in his mind until he finally gave that thought enough power to finally cause him to act on it.This knowledge is something better left alone, if possible. The knowledge in itself is not necessarily destructive to the recipient but if the purpose for obtaining that knowledge is different from its intended use, it easily could be destructive. Angels are not made like man and it would have taken a very long time to get to a really bad condition because it would have had to fight against a hard-wired mind dedicated to serving God.
Angels are not hard wired to serve God any more than we are. They have free will, they choose to obey and serve.
That same knowledge, only intended for angels dedicated to fighting evil, to the Human mind was devastating and immediately turned them to evil behavior. Only in man can evil have its full potential realized. Satan looks on in wonder at the depths of depravity that man is capable of and can only wish that he could be so evil. Satan was able to survive his dose of knowledge and does not die of natural causes, so he has had a lot of time to hone his skills in manipulating men to works of evil and time to hate men, more and more.

Only in man can evil be fully realized? Since when? What do you base this argument off of? Considering that Satan/Lucifer is the most evil being in existence I find that very hard to believe. When you have nothing left to lose, like the fallen angels, then you don't feel the need to hold back on your evil thoughts any longer.

The idea that the Bible says knowledge is a bad thing is just ridiculous. The only thing we know of good and evil is that doing God's will is good, and not doing it is bad. Since God is the most intelligent, wise, and loving being in existence, anything he does cannot be questioned. Think of God as the ultimate philosopher king. Many people would gladly follow a human being on earth, but they won't consider following God. I don't understand that really.

People constantly argue that God is a bad guy, because he allows suffering. I would argue that maybe you are just too stupid to understand what is going on, and since you don't have all the relevant information you cannot make a valid argument that God is bad. He's only bad from your limited perspective, which will one day change when you die.

At least God won't put you in jail for the rest of your life for downloading some mp3's. Our ideas of what are right and wrong are corrupt, they have been corrupted over time, until we see God's law as evil and man's law as good.
 
I think that it's worse than that, actually! This god actually is a very bad guy, and we are supposed to obey him because he's omnipotent.
Jesus is a kind of rebel against this attitude - within the framework of religion. He changes the psychopathic god of original sin into a god of forgiveness and love-thy-neighbour, which is quite an accomplishment!
If you are a fan of the originial vindictive psycho, you interpret the story of Jesus as just another addition to the original sin: Now we're not only sinners, we've also killed the son of God!
If you are a fan of the Jesus god, however, you tend to feel embarrassed about his origins and reinterpret (or try to forget about) the stories of Adam and Eve, Abraham and Isaac etc: Jesus died for our sins, so we are no longer sinners and the god is so good that he actually sacrificed his own son to save us. In a weird psychological sense that is actually a giant step forward!

Have you ever thought that your idea of what God is, is wrong? You're trying to define what is good and bad from a human perspective.

Humans make much of our lives on this planet, tthat they have some importants, the stuff we buy, the job we have, etc... In God's mind these things are meaningless. Showing your obedience to God is what matter on this planet.

So all the death and destruction that occurs really isn't as important as we think it is. We place way too much importance on it.

Much of the mass murder in the Bible can be directly linked to the seed of Lucifer. If you know you Bible you know that Angels came down in Genesis 6 and mated with human women.

They created a race of hybrids called Nephilim. The flood was God's way of wiping out these abominations that were created, who did nothing but evil. Noah and his family were the only people on the planet who did not have mixed blood. In that case it was completely justified for God to do what he did.

He also locked those Angels up in the bottomless pit, so they no longer were around to do such a thing. They had originally done this to try and stop the coming of the messiah, because this was all planned out a long time ago. They knew what was to come and they tried to stop it. They failed and paid the price.

People who talk about God being an evil being have zero understanding of God, or existence. They have a warped sense of what is good, because they have been corrupted by evil.

God is the most intelligent, wise, and loving being in existence, yet you claim to know more than he does? Your thinking is too limited to even begin to mount and argument against God. Good luck arguing with him on Judgement day, I'm sure that will go well for you.
 
And you know all this how? There were people created by god who were totally totally evil? Even as little kids? This sounds like a specific "brand" of theology.

You seem to believe very strongly in your version of the myth and you seem to have explained it well to yourself... now why don't you see if you can get Radrook to agree. If this life doesn't matter, then why live it? Why not kill your kids while they are young so they can go straight to heaven while they are sin free? What kind of god makes such a creepy test where he makes people who are ALL BAD? That is the creepiest god story I"ve heard. Is that the Mormon Version? You ought to duke it out with Radrook--he has the Jehovah Witness version... and when all biblical literalists actually agree on the story, then you are all on the same page as to what it was your invisible friend was trying to convey, then maybe we can take it a little more seriously than say, a book report on the "true meaning" of Dianetics and what L. Ron was truly trying to convey.

I'll take human morality... particularly that of current civilization over your invisible savior any day. You may have rationalized it in your head, but it comes off as sounding as crazy as any woo version of a woo story to me.
 
I don't believe there was ever, literally, an Adam or an Eve, or that, literally, there were any garden with forbidden trees, or talking serpents and punishments. I believe these are metaphors dealing with the transformation (evolution) of mankind into higher thinkers, and the realization of the responsibilities associated with that.

Try telling any Christian that Genesis is a metaphor for evolution. ;)

PS. There's a good fiction novel called Ishmael which presents a very interesting metaphor of Cain and Abel.
 
Yeah, but a real Jesus can't have been killed for a metaphor.

-which isn't a problem for me since I don't believe in "divine people"-- incarnate or not. The whole story is as mythological to me as any other myth or L. Ron's Xenu story. I don't really care what people think it means. I can read the words myself and decide for myself what it means-- and the god of a the bible is not someone I'd worship or pattern myself after-- nor would I admire anyone who worships such an unsavory sort. He is a crappy "parent" with an astounding ego. I would not create a single child if I believe there was a remote chance that he could suffer forever. It's just wrong--evil. And putting temptation in front of people (or animals) that cannot resist is called "entrapment".

If I leave out food and my dog eats it... I am to blame-- not my dog.
 
Last edited:
Have you ever thought that your idea of what God is, is wrong? You're trying to define what is good and bad from a human perspective.
The nerve of some people.

Humans make much of our lives on this planet, tthat they have some importants, the stuff we buy, the job we have, etc... In God's mind these things are meaningless. Showing your obedience to God is what matter on this planet.
Is that what god told you?

So all the death and destruction that occurs really isn't as important as we think it is. We place way too much importance on it.
Yeah, making sure people have enough to eat is just delaying the inevitable. If we kill them or cure them, it makes no difference.

Much of the mass murder in the Bible can be directly linked to the seed of Lucifer.
And much more can be linked to the actions or requests of god.

If you know you Bible you know that Angels came down in Genesis 6 and mated with human women.

They created a race of hybrids called Nephilim. The flood was God's way of wiping out these abominations that were created, who did nothing but evil. Noah and his family were the only people on the planet who did not have mixed blood. In that case it was completely justified for God to do what he did.
Because mixed blood is just wrong. Lovely.

He also locked those Angels up in the bottomless pit, so they no longer were around to do such a thing.
Better late than never, I guess. Oops, there I go again, judging by human standards.

They had originally done this to try and stop the coming of the messiah, because this was all planned out a long time ago. They knew what was to come and they tried to stop it. They failed and paid the price.
Hey, you know what wouldn't have been shortsighted? God could have made Eve, then make her pregnant, and let Adam be the messiah. I mean, if it was all planned so long ago, just cut off those womanizing angels at the pass.

People who talk about God being an evil being have zero understanding of God, or existence. They have a warped sense of what is good, because they have been corrupted by evil.
Probably mixed blood, don't you reckon?

God is the most intelligent, wise, and loving being in existence, yet you claim to know more than he does?
I know how this mess could have been avoided. Don't make those angels!

Your thinking is too limited to even begin to mount and argument against God. Good luck arguing with him on Judgement day, I'm sure that will go well for you.
Now I'm sweating.
 
Have you ever thought that your idea of what God is, is wrong? You're trying to define what is good and bad from a human perspective.
I've considered that idea. And came to the conclusion that defining good and bad from a human perspective is the only thing i could. Trying to understand good and bad from the perspective of a being who is beyond our understanding (as claimed by a lot of christians) is beyond me.

Humans make much of our lives on this planet, tthat they have some importants, the stuff we buy, the job we have, etc... In God's mind these things are meaningless. Showing your obedience to God is what matter on this planet.
I like how you pretend to know what is, and what is not, important to God. Care to elaborate how you are so certain that showing obedience to God is the only thing that is important to him?

So all the death and destruction that occurs really isn't as important as we think it is. We place way too much importance on it.
I realy think you should start preaching this to your fellow christians. Might make this world a safer and more peaceful place. In the mean time, as an atheist, I value my (only) life and by extension the life of others. I'd rather not see those lives wasted.

Much of the mass murder in the Bible can be directly linked to the seed of Lucifer. If you know you Bible you know that Angels came down in Genesis 6 and mated with human women.
Ok

They created a race of hybrids called Nephilim. The flood was God's way of wiping out these abominations that were created, who did nothing but evil. Noah and his family were the only people on the planet who did not have mixed blood. In that case it was completely justified for God to do what he did.
Evidence please... that this hybrid race actually existed. We can discuss if God was justified with his actions once it has been established that this race did indeed excist AND that this race only did evil. Till such evidence has been presented I have no other recourse but to believe that these Nephilim did not exist and that the people that were killed in this flood were in fact human. (Assuming that the flood as described in the bible is even possible)

He also locked those Angels up in the bottomless pit, so they no longer were around to do such a thing. They had originally done this to try and stop the coming of the messiah, because this was all planned out a long time ago. They knew what was to come and they tried to stop it. They failed and paid the price.
Ok...

People who talk about God being an evil being have zero understanding of God, or existence. They have a warped sense of what is good, because they have been corrupted by evil.
Please explain... Because I'm realy curious why you would think that my sense of good and evil is warped. And in particular how you have reached the conclusion that I have been corrupted by evil.

God is the most intelligent, wise, and loving being in existence, yet you claim to know more than he does? Your thinking is too limited to even begin to mount and argument against God. Good luck arguing with him on Judgement day, I'm sure that will go well for you.
I do not make any such claim (knowing more then God). But if Judgement day does come he will have some explaining to do.
 
The first mindless knee jerk response in an effort to prevent a nose bleed if thinking is attempted. This fellow makes no point at all.
It seems that need to explain this point to you. I had hoped that you had enough intelligence to understand it without further help.

Lets take this example:
Proverbs 1:7
The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge: but fools despise wisdom and instruction.
This clearly points to the believe that knowledge and wisdom is only found in the context of that god. This only helps to disregard knowledge or wisdom from other sources.

Similar are the catchphrases of Christians (who claim a religion of love) and Muslims (who claim a religion of peace). Both terms find their special context inside their religions. You could phrase it as such: those who submit themselves to Allah will find peace. Or: Those who let Jesus into their hearts will feels his love.
This perverts the meaning of both words into an exclusive mockery.
 
They created a race of hybrids called Nephilim. The flood was God's way of wiping out these abominations that were created, who did nothing but evil. Noah and his family were the only people on the planet who did not have mixed blood. In that case it was completely justified for God to do what he did.

He also locked those Angels up in the bottomless pit, so they no longer were around to do such a thing. They had originally done this to try and stop the coming of the messiah, because this was all planned out a long time ago. They knew what was to come and they tried to stop it. They failed and paid the price.


This all sounds much less offensive if you imagine it being said by Napoleon Dynamite.

Seriously though, back to the original point of this thread; is anyone investigating this serious increase in peanut allergies?
 
I think the problem consists in the use of all-encompassing generalizations which leave the generalizer susceptible to easy refution via counterexamples. After all, it's well-known that a universal generalization is easily toppled by one counterexample. When these examples are suddenly presented, of course, panicking doesn't help. It merely demonstrates the indefensibility of the proposition. Instead, the use of premise qualifiers such as most, the majority, the minority, some, a few, would remedy the situation. However, that's where dramatic effect is lost and from the godless viewpoint, drama is far more important than accuracy or logic. So it's futile to expect a modification in premise positing I guess. Sigh!
Oh Dear. It seems that an irony nexus has been created on the internet. Everyone back up your important data before the EMP generated by the projection pulse damages your hard drives.
 
I've considered that idea. And came to the conclusion that defining good and bad from a human perspective is the only thing i could. Trying to understand good and bad from the perspective of a being who is beyond our understanding (as claimed by a lot of christians) is beyond me.

We don't have the whole picture, hence the "see through a glass darkly" statement in the NT. We are to take things on faith.
I like how you pretend to know what is, and what is not, important to God. Care to elaborate how you are so certain that showing obedience to God is the only thing that is important to him?
We only have what is written in the Bible, so we cannot know what else God wants besides that. Being obedient is only part of what God wants. He has plans for those people who are obedient, plans that we cannot even imagine.

However, it seems that while we are on this plane of existence, we are too obey the word of God.
I realy think you should start preaching this to your fellow christians. Might make this world a safer and more peaceful place. In the mean time, as an atheist, I value my (only) life and by extension the life of others. I'd rather not see those lives wasted.

Most war is caused not by Religion but pure human greed. The world would be a much better place if we all lived as Jesus directed us to do. That will never happen of course, not in this lifetime.

Evidence please... that this hybrid race actually existed. We can discuss if God was justified with his actions once it has been established that this race did indeed excist AND that this race only did evil. Till such evidence has been presented I have no other recourse but to believe that these Nephilim did not exist and that the people that were killed in this flood were in fact human. (Assuming that the flood as described in the bible is even possible)

The Bible says so? Obviously not good enough for you. Consider how much information has been lost in the sands of time. We have such a tiny amount of information about the past, of what happened, who existed, the wars that were fought, the people who lived.

We didn't even think that Romans could make complex machines with gears, yet we found one at the bottom of the ocean. One of how many that might have existed.

What else existed that has been lost to time, so we assume that they were more primitive than they were.

I would also argue that the flood of the Bible was more than possible, and that it did happen. Just because your scientific method does not detect it does not mean that it did not happen, or that your methedology is missing something.

Please explain... Because I'm realy curious why you would think that my sense of good and evil is warped. And in particular how you have reached the conclusion that I have been corrupted by evil.

We have all been corrupted according to the Bible, and our view of good and evil has been warped. Hence we look at the Bible and say, no sex before marriage? No thanks!

Just because you think it's ok doesn't mean it is in the eyes of God. He created man and woman to cling together, one man and one woman. The reason it is wrong has to do with not obeying God's word.

It all comes down to obedience.

I do not make any such claim (knowing more then God). But if Judgement day does come he will have some explaining to do.

When Judgement day comes he won't be defending himself to anyone, especially not atheists who's world view is extremely narrow, and tainted by anger towards being told how they should live their lives.

One day you will understand, we will all understand, but only some of us will get to see the reward that comes after.

Just remember when the Anti-Christ rises up and starts performing miracles, and those who are not saved worship him, turn to your Bible and get right with God.

If you think that's all a joke, go read up on the Gog Magog war in Ezekiel 38 and 39. We are seeing the creation of that situation right now in the middle east with Russia, Iran, and Israel.
 
We don't have the whole picture, hence the "see through a glass darkly" statement in the NT. We are to take things on faith.
I don't need the whole picture to determine what is good and what is evil.

We only have what is written in the Bible, so we cannot know what else God wants besides that. Being obedient is only part of what God wants. He has plans for those people who are obedient, plans that we cannot even imagine.

However, it seems that while we are on this plane of existence, we are too obey the word of God.
Get back to me when all christians (and I mean all of them) have finally agreed to what this word of God is exactly that we are supposed to obey. Too many different interpretations still exist of this supposed Word; how do I decide which interpretation is the right one?

Most war is caused not by Religion but pure human greed. The world would be a much better place if we all lived as Jesus directed us to do. That will never happen of course, not in this lifetime.
Ok, but it seems to me that a lot of christians are still too bothered by the death and destruction that occurs in this world.

The Bible says so? Obviously not good enough for you. Consider how much information has been lost in the sands of time. We have such a tiny amount of information about the past, of what happened, who existed, the wars that were fought, the people who lived.

We didn't even think that Romans could make complex machines with gears, yet we found one at the bottom of the ocean. One of how many that might have existed.

What else existed that has been lost to time, so we assume that they were more primitive than they were.
I'm pretty sure that if there was a complete race of these Nephilim that we would have found some evidence (a set of bones or something) by now. The possibility exists of course that we will find such evidence in the future. And I promise that I will evaluate my position once that happens. But till then I will remain doubtfull if these 'hybrids' actually existed.

I would also argue that the flood of the Bible was more than possible, and that it did happen. Just because your scientific method does not detect it does not mean that it did not happen, or that your methedology is missing something.
Same as above. Present some compelling evidence of this biblical flood and I will reconsider my position. Till such a time I will remain doubtful that said flood actually happened.

We have all been corrupted according to the Bible, and our view of good and evil has been warped. Hence we look at the Bible and say, no sex before marriage? No thanks!

Just because you think it's ok doesn't mean it is in the eyes of God. He created man and woman to cling together, one man and one woman. The reason it is wrong has to do with not obeying God's word.

It all comes down to obedience.
I guess your God should have been smart enough to realize that some people like myself aren't very obedient when it comes to following the guidelines laid down by an invisible being. Not without proof that said invisible being actually exists. I'm sure that with his infite wisdom and power he could have done something that would have set me straight.

When Judgement day comes he won't be defending himself to anyone, especially not atheists who's world view is extremely narrow, and tainted by anger towards being told how they should live their lives.
You don't even know me (except from this one post). From that it follows that you have no idea how wide or narrow my world view is. You also have no idea if I am angry about being told how to live, or if I'm just indifferent.

And honestly, if your God can do no better then 'Because I say so' in response to my question; He should have been smart enough to give me a somewhat less developed brain.

One day you will understand, we will all understand, but only some of us will get to see the reward that comes after.
Perhaps, I hope you choose well.

Just remember when the Anti-Christ rises up and starts performing miracles, and those who are not saved worship him, turn to your Bible and get right with God.
I'll take a pass on this one (untill shown proof that God actually exists)

If you think that's all a joke, go read up on the Gog Magog war in Ezekiel 38 and 39. We are seeing the creation of that situation right now in the middle east with Russia, Iran, and Israel.
And these end of day predictions have been coming for how long now? It seems to me that in any given period some christians are seeing signs that the end is near and yet here we are.
 
And these end of day predictions have been coming for how long now? It seems to me that in any given period some christians are seeing signs that the end is near and yet here we are.
Great Googly Magoogly, this means WAR!

This type of theist seems a lot like a celebrity stalker to me. They've become convinced that they're really, really special -- "Yes, JESUS loves me!" -- and they receive "secret messages" that other people miss (like Charlie Manson getting secret messages through the White Album). They are special people, living in a special time, just waiting for the inevitable opportunity to take their place by the side of their favorite celebrity. If you were Jesus it would probably be kind of scary/creepy, but since Jesus is long gone it's mostly just pathetic.
 
I think the problem consists in the use of all-encompassing generalizations which leave the generalizer susceptible to easy refution via counterexamples. After all, it's well-known that a universal generalization is easily toppled by one counterexample. When these examples are suddenly presented, of course, panicking doesn't help. It merely demonstrates the indefensibility of the proposition. Instead, the use of premise qualifiers such as most, the majority, the minority, some, a few, would remedy the situation. However, that's where dramatic effect is lost and from the godless viewpoint, drama is far more important than accuracy or logic. So it's futile to expect a modification in premise positing I guess. Sigh!
I'll translate.

The problem is that when you say "everything is such-and-such," you can be proven wrong when someone shows you one thing that isn't. And when someone does that, if you get angry, it only makes you look more wrong. If you use words like "most," this won't happen to you. But people don't want to do that because it sounds weaker. I also think that atheists care more about sounding strong than being right. So I don't think they'll change.

Intelligence is in WHAT you say, not how you say it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom