Merged Too Much NoC Evidence?

You know, a lot of the time I have a hard time following the more technical discussions here, but frankly in this situation even I can see that CIT are out-and-out being dishonest. This is absolutely disgraceful.

How on Earth are we supposed to believe ANYTHING they say?
 
Last edited:
nicepants said:
I believe this "flyover witness" is the one who reported a plane flying over the pentagon after AA77 slammed into it. His story creates a minor problem with the flyover theory.....since he claims there were 2 planes...one hitting the pentagon and one flying over. Hmm...whose theory does that sound more like?
Please, God, don't remind me of Terral.

Actually, I'm thinking his story sounds more like what we know to be true...since the plane he saw fly over had.....PROPELLERS and not turbofans.

WHOOPS!:jaw-dropp

Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury...it sounds to me like he saw the C-130 (the only plane in the area with propellers). It sure as H-E double hockeysticks wasn't a Boeing 757.
 
First, the thread has had another merged into it, in case it feels off, but the subjects fit well. Too much evidence for a scenario that didn't happen, as shown by the actual impact. :)
Actually, I'm thinking his story sounds more like what we know to be true...since the plane he saw fly over had.....PROPELLERS and not turbofans.

WHOOPS!:jaw-dropp

Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury...it sounds to me like he saw the C-130 (the only plane in the area with propellers). It sure as H-E double hockeysticks wasn't a Boeing 757.

Why do you think he saw propellors? He said it was jet engines on a silver commercial airliner, banking just above the light poles southwest of the Pentagon heading towards the Pentagon. Go find a transcript and double check.

THIS is the plane he saw 'just after the event," and THEN it flew over and away to the southwest as well, he says. That part's made up IMO.

As far as after 77's crash, check again his description of this event. "the plane hit the building," said amongst references to watching the teevee. CIT never asked how he knew - sound? Shockwaves? Looking at the screen? Never clarified once. He later says "the explosion hit" and after he realized what CIT wanted to hear, he does say "upon impact." That's the best it gets. He saw 175 crash on TV IMO. Then saw 77 approach.
 
Last edited:
First, the thread has had another merged into it, in case it feels off, but the subjects fit well. Too much evidence for a scenario that didn't happen, as shown by the actual impact. :)

Why do you think he saw propellors? He said it was jet engines on a silver commercial airliner, banking just above the light poles southwest of the Pentagon heading towards the Pentagon. Go find a transcript and double check.

THIS is the plane he saw 'just after the event," and THEN it flew over and away to the southwest as well, he says. That part's made up IMO.

As far as after 77's crash, check again his description of this event. "the plane hit the building," said amongst references to watching the teevee. CIT never asked how he knew - sound? Shockwaves? Looking at the screen? Never clarified once. He later says "the explosion hit" and after he realized what CIT wanted to hear, he does say "upon impact." That's the best it gets. He saw 175 crash on TV IMO. Then saw 77 approach.
is this the guy who saw this all at 9:11 and 9:12! time messes up his story; time then, time now
 
is this the guy who saw this all at 9:11 and 9:12! time messes up his story; time then, time now

Exactly. We're off topic tho... but quickly.

CNN showed 175 impacting at these times
9:06:30
9:07
9:10
etc...
NOT live at 9:03.
Threatcon would be called by DPS/PFPS when? Shortly after 9:03? 9:05?
Roberts hears of this on the phone and hangs up exactly as the plane hits the building. 9:10 replay?
He runs outside. 9:11 or 9:12. Time passes that he forgets, how strange, to truncate time when tying together two plane strikes on a traumatic morning! Strange but quite possible. Flight 77 approaches at 9:38. He fails to describe impact clearly. People think second plane, maybe C-130, maybe flyover. Everyone gets confused, CIT drools...
 
First, it's a bit late now, but apologies for multiple left/right mix-ups earlier in the thread. How I can be so dyslexic on an issue based on clearing up n/s-l/r confusion, I dunno.

I'm still not quite done with this thread. I mean to examine a few more witnesses, mostly to go on the record on CIT's entire touted list of 13 NoC witnesses, and cover the newly seen NORAD animation. But first I'll just present this qualification to Exhibit G (ANC witnesses). It's exonerating somewhat in their favor.

I was looking at the case of George Aman (one of the NoC 13, at the ANC, but not one of the four in exhibit G) and it occurred to me what a long view there was from the ANC maintenance area and what a role distance would play in perception of the plane. Below is a montage in 2 parts, based on CIT's camera scanning the whole scene. I used the Navy Annex, Citgo, first pole damage, and impact point to trace the plane at its different apparent sizes coming from far/small to near/large, and back again, all while on the essentially straight official path.
left side
right side

It seems quite likely to see this as the plane approaching you from the south and thn passing back south again, an overall curving right turn, with the apex pointing right at the viewer. That's what all four drew.

This can't explain a memory of a right wing bank, as described by Stafford, except in making it a deduction based on the perceived turn. I'm not so sure all of them should have succumbed to the illusion instead of realizing it was about straight, or saw the left wing banked low, and reasoned it out. I'm still suspicious of these guys and how perfectly they came to CIT's rescue, but more than before I have to consider it might be all - or mostly - honest mistake after all.
 
I'm starting a new thread shortly that'll flush CIT's star witnesses's testimony right down the toilet.
 
Right on. Which star witness? Lagasse is what I think as star of the stars. He's a real pro, the only one they trust with the revelation - uh, dude, your story totally conflicts with the official story. No it doesn't, he snaps. It went north AND impacted, end of story. They don't ask the others. They know he's a pro at this. He's a special case because of this - he actually showed where the light poles were knocked down (wrong spot!) because they confronted him with the truth of where the downed poles were. It DID NOT cause him to say really? Well maybe I'm wrong. Because he's a pro.

I don't mean necc. a professional disinfo guy, just fully dedicated for whatever reason for promoting a wrong notion. He knows it's wrong and keeps going.
 
Exactly! Lagasse put the light poles and cab in the wrong spot! They tried to prove him right and ended up proving him wrong. And they still don't know it. Wow. Great "researchers".
 
Nice graphics. I think http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/FrustratingFraud/ANC_Witnesses_all.jpg and http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/FrustratingFraud/ANC_panoramic_full_res_right.jpg show quite well what I tried to describe in my thread a few months ago about trauma and memory. A well-known phenomenon in the formation of memories of traumatic events is that the threatening object is perceived as being much closer to the observer due to a telescoping or narrowing of the visual field. The plotted lines of the ANC witnesses essentially have the plane head straight towards them -- that's how they experienced the event, they saw this threatening plane streak over 500 mph and the normal thought would have been, "Oh my god, that thing's gonna kill me!" The plane however didn't, and crashed into the Pentagon in the location whose scar was visible for months afterward. So it makes sense that they perceived the bank in the wings as effecting a change in heading that begins right at their own ANC location. And that is what the drawn lines suggest -- the plane made its closest approach at the ANC maintenance area, and then veered off to crash into the Pentagon. The paroramas showing their field of view (especially http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/FrustratingFraud/ANC_panoramic_full_res_right.jpg) make it quite clear how easy it was to perceive the plane as closer than it really was. The plane was in the air with no landmarks in front of it or behind it and the ground itself was partly obscured by the fence. With the plane first coming into view to the RIGHT of the Citgo, it is not hard to see that it could have been perceived as staying to the right and slicing just to the right above the Citgo, when it was really flying to the left of it. The telescoping of the senses during traumatic events would quite easily contribute to this impression.

Again, just a theory of mine about the ANC witnesses (which applies just as well to the Pentagon City witnesses that placed the plane much closer to THEM very near or on I-395).
 
Nice graphics. I think http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/FrustratingFraud/ANC_Witnesses_all.jpg and http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/...tratingFraud/ANC_panoramic_full_res_right.jpg show quite well what I tried to describe in my thread a few months ago about trauma and memory. A well-known phenomenon in the formation of memories of traumatic events is that the threatening object is perceived as being much closer to the observer due to a telescoping or narrowing of the visual field. The plotted lines of the ANC witnesses essentially have the plane head straight towards them -- that's how they experienced the event, they saw this threatening plane streak over 500 mph and the normal thought would have been, "Oh my god, that thing's gonna kill me!" The plane however didn't, and crashed into the Pentagon in the location whose scar was visible for months afterward. So it makes sense that they perceived the bank in the wings as effecting a change in heading that begins right at their own ANC location. And that is what the drawn lines suggest -- the plane made its closest approach at the ANC maintenance area, and then veered off to crash into the Pentagon. The paroramas showing their field of view (especially http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/...tratingFraud/ANC_panoramic_full_res_right.jpg) make it quite clear how easy it was to perceive the plane as closer than it really was. The plane was in the air with no landmarks in front of it or behind it and the ground itself was partly obscured by the fence. With the plane first coming into view to the RIGHT of the Citgo, it is not hard to see that it could have been perceived as staying to the right and slicing just to the right above the Citgo, when it was really flying to the left of it. The telescoping of the senses during traumatic events would quite easily contribute to this impression.

Again, just a theory of mine about the ANC witnesses (which applies just as well to the Pentagon City witnesses that placed the plane much closer to THEM very near or on I-395).


These are very good points regarding trauma and memory. Another, somewhat related, problem is that the drawing upon which the witnesses were asked to draw their perceived flight path already had the "FIREBALL" location marked on it which, of course, could only serve to lead the witnesses to draw the path that the interviewers wanted them to draw. A non-leading drawing would not have had the "FIREBALL" notation on it, and may very well have resulted in very different paths being drawn by the witnesses.
 
Mangoose, lashL, good pints. The ANC perspective should be expected to do just what CIT wants to hear - make people deduce a more northerly path perhaps with a right turn. Little wonder that their list of 13 includes at least 6 (Exhibit G + Aman and de La Cerda) at the ANC. Add to this any leading in the interview questions, that fireball label that all four of the drawn paths were drawn to, and we have a plausible reason for the curves these guys drew.

I'm agnostic as to whether that's really the cause or not, but anyway...

and again, this has no bearing on the three original Citgo witnesses, or the Citgo manager's odd clues, or the reasons for the animation errors. There's still enough that rational thinkers should be left scratching their heads a bit.
 
Again, just a theory of mine about the ANC witnesses (which applies just as well to the Pentagon City witnesses that placed the plane much closer to THEM very near or on I-395).

But, but, but... when TC was still posting here he accused me of lying when I kept asking about the witnesses that put the plane on, about, or crossing I-395. He claims they don't exist.
 
Phantom Wolf said:
But, but, but... when TC was still posting here he accused me of lying when I kept asking about the witnesses that put the plane on, about, or crossing I-395. He claims they don't exist.


You mean like Dawn Vignola's flight path as sketched by her husband, Dave Winslow's statement that it looked like the rear of the airplane was riding I-395, Michael Tinyk's perception that the plane flew right up I-395 to the Pentagon, Steve Patterson's comment that he thought the plane was going to land on I-395, Mitch Mitchell's placement of the plane as about 100 feet in front of him on I-395, and possibly David Ensor's wife Barbara who said that the plane was "coming down towards the side of the -- of 395. And when it came down, it just missed 395"?
 
You mean like Dawn Vignola's flight path as sketched by her husband, Dave Winslow's statement that it looked like the rear of the airplane was riding I-395, Michael Tinyk's perception that the plane flew right up I-395 to the Pentagon, Steve Patterson's comment that he thought the plane was going to land on I-395, Mitch Mitchell's placement of the plane as about 100 feet in front of him on I-395, and possibly David Ensor's wife Barbara who said that the plane was "coming down towards the side of the -- of 395. And when it came down, it just missed 395"?

Yeah, I have a feeling there are a few that had it crossing I-395 as well, including one that claimed it had to pull up to clear the I-395 overpass before dropping down into the Pentagon.
 
You know, I just started a thread about 77's eyewitness testimonies. I might get my feelings hurt if no one posts :mad:
 
Bleah, how can someone that claims to be unloved get their feelings hurt when no one loves them enough to post in their thread, hmmm? ;)
 
You know, I just started a thread about 77's eyewitness testimonies. I might get my feelings hurt if no one posts :mad:
Ha, done and done, but don't expect much more. It's quite boring to a lot of people, and I'm just getting tired of it myself. No amount of words will affect anything here - logic and language have no power in this shadow realm... Besides, it might just get merged here. It's already sucked in a thread of greater mass, clearing an orbit to become a planetoid-level thread. Don't feel bad if so.

You mean like Dawn Vignola's flight path as sketched by her husband, Dave Winslow's statement that it looked like the rear of the airplane was riding I-395, Michael Tinyk's perception that the plane flew right up I-395 to the Pentagon, Steve Patterson's comment that he thought the plane was going to land on I-395, Mitch Mitchell's placement of the plane as about 100 feet in front of him on I-395, and possibly David Ensor's wife Barbara who said that the plane was "coming down towards the side of the -- of 395. And when it came down, it just missed 395"?

Great list, if I wasn't so sporadically inspired, i'd be updating my list of SoC witnesses again. And PW too, your posts on the 395 witnesses were useful. Also add Mrs. Hubbard, who CIT have supporting a nearly north path that she wouldn't be able to see. What she describes is a plane passing with some east direction, that she thought had hit the highway.

And as far as thinking it was right over me, coming towards me, etc., that's the most basic thing I first noticed when looking at accounts, found it based on essential ego-centric survival instincts, and dubbed it ROME (right over me effect). and of course CIT ignores it to turn this into a lever to use selectively to accept non-ROME-corrected accts that put the plane where they want, and to dismiss those they dislike by reading the ROME as literal fact and calling it a lie.
 
Ha, done and done, but don't expect much more. It's quite boring to a lot of people, and I'm just getting tired of it myself. No amount of words will affect anything here - logic and language have no power in this shadow realm... Besides, it might just get merged here. It's already sucked in a thread of greater mass, clearing an orbit to become a planetoid-level thread. Don't feel bad if so.



Great list, if I wasn't so sporadically inspired, i'd be updating my list of SoC witnesses again. And PW too, your posts on the 395 witnesses were useful. Also add Mrs. Hubbard, who CIT have supporting a nearly north path that she wouldn't be able to see. What she describes is a plane passing with some east direction, that she thought had hit the highway.

And as far as thinking it was right over me, coming towards me, etc., that's the most basic thing I first noticed when looking at accounts, found it based on essential ego-centric survival instincts, and dubbed it ROME (right over me effect). and of course CIT ignores it to turn this into a lever to use selectively to accept non-ROME-corrected accts that put the plane where they want, and to dismiss those they dislike by reading the ROME as literal fact and calling it a lie.

LOL. I figured it might be redundant, and it does get boring. But... I'm trying to get a few CIT YouTube spammers over here to join in. So far they've refused. Anyhoo, I've learned more in one month in the JREF than over two years dealing with the spammers and trollers of YouTube.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom