Merged Too Much NoC Evidence?

I just find it interesting that the vast majority of your posts are on one particular topic, CIT and NoC, and that most of your posting occurs almost 2 years after your join date.
Happens from time to time, sometimes it is for completely benign reasons, sometimes not.

As for Lord Mayor's hat, well I am more interested in whether his shoes fit or not.

TAM;)
 
So, let's take that one a little further, because these policemen didn't instantaneously lose their observational abilities between the time the plane flew over and the time it hit the Pentagon. Your argument is that the policemen's observations of the flight path are to be given strong weight because they were trained observers, therefore the plane flew north of the Citgo, therefore the plane could not have hit the Pentagon, therefore the policemen's observations of the impact are to be discounted because they are incompatible with the policemen's observations of the flight path. Don't you have even the slightest difficulty accepting the validity of that argument?

Dave

No, you are wrong about my argument, Dave. My argument is that they saw the plane fly North of Citgo. That's all. Everything else you surmise about my argument is supposition.
 
I just find it interesting that the vast majority of your posts are on one particular topic, CIT and NoC, and that most of your posting occurs almost 2 years after your join date.
Happens from time to time, sometimes it is for completely benign reasons, sometimes not.

As for Lord Mayor's hat, well I am more interested in whether his shoes fit or not.

TAM;)

I wonder what you think non-benign reasons could be?
 
No, you are wrong about my argument, Dave. My argument is that they saw the plane fly North of Citgo. That's all. Everything else you surmise about my argument is supposition.

Then who cares?

If you want to extend the argument further, then you might have something to say. But if all you're claiming, honestly, is that the flight path of AA77 was not what it's thought to be, then all you're trying to do is quibble over an irrelevance.

Now, maybe you'll go on to point out that the impact damage was inconsistent with NoC. But that's more than you claim as your argument, and you knew that all along, so the bolded statement is a lie.

So you're either quibbling over trivia, or lying. Which one?

Dave
 
Then who cares?

If you want to extend the argument further, then you might have something to say. But if all you're claiming, honestly, is that the flight path of AA77 was not what it's thought to be, then all you're trying to do is quibble over an irrelevance.

Now, maybe you'll go on to point out that the impact damage was inconsistent with NoC. But that's more than you claim as your argument, and you knew that all along, so the bolded statement is a lie.

So you're either quibbling over trivia, or lying. Which one?

Dave

I would hardly call the wrong flight path an irrelevance or trivia. But then maybe it might be to you.

I'll agree that the impact damage appears to be inconsistent with NOC. I only want to know why. And it wasn't a lie, but then I've noticed in the past that anybody who disagrees with your point of view is dissed.
 
I would hardly call the wrong flight path an irrelevance or trivia. But then maybe it might be to you.

Yes, I would call it an irrelevance or trivia. Would the effect on global politics of the 9/11 attacks be any different if Hani Hanjour had approached the Pentagon from a slightly different angle? I can see no rational line of argument that would suggest anything of the sort.

I'll agree that the impact damage appears to be inconsistent with NOC. I only want to know why. And it wasn't a lie, but then I've noticed in the past that anybody who disagrees with your point of view is dissed.

Can I remind you that the function of this forum is to discuss alternative interpretations of the events surrounding the 9/11 attacks? If you don't feel that the possibility of a NoC flight path may lead to alternative explanations of the 9/11 attacks, then you're posting on the wrong forum, and your entire line of argument is an irrelevance. If you do feel that the possibility of a NoC flight path may lead to alternative explanations of the 9/11 attacks, then you were lying when you denied that there was anything more to your argument than that the policemen claimed to have seen the plane fly north of the Citgo.

It's quite simple; you've claimed not to be discussing a conspiracy theory, on a forum for discussing conspiracy theories. Either you're lying, or your comments are irrelevant. The only other possibility would be that you're unaware that your statement is false, but since it concerns your own motivations I'm not prepared to consider that possibility yet.

Dave
 
Yes, I would call it an irrelevance or trivia. Would the effect on global politics of the 9/11 attacks be any different if Hani Hanjour had approached the Pentagon from a slightly different angle? I can see no rational line of argument that would suggest anything of the sort.



Can I remind you that the function of this forum is to discuss alternative interpretations of the events surrounding the 9/11 attacks? If you don't feel that the possibility of a NoC flight path may lead to alternative explanations of the 9/11 attacks, then you're posting on the wrong forum, and your entire line of argument is an irrelevance. If you do feel that the possibility of a NoC flight path may lead to alternative explanations of the 9/11 attacks, then you were lying when you denied that there was anything more to your argument than that the policemen claimed to have seen the plane fly north of the Citgo.

It's quite simple; you've claimed not to be discussing a conspiracy theory, on a forum for discussing conspiracy theories. Either you're lying, or your comments are irrelevant. The only other possibility would be that you're unaware that your statement is false, but since it concerns your own motivations I'm not prepared to consider that possibility yet.

Dave

Quite possibly it wouldn't have altered global politics, if he approached from a slightly different angle of approach,but it would certainly throw up an awful lot of anomolies, which would require answering.

Of course we are discussing a conspiracy theory, (by the way, thanks for reminding me:rolleyes:). Where did I claim I wasn't? And possibly my comments are irrelevant, but that still doesn't answer the conundrum about the statements of the two police officers. Which of my statements do you think are false?
 
Have I got this staight ? The two cops say that they saw the plane fly the Northerly route. They further claim that they saw AA77 strike the Pentagon.

Connecting those two dots means that AA77 could not have knocked over the lightpoles.

So if the lightploes are absolutely essential then the cops are lying or the cops really believe what they are saying despite the lightpole problem.
 
Last edited:
I wonder what you think non-benign reasons could be?

non-benign reason would be if you were a sock puppet who in 2007 set up the account, posted a few times, then left the account, only to return to it 2 years later, when his or her other accounts were banned.

benign reason would be that you simply posted a couple of times, went from the JREF altogether, then 2 years later just decided to post here again.

I have seen both scenarios occur, so for now I am reserving judgement.

TAM:)
 
Originally Posted by UNLoVedRebel
Nice bump. Maybe fourbrick will chime in and explain the infamous flyover. I smell a stundie brewing.
Sorry to disappoint, Unloved, but if the Policemen (who are normally trained to observe accurately) are correct then there is a problem with the SOC flight path. Would you not agree? Where did I say there was a flyover?

If it flew north and all the damage was consistent with a south path, it couldn't hit anything. If it didn't we have two problems - the plane-caused damage has to be caused otherwise, and the damage-destroyed plane istead needs to be got rid of another way. As I see it, that's a flyover or a flyinder, or a major, impossible veer away no one reported. So which of the three would you support, if any?

Originally Posted by UNLoVedRebel
Exactly! Lagasse put the light poles and cab in the wrong spot! They tried to prove him right and ended up proving him wrong. And they still don't know it. Wow. Great "researchers".
Where exactly did Lagasse place them, then, seeing as he said didn't see them hit?
The answers are in here
Also:
Eastman:
2. You did not say whether you saw the poles being struck down. Am I right
in assuming that you did? Did you see how high on any of the poles contact was made?

3. Can you recall seeing what part of the plane struck any of the poles?

Lagasse:
Question #2.... near the top....yes I saw the plane hit them..granted at the
speed it was traveling I cant be 100% sure of exactly where on the
poles...but I did remember a black and orange cab that was struck by one of
them

Question #3 Wings....there was composite material from the wings in the
area around the poles that had been struck..the fuse could have struck one
of the poles as well.

Later he tells CIT he didn't actually see them GET hit, but all the pole-cab damage was over where he saw the plane so in his confused (??) mind there's no discrepancy to worry about.

So what do you think? We have three clear unequivocal north side impact witnesses, the impossibility of that scenario, and a choice which part to discount: path or impact, and the conclusions to be drawn. C'mon, show us what you've been learning off somewhere the past two years. Some critical thinking.
 
Have I got this staight ? The two cops say that they saw the plane fly the Northerly route. They further claim that they saw AA77 strike the Pentagon.

Connecting those two dots means that AA77 could not have knocked over the lightpoles.

So if the lightploes are absolutely essential then the cops are lying or the cops really believe what they are saying despite the lightpole problem.

:boggled:
 
Have I got this staight ? The two cops say that they saw the plane fly the Northerly route. They further claim that they saw AA77 strike the Pentagon.

Connecting those two dots means that AA77 could not have knocked over the lightpoles.

So if the lightploes are absolutely essential then the cops are lying or the cops really believe what they are saying despite the lightpole problem.

It also couldn't cause the damage to the pentagon. That's all at the wrong angle and had to be faked. Had to fly over, under, or away. Your best bet to keep in character is to just deny that and keep saying Lagasse and Brooks are somehow correct.
 
My argument is that they saw the plane fly North of Citgo. That's all.

Which of my statements do you think are false?

See above. It's absolutely fundamental to your whole line of argument that the NoC path is inconsistent with some other piece of evidence, otherwise it wouldn't be worth mentioning on this forum. You're playing the classic disingenuity card, the I-just-wanted-to-ask-about-this-one-anomaly card, that's the usual preparation for the no-claimer.

We know that Lagasse and Brooks gave their statements to CIT years after the events. I seem to remember that security camera film shows Lagasse on the opposite side of the Citgo station to the side he remembers being on, facing in the opposite direction to the direction he remembers facing in. So the question is: if he could be mistaken about where he was standing, and about which way he was facing, and it's fundamental to CIT's argument that he could have been mistaken about seeing the plane hit the Pentagon, why is it so absolutely rock-hard certain that the one thing he must remember correctly is which side the plane passed him on?

And if you don't have a cast-iron answer to that question, then there is, quite simply, no anomaly to investigate.

Dave
 
... My argument is that they saw the plane fly North of Citgo. ...
That statement has been wrong for 8 years. Flight 77 flew the path where it hit lamp posts south of the CITGO. The physical evidence beats testimony given to idiots years, many years after they testified 77 impacted the Pentagon. You have been fooled by dolts. Can you think of something worse than being fooled by dolts who can't figure out 911?
If you need some help, the final true track heading of flight 77 was 61.2 degrees. Line this track up with Google earth to the impact at the Pentagon, proves the ground track of 77 was south of the CITGO station.

The FDR recorded the track of flight 77. This final track is 61.2 degree. Take the ruler in Google earth and line it up to 61.2 degrees and the line passes over the downed lampposts and into the exact point of impact on the Pentagon. This makes your opinion a lie, a failed opinion, a moronic delusion as you insist on repeating it.

Do you need help with Google earth?
61pt2degreePentagon.jpg

I imagined CIT can't figure out north but I was wrong as they prove their ignorance by plotting the failed tracks that don't hit the lampposts witnesses saw hit by Flight 77. The white line is 61.2 degree true and matches the FDR and the path of Flight 77 on 911. If you don't know where the CITGO station is in this photo you lack of knowledge is showing.

Google earth proves you wrong; see the 61.2 degrees in the box. Using real evidence your argument they saw Flight 77 north of the CITGO is proved wrong. Need help finding the FDR files?
61pt2degreePentagon2.jpg

Ironically these last seconds of data from the FDR were provided by truthers! This is classic, truthers provided a full decode of the FDR which proves them wrong. This is standard procedure for truthers; they present data that proves their moronic conclusions wrong. The term "NAVtrackangletrue" is the true track of Flight 77, the yellow column.

One problem CIT has, they are teamed up with Balsamo of p4t which is a group of pilots who can't figure out flying or 911. Balsamo has no clue when a jet is going over 460 knots, the slight bank angles 77 was making prior to impact would not turn the aircraft but .3 degrees in the last 15 seconds of flight. Physics is not a strong suit of p4t paranoid nut case conspiracy theorist Balsamo who tries to make money selling his delusions on DVD.

I find it sad you may fail to comprehend 19 terrorists killed pilots and crew, took aircraft to kill people in NYC and the Pentagon; and the cowards you want to apologize for failed on Flight 93 when a group of people figured out 911 in minutes. What is your problem after 8 years? It takes heroes minutes to figure out 911, it has been 8 years and you seem to support delusions.

Your argument is wrong. Did you miss their original testimony in 2001?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5212391&postcount=112 You can find their original statements about 911 at this post if you really want the truth instead of your failed argument.
 
Personally I trust nothing that comes out of the Pentagon. I smell 'setup' all the way. A honeypot to create and snare conspiracy theorists.
 
Personally I trust nothing that comes out of the Pentagon. I smell 'setup' all the way. A honeypot to create and snare conspiracy theorists.

If you don't trust what comes out of the Pentagon Bill, then why the interest of the 84 tapes, the FDR's & Flight 77 not hitting the building?

Honeypot? Snare? NOOOOOWAY!

You Truthers pretty much done that yourselves without our help.

Thanks!
 
Personally I trust nothing that comes out of the Pentagon. I smell 'setup' all the way. A honeypot to create and snare conspiracy theorists.

Bill - honeypot rather than flyover/under/away is about the first sane choice I've seen you profess to. I'm not saying it is one, but if something's to be made of this crap, this is the way to go. Defense Protective Services folks are writing this storyline, and the CIT are so in love with it they're running around looking for DoD operatives among the ranks of cab drivers and priests and whoever else happened to be nearby and paying attention to what ACTUALLY happened, which I'm sure you still have many *questions* about.

Cheers
 
Bill - honeypot rather than flyover/under/away is about the first sane choice I've seen you profess to. I'm not saying it is one, but if something's to be made of this crap, this is the way to go. Defense Protective Services folks are writing this storyline, and the CIT are so in love with it they're running around looking for DoD operatives among the ranks of cab drivers and priests and whoever else happened to be nearby and paying attention to what ACTUALLY happened, which I'm sure you still have many *questions* about.

Cheers

This witness thing steenks like feesh to me. For the rest CIT seem to have a pretty well impregnable case.
 
non-benign reason would be if you were a sock puppet who in 2007 set up the account, posted a few times, then left the account, only to return to it 2 years later, when his or her other accounts were banned.

benign reason would be that you simply posted a couple of times, went from the JREF altogether, then 2 years later just decided to post here again.

I have seen both scenarios occur, so for now I am reserving judgement.

TAM:)

Thanks for reserving judgement, That makes me feel so much better.:rolleyes:
Do you also give absolutions in your spare time, by any chance?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom