Merged Too Much NoC Evidence?

Anyhoo, I've learned more in one month in the JREF than over two years dealing with the spammers and trollers of YouTube.

Uhhh, yeah. That'll happen.
:)
You could learn more in one hour of trying to flush your head down the toilet.

Youtube spammers... it does bug me how many people out there are claiming to be so dumb, and in fact it's unsettling, but it seems little can be done. AFAIK they're all just lines of code written to annoy and waste time.
 
Caustic Logic said:
that's the most basic thing I first noticed when looking at accounts, found it based on essential ego-centric survival instincts, and dubbed it ROME (right over me effect).


EXACTLY! That's exactly what I'm talking about.

BTW, a thought just occurred to me about Steve Patterson. Like Dawn Vignola and Dave Winslow (who both seemed to have placed to plane closer to I-395 than it really was), Patterson viewed the plane from Pentagon City. Patterson was also the witness that famously claimed that it was a small plane that hit the Pentagon, whose quote was used incessantly by troofers in the early days of the TM. Maybe this is the explanation. If Patterson thought the plane was going to land on I-395, then he thought it was closer to him than it really was whereas the smaller apparent size of the plane was due to its greater distance away. Makes perfect sense.

I should check to see if there is a record of which building Patterson was in. I know that Winslow was in The James, the River House that was closest to I-395. Winslow said that he saw the tail riding on I-395 and he called in his witness report just minutes after the attack. His witness account was the source of the first report on the wire that a plane crashed into the Pentagon.
 
Okay, I found Steve Patterson's residential address again....I don't want to post it in case it would violate his privacy, so I will just say that Patterson's apartment was definitely in the Potomac at River House (the middle one of the three), on the 14th floor. And this is his account in the Washington Post (his spouse was a writer for the Post, which was how Patterson came to be interviewed):

Steve Patterson said:
The plane was about 150 yards away, approaching from the west about 20 feet off the ground, Patterson said. He said the plane, which sounded like the high-pitched squeal of a fighter jet, flew over Arlington cemetary so low that he thought it was going to land on I-395.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/metro/daily/sep01/attack.html


Actually 150 yards would have put the plane within Pentagon City between The James and The Potomac, so he is clearly underestimating even the distance to I-395, but he is definitely putting the plane very close to him, such that it appeared to him like the plane was going to land on I-395.
 
Last edited:
about 150 yards away

That would certainly explain his saying it was a small plane. A plane at 300 yards would be twice the real size of one at 150 yards, but they'd have the same apparent size to an obseverer. By placing the plane a lot closer, it has to become smaller too, a similar issue that some of TC's witnesses in Shanksville have.

Interestingly UFO witnesses often find themselves suffering from the opposite effect. They put close by objects further away and thus over estimate their size.
 
Last edited:
Phantom Wolf: It is worth noting that had the plane been centered over I-395, it would have been about 480 yards away at its closest approach to The Potomac at River House, and the actual position of the plane along the official path would have been about 635 yards away. The distance of 150 yards was about a fourth of that.
 
Phantom Wolf: It is worth noting that had the plane been centered over I-395, it would have been about 480 yards away at its closest approach to The Potomac at River House, and the actual position of the plane along the official path would have been about 635 yards away. The distance of 150 yards was about a fourth of that.

Using those distances, a 757 at 635 yards would have the same apparent size as a 11m long, 4m high jet at 150 yards. A Lear Jet is 14m by 3.75m, so about the same size as what Patterson thought he saw. It actually fits very well and would certainly explain his thinking it was a small jet.
 
Good thinking on patterson as well. That had occurred to me as well, and given his ironed out location, it's even more clear.

Also, I hear someone tried to find him but he disappeared, and was a graphic artist. Perhaps he was so embarrassed by his lack of graphical artistry 3-D perception that he just relocated and changed his name. :p
 
Good thinking on patterson as well. That had occurred to me as well, and given his ironed out location, it's even more clear.

Also, I hear someone tried to find him but he disappeared, and was a graphic artist. Perhaps he was so embarrassed by his lack of graphical artistry 3-D perception that he just relocated and changed his name. :p

I don't know, I know someone that is proud of doing Photo analysis for the JFK Congressional Hearings, claims to have studied Apollo for 30 years, claims to have been a professional photographer for longer, and still can't identify which side of the LM he's looking at in a photo. Now that should be embarassing, but he hasn't disappeared.
 
Nice bump. Maybe fourbrick will chime in and explain the infamous flyover. I smell a stundie brewing.
 
Nice bump. Maybe fourbrick will chime in and explain the infamous flyover. I smell a stundie brewing.

This can forever be the thread for people who can't just dismiss the patterns here - multiple people at one gas station clearly, consistently describe the plane as passing north. How can that just be error? How can TWO semi-official animations show the same thing?

Well this thread does not just dismiss either the abundance of north path evidence, nor the obvious conclusion from the evidence that the plane DID NOT actually fly north, and actually hit the building, as Lagasse, says, "where it meets the ground."

There's too much NoC evidence to just wave away as random errors, but no mater how much it can't trump physical reality. Heck, this "unanimous north path testimony" from all genuine non-suspect witnesses can't even stand up to the preponderance of eyewitness descriptions of the same south path attested to by the rest of the 3-D world.

Here's an exercise for anyone who is considering CIT's breakdown of the witness field as at all reliable:
Compare the members of this list of the best south path witnesses
with this list of the most evil, lying, suspect plant witnesses.
Why the remarkable overlap? You can guess CIT's justification, but if you think for just a minute you could easily see other possiblities.
 
There's too much NoC evidence to just wave away as random errors, but no mater how much it can't trump physical reality. Heck, this "unanimous north path testimony" from all genuine non-suspect witnesses can't even stand up to the preponderance of eyewitness descriptions of the same south path attested to by the rest of the 3-D world.
That won't stop Sybil from claiming otherwise on some crackpot alternative medium. (See new thread for details.)

edit: there's a link to your video in there. Thanks for your hard work, and John Farmer's of course (may he rest in peace).
 
Last edited:
Where are those statements, Dom? Are you going to make the same excuses Craig and Aldo did, that the FBI "confiscated" all the eyewitness reports from everyone in cars on the freeways, on the bridges, in their offices, in their homes, on the other side of the Pentagon?

LOL do you have a source for them saying that? I want to build up a collection of stupid crazy stuff truthers say
 
Nice bump. Maybe fourbrick will chime in and explain the infamous flyover. I smell a stundie brewing.

Sorry to disappoint, Unloved, but if the Policemen (who are normally trained to observe accurately) are correct then there is a problem with the SOC flight path. Would you not agree? Where did I say there was a flyover?

Exactly! Lagasse put the light poles and cab in the wrong spot! They tried to prove him right and ended up proving him wrong. And they still don't know it. Wow. Great "researchers".

Where exactly did Lagasse place them, then, seeing as he said didn't see them hit?


That would certainly explain his saying it was a small plane. A plane at 300 yards would be twice the real size of one at 150 yards, but they'd have the same apparent size to an obseverer. By placing the plane a lot closer, it has to become smaller too, a similar issue that some of TC's witnesses in Shanksville have.

He didn't say he saw
a small plane. He said it sounded like "the squeal of a fighter jet" All the above about he was mistaken about the size because he was further away is just a load of guff.
 
Last edited:
Sorry to disappoint, Unloved, but if the Policemen (who are normally trained to observe accurately) are correct then there is a problem with the SOC flight path. Would you not agree?

So, let's take that one a little further, because these policemen didn't instantaneously lose their observational abilities between the time the plane flew over and the time it hit the Pentagon. Your argument is that the policemen's observations of the flight path are to be given strong weight because they were trained observers, therefore the plane flew north of the Citgo, therefore the plane could not have hit the Pentagon, therefore the policemen's observations of the impact are to be discounted because they are incompatible with the policemen's observations of the flight path. Don't you have even the slightest difficulty accepting the validity of that argument?

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom