Merged Too Much NoC Evidence?

Anything that debunks flyover, debunks NoC

CIT proponents ignore all debunking of Flyover, passing it off as "we don't argue for flyover, we argue for NoC".

However, this handwave is defeated by Craig Ranke's own logic. In the PentaCon video, he explains how it is impossible for the plane to have both hit the Pentagon AND flown north of the Citgo. This is given all available evidence and witness testimony. The entire CIT case is contingent upon this. If CIT abandons the argument that the plane hitting the Pentagon and NoC flight path are mutually exclusive events, their entire case falls. It is what their entire case is based on; without it, I can just say, okay, the plane flew north of the Citgo, but it was still Flight 77 and it was still flown by Islamic radicals, and it still hit the Pentagon. The official story is no longer contradicted. CIT MUST accept that P(Plane hitting the Pentagon | Plane flying north of the Citgo) = 0, or else they don't have anything on the "official story".

Now if we accept that these are mutually exclusive events, I will now show that flyover is the only possibility for NoC. CIT's own witnesses all agree on and corroborate one fact: that the plane hit the Pentagon. CIT's handwave is that the fireball must have covered the plane so that everyone would be fooled into thinking that it crashed. This REQUIRES a Flyover, because there is no other option. What else could have happened? Did the plane tunnel under the Pentagon? Did the plane phase out of physical timespace and go through the Pentagon? Did the plane suddenly lose all forward momentum and go around the Pentagon? There is simply no other logical possibility. If the plane flew on the NoC flight path, then it MUST have flown over the Pentagon.

And therefore, any argument that debunks a flyover in turn debunks NoC, by the transitive property of mathematical logic.

QED.
 
Last edited:
Yet another CIT thread?

The CIT crap has been refuted by aeronautical physics, 84th RADES data, DCA Radar data, ADW Radar data, Tribby Video, Looney Photographs, ATC transcripts/recordings, FDR, and common sense. How many more ways are needed before it is a bad memory?

CIT was a failed theory many months ago. It exists only on the life support of pure loons and not deserving of attention not initiated by it's supporters.
 
CIT proponents ignore all debunking of Flyover, passing it off as "we don't argue for flyover, we argue for NoC".

They don't explicitly argue for a flyover because they know full well they have no evidence for a flyover. They will never admit that the NoC has implications they can't possibly deal with.

That's why it's so easy to corner the likes of Turbofan, radical logic, and TCxxx. They have no way out of the mess of their own creation.
 
I'm trying to recall what the idea was behind the whole NoC thing. They wanted to show that flight 77 didn't crash into the Pentagon, so they came up with this steaming turd of a theory. But why didn't they just speculate that the airliner everyone saw did a flyover, without compounding their troubles by also proposing a NoC path? The NoC/flyover idea is WAY less plausible than the flyover by itself (which is still way low on plausibility anyway).

What was the motive for NoC in the first place? Was it just because Craig found those three people who seemed to recall it on the north side? (I don't count Paik as supporting their NoC idea with his statements.)
 
What was the motive for NoC in the first place? Was it just because Craig found those three people who seemed to recall it on the north side? (I don't count Paik as supporting their NoC idea with his statements.)

Being completely unable to muster any evidence that would directly support the "flyover" claim, they instead resort to trying desperately to find something- anything- that would refute any aspect of what twoofers vilify as the "official story", in the mistaken belief that this would destroy said "story" entirely and leave the CT of their choice, whatever it might be, as the victor by default.

Somehow they seem to forget that the entire point of claiming that AA77 didn't hit the Pentagon was exactly the same- to find some sort of "anomaly" to gloat over.
 
I don't know if this is the proper place for it, but I think the north of Citgo testimonies have a totally rational explanation. Humans are (unlike e.g. rabbits) not well built for observing things that pass overhead. Just stand up and try to follow an imaginary object coming from behind and passing quickly over your head, and you'll see what I mean.

However, I have been a bit around planes, and there is one thing that is sometimes very noticeable with low-flying planes: Their ground-shadow. Unlike overhead objects, humans are very capable of spotting and following things moving on the ground *), and the huge, fast-moving shadow of a low-flying plane is a real eye catcher.

On the morning of sept 11 2001, the weather was clear and the sun was in the southeast. The people at the Citgo, unprepared for a low overfly, may not actually have seen the plane till it was past them, but they may well have seen its shadow, following a couple of hundred yards northwest of the plane's position, and when reconstructing the event in their minds have concluded that it marked the actual path of the plane.

Hans

*) This is a logical effect of evolution for a creature that has relatively little to fear from overhead enemies but must be able to spot both predators and prey moving on the ground.
 
I don't know if this is the proper place for it, but I think the north of Citgo testimonies have a totally rational explanation.

What I think is more likely is that people saw the plane low to the ground and assumed it was closer to them than it was. (As has been pointed out...the further north they were, the further north of the citgo they reported it) That, combined with the fact that the impact point on the pentagon was northeast of the citgo station...it would be pretty easy to mistake the exact direction that the plane came from. If you assumed that it went straight in, the path would definitely be north of the citgo station. Anyone who's studied eyewitness testimony knows that the mind has a remarkable ability to "fill in the gaps".

DNA evidence isn't called into question when it's contradicted by eyewitnesses.....likewise in this case, the physical evidence overwhelmingly shows that a few people weren't able to pinpoint the location of a 757 as it sped by them at >100mph.

Using CIT's logic, the OP is right...anything that disproves the flyover also disproves NOC...however they seem to think that their witnesses cannot be wrong since they've been "independently scientifically corroborated"...whatever that means.
 
CIT proponents ignore all debunking of Flyover, passing it off as "we don't argue for flyover, we argue for NoC".

However, this handwave is defeated by Craig Ranke's own logic. In the PentaCon video, he explains how it is impossible for the plane to have both hit the Pentagon AND flown north of the Citgo. This is given all available evidence and witness testimony. The entire CIT case is contingent upon this. If CIT abandons the argument that the plane hitting the Pentagon and NoC flight path are mutually exclusive events, their entire case falls. It is what their entire case is based on; without it, I can just say, okay, the plane flew north of the Citgo, but it was still Flight 77 and it was still flown by Islamic radicals, and it still hit the Pentagon. The official story is no longer contradicted. CIT MUST accept that P(Plane hitting the Pentagon | Plane flying north of the Citgo) = 0, or else they don't have anything on the "official story".

wrong.

noc = what knocked down the light poles, shredded a tree top, and tore through that generator coming low and level across the lawn.

every eyewitness puts the plane noc.



Now if we accept that these are mutually exclusive events, I will now show that flyover is the only possibility for NoC. CIT's own witnesses all agree on and corroborate one fact: that the plane hit the Pentagon.


wrong. quite a few did not watch because being honest and not embellishing some superman version they actually ran in fear because a large plane was coming right at them.


CIT's handwave is that the fireball must have covered the plane so that everyone would be fooled into thinking that it crashed. This REQUIRES a Flyover, because there is no other option. What else could have happened? Did the plane tunnel under the Pentagon? Did the plane phase out of physical timespace and go through the Pentagon? Did the plane suddenly lose all forward momentum and go around the Pentagon? There is simply no other logical possibility. If the plane flew on the NoC flight path, then it MUST have flown over the Pentagon.

and as officer roosevelt roberts saw going away over the south parking lot the plane did fly over......

And therefore, any argument that debunks a flyover in turn debunks NoC, by the transitive property of mathematical logic.

QED.

wrong. noc cannot be debunked with look the fuselage...ummm...nose cone... i mean landing gear blew through the c-ring wall so therefor noc is debunked.

the source for the plane impacting is the source for saddam has ties to al qaeda and has weapons of mass destruction and the next warning could be a mushroom cloud if we don't act now as well as many other proven lies like jessica lynch and pat tillman versus honest everyday average americans.

i know who i believe.
 
every eyewitness puts the plane noc.

That's cool. Say Dom, now that you are here touting the NOC, I have a request:

"give us the flight path and calculations for the CIT/PFT path: you know, over the Annex, bank north of citgo, dip below the level of the trees, arrest the descent and then pull up and over the impact site."

You believe it so you must have proven to yourself that a plane can do what Craig and Aldo said it did.

Thanks in advance. Don't worry if the calculations are above our heads, we'll muddle through somehow.

I look forward to it!
 
Last edited:
What really bugs me about CIT is they use the same shoddy investigation methods which have landed so many innocent people in jail. This man here was picked out of a photo line up and found guilty. He was exonerated by DNA evidence. There are countless cases like this. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable. That's why investigators use the PHYSICAL EVIDENCE to determine what happened, and not use contradicting eyewitness testimony as "total proof".

msnbc.msn.com/id/10995872/

Ironic points... CIT will tell you the physical evidence actually supports them. Damage is inconsistent! In showing this they used photos that led me to several new proofs that a B757 did in fact hit (foundation damage, right wing damage issues, etc...) They accept that DNA may be there, but planted, since physical evidence is trumped by eyewitnesses supported by... misread phys evidence. Same for plane parts, planted. Radar and FDR video, must all be faked since it matches the impact story. Everyone who could see what the plane did at the very end, even their own witnesses, said it polwed inside. Thet were fooled or lying, since eyewitness testimony and phys evidence trumps the same. Antrhing trumps anything, so long as it supports a concoted theory they hold.

That's all been established. They are even more wrong than their research strategies are. The only reason this has ever had any traction is CIT's self-assured bluster, the naivity/gullibility of their fans, and of course the fact that more witnesses than should have said clearly the plane was NoC. And that we keep getting cartoons showing just that, which keeps the image alive in some right-brain way. Scan the exhibits thus far. Error and chance? Perhaps. I suspect something more.
 
Exhibit G: The ANC Witnesses

CIT started floundering after their first batch of Citgo witnesses, relying more strongly on pure distortion to wrangle more supporting evidence. I know I've said somewhere how their only hope was another batch of overly-compliant eyewitnesses, but I couldn't find a good quote from before the arrival of their salvation. It would make this post more punchy, but anyway, they got just what I thought they needed. This batch were of workers at the Arlington National Cemetery, mostly catalogued also by the Center for Military History. If I'm not mistaken CIT ally and Arlington resident "22205" (aka Fedzcametogetme, etc.) actually conducted the four interviews on June 6 this year. Names: Donald Carter, Darrell Stafford, William Middelton sr, Darius Prather.

These formed the core of CIT's new video The North Path Flyover, which I think I'll probably never watch. Some details are available here, all I need to decide these guys collectively get a solid placement on this list of too much NoC evidence. So I have no additional clues from language, gestures, etc., but this is all I need to see: their drawn flight paths:
http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/FrustratingFraud/ancpathcomposite.jpg
All I need to ask is what are the odds? I understand perspective issues play in here like they do not with the citgo witnesses - both paths are south of the witnesses, and it's entirely natural to misjudge the distance, especially in fudging it close to oneself. But they all fudged it to the same degree, and all but Middleton indicate app. the same sharp right bank that CIT has proposed, as opposed to the slight left bank that actually happened. Also unlike the original PentaCon witnesses, these guys have another issue hanging over them - did they see the PentaCon? They're more equipped to simply tell CIT what they want without any external prodding...
ANC_Witnesses_all.jpg
 
Last edited:
That's cool. Say Dom, now that you are here touting the NOC, I have a request:

"give us the flight path and calculations for the CIT/PFT path: you know, over the Annex, bank north of citgo, dip below the level of the trees, arrest the descent and then pull up and over the impact site."

You believe it so you must have proven to yourself that a plane can do what Craig and Aldo said it did.

Thanks in advance. Don't worry if the calculations are above our heads, we'll muddle through somehow.

I look forward to it!

watch
 
HA! Nice job, Dom. Just admit you don't have the calculations. Oh wait...you just did.
 
Last edited:
Paik said the plane was noc?

Morrin said the plane was noc?


quit being dishonest jason you know paik puts the plane headed towards the navy annex and morin puts it directly above it and that can only occur in a noc flight path.
 
HA! Nice job, Dom. Just admit you don't have the calculations. Oh wait...you just did.

video leaves you speechless?

time to change the subject??

you asked for proof that a noc flight path is possible and then when given that proof from authorities you accept all your other known truths from you demand i prove them right........

i don't have to.

the cit eyewitnesses corroborate it.

its your job to duh-bunk it duh-bunker. duh!
 

Uh, OK. So anyway, can you address my request. It is:

"give us the flight path and calculations for the CIT/PFT path: you know, over the Annex, bank north of citgo, dip below the level of the trees, arrest the descent and then pull up and over the impact site."

I bolded the part that your cartoon did not address.

Your video showed the plane HITTING the PENTAGON.

So you agree the plane hit the Pentagon?

C'mon Dom, I watched your cartoon. Please come up with the math.

PLEASE!
 
video leaves you speechless?

time to change the subject??

you asked for proof that a noc flight path is possible and then when given that proof from authorities you accept all your other known truths from you demand i prove them right........

i don't have to.

the cit eyewitnesses corroborate it.

its your job to duh-bunk it duh-bunker. duh!
The animation shows 77 hitting the Pentagon. ... you debunked yourself!

Zero witnesses saw 77 fly over the Pentagon. Your own witnesses saw 77 hit the Pentagon. Failed investigation techniques, doomed your fly over lie.

You use an animation, to support your Pentagon impact? Are you paying attention? Now 77 hit the Pentagon. Your finally got something right!

You got us now!
The video you defend debunks your fly over.
TC defends an animation, it takes 83 degrees of bank and 8.2 Gs! Wing fall off, like all of CIT non-paths. Impossible. Is this another example of CIT/p4t failed physics?


8.2 Gs, 83 degrees of bank! Farmer knew you guys would have a cow, make up moronic ideas, all from this bone/trap/bait he posted. You fell for it; Farmer is amused.
it is funny
 
Last edited:
video leaves you speechless?

time to change the subject??

you asked for proof that a noc flight path is possible and then when given that proof from authorities you accept all your other known truths from you demand i prove them right........

i don't have to.

the cit eyewitnesses corroborate it.

its your job to duh-bunk it duh-bunker. duh!

No...your ignorance leaves me speechless. You changed the subject, not me. We asked for calculations...many, many times. You haven't provided those calculations. Can you provide those calculations, Dom? Yes or no?
 
So TC, when are you going to be sending all of you evidence to KSM's lawyer?

His name is Prescott L. Prince and his business information is publically availible on the net, but I'll list it here for you so you don't have to figure out Google.

Prescott L. Prince
5511 Staples Mill Road
Richmond, VA 23228

Phone: (804) 261-6101
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom