Merged Too Much NoC Evidence?

quit being dishonest jason you know paik puts the plane headed towards the navy annex and morin puts it directly above it and that can only occur in a noc flight path.

Hmmm, here's Craig's photo with Paik's drawn-in flight path, and my inserting of the Citgo location:

CITGO2.jpg
 
Hmmm, here's Craig's photo with Paik's drawn-in flight path, and my inserting of the Citgo location:

[qimg]http://i164.photobucket.com/albums/u27/kikapurider/CITGO2.jpg[/qimg]

What is funnier is that the line that looks like it was almost done with a ruler and then stopped is closer to where Paik actually pointed than the widely free hand one that goes all over the Navy Annex and then south of Citgo.
 
Last edited:
paik's path puts the plane over the navy annex.

someone explain how that supports the oct.....
 
he's on the south side of the navy annex.

oct requires "aa77" on south side of nave annex at all times.

it would be out of paik's site before he could even associate it to the annex if the oct is true. no aspect of paik's testimony can be true if the oct flight path is true.
 
it would be out of paik's site before he could even associate it to the annex if the oct is true. no aspect of paik's testimony can be true if the oct flight path is true.

This is total unadulterated BS.

To where did Paik point with his hands in the video?

Why did he think the aircraft hit the VDOT tower?
 
he's on the south side of the navy annex.

oct requires "aa77" on south side of nave annex at all times.

it would be out of paik's site before he could even associate it to the annex if the oct is true. no aspect of paik's testimony can be true if the oct flight path is true.
Is there any particular reason you don't write proper English? I mean, you are obviously not dyslexic or otherwise (language-) challenged.

no aspect of paik's testimony can be true if the oct flight path is true

Assuming (but not necessarily agreeing) this is correct, so what? Witnesses are sometimes completely wrong, sometimes even unintentionally.

Hans
 
paik puts the plane headed towards the navy annex and morin puts it directly above it and that can only occur in a noc flight path.

Morin puts it "parallel to the outer edge" which would not put it north of the citgo.

Back to your claim:

every eyewitness puts the plane noc.

Lloyd England puts the plane NOC?
 
and as officer roosevelt roberts saw going away over the south parking lot the plane did fly over......

I'm so pleased you illustrated my point for me, TC329.

Now, if roberts saw the plane flying over the parking lot, then you can provide us with all of the eyewitness testimony of those on the far side of the Pentagon in Metro DC who would have witnessed the flyover too.

Right?

Where are those statements, Dom? Are you going to make the same excuses Craig and Aldo did, that the FBI "confiscated" all the eyewitness reports from everyone in cars on the freeways, on the bridges, in their offices, in their homes, on the other side of the Pentagon?

Come on, Dom, what's the matter?
 
paik's path puts the plane over the navy annex.

someone explain how that supports the oct.....

The photo with the flight path drawn on it surely doesn't support your NOC claim. In fact, the flight path drawn on the photo clearly shows it going south of the Citgo.

Care to explain how that photo helps your NOC claim in any way?
 
wrong.

noc = what knocked down the light poles, shredded a tree top, and tore through that generator coming low and level across the lawn.

Clarification, please? I don't understand what you're trying to say. It looks to me like you have just presented evidence that [Plane hitting the Pentagon] and [Plane flying North of Citgo] are, indeed, mutually exclusive events. So here you actually HELP my case with the evidence you mention, if I'm interpreting you correctly.

wrong. quite a few did not watch because being honest and not embellishing some superman version they actually ran in fear because a large plane was coming right at them.

You know, it would be nice if CIT would make all of their witness interviews available. Have they done that yet? I haven't been keeping up.

In any case, in all the interviews I've seen they agree that the plane hit the Pentagon, not to mention all the other witness accounts available on 911research site, and that one guy, what was his name, Lagasse? even got pissed at CIT for suggesting that the plane didn't hit the Pentagon.

and as officer roosevelt roberts saw going away over the south parking lot the plane did fly over......

I'd like to see this interview with Roberts, or at the very least a complete quote in full context.

wrong. noc cannot be debunked with look the fuselage...ummm...nose cone... i mean landing gear blew through the c-ring wall so therefor noc is debunked.

the source for the plane impacting is the source for saddam has ties to al qaeda and has weapons of mass destruction and the next warning could be a mushroom cloud if we don't act now as well as many other proven lies like jessica lynch and pat tillman versus honest everyday average americans.

i know who i believe.

.......what????
 
And therefore, any argument that debunks a flyover in turn debunks NoC, by the transitive property of mathematical logic.

QED.

Unless you're talking about two planes on two paths, of course it does.

All real witnesses with accurate accounts also debunk NoC. Morin does, Hemphill, Elgas, Riskus, Probst, Wallace, McGraw, England, Zakhem, Timmerman, Vignola, Wheelhouse, NEIT 567...

They have one flyover witness? Can they provide a flight path of what he meant by the direction it was flying away? No other witnesses even, just follow up on the key one? The first flyover witness and they didn't get him to draw a path and they won't eve do one themselves based on the many clear words he gave them. Reason - he was messing with them.

Bad sign for CIT: their critics are more excited about Roosevelt's account than they are! Here's my path and the words it's based on.
Roberts_Flight_Path.jpg
 
This is total unadulterated BS.

To where did Paik point with his hands in the video?

Why did he think the aircraft hit the VDOT tower?
Edwardpointsnorth.gif

He point right to the impact point! What a witness, he debunks CIT! First point!

The first point as he looks at the Pentagon, direct hit!
 
I'd like to see this interview with Roberts, or at the very least a complete quote in full context.

I believe this "flyover witness" is the one who reported a plane flying over the pentagon after AA77 slammed into it. His story creates a minor problem with the flyover theory.....since he claims there were 2 planes...one hitting the pentagon and one flying over. Hmm...whose theory does that sound more like?
 
I believe this "flyover witness" is the one who reported a plane flying over the pentagon after AA77 slammed into it. His story creates a minor problem with the flyover theory.....since he claims there were 2 planes...one hitting the pentagon and one flying over. Hmm...whose theory does that sound more like?

Please, God, don't remind me of Terral.
 
[qimg]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/Edwardpointsnorth.gif[/qimg]
He point right to the impact point! What a witness, he debunks CIT! First point!

The first point as he looks at the Pentagon, direct hit!

Yeah it always amazes me that CIT take this as where he is pointing:

1557948d2cf9a5505f.gif


rather then where he obviously initally points:

1557948d2cf9a1e570.gif
 
Yeah it always amazes me that CIT take this as where he is pointing:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/1557948d2cf9a5505f.gif[/qimg]

rather then where he obviously initally points:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/1557948d2cf9a1e570.gif[/qimg]

I see that in the video he initially points along the correct flight path. What CIT interprets, is his arm swinging down casually as he relaxes and moves his body.

So, basically, CIT are liars. That's disappointing. I was under the impression that they were different from other Truthers, that they did true and honest research. But it turns out they didn't. Sad. CIT lied; there goes the last millinanogram of faith that I had in the Truth Movement.
 
Here is a rendering posted by Craig:
Edward_POV_more_left.jpg


Here is the still picture taken from the video with Edward looking in the direction he is pointing:
1557948d2cf9a1e570.gif


Why do the two not match?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom