Interesting Ian
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 9, 2004
- Messages
- 7,675
I wouldn't say it was superfluous. We do assume that our car will still be in the driveway in the morning, even if nary a soul perceived it during the night. This is why, when I ask you to explain the workings of your metaphysic, I include the question of how the Metamind maintains the consistency of the perceptions of the individual minds.
I wish you would stop talking about my metaphysic all the time. Speculative hypotheses on my part do not constitute my metaphysic.
A mind-independent reality is hypothesised to explain the systematic patterns in our qualia. Thus in my visual field I might experience a certain brown colour of a certain shape resembling a table -- in making certain appropriate bodily movements the shape and size of my visual perceptual experiences (qualia) changes in a systematic manner. Moreover such appropriate bodily movements, including stretching out my arm, will furnish me with a tactile sensation of hardness. If you too are located in the same location as me and make similar bodily movements you would also have similar perceptual experiences (qualia). So we hypothesise a mind-independent table that is somehow responsible for the family of qualia that we experience.
So our very perceptual experiences themselves do not constitute the table. The table is something separate from our perceptual experiences (qualia). So the interesting question here is to ask what the real table is like. Is it similar to our qualia? Or is it something wholly unlike our qualia? I don't think it can be similar to our qualia because what we perceptually experience is an end of a chain of physical cause and effect. Thus brown light is reflected from this real table, enters our eyes, initiates appropriate physical activity in the brain, then this somehow leads to the appropriate visual qualia. So the qualia is supposedly an interpretation by the brain of the light it receives. What the table itself is like must forevermore remain a mystery since necessarily we are trapped in the world of our perceptual experiences (qualia). This then leads to a profound skepticism about the true nature of the world.
Why not just suppose the external world is constituted by our perceptual experiences (qualia)?? Thus there is no objective world but rather one which is inter-subjective. Provided you have similar perceptual experiences as me when at the same locality, then in a sense we live in "the same world" and communication is possible.
Why then do our qualia exhibit systematic patterns if not for this mind-independent reality? Well one could state that this simply is the way the world is. Why can't the Universe be simply what it is? Certainly one could argue that hypothesising, not only an unknown, but an unknowable reality is not enlightening.
Alternatively we might hypothesise that our perceptual experiences are directly imposed upon us by God. What we term the "physical world" is simply a direct communication from God's mind to finite minds (i.e our minds). This is why our qualia exhibit the systematic patterns it does because God is an intelligent agent and possesses infinite causal powers.
This is a more plausible hypothesis than supposing there is a mind-independent world responsible for our perceptual qualia because, as already pointed out, we have absolutely no idea of what such a mind-independent reality is like. Nor can we say how it actually produces our perceptual qualia. Saying it possesses the causal power to do so is essentially vacuous.
On the other hand we immediately experience our own causal agency whenever we voluntarily move our bodies, so the notion of God possessing such causal powers is at least something we can understand.