To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

I wouldn't say it was superfluous. We do assume that our car will still be in the driveway in the morning, even if nary a soul perceived it during the night. This is why, when I ask you to explain the workings of your metaphysic, I include the question of how the Metamind maintains the consistency of the perceptions of the individual minds.

I wish you would stop talking about my metaphysic all the time. Speculative hypotheses on my part do not constitute my metaphysic.

A mind-independent reality is hypothesised to explain the systematic patterns in our qualia. Thus in my visual field I might experience a certain brown colour of a certain shape resembling a table -- in making certain appropriate bodily movements the shape and size of my visual perceptual experiences (qualia) changes in a systematic manner. Moreover such appropriate bodily movements, including stretching out my arm, will furnish me with a tactile sensation of hardness. If you too are located in the same location as me and make similar bodily movements you would also have similar perceptual experiences (qualia). So we hypothesise a mind-independent table that is somehow responsible for the family of qualia that we experience.

So our very perceptual experiences themselves do not constitute the table. The table is something separate from our perceptual experiences (qualia). So the interesting question here is to ask what the real table is like. Is it similar to our qualia? Or is it something wholly unlike our qualia? I don't think it can be similar to our qualia because what we perceptually experience is an end of a chain of physical cause and effect. Thus brown light is reflected from this real table, enters our eyes, initiates appropriate physical activity in the brain, then this somehow leads to the appropriate visual qualia. So the qualia is supposedly an interpretation by the brain of the light it receives. What the table itself is like must forevermore remain a mystery since necessarily we are trapped in the world of our perceptual experiences (qualia). This then leads to a profound skepticism about the true nature of the world.

Why not just suppose the external world is constituted by our perceptual experiences (qualia)?? Thus there is no objective world but rather one which is inter-subjective. Provided you have similar perceptual experiences as me when at the same locality, then in a sense we live in "the same world" and communication is possible.

Why then do our qualia exhibit systematic patterns if not for this mind-independent reality? Well one could state that this simply is the way the world is. Why can't the Universe be simply what it is? Certainly one could argue that hypothesising, not only an unknown, but an unknowable reality is not enlightening.

Alternatively we might hypothesise that our perceptual experiences are directly imposed upon us by God. What we term the "physical world" is simply a direct communication from God's mind to finite minds (i.e our minds). This is why our qualia exhibit the systematic patterns it does because God is an intelligent agent and possesses infinite causal powers.

This is a more plausible hypothesis than supposing there is a mind-independent world responsible for our perceptual qualia because, as already pointed out, we have absolutely no idea of what such a mind-independent reality is like. Nor can we say how it actually produces our perceptual qualia. Saying it possesses the causal power to do so is essentially vacuous.

On the other hand we immediately experience our own causal agency whenever we voluntarily move our bodies, so the notion of God possessing such causal powers is at least something we can understand.
 
Then perhaps you are using a different definition of the word real than many of us. Is the external world real in the sense that it has an effect on me, or is it just an illusion generated by the Metamind to justify my internal experiences?

~~ Paul

No the external world is not an illusion. It's meaningless to say everything is an illusion or everything is a dream. If we start to call everything an illusion, how do we distinguish normal illusions from what we would normally consider to be non-illusions?

And are you asking if the external world has causal powers in and of itself?
 
Ian, you sound better than what you normally write, please dont stop. Still, I have to comment that this seems ironical coming from you, because you dont seem to be aware that what is superfluous is to asume a complete series of metaphysical "stuff" like souls and PSI (in other words, your ideas).

I take a soul as meaning a self which survives death. It seems that other people mean something different by a soul (from reading this other thread which I did not contribute to). But that's what I mean by a soul.

So the charge boils down to saying the self is superfluous. First of all it certainly isn't in everyday conversation. We use the word "I" and "you" all the time, and it would be impossible to not use these words. In practical terms we have to make use of the concept of a self and that we are selves.

You would surely agree that there exists families of experiences? That is to say "I" might be presently experiencing music and toothache, and thinking about what happened yesterday etc. We normally think that the reason why I am grouping these separate experiences into a particular family is because *I* experienced them. That is to say my self had these experiences. If we abandon the notion of a self, what entitles us to distinguish "my" experiences from anyone elses experiences?

Superfluous? I think not. The self does not exist? Possibly, but it is a reasonable hypothesis.
 
Ian said:
I wish you would stop talking about my metaphysic all the time. Speculative hypotheses on my part do not constitute my metaphysic.
They don't? Then what does constitute it?

A mind-independent reality is hypothesised to explain the systematic patterns in our qualia. Thus in my visual field I might experience a certain brown colour of a certain shape resembling a table -- in making certain appropriate bodily movements the shape and size of my visual perceptual experiences (qualia) changes in a systematic manner. Moreover such appropriate bodily movements, including stretching out my arm, will furnish me with a tactile sensation of hardness. If you too are located in the same location as me and make similar bodily movements you would also have similar perceptual experiences (qualia). So we hypothesise a mind-independent table that is somehow responsible for the family of qualia that we experience.
You hypothesize a table independent of individual minds, but it cannot be independent of Mind, because Mind is all there is. So we have a Mind that is capable of presenting consistent worldviews to individual minds, yet without using a separate external reality. I'd simply like to read a few sentences on how this works.

So our very perceptual experiences themselves do not constitute the table. The table is something separate from our perceptual experiences (qualia). So the interesting question here is to ask what the real table is like. Is it similar to our qualia? Or is it something wholly unlike our qualia? I don't think it can be similar to our qualia because what we perceptually experience is an end of a chain of physical cause and effect. Thus brown light is reflected from this real table, enters our eyes, initiates appropriate physical activity in the brain, then this somehow leads to the appropriate visual qualia. So the qualia is supposedly an interpretation by the brain of the light it receives. What the table itself is like must forevermore remain a mystery since necessarily we are trapped in the world of our perceptual experiences (qualia). This then leads to a profound skepticism about the true nature of the world.
(The table has a color? I swear that's not what you said before.)

I cannot reconcile this paragraph with your statement that the Mind plays the external world on our senses. I thought there was no external reality. How then is there a "real table" or a physical brain? What is wrong with the statement "the table is part of a separate physical reality"?

Why not just suppose the external world is constituted by our perceptual experiences (qualia)?? Thus there is no objective world but rather one which is inter-subjective. Provided you have similar perceptual experiences as me when at the same locality, then in a sense we live in "the same world" and communication is possible.
How can we have inter-subjective consistency without something like an objective world? Isn't the very definition of inter-subjectivity the same as objectivity?

Why then do our qualia exhibit systematic patterns if not for this mind-independent reality? Well one could state that this simply is the way the world is. Why can't the Universe be simply what it is? Certainly one could argue that hypothesising, not only an unknown, but an unknowable reality is not enlightening.
The universe certainly is what it is. But you have artificially divided it into two types of things: (1) those things that we can attempt to explain through scientific investigation; and (2) those things that we cannot explain. As far as I can tell, type (1) explains everything there is to explain. You claim that it cannot explain consciousness, but that claim is clearly lacking in substance, at least at this point in history. So I see no reason for type (2) things at all.

Alternatively we might hypothesise that our perceptual experiences are directly imposed upon us by God. What we term the "physical world" is simply a direct communication from God's mind to finite minds (i.e our minds). This is why our qualia exhibit the systematic patterns it does because God is an intelligent agent and possesses infinite causal powers.
This is the hypothesis that our experience is nothing but an hallucination driven by god. Again, you dismiss the necessity of explaining how god works and say "he just does."

This is a more plausible hypothesis than supposing there is a mind-independent world responsible for our perceptual qualia because, as already pointed out, we have absolutely no idea of what such a mind-independent reality is like. Nor can we say how it actually produces our perceptual qualia. Saying it possesses the causal power to do so is essentially vacuous.
But it is precisely as vacuous as your hypotheses. One way or the other, we have no idea what "external reality" is like, be it a physical external reality, god, Mind, or whatever. You make a list of the things we cannot know. You make another list of hypotheses for what that stuff is. Then you reject some hypotheses and adopt others. On what basis? You have no basis.

On the other hand we immediately experience our own causal agency whenever we voluntarily move our bodies, so the notion of God possessing such causal powers is at least something we can understand.
Only if you never go under the surface of "I understand what it is like to move my arm, so therefore I understand what it is like for X to move its arm."

~~ Paul
 
Ian said:
No the external world is not an illusion. It's meaningless to say everything is an illusion or everything is a dream. If we start to call everything an illusion, how do we distinguish normal illusions from what we would normally consider to be non-illusions?
As far as I can tell, if the external world does not exist separately from us, then it is an illusion. It certainly seems separate from us, so someone is tricking us.

And are you asking if the external world has causal powers in and of itself?
Yes, that's an interesting question. Does it? If so, how exactly does your model of the external world differ from materialism?

It appears that you are constructing your metaphysic just so consciousness can be a fundamental existant and therefore you can beg off its explanation.

~~ Paul
 
Ian said:
You would surely agree that there exists families of experiences? That is to say "I" might be presently experiencing music and toothache, and thinking about what happened yesterday etc. We normally think that the reason why I am grouping these separate experiences into a particular family is because *I* experienced them. That is to say my self had these experiences. If we abandon the notion of a self, what entitles us to distinguish "my" experiences from anyone elses experiences?
There are multiple notions of self. We can abandon the one that says the self is some sort of separate, coherent entity with a history beyond the body, without abandoning the use of the term to refer to my personage. There is a difference between self and myself.

~~ Paul
 
Thus in my visual field I might experience a certain brown colour of a certain shap

A mind-independent reality is hypothesised to explain the systematic patterns in our qualia.

No. Qualia is the speculation, the world is naturally and instinctively asumed as real by uninformed human beings.
 
I take a soul as meaning a self which survives death.

Speculation.

So the charge boils down to saying the self is superfluous. First of all it certainly isn't in everyday conversation. We use the word "I" and "you" all the time, and it would be impossible to not use these words. In practical terms we have to make use of the concept of a self and that we are selves.

I never implied that the self is superfluous. And you fail to realize that there are never "selfs" without "bodies". Never. Ever.
 
II
A mind-independent reality is hypothesised to explain the systematic patterns in our qualia. Thus in my visual field I might experience a certain brown colour of a certain shape resembling a table -- in making certain appropriate bodily movements the shape and size of my visual perceptual experiences (qualia) changes in a systematic manner. Moreover such appropriate bodily movements, including stretching out my arm, will furnish me with a tactile sensation of hardness. If you too are located in the same location as me and make similar bodily movements you would also have similar perceptual experiences (qualia). So we hypothesise a mind-independent table that is somehow responsible for the family of qualia that we experience.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
You hypothesize a table independent of individual minds, but it cannot be independent of Mind, because Mind is all there is.

No no no! I'm explaining the "commonsense" hypothesis.

So we have a Mind that is capable of presenting consistent worldviews to individual minds, yet without using a separate external reality. I'd simply like to read a few sentences on how this works.

Forgetting about the fact that you're jumping to the end of my post, why should God require a mind-independent realty in order to be able to have a concept of such a reality? Are you seriously suggesting that God could not think of such a reality without having prior experience of such a reality? So much for his omnipotence!

Sorry but I'm not an empiricist. And even if I were, it is highly questionable to suppose that God must be subject to the same limitations as we are.

II
So our very perceptual experiences themselves do not constitute the table. The table is something separate from our perceptual experiences (qualia). So the interesting question here is to ask what the real table is like. Is it similar to our qualia? Or is it something wholly unlike our qualia? I don't think it can be similar to our qualia because what we perceptually experience is an end of a chain of physical cause and effect. Thus brown light is reflected from this real table, enters our eyes, initiates appropriate physical activity in the brain, then this somehow leads to the appropriate visual qualia. So the qualia is supposedly an interpretation by the brain of the light it receives. What the table itself is like must forevermore remain a mystery since necessarily we are trapped in the world of our perceptual experiences (qualia). This then leads to a profound skepticism about the true nature of the world.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
(The table has a color? I swear that's not what you said before.)

Eh . . . . The table has a colour both from the commonsensical perspective (just described) and from my perspective. I don't know what it would mean to say it doesn't have a colour. If it didn't have a colour are you saying it's wholly transparent i.e invisible?

As usual it seems that we simply talk at cross-purposes all the time. It doesn't seem you understand much of what I say, and therefore I do not understand your responses.

I cannot reconcile this paragraph with your statement that the Mind plays the external world on our senses.

This is because they are 2 competing hypotheses regarding the origin of our qualia. Of course they cannot be reconciled otherwise they wouldn't constitute competing hypotheses.

I thought there was no external reality. How then is there a "real table" or a physical brain? What is wrong with the statement "the table is part of a separate physical reality"?

"Wrong with it"? What do you mean? It's a hypothesis, and I've explained why it is not entirely satisfactory (if you read to the end of my post).

II
Why not just suppose the external world is constituted by our perceptual experiences (qualia)?? Thus there is no objective world but rather one which is inter-subjective. Provided you have similar perceptual experiences as me when at the same locality, then in a sense we live in "the same world" and communication is possible.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
How can we have inter-subjective consistency without something like an objective world?
I've already gone through this in the very post you're responding to.

Isn't the very definition of inter-subjectivity the same as objectivity?

No it isn't. Objectivity is the view from nowhere. To say there is an objective reality is to say there is a reality independently of our perceptions, but to which our perceptions conform. Nevertheless no one perceives such an objective reality for what it really is (hence it is the view from nowhere). Intersubjective just means we agree. Take that chess board with a cylinder on it "illusion". We both agree that squares "A" and "B" differ in colour. Anyone in the world would agree they are different colours. But "objectively" they are the same colour. Therefore inter-subjectivity cannot mean the same as objective. The question here is whether the objective exists? Yes we can take measurements and discover the pixels are the same colour. But our measurements and reading those measurements are also cashed out in the patterns in our qualia. So when we say that the squares are the same colour really, this simply means that if we take our perception that they are different colours, there is an inconsistency with other qualia (when we take measurements). We can resolve this by hypothesising an objective reality. But it doesn't entail such a reality.

II
Why then do our qualia exhibit systematic patterns if not for this mind-independent reality? Well one could state that this simply is the way the world is. Why can't the Universe be simply what it is? Certainly one could argue that hypothesising, not only an unknown, but an unknowable reality is not enlightening.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
The universe certainly is what it is. But you have artificially divided it into two types of things: (1) those things that we can attempt to explain through scientific investigation;

We can't explain anything through scientific investigation. Ultimately all science does is describe -- via hypotheses and laws -- the patterns in our qualia.

and (2) those things that we cannot explain. As far as I can tell, type (1) explains everything there is to explain. You claim that it cannot explain consciousness, but that claim is clearly lacking in substance, at least at this point in history. So I see no reason for type (2) things at all.

Consciousness has qualia or experiences qualia. Science describes the patterns in our qualia, but no, it obviously has nothing to say about consciousness itself. The most it can say is that certain of our qualia when we are looking inside a living brain is correlated with some of the reported experiences of the subject (i.e there are correlations between physical activity in the brain and mental states).

Another way of putting this is to say that science "explains" our experiences, but it is a conceptual confusion to suppose that, in addition, it explains the experiencer which has these experiences. To suppose this is to misunderstand what science is. Of course if you deny the existence of consciousness and qualia there is no problem. But to suppose consciousness doesn't exist is flat out false. I know with incorrigible certitude that I myself am conscious.

II
Alternatively we might hypothesise that our perceptual experiences are directly imposed upon us by God. What we term the "physical world" is simply a direct communication from God's mind to finite minds (i.e our minds). This is why our qualia exhibit the systematic patterns it does because God is an intelligent agent and possesses infinite causal powers.


Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
This is the hypothesis that our experience is nothing but an hallucination driven by god.

Complete nonsense. It would be much more accurate to say that if our perceptions are caused by a mind-independent world, then everything we ever perceive is an illusion. When I say an object is green I mean what I say. I do not mean that a certain wavelength of electromagnetic radiation is reflected from said object which my brain interprets as green. It is that interpretation which entails that everything thing we ever perceive of the physical world is illusionary.

Again, you dismiss the necessity of explaining how god works and say "he just does."

How does the external world make us perceive it? Physical causal powers? All we ever witness is physical event X followed by physical event Y. I never see any innate causal power in the world. Mental causal power is at least something we are acquainted with i.e when we voluntarily move our bodies.

II

On the other hand we immediately experience our own causal agency whenever we voluntarily move our bodies, so the notion of God possessing such causal powers is at least something we can understand.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
Only if you never go under the surface of "I understand what it is like to move my arm, so therefore I understand what it is like for X to move its arm."

Well such psychokinesis is simply a brute fact about what we are able to do. My consciousness appears to be able to initiate small movements in the physical world in my brain. This leads by a physical chain of cause and effect to movements of a macroscopic object -- namely my body. What's the problem?
 
At some point, something must exist for us to be here considering the point. We can either accept the reality we see around us, or if you wish to seriously consider the possibility that "this is all a dream" then somewhere there must be a real dreamer. I'll side with Occam's Razor - proposing the existance of a dreamer who is responsible for our reality is just adding an unnecessary level of complication.

Reality simply is. And no amount of wooly-brained "philosophy" can change that.

I don't have "faith" that the world around me is real. I can see it, I can touch it, it's real. If you want to claim otherwise, show me some proof.
I completely agree with this.
Ian and I agree on something. . ?

**looking out window** Oh. . . my. . . GOD!! Fish are in trees! The sky is purple! Water is flowing uphill!

Ian, you're a complete nitwit! A total cranio-rectal inverted woo nutjob!! You and Iacchus should move in together somewhere on the other side of normal space and time and leave the rest of us alone!!

**looking out the window again** Whew. . . back to normal. That was close!

:D
 
Ian said:
No no no! I'm explaining the "commonsense" hypothesis.
Oh, sorry. It sounded so reasonable, too.

Forgetting about the fact that you're jumping to the end of my post, why should God require a mind-independent realty in order to be able to have a concept of such a reality? Are you seriously suggesting that God could not think of such a reality without having prior experience of such a reality? So much for his omnipotence!
Ian, sorry, but your question is no different from "Why should Snorgle require a mind-independent reality in order to ...". I have absolutely no idea what you think God is beyond "the thing that makes everything happen the way I like to think it does."

Sorry but I'm not an empiricist. And even if I were, it is highly questionable to suppose that God must be subject to the same limitations as we are.
Well sure, we wouldn't want that. Then we might have to explain stuff.

Eh . . . . The table has a colour both from the commonsensical perspective (just described) and from my perspective. I don't know what it would mean to say it doesn't have a colour. If it didn't have a colour are you saying it's wholly transparent i.e invisible?
Sorry again, but that is not what you seemed to be saying in the other thread: Color was introduced by my mind. In the chessboard illusion, if the two squares have color at all, they have the same color.

As usual it seems that we simply talk at cross-purposes all the time. It doesn't seem you understand much of what I say, and therefore I do not understand your responses.
Because you say confusing things, like the previous paragraph. Can you grok the fact that we still don't understand what you mean by color, in spite of multiple threads on the subject?

No it isn't. Objectivity is the view from nowhere. To say there is an objective reality is to say there is a reality independently of our perceptions, but to which our perceptions conform. Nevertheless no one perceives such an objective reality for what it really is (hence it is the view from nowhere). Intersubjective just means we agree. Take that chess board with a cylinder on it "illusion". We both agree that squares "A" and "B" differ in colour. Anyone in the world would agree they are different colours. But "objectively" they are the same colour. Therefore inter-subjectivity cannot mean the same as objective.
No, they are not different colors. I do not agree with you. They are the same color, but I perceive them as different colors unless I do something quite simple to allow me to perceive their sameness. There might even be people who perceive them as the same color without any help.

[bunch of stuff left out]

How does the external world make us perceive it? Physical causal powers? All we ever witness is physical event X followed by physical event Y. I never see any innate causal power in the world. Mental causal power is at least something we are acquainted with i.e when we voluntarily move our bodies.
Crap. I kick a ball and it rolls down a hill. The kick and gravity is the cause. On the other hand, you're asleep and I tap your knee with a hammer. You kick. Absolutely no voluntary movement involved.

Well such psychokinesis is simply a brute fact about what we are able to do. My consciousness appears to be able to initiate small movements in the physical world in my brain. This leads by a physical chain of cause and effect to movements of a macroscopic object -- namely my body. What's the problem?
One problem is that you don't even know if this model is correct. How do you know you are initiating the movement using your free will? It could very well be that God is operating you like a puppet and diddling the external world to match, just to fool you into thinking there is internal/external consistency. Heck, if there is such a thing as psi, these might be cases where God screws up and doesn't make things consistent. But how can we know, because you have no details in your model of reality.

You do not seem able to imagine the possibility that your view of reality does not have the explanation that you desire. In any event, you are unable to give details of the explanation, so you attribute them en masse to one gigantic magical act of God. We can use science to understand the virtual reality created by God, but we cannot use science to go any deeper. It's so vapidly convenient. Fortunately, it doesn't really make any difference.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Its called "cantinflear" in spanish, this is, to make aparent that one is actually saying something, when in fact its just going in circles, confusing the terms and concepts involved.

Now, to be fair, Ian certainly has evolved in the forum (with so many intelligent people from who he can learn is nice to see that he actually learns, slowly, but learns), his words now are more coherent than before... this is, of course, before he starts to talk about PSI and souls and causality and (the list continues).
 
James,
If you read through VonNeumann's earlier posts, you'll see that his central thesis is that skeptics and scientists who don't reach the same conclusions as him are mired in religious thinking. Rather than addressing individuals' arguments directly, he continuously invokes strawmen, such as "darwin-faithers". After pages upon pages of this, the inclination to treat him with respect and patience evaporates.

See this thread: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=50787
VonNeumann debuts here on page 2: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=1403907#post1403907
Oh, thank you so much chipmunk for your unbiased summary.:rolleyes:

Let me try to summarize, myself. I believe I observed that where theories are incomplete, there is a lot of, what should I call it : extrapolation? fitting evidence to the theory? filling in the gaps? Do I disagree with this method or tendancy. Much of it, no. Some of it? Some of it seems surprisingly stuck in a rut.

This is the rub: when gaps are filled in with (not going to use the word 'faith') biased thinking, it closes the mind to the kind of omnidirectional thinking that I think is beneficial. It is one reason why a bunch of independent thinkers do better than a collective. Especially in the area of 'origins', and particularly evolution, there appears to me to be a guarding of the dogma rather than good skeptical thinking. This is ironical to me - especially in the stage of this rorum of skeptics. That is why I use such terms as 'so-called-skeptics'. That is a self-assigned label. If you think you are a skeptic, free yourself from the dogma, at least SOME of the time. I think this is good healthy advice.

There needs to be a good balance between: being afraid of what others think about what you think is plausible; and, allowing yourself to become a dreamer entertaining all kinds of nonsense.

In the thread of 'Physical Laws: best case for ID?', I observed that a few skeptics seemed to me to have allowed themselves to have fallen into the trap of thinking Science = Truth. That is why I started this thread. I intended to sit back and 'listen' but you saw how it started. I am appreciative that you and Ian brought in some interesting views so that this thread took off and we can all learn from the trade of ideas.

There appears to be a collective culture here that guards itself and impedes independent thought. My guess that it is even some of the most Objectivist types (in the sense of Ayn Rand), who would abhor collectivism, will fall into the groove of complying for fear of ridicule.

It is in this independent spirit that I come in here, as what I coined an 'isotropic skeptic', to appeal to each of you to break it up a little. Don't let what I say piss you off. Try to get some value out of it. Remember Howard Roark (of Rand's Fountainhead) - just do it and don't care what others think.

Allow yourself to break away from this mocking crowd that makes fun of church lady when she ventures here. Don't you see, that is easy and lazy? Look at yourself. Know yourself.

Just ask yourself: what do I take on faith? Where are the gaps. Just do it every once in a while and then... get back to work.

This is the closest I will really come to trying to tell anybody what I think they should or shouldn't do or think. If you go back and read my posts, my mode of operation was mostly to say what I thought was plausible or implausible, and then ask what others think. Some people just do not want to hear contrarian views to what they already have secured for themselves as 'the answer'. To question those basic things is to speak heresy - the angry reactions speak for themselves.

Another rebuttal to chipmunk... He said I did not take on argument directly with the individual. There is some truth to that but unfairly stated. I found that an impasse could be quickly reached. The subjective bias confronting me lead to futility when I tried. The amount of posts from the numbers of those with the same mindset, is not surprising, but hardly anything I could keep up with. I think I came up with at least a couple good points that could have stirred up some agreement; but why should I expect an individual to concede he could see the other side, in full view of his collective peers? But I did not come here to try to convince people of particular theories - I kept most of my talk at a meta- level. Talking about thinking about science/conjectures. This was often confused with the science/conjecture, itself. Surely if I were a better writer, there would have been less confusion.

I did often use the term 'darwin-faither' often because it expressed my view. Other terms: Darwinist, evolutionist, etc did not, IMO, honestly describe the way that the theory was embraced by the individual. My point was about how the gaps were filled in with too much faith that it could be 'just so'. Please, (anyone) do not rebut this here (again). I am just telling of my attempt to convey my own view on another thread, since chipmunk brought it up.

And after all of that, I do not think anyone changed his view; certainly not me. I think chipmunk is distorting the evaporation of respect and patience. I think many of us petered out on it about the same time. Some expected some kind of concession, which is unrealistic either way. By looking at the number of posts, some of these guys have been round and round the block on some of this already; I was new here. I think I was surprised at the good amount of patience and disappointed in the amount of stereotyping.

But finally, I'll say to chipmunk, why do you volunteer to broadcast condemnation of me? Anyone can click on my name and see where I've posted and draw their own conclusions. All you do by volunteering to openly declare your negative opinion of me is to be a gossiper. ...like the public needs police like you and Complexity?
 
VonNeumann, if you spent less time trying to highlight your (apparently self-viewed) moral highground, and instead ignored those comments not relevent to what your claimed topic of discussion was, you'd come off a lot better.

Keep in mind also,
But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.
Carl Sagan

-- Just because someone is defending the status quo does not mean they are necessarily a sychophant, and neither does challenging the status quo automagically make someone more objective to the topics at hand.

Also consider, "You can catch more flies with honey than vinegar."
 
Von said:
This is the rub: when gaps are filled in with (not going to use the word 'faith') biased thinking, it closes the mind to the kind of omnidirectional thinking that I think is beneficial. It is one reason why a bunch of independent thinkers do better than a collective. Especially in the area of 'origins', and particularly evolution, there appears to me to be a guarding of the dogma rather than good skeptical thinking. This is ironical to me - especially in the stage of this rorum of skeptics. That is why I use such terms as 'so-called-skeptics'. That is a self-assigned label. If you think you are a skeptic, free yourself from the dogma, at least SOME of the time. I think this is good healthy advice.
Free myself from the dogma and do what? I could say "Oh, yes, maybe this biological mechanism was designed." Then what? Where do I go from there? What path in that direction is not simply vapid and sterile? It seemed to me as if many of us had walked further along that path than you and so could more reasonably claim that it had been investigated and found to be wanting.

Really Von, I'm perfectly happy to take a path away from the dogma, but not just so I can claim loudly that I'm not dogmatic.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom