To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

There is no axiom about objective reality, if by that you mean an ontological axiom.

But this need not be an "external, physical universe." How would we know? Science really only needs the axioms listed in my previous post.

That said, most scientists certainly assume that there is an external, physical universe.
And therein is your problem; the selection of physical is nothing but ontological.

When evidence arises for the Matrix, or brain in a vat, or computer simulation, or everything-is-mind, then that assumption will be shown to be incorrect.
Agreed, yet Science & the scientiific method can neither affirm nor deny any of these hypothesis. You may of course have faith that your application of Occam to deny them is correct. ( I have faith Thought Exists. :) )

Meanwhile, the assumption doesn't really matter. If someone wants to criticize science because scientists make ontological assumptions, fine, but it's a pretty vapid criticism.
Correct in that Science doesn't care what the answer is, only that objectivity exists. Logic may suggest one choice is "better' than some other choice.

Note again thay no one is criticizing Science per se, only noting that some questions may not be answered by the scientific method; morality, ethics, etc.
 
At some point, something must exist for us to be here considering the point. We can either accept the reality we see around us, or if you wish to seriously consider the possibility that "this is all a dream" then somewhere there must be a real dreamer. I'll side with Occam's Razor - proposing the existance of a dreamer who is responsible for our reality is just adding an unnecessary level of complication.

Reality simply is. And no amount of wooly-brained "philosophy" can change that.

I don't have "faith" that the world around me is real. I can see it, I can touch it, it's real. If you want to claim otherwise, show me some proof.

I completely agree with this.
 
(IMHO)
It's an interesting set of questions, but it's a useless line of thought. but mabye that's because I'm studying to be an engineer, not a philosopher or scientist.

Science isn't for finding "truth". it's for finding things about the observable physical universe. I don't think it matters if the observable physical universe doesn't exist, because science works in describing whatever we see as the observable physical universe.

as long as the applied sciences keep working, I can't be brought to care about the argument. Philosophy never gave us anything useful AFAIK.
(/IMHO)
 
Hammegk said:
And therein is your problem; the selection of physical is nothing but ontological.
But it doesn't matter! The scientific endeavor doesn't need to make any assumption about what stuff actually is. The fact that individual scientists do is irrelevant to the overall enterprise in the long term.

Agreed, yet Science & the scientiific method can neither affirm nor deny any of these hypothesis. You may of course have faith that your application of Occam to deny them is correct. ( I have faith Thought Exists. )
So you're saying that there can't possibly be any evidence for ontological hypotheses? I'm not sure why that is necessarily true, but if it is, it simply sustains my observation that ontology is irrelevant.

Correct in that Science doesn't care what the answer is, only that objectivity exists. Logic may suggest one choice is "better' than some other choice.
Correct, although we haven't found that magical bit of logic after thinking about this for thousands of years.

~~ Paul
 
Genesius said:
I don't have "faith" that the world around me is real. I can see it, I can touch it, it's real. If you want to claim otherwise, show me some proof.

Ian said:
I completely agree with this.
I thought your metaphysic holds that the external world is played on my senses by the Metamind.

~~ Paul
 
Hammegk said:
Certainly you haven't anyway [found that magical bit of logic after thinking about this for thousands of years].
Have you? Care to enlighten us? What's the bit of logic that distinguishes between ontologies?

~~ Paul
 
More and more it appears to me each person needs to find their own path. This makes sense to me in that every individual has their unique knowledge base that needs to be examined by that individual.




or ....




mu
 
Originally Posted by Genesius :
I don't have "faith" that the world around me is real. I can see it, I can touch it, it's real. If you want to claim otherwise, show me some proof.



Originally Posted by Ian :
I completely agree with this.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
I thought your metaphysic holds that the external world is played on my senses by the Metamind.

Well yes, that would be my hypothesis.

There is no contradiction here whatsoever.

Be patient. I'm just reading through the thread at this moment. I shall make comments where appropriate.
 
VonNeumann,

I'm very sorry to see the level of derision and unwarranted dismissiveness that your post has met with so far. Personally I've been struggling with this and similar issues for a while now, and while I still hold out some hope that the scientific method can ultimately be rationally justified, I haven't found the way to do it yet. To those who dismissively point out that this is an issue that has been raised before (it goes way back before The Matrix, in case some of you were unaware), that's certainly true, but it keeps arising because unfortunately no one has yet offered a satisfactory response to it. (Or maybe someone has, and I'm just unaware of it).

The short answer to your question is, yes, the scientific method does rest on faith in the reality of our perceptions that cannot be (or has not yet been) rationally justified. Descartes struggled with this problem, and thought he had solved it by arguing that God would not permit us to be so deceived by our senses as to hold false beliefs about the nature of reality. Unfortunately that solution doesn't work for anyone who does not accept a priori the existence of God.

I would say it doesn't work anyway.

So you're absolutely right that every scientific conclusion rests on faith to the extent that we assume that our observations reflect some external reality. This is problematic, of course, because most skeptics criticize the religious for their acceptance of certain beliefs on nothing more than faith, with no empirical evidence to justify that belief. The unfortunate irony is that skeptics do the same thing, by resting belief on a faith in empirical observations.

I think there's sooo much confusion here.

Our empirical observations just tell us the way reality operates. The only faith here is to suppose that reality is uniform. In other words there is the "faith" that reality will keep on exhibiting the same patterns as it has in the past and it will keep doing so for the future.

Unfortunately, the problem of the logical invalidity of scientific inquiry doesn't end there. I had a few posts a couple of weeks ago in the Enlightenment re-start thread about this, but it's relevant here too. Hume came along and proved pretty convincingly that, to use an example cited by both Hume and strathmeyer, we have no logically valid reason to believe that the sun will come up tomorrow. The argument proceeds as follows: All of our scientific knowledge (i.e., anything relying on empirical observation, excluding only mathematics and geometry) relies on inductive reasoning-- the process by which we draw general conclusions from a series of specific instances. The sun has come up every morning of my life so far, so I naturally expect that it will rise again tomorrow at about the same time. Inductive inference, however, relies on the premise of the uniformity of nature: i.e., that things will behave in the future in the same way that they have in the past. The last hundred times that I've dropped a pencil, it has fallen to the floor. Therefore I expect that if I drop this pencil, it will also fall to the floor. This only works if I have reason to believe that the same forces will act on the pencil in the future as have acted on it in the past.

Unfortunately, the principle of the uniformity of nature can't be validated by non-circular reasoning. It's not a logical necessity-- we can certainly conceive of, say, the law of gravity suddenly changing. The principle, therefore, can only be justified by inductive reasonining-- nature always has been uniform in the past, therefore it always will be. This, obviously, is circular logic-- we can't justify inductively the principle by which we seek to logically validate inductive reasoning.

Hume concluded that, therefore, we have no logically valid basis for believing that the future will resemble the past, and our practice of drawing conclusions on the basis of experience is simply a matter of custom rather than logic. In other words, it is purely a matter of faith that any of the scientific theories we have derived through observation will hold true in the future.

Yes absolutely. However I fail to see what this has to do with the subject of this thread.

I don't see how one gets around either of these problems,

I don't see why there is a problem here. Yes the next time I release an object it might not fall, it might instead "fall" upwards. Or anything whatsoever might happen. Maybe in the very next second the Universe might dissolve in complete chaos. Nor can we say that is an "unlikely" scenario.

{shrugs}

It doesn't threaten the skeptic worldview anymore than any other worldview.

and I think you're right that there does seem to be something hypocritical in the skeptical insistence that beliefs be founded on evidence rather than on faith, when belief founded on evidence still ultimately rests on faith.

The word "faith" is surely being used in differing senses here? Science just tells us how the world operates. Yes we have a faith in the notion that reality operates uniformly -- i.e the future will resemble the past. But that is a fundamental axiom for everything we ever do -- for our day to day activities.

I'm still a skeptic, though, because it feels right,

And let's ignore all the evidence opposing it shall we . . .
 
More and more it appears to me each person needs to find their own path. This makes sense to me in that every individual has their unique knowledge base that needs to be examined by that individual.
or ....
mu

Yes, but people on the same page have much of the path laid out already. That is the cool thing about both science and education...it's cumulative...
information from the past and technologies of the past are utilized and honed and refined to become the knowledge and tools of the present...then future. Everyone can add a piece to the discovery...or even point out the pieces that aren't part of the puzzle. The thing about being on the "same page" in the scientific world, is that you can add to and revel in the new discoveries as they are made without having to worry about whether they fit with whatever story you've been telling yourself.

Yes, people do have to find their own path...if they believe there is a path or a purpose or somewhere in particular they are going...others don't worry about paths...they enjoy the journey as it unfolds and enjoy adding to the accumulation of knowledge and understanding.
 
we can pretty easily just stipulate that science assumes the existence of the external world,

What does "external world" mean?

Science is science is science. Science as such doesn't assume anything apart from the uniformity of nature*. Don't conflate science with the metaphysical presumptions of scientists.

*Science has to take the unifirmity of nature as an axiom, otherwise, by definition, science couldn't get off the ground.
 
I'm confused... you're claiming that we can never know something before it happens? So if I drop a pen, I don't know if it will fall to the ground or fly up to the ceiling because I haven't dropped it yet? How am I supposed to live my life if I can't plan for the future?

You just have to assume the uniformity of nature. Otherwise you couldn't operate.

Also, if you think that "the sun will rise tomorrow" is not a fact, then I would like to place a bet with you that it will. I will give you any odds.


We can't even say that it is "likely" the sun will rise tomorrow. But no one will take your bet up :)
 
No, it doesn't.

The scientific method rests on experience in the reliability of our preceptions -- the rational justification is simply "induction."

Yes.

Science would work just as well in the universe of the Matrix, assuming that the computer was actually well-enough programmed to avoid obvious inconsistencies.

Yes.

It would simply lead us to conclusions that would not, in point of fact, be accurate -- but they would still be predictive.

No. You misunderstand what science is. Science is nothing over and above predictions. Anything else is metaphysical speculation.

Scientists -- particularly in physics -- have happily accepted the idea that their theories may be predictive without being "correct" in some metaphysical sense for quite some time.

Yes indeed. Physicists are wise in this. Take note!

To address the question of correctness, however, we can turn from the problem of induction to Occam's razor.

Can you justify Occam's Razor? I suspect not. In point of fact, the usual phrasing of Occam's Razor ("Entities should not be multiplied unnecessarily") specifically denies the possiblity of "justification' in the usual sense, because it's an instruction, not a statement about the world.
However, given the track record -- evidence -- of success Occam's razor has provided, we've again got a rational basis for its acceptance.

It's just a rule of thumb. If we have 2 hypotheses which equally explain some phenomenon, then all things being equal we should provisionally accept the hypothesis which introduces fewer entities. There is absolutely no reason to suppose that reality has a predilection towards minimal entities to explain phenomena.

And Occam's razor demands that, absent evidence, we should not believe in an invisible world as well as a visible one. It multiplies the number of "worlds" unnecessarily.

Occam's razor demands nothing whatsoever. There is no immutable law demanding that reality be "simple". Reality can be what it likes. And as a matter of fact we have found that we have needed to introduce a plethora of elementary particles to describe reality.

Now if you were to argue that reality demands mathematical simplicity, harmony and beauty, you would have much evidence to draw upon.
 
I would say it doesn't work anyway.

I think it works if you accept that God exists, and that It is always looking out for your best interests. But we seem to agree that Descartes's solution to the problem fails.


Our empirical observations just tell us the way reality operates. The only faith here is to suppose that reality is uniform. In other words there is the "faith" that reality will keep on exhibiting the same patterns as it has in the past and it will keep doing so for the future.

How is that not what I said? We take the principle of uniformity of nature on faith, or as an axiom, since some prefer that euphemism. Either way, it's a fundamental assumption that we make since, as you subsequently pointed out, science couldn't get off the ground without it. It doesn't seem like we're disagreeing here.

Yes absolutely. However I fail to see what this has to do with the subject of this thread.
I don't understand what you fail to see. The language you quoted was setting out the induction problem, so it seems to me that the above paragraph explains its relevance to the thread. Am I missing something?


I don't see why there is a problem here. Yes the next time I release an object it might not fall, it might instead "fall" upwards. Or anything whatsoever might happen. Maybe in the very next second the Universe might dissolve in complete chaos. Nor can we say that is an "unlikely" scenario.

I don't see how that isn't a problem, at least insofar as I would like to believe that my reliance on inductive inference to predict future events is valid.

It doesn't threaten the skeptic worldview anymore than any other worldview.
Well, the skeptic/scientific worldview places particular emphasis on empiricism and inductive reasoning. So, a logical inconsistency at the foundation of induction seems to me to be a matter of particular concern to the skeptic. But of course, one needn't be an avowed skeptic or scientist for this problem to be relevant.


The word "faith" is surely being used in differing senses here? Science just tells us how the world operates. Yes we have a faith in the notion that reality operates uniformly -- i.e the future will resemble the past. But that is a fundamental axiom for everything we ever do -- for our day to day activities.
Again... how are we disagreeing? Isn't that what I said?


And let's ignore all the evidence opposing it shall we . . .

I don't think there's "evidence" opposing the validity of skepticism; the problem is that the very methodology by which empirical evidence is relevant to finding truth appears to suffer from an inconsistency. But for lack of any better truth-finding methodology, I'll stick with what seems to produce the best results and continue seeking (or hoping for) a solution to the apparent underlying inconsistency.
 
I am embarrassed for you who volunteer to guard Randi's fine forum from heresy to your own religious beliefs. I do not see anything resembling that which I thought was the spirit of being a skeptic, amongst you few.

To those of you who are observers of this, and not just those who haven't gotten the opportunity yet to get in your 'kick', note the anger and other immature emotional responses from so-called-skeptics.

I am here to see what people think. Many times they do not want to reveal even to themselves what conclusions they must draw. That is when their limbic system answers for them.

Well I think reality is as it is, around us. We can validate it to a point, which is where science is at. The philosophy of whether its a dream etc is just really long in the tooth and I feel a result of too much drugs in the 60's. I mean I can sit here and spin my mind out with stuff like, wow is my cat real? is it my imagination? But the seeming lunacy of that statement and time it wastes coming to no conclusion accept the same question time and time again is why I tend to think what your saying is fairly vague, and sounds like some form of wooish belief. Some minds spin out about it, I guess im just over it. 'It' being those questions which make you 'spin out'. Whatver reason you believe your reality is not as such, is pretty much a form of belief and faith, unprovable, but also only seen by you. The answers to the questions you raise appear in my mind as fantasy solutions, not sustainable by the cold hard reality out there. Improbable as something real.

for me, I like what is coined as the common accepted reality, and it tends to be that I accept with some questions what is presented to me that defines it as such. If someone says the sky is really red, thats obvious bs, but when people worry about such things as 'are we real?', 'am I really alive?', 'Is earth really here?' etc, I think its kinda hmmmm, 'try hard' - only because we are now in 2006. 50 -100 years ago, it was a cool kind of philosophy maybe, but now it just seems deliberately eccentric with what we know.

Science goes where the evidence takes it. I tend to think if we sat here and worried about these questions alongside say evolution, you would come to the same question over and over, whereas evolution would, well, evolve and new questions would be put forth. Philosophy is healthy, but not if it asks pretty much an obvious fantasy of reality.

Besides if it was a computer simulation, why is there so many if/case/switch conditions? Why not simplify it, make the code linear like a 3d shooter? Why would someone programming this 'reality' simulation make us so random so then have to deal with all the error fixing? Cant this programmer even learn from the way we make and produce software? It has much less code issues. I mean we are far from being even object orientated arent we? Whoever coded this 'reality' is a shocking programmer I must say.

my two cents

cheers



my two cents
 
Last edited:
... No. You misunderstand what science is. Science is nothing over and above predictions. Anything else is metaphysical speculation...

... It's just a rule of thumb. If we have 2 hypotheses which equally explain some phenomenon, then all things being equal we should provisionally accept the hypothesis which introduces fewer entities...


You might claim the opposite, but you have learn lots of stuff in this forum. You even sound coherent from time to time, like some of your posts so far in this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom