Lord Muck oGentry
Graduate Poster
It's just a rule of thumb. If we have 2 hypotheses which equally explain some phenomenon, then all things being equal we should provisionally accept the hypothesis which introduces fewer entities. There is absolutely no reason to suppose that reality has a predilection towards minimal entities to explain phenomena.
Occam's razor demands nothing whatsoever. There is no immutable law demanding that reality be "simple". Reality can be what it likes.
Interesting Ian,
drkitten certainly doesn't need my help, but there may be some naive souls out there who imagine that you are making some profound criticism of Occam's Razor, or at least of its use by your opponents. No one is suggesting that Occam's Razor is or implies an "immutable law demanding that reality be 'simple'" ( your words). The Razor is there to spare investigators the effort of speculating about entities with no testable consequences: to get rid of timewasters.
Regards