To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

It's just a rule of thumb. If we have 2 hypotheses which equally explain some phenomenon, then all things being equal we should provisionally accept the hypothesis which introduces fewer entities. There is absolutely no reason to suppose that reality has a predilection towards minimal entities to explain phenomena.



Occam's razor demands nothing whatsoever. There is no immutable law demanding that reality be "simple". Reality can be what it likes.

Interesting Ian,

drkitten certainly doesn't need my help, but there may be some naive souls out there who imagine that you are making some profound criticism of Occam's Razor, or at least of its use by your opponents. No one is suggesting that Occam's Razor is or implies an "immutable law demanding that reality be 'simple'" ( your words). The Razor is there to spare investigators the effort of speculating about entities with no testable consequences: to get rid of timewasters.

Regards
 
Having read the entire thread, I am opting only reply to the OP rather than jump in at the current point in the discussion. That being said;

Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?
We can only prove reality to the extent that we, as part of the system, can self define it, or, if we could step outside of the system, so far as our observations on the system would affect it.

By definition, Science is constrained in scope to that which can be empirically demonstrated. A relationship that can be demonstrated between what our senses send to our brain, our observations, and an external objective reality, must be performed via the same observation mechanism. So can we validate objectively?
We can validate objectively because it is based on what we define it to be. In most cases it is person A telling person B if they do X and Y they we receive results Z. Person B can test this independently of person A and observe if they receive results Z or not.

We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us. So is it not an illusion or a preferred paradigm, this idea, that only those things are real which can be Scientifically proven?
It is better than the alternatives of nihilism, or solapsism, etc

If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation. I am curious what others think about this.
Whether intended or not, this statement carries heavy overtones. If it is meant as a reminder that, even if we observe a result 5 gajillion times, there is a 1/5gajillion+1 chance it could be different, then I agree. If, on the other hand, it is somehow meant to suggest that science is "faith-based" in the same way that Xtians believe in Heaven, or Hindus in Nirvana, then I take exception.
 
No. Justification simply means that there is reason to believe something is true. Certainly believing something is true because it is probably is a legitimate justification, absent further information. I believe that the city of Tokyo is still there [has not been eaten by Godzilla] because I find it improbable that it has disappeared.... and I have no further information at this time. If I really wanted to, I could fly to Tokyo and check, but that still wouldn't "prove" the statement.




So what? We have ample demonstration -- including the ability to perform new experiements -- to justify the belief in the uniformity of nature.

Basically, you're saying "but you can't PROVE that the sun will rise tomorrow!"

However, that doesn't make my belief that the sun will rise tomorrow any less justified. The question I ask you is, "do I have reason to believe that ths sun will, in fact, rise tomorrow?" If I do, then my belief is justified, despite the absence of formal proof. If I do not, then you should be willing to accept a small wager....

No, ultimately we have no reason to believe the Sun will rise tomorrow. We can only have a reason if we presuppose the inductive principle. But induction itself cannot be justified.

We simply have to presuppose induction is true without reason or evidence. In contrast to JamesDillon, however, this does not perturb me whatsoever.
 
Originally Posted by drkitten :
That's because the problem as Hume articulated is, simply put, not a problem.
Its an observation that we could be wrong.

JamesDillon
Hume's argument is more than that-- it's an observation that not only could we be wrong, but we have no reason to believe that we're right, even when inductive reasoning accurately predicts the outcome of an experiment. Obviously this seems to contradict some deeply ingrained method of reasoning common to everyone.

This sounds utterly outrageous, but I would just like to confirm that JamesDillon is absolutely right.
 
First, there is no FTL information transfer, in any meaningful sense of 'information'.

Second, 'collapse of the wave function' does not have anything to do with consciousness.

How do you know? There's only consciousness or something physical which can do the collapsing. And if it is something physical then that something is not itself described by QM. In which case QM does not give a complete description of reality. So if it is not consciousness which is responsible for the collapsing of the wave function the onus is on you to demonstrate this.

That is an interpretation of quantum mechanics, and an unsupported one, at that. Don't talk QM unless you can show the math, because QM is math.

Not the interpretation of QM. That's metaphysics.
 
You make a good point there, and it does make me feel a bit better about the situation (believe it or not this is the sort of thing that I lie awake worrying about at night). I suppose it's true that any system of argumentation rests on one or more fundamental principles that simply have to be accepted as primitive or self-evident, and uniformity of nature seems much more plausible to take on "faith" than does the existence of an invisible, onmipotent man in the sky.

Well yes. More "plausible" even than a sophisticated concept of God.

Of course "plausible" here means no more than our psychological dispositions.

As to the existence of external objects problem, I'm less concerned about that one though it is still important to acknowledge as defining an edge, beyond which the scientific method (bound as it is by the assumption of uniformity) can cast no light. I'm not really uncomfortable making the concession that, yes, the scientific method does assume the existence of external objects with no sufficient evidence to prove that proposition scientifically,

I don't think the scientific method assumes the existence of a world existing wholly independently of our conscious perceptions of it. This tends to be the presupposition of scientists. The notion of such a reality is superfluous to both science and indeed our day to day lives.

I would be interested in working out the corollaries to the observation that the scientific method can offer no insight into the truth value of propositions that lack empirically testable content (which may, of course, nevertheless be true). The brain in a vat problem is one of these. The God of deism is another, although the God of theism, to the extent that it meddles in the material world and thus would leave empirically observable traces, is not.

A God wouldn't leave empirically observable traces if in fact the whole of reality is simply a manifestation of God's thoughts.

What other things might we want to know that the scientific method can't tell us anything about?

I think the whole concept of the scientific method is seriously dodgy. Read Feyerabend's Against Method.

I'm very impressed with your posts btw. It makes such a pleasant change for a skeptic to understand stuff.
 
Yeah! He's not a high quality troll like me!
Sorry, Ian, but you're not a high-quality troll, either. I won't attempt to compare mediocrities.

You have many of the qualities of a derailed obsessive-compulsive.

VonNeumann, on the other hand, imagines himself to be a cat playing with mice, or a godling burning skeptic ants with a lens. I keep picturing him as a nasty prepubescent child.

You are more sincere than VonNeumann, but you are both wrong.
 
Sorry, Ian, but you're not a high-quality troll, either. I won't attempt to compare mediocrities.

You have many of the qualities of a derailed obsessive-compulsive.

VonNeumann, on the other hand, imagines himself to be a cat playing with mice, or a godling burning skeptic ants with a lens. I keep picturing him as a nasty prepubescent child.

You are more sincere than VonNeumann, but you are both wrong.

Being relatively new here, I've had no prior contact with Ian or VonNeumann outside of this thread, but it seems to me that, at least here, they've raised some interesting and cogent points about skeptical epistemology,* only to be met with ad hominem attacks and derisive dismissals that fail to address the substance of their arguments.

I note that you have a quote from Bertrand Russell in your signature. Russell, at least, took the problems we are discussing here seriously, and did not seem to believe that they could be adequately refuted. In The History of Western Philosophy, he wrote that

Hume... showed that empiricism, carried to its logical conclusion, led to results which few human beings could bring themselves to accept, and abolished, over the whole field of science, the distinction between rational belief and credulity. (Book Three, Chapter 20)

and that

It is evident that [Hume] started out with a belief that scientific method yields the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth; he ended, however, with the conviction that belief is never rational, since we know nothing.
...
The growth of unreason throughout the nineteenth century and what has passed of the twentieth is a natural sequel to Hume's destruction of empiricism. (Book Three, Chapter 17)

Are we to conclude that Lord Russell was also an "obsessive compulsive," "prepubescent child"?

*Note that I take no position on VonNeumann's comments regarding consciousness and collapsing wave functions, because I don't know enough about quantum mechanics to hold an informed opinion on that issue.
 
Last edited:
Ian said:
I think the whole concept of the scientific method is seriously dodgy. Read Feyerabend's Against Method.
I can't remember who said it, but Feyerabend has important things to say, but he makes too much of a big deal out of them. Critics of the "scientific method" take some statement of the method as if it were unarguable, then proceed to give counterexamples. I don't know any scientists who argue for the unarguability of the scientific method.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Being relatively new here, I've had no prior contact with Ian or VonNeumann outside of this thread, but it seems to me that, at least here, they've raised some interesting and cogent points about skeptical epistemology,* only to be met with ad hominem attacks and derisive dismissals that fail to address the substance of their arguments.
*Note that I take no position on VonNeumann's comments regarding consciousness and collapsing wave functions, because I don't know enough about quantum mechanics to hold an informed opinion on that issue.
Two things:
1. MrComplexity is troubled by my/our presence. He thinks of himself as a skeptic and finds sanctuary in this culture. He is trying to dislodge discussion that upsets his black/white model of 'what is'. He is merely trying to protect this culture - that's all. He is exhibit 'A': that this flavor of skepticism has some attributes of a cult/religion. I do not take it personally (I forgive you Complexity. You are just a fellow human trying to figure it all out (and we never will).).

2. I'm glad you brought up the conscious collapse of the wave function. Not having but pop-sci level of information on QM (my formal QM math stopped at the beginning: Schroed's equation), I would like to see if some specialist here can answer the question about whether an 'observer' needs be a 'conscious observer'. Didn't the 'delayed choice' experiment base resolution on human choice?
 
me said:
I thought your metaphysic holds that the external world is played on my senses by the Metamind.

Ian said:
Well yes, that would be my hypothesis.

There is no contradiction here whatsoever.
Then perhaps you are using a different definition of the word real than many of us. Is the external world real in the sense that it has an effect on me, or is it just an illusion generated by the Metamind to justify my internal experiences?

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Ian said:
I don't think the scientific method assumes the existence of a world existing wholly independently of our conscious perceptions of it. This tends to be the presupposition of scientists. The notion of such a reality is superfluous to both science and indeed our day to day lives.
I wouldn't say it was superfluous. We do assume that our car will still be in the driveway in the morning, even if nary a soul perceived it during the night. This is why, when I ask you to explain the workings of your metaphysic, I include the question of how the Metamind maintains the consistency of the perceptions of the individual minds.

~~ Paul
 
I don't think the scientific method assumes the existence of a world existing wholly independently of our conscious perceptions of it. This tends to be the presupposition of scientists. The notion of such a reality is superfluous to both science and indeed our day to day lives.

Ian, you sound better than what you normally write, please dont stop. Still, I have to comment that this seems ironical coming from you, because you dont seem to be aware that what is superfluous is to asume a complete series of metaphysical "stuff" like souls and PSI (in other words, your ideas).

The notion of a concrete and objective reality is natural for every human being, even without any kind of instruction.
 
Besides if it was a computer simulation, why is there so many if/case/switch conditions? Why not simplify it, make the code linear like a 3d shooter? Why would someone programming this 'reality' simulation make us so random so then have to deal with all the error fixing? Cant this programmer even learn from the way we make and produce software? It has much less code issues. I mean we are far from being even object orientated arent we? Whoever coded this 'reality' is a shocking programmer I must say.

my two cents

cheers
I think that is a backward approach to assume 'it' a simulation first, and then try to guess why it is designed the way it is. I think the approach should be, what kind of model explains the wierdness of QM, relativity, turbulence, and see what model comes up. If it looks like an information processing system, then that model may be the best one.

I am only giving you 2 cents worth in return to give my opinion that a digital computation model may be the best model for the unified theory. I don't think I need to disclaim being an expert, I'm sure it is sorely apparent.

I keep running across the reaction to the idea of simulation, that the programmer was/is incompetent (which it seems you suggest). I don't see it that way - I just go 'man, what a lot of code, it never crashes except maybe inside black holes, also, ... go outside, the graphics are bitchin', man':) .

I generally understand your complaint, though not your detail, and I think it is along the lines of what Heisenberg is puported to have said. Something like: "when I die, I am going to ask God two questions: why relativity, and why turbulence. I expect he'll have an answer for the first."
 
JamesDillon - You need to get around more - read some other threads.

I think I've described Ian and VonNeumann accurately. Neither of them has anything of value to say.

I have quite a bit of interest in the nature and limitations of the reason and the scientific method. I won't engage in discussions on topics of such importance with the likes of Ian, VonNeumann, and dozens of others that would chime in mindlessly. There are several people on this forum that I would enjoy discussing these matters with, but not with the distractions of fools.

There are a great many topics that are worthy of serious discussion. I think that some topics are only worth discussing in slow time - seriously, thoughtfully, with intelligence, with sincerity, and with time enough for contemplation. Some topics are only worth discussing in private - with oneself, with a good book, and, perhaps, with one's perfect reader. For me, the philosophy of science and philosophy in general fall somewhere into the last two categories, mostly in the last.

I am unlikely to participate in any discussion of philosophy on a forum for this reason.

I have a lot of respect for Bertrand Russell - far too much to discuss him with Ian and VonNeumann.

*Note that I take no position on VonNeumann's comments regarding consciousness and collapsing wave functions, because I don't know enough about quantum mechanics to hold an informed opinion on that issue.
Very few people on this board know enough about quantum mechanics to have an opinion on it - either on the math, the physics, or the various interpretations.

Certainly, Ian and VonNeumann don't. I know that I don't, and I've actually taken physics through the first QM course.
 
[Complexity] is merely trying to protect this culture - that's all. He is exhibit 'A': that this flavor of skepticism has some attributes of a cult/religion.
James,

If you read through VonNeumann's earlier posts, you'll see that his central thesis is that skeptics and scientists who don't reach the same conclusions as him are mired in religious thinking. Rather than addressing individuals' arguments directly, he continuously invokes strawmen, such as "darwin-faithers". After pages upon pages of this, the inclination to treat him with respect and patience evaporates.

See this thread: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=50787
VonNeumann debuts here on page 2: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=1403907#post1403907
 
I think that is a backward approach to assume 'it' a simulation first, and then try to guess why it is designed the way it is. I think the approach should be, what kind of model explains the wierdness of QM, relativity, turbulence, and see what model comes up. If it looks like an information processing system, then that model may be the best one.

I am only giving you 2 cents worth in return to give my opinion that a digital computation model may be the best model for the unified theory. I don't think I need to disclaim being an expert, I'm sure it is sorely apparent.

I keep running across the reaction to the idea of simulation, that the programmer was/is incompetent (which it seems you suggest). I don't see it that way - I just go 'man, what a lot of code, it never crashes except maybe inside black holes, also, ... go outside, the graphics are bitchin', man':) .

I generally understand your complaint, though not your detail, and I think it is along the lines of what Heisenberg is puported to have said. Something like: "when I die, I am going to ask God two questions: why relativity, and why turbulence. I expect he'll have an answer for the first."

Sweet, I understand your position and thoughts a bit better now - I think, though id steer from anything as being 'designed' myself.

Id say regarding QM, there is a sh*tload of code to look through thats probably uglier and more confusing then the DX libraries....;)

A short answer from mwaha for the topic is 'science goes where the evidence takes it'. Obviously some amount of faith could be thought to be assumed for future science, but again I think its not faith, just expected evidence/facts/data to come. I really cant see how faith can exist in any science because of this ideal.

Faith is a dirty word....to me....

Cheers mate
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom