To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

No. People say that simply because someone is laughed at does not necessitate that this someone is wrong. I very much doubt that anyone has ever claimed that being laughed at constitutes evidence that they are right.

But feel free to prove I'm wrong.

Lol, you play with the idea all the time. Please don't deny it. You like to believe that you are more intelligent that anybody BECAUSE people in here does not agree with you. You would like also to believe that people do not understand you because you are "obviously" a genious of some sort.

On the other hand, what would be to "prove you wrong" if you are always hidden behind your own interpretation of words?
 
A mind-independent reality is hypothesised to explain the systematic patterns in our qualia.

In all reality is very simple, for example you are wrong here. It is the "Qualia" what is hypothesized by some dualists to try to resolve some problems. The "mind independent reality" is naturally asumed by every uninformed human being, its not an hypothesis.
 
Sagan's quote says that (premise) some geniuses were laughed at does not imply (conclusion) all who are laughed at are geniuses. Quoting this is not tantamount to claiming that there are people who say "anyone who is laughed at must be right."

~~ Paul

Quite correct; Sagan was providing a specific example of the Composition(1) Fallacy that is often used by those outside the currently accepted scientific paradigm.


(1)Description of Composition

The fallacy of Composition is committed when a conclusion is drawn about a whole based on the features of its constituents when, in fact, no justification provided for the inference. There are actually two types of this fallacy, both of which are known by the same name (because of the high degree of similarity).

The first type of fallacy of Composition arises when a person reasons from the characteristics of individual members of a class or group to a conclusion regarding the characteristics of the entire class or group (taken as a whole). More formally, the "reasoning" would look something like this.

1. Individual F things have characteristics A, B, C, etc.
2. Therefore, the (whole) class of F things has characteristics A, B, C, etc.

This line of reasoning is fallacious because the mere fact that individuals have certain characteristics does not, in itself, guarantee that the class (taken as a whole) has those characteristics.

It is important to note that drawing an inference about the characteristics of a class based on the characteristics of its individual members is not always fallacious. In some cases, sufficient justification can be provided to warrant the conclusion. For example, it is true that an individual rich person has more wealth than an individual poor person. In some nations (such as the US) it is true that the class of wealthy people has more wealth as a whole than does the class of poor people. In this case, the evidence used would warrant the inference and the fallacy of Composition would not be committed.

From here: http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/composition.html
 

(1)Description of Composition

The fallacy of Composition is committed when a conclusion is drawn about a whole based on the features of its constituents when, in fact, no justification provided for the inference. There are actually two types of this fallacy, both of which are known by the same name (because of the high degree of similarity).

The first type of fallacy of Composition arises when a person reasons from the characteristics of individual members of a class or group to a conclusion regarding the characteristics of the entire class or group (taken as a whole). More formally, the "reasoning" would look something like this.

1. Individual F things have characteristics A, B, C, etc.
2. Therefore, the (whole) class of F things has characteristics A, B, C, etc.




Yes, so we have the claim that some or most believers reason that because Galileo was correct and he was laughed at, therefore anyone who is laughed at is likely to be correct too.

The trouble is that this is a complete strawman. No believer that I am aware of has ever committed this fallacy. What believers argue is that simply because someone is laughed at, this in itself does not entail that the laughed at person is wrong.

This line of reasoning is fallacious

Yes we all know that. But has anyone in the history of the Universe ever committed this error??
 
Quite correct; Sagan was providing a specific example of the Composition(1) Fallacy that is often used by those outside the currently accepted scientific paradigm.
...

Additionally, it also shows the inherent neutrality in the scientific process, in that, the reactions to a given idea are not an indicator for, or against, the validity of the idea itself. Rather, the idea must stand on its own merits.
 
Yes, so we have the claim that some or most believers reason that because Galileo was correct and he was laughed at, therefore anyone who is laughed at is likely to be correct too.

The trouble is that this is a complete strawman. No believer that I am aware of has ever committed this fallacy. What believers argue is that simply because someone is laughed at, this in itself does not entail that the laughed at person is wrong.



Yes we all know that. But has anyone in the history of the Universe ever committed this error??

If you'd bothered to read my entire post, instead of taking Sagan's quote for a tangent you'd have seen my following sentence, "Just because someone is defending the status quo does not mean they are necessarily a sychophant, and neither does challenging the status quo automagically make someone more objective to the topics at hand." Which was in response to Von's post.

So, by taking my quote out of the context of the post, you've managed to completely derail things.
 
If you'd bothered to read my entire post, instead of taking Sagan's quote for a tangent you'd have seen my following sentence, "Just because someone is defending the status quo does not mean they are necessarily a sychophant, and neither does challenging the status quo automagically make someone more objective to the topics at hand." Which was in response to Von's post.

So, by taking my quote out of the context of the post, you've managed to completely derail things.

What are you talking about??

You said Paul C. Anagnostopoulos was correct. As I've already explained he's not correct and therefore neither is Carl Sagan and therefore neither are you.

Prove me wrong and name some believers who have argued that because someone is laughed at, that someone must necessarily be right.
 
Delighted to oblige.


Lasagna Recipe
Easy Lasagna

* 8 ounces lasagna noodles
* 1 pound lean ground beef
* 1/2 cup chopped onion
* 8 ounces mushrooms, optional
* 1 jar (about 16 ounces) spaghetti sauce, your favorite
* 1 teaspoon garlic powder
* 1/2 teaspoon salt
* 1 teaspoon dried leaf oregano, crumbled
* 1/2 teaspoon dried leaf basil, crumbled
* 1 1/2 cups ricotta cheese
* 2 cups shredded Monterey Jack cheese
* 3/4 cup grated Parmesan cheese




Cook lasagna noodles according to package directions; drain and set aside. In a large skillet, brown beef, onion, and mushrooms; drain well. Stir in spaghetti sauce, garlic powder, salt, oregano, and basil. In a 2-quart buttered baking dish (about 11x7x2-inches), layer 1/3 of the lasagna noodles, 1/3 of the sauce and 1/3 of the ricotta cheese, Monterey Jack cheese, and Parmesan cheeses. Repeat layers twice. Bake lasagna for 30 minutes, or until thoroughly heated and bubbly. Let stand for 8 to 10 minutes before cutting and serving. Serves 6 to 8.


Are you trying to promote The Flying Spaghetti Monster agenda? Are you a pastafarian?

Von...this could all be an illusion...this whole internet thing--JREF Forum included...all of these people typing to you...they could all be parts of your brain...part of some crazy reality you are building yourself--I mean, there is no proof that we exist...data on a screen does not mean that real people actually exist behind these messages...you could be creating us all to experience the reality you wish to experience...It could all disappear the moment you stop looking at it...
 
What are you talking about??

You said Paul C. Anagnostopoulos was correct. As I've already explained he's not correct and therefore neither is Carl Sagan and therefore neither are you.

Prove me wrong and name some believers who have argued that because someone is laughed at, that someone must necessarily be right.

HELLO! It is using hyperbole(1) to illustrate a point.

Additionally, you are (intentionally?) misinterpretting the quote. It does not mean, "because someone is laughed at, that someone must necessarily be right". It is a counter to people who claim that because they are not accepted by the current paradigm that they are like people such as Columbus who were right, but not believed.

Are you being intentionally obtuse?



(1) per m-w.com
Main Entry: hy·per·bo·le
Pronunciation: hI-'p&r-b&-(")lE
Function: noun
Etymology: Latin, from Greek hyperbolE excess, hyperbole, hyperbola, from hyperballein to exceed, from hyper- + ballein to throw -- more at DEVIL
: extravagant exaggeration
 
Are you trying to promote The Flying Spaghetti Monster agenda? Are you a pastafarian?

Von...this could all be an illusion...this whole internet thing--JREF Forum included...all of these people typing to you...they could all be parts of your brain...part of some crazy reality you are building yourself--I mean, there is no proof that we exist...data on a screen does not mean that real people actually exist behind these messages...you could be creating us all to experience the reality you wish to experience...It could all disappear the moment you stop looking at it...
Perhaps you should read about quantum gravity or read Feynman's QED, for starters. Whatever reality is, it is more weird than you might think.
 
HELLO! It is using hyperbole(1) to illustrate a point.

What point?

Additionally, you are (intentionally?) misinterpretting the quote. It does not mean, "because someone is laughed at, that someone must necessarily be right". It is a counter to people who claim that because they are not accepted by the current paradigm that they are like people such as Columbus who were right, but not believed.

Yes people believe they are like Galileo or whoever in that sense. That includes me.

But then his statement:

"But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown".

makes no sense whatsoever. Who has ever argued that the fact that some geniuses were laughed at means they were necessarily correct? And what has Bozo the clown have to do with anything? People are not saying they are like Bozo, but rather like Columbus.

At this point it seems sensible to suppose that Sagan just made a silly mistake. But we keep getting skeptics approvingly quoting him all the time. But since his statement is completely nonsensical, why do they keep quoting it??

I don't understand. Is anyone able to explain?
 
Oh, no, it was extremely biased. I fully own that.
James said he thought you were being treated unfairly. The links were to illustrate why I disagree with his assessment. Gossipy? Maybe.
I see. I think you are correct, by what appears to be the criteria for "fair" around here.

I would presume that each of you would behave much differently one-on-one, eye-to-eye, with me than you do in a pack. Such is the forum culture - it is all on stage.
 
Von said:
I would presume that each of you would behave much differently one-on-one, eye-to-eye, with me than you do in a pack. Such is the forum culture - it is all on stage.
I wouldn't behave any differently. However, one-on-one, there would be no pack for you to react to, would there?

I would be careful when calling a group of people who disagree with you a pack. It may just be a group of people who happen to disagree with you.

~~ Paul
 
What point?



Yes people believe they are like Galileo or whoever in that sense. That includes me.

But then his statement:

"But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown".

makes no sense whatsoever. Who has ever argued that the fact that some geniuses were laughed at means they were necessarily correct? And what has Bozo the clown have to do with anything? People are not saying they are like Bozo, but rather like Columbus.

At this point it seems sensible to suppose that Sagan just made a silly mistake. But we keep getting skeptics approvingly quoting him all the time. But since his statement is completely nonsensical, why do they keep quoting it??

I don't understand. Is anyone able to explain?


Let me put it in a more structured example:
P1: The status quo laughed at Columbus' theory, then he was proven right
P2: The status quo laughs at my theory
C: Therefore, I am right

This is a fallacy of affirming the consequent. A refutation of which is;
P1: The status quo laughed at Columbus' theory then he was proven right
P2: The status quo laughed at Bozo the Clown's theory then he was proven to be a clown
P3: The status quo laughs at my theory
C: Therefore, I am either right, or I am a clown


If you want examples of people exhibiting the first example, look to any woo website where they claim that "they", "the government", "the scientific community", "the status quo", etc are keeping their "revolutionary" ideas from being recognized.
 
Last edited:
I see. I think you are correct, by what appears to be the criteria for "fair" around here.

I would presume that each of you would behave much differently one-on-one, eye-to-eye, with me than you do in a pack. Such is the forum culture - it is all on stage.

You may which to familiarize yourself with John Gabriel's Greater Internet (rule 8) Theory http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19

It is just a reality of being on the net.
 
I wouldn't behave any differently. However, one-on-one, there would be no pack for you to react to, would there?

I would be careful when calling a group of people who disagree with you a pack. It may just be a group of people who happen to disagree with you.

~~ Paul
Well, you were never one to join in with surly comments, I don't think.

On using the word 'pack', I hear you and agree with you, but will explain: A 'group' is not sufficiently descriptive, lacking the attributes of similar mindset. A pack has a mutually similar mindset and circles like wolves. But... OK, it has a derogatory connotation - emmanating from my shock at being called, amongst other things, a 'prick'. BTW, thank you for stepping in and moderating the extreme name calling. A shot fired like that ricochets and reverberates for a while.
 
Ah, now you're changing your mind again!


Let me put it in a more structured example:
P1: The status quo laughed at Columbus' theory, then he was proven right
P2: The status quo laughs at my theory
C: Therefore, I am right

This is a fallacy of affirming the consequent. A refutation of which is;

A refutation is uninteresting if no one in the history of the Universe has ever made such an argument in the first place.

As I keep repeating, you need to prove that many believers employ such an argument.


I'm still waiting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom