To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

VonNeumann, if you spent less time trying to highlight your (apparently self-viewed) moral highground, and instead ignored those comments not relevent to what your claimed topic of discussion was, you'd come off a lot better.

Keep in mind also,
Carl Sagan

-- Just because someone is defending the status quo does not mean they are necessarily a sychophant, and neither does challenging the status quo automagically make someone more objective to the topics at hand.

Also consider, "You can catch more flies with honey than vinegar."
I cannot connect what you associate with me as self-assumed 'moral highground'. What did I say about morals? As far as responding when I could have ignored - I did much of that but the negative barrage this time needed to be dealt with.

I whole-heartedly agree about being two sides to the thinking. But you are second-hand on pointing it out. I point out there are two sides by pointing out the other side and then you say 'yeh but, there are two sides'. OK - so we agree on that.

I certainly don't know 'the best way to come off' and so appreciate your suggestions. Vinegar is not all bad. A little vinegar kicks up some discussion, and I noticed honey does not last long around opposing viewpoints - it ferments quickly.

So yours are good points and are also to the point of my stressing 'individualism'. It is good we are not all alike - the seemingly futile beating a dead horse still might spawn some new thinking in some of us. That's what I hope, at least, for myself.
 
I believe I observed that where theories are incomplete, there is a lot of, what should I call it : extrapolation? fitting evidence to the theory? filling in the gaps? Do I disagree with this method or tendancy. Much of it, no. Some of it? Some of it seems surprisingly stuck in a rut.

Yes. Damned evidence! The annoying thing with the truth is that you never have a complete picture of it. That's why people prefer, shall I say, "alternative" solutions, such as faith.

This is the rub: when gaps are filled in with (not going to use the word 'faith') biased thinking, it closes the mind to the kind of omnidirectional thinking that I think is beneficial.

How is that ? Obviously, you have to provisionally fill those gaps to be able to work the theory and the science. It's when the gap-filler becomes dogma that it's a problem.

It is one reason why a bunch of independent thinkers do better than a collective.

How is a collective different from a bunch of people ?

Especially in the area of 'origins', and particularly evolution, there appears to me to be a guarding of the dogma rather than good skeptical thinking.

No, I just think it's the area of science that disagrees with your worldview, and you can't take it. You've shown in at least one previous thread that "skeptical" thinking isn't your forte.

This is ironical to me - especially in the stage of this rorum of skeptics. That is why I use such terms as 'so-called-skeptics'. That is a self-assigned label.

No, it's not. You assigned it.

If you think you are a skeptic, free yourself from the dogma, at least SOME of the time. I think this is good healthy advice.

You're proceeding from false assumptions, again. I, for one, will certainly never bring anything worthwhile to science. I'm a computer programmer. So if I start speculating about the "origins" of life or whatnot, it's just that : speculation. I rely on smarter people to do what's needed. Does that mean I believe what they say at face value ? No! But beign in the situation that I am, I can only browse through the information that I have and come to a conclusion based, in part, on my own thinking, but mostly on that of others, like people on this forum, for example.

My conclusion ? Evolution works fine. Special creation doesn't.

There needs to be a good balance between: being afraid of what others think about what you think is plausible; and, allowing yourself to become a dreamer entertaining all kinds of nonsense.

Ad hominem AND strawman in one breath! What makes you think we are affraid of anything ? We just don't have time to consider every single little possibility.

In the thread of 'Physical Laws: best case for ID?', I observed that a few skeptics seemed to me to have allowed themselves to have fallen into the trap of thinking Science = Truth.

Science ~ Truth, Von. Religion <> Truth.

...and Chuck Norris IS truth.

There appears to be a collective culture here that guards itself and impedes independent thought.

Is that so ? Well, gee darn. I guess that's why none of our technologies work and why science and medecine don't progress over the years... wait a minute. THEY DO!

You can come up with any theory you like, Von. Unfortunately, as I said, we have no time to study them all, otherwise we'd still be chasing pink unicorns. It's the burden of the claimant to prove his point. The current theories are well-supported, so they've become the default. Prove another theory right (or right-er), and we'll talk.

My guess that it is even some of the most Objectivist types (in the sense of Ayn Rand), who would abhor collectivism, will fall into the groove of complying for fear of ridicule.

I think personnal freedoms are highly over-rated. There.

It is in this independent spirit that I come in here, as what I coined an 'isotropic skeptic', to appeal to each of you to break it up a little. Don't let what I say piss you off. Try to get some value out of it. Remember Howard Roark (of Rand's Fountainhead) - just do it and don't care what others think.

Well said. If only you followed your own advice.

You seem to think that thinking AGAINST the current theory is the way to go. But that's not the skeptic or the scientific way: EVIDENCE is the way to go.

Allow yourself to break away from this mocking crowd that makes fun of church lady when she ventures here. Don't you see, that is easy and lazy? Look at yourself. Know yourself.

You're becoming entwined in your own fantasies, Von. Snap out of it.

Just ask yourself: what do I take on faith? Where are the gaps. Just do it every once in a while and then... get back to work.

So there are gaps.

There were gaps a hundred years ago. People attributed them to Gunderscored. They were proven wrong. They've been proven consistently wrong for the last few thousand years. I don't think your "designer" fellow is going to show, after all.

I did often use the term 'darwin-faither' often because it expressed my view. Other terms: Darwinist, evolutionist, etc did not, IMO, honestly describe the way that the theory was embraced by the individual.

How about Evidencialist ?

My point was about how the gaps were filled in with too much faith that it could be 'just so'.

You're lying, here. People have been very patient with you: explaining why your hypotheses don't work and why the current theories do. Who said "it's just that way, and that's it" ?
 
Oh, thank you so much chipmunk for your unbiased summary.:rolleyes:
Oh, no, it was extremely biased. I fully own that.
But finally, I'll say to chipmunk, why do you volunteer to broadcast condemnation of me? Anyone can click on my name and see where I've posted and draw their own conclusions. All you do by volunteering to openly declare your negative opinion of me is to be a gossiper. ...like the public needs police like you and Complexity?
James said he thought you were being treated unfairly. The links were to illustrate why I disagree with his assessment. Gossipy? Maybe.
 
VonNeumann, if you spent less time trying to highlight your (apparently self-viewed) moral highground, and instead ignored those comments not relevent to what your claimed topic of discussion was, you'd come off a lot better.

Keep in mind also,
"But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown".

Carl Sagan

And no one has ever remotely suggested that simply because people laugh at someone, that this someone is necessarily correct. It's a complete strawman which many skeptics like to periodically quote because they are not interested in an honest debate, but are purely interested in "winning".

And shame on Carl Sagan. I actually thought he was quite a reasonable guy until I saw that quote.
 
Once again - thank you, Ian and VonNeumann, for demonstrating your idiocy beyond reasonable doubt.
 
And no one has ever remotely suggested that simply because people laugh at someone, that this someone is necessarily correct. It's a complete strawman which many skeptics like to periodically quote because they are not interested in an honest debate, but are purely interested in "winning".

And shame on Carl Sagan. I actually thought he was quite a reasonable guy until I saw that quote.
I would think that with 15,000 posts, Ian would have bumped into someone like that. I sure have. Sometimes it gets up to a daily basis.
 
I would think that with 15,000 posts, Ian would have bumped into someone like that. I sure have. Sometimes it gets up to a daily basis.

Someone who says that because someone is laughed at that someone must be right??

I'm afraid you'll need to back that up.
 
You're lying, here. People have been very patient with you: explaining why your hypotheses don't work and why the current theories do. Who said "it's just that way, and that's it" ?
Lying? I already said people are generally patient. ... but what explanation for what hypotheses? ...what won't work? I don't know what you are talking about.
 
Oh please, Ian. Skeptics don't claim that anyone says someone who is laughed must be right. Get your anecdotes right, will you?

~~ Paul

You what? You missed Sagan's quote which skeptics always quote?

"But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown".

Carl Sagan
 
Sagan's quote says that (premise) some geniuses were laughed at does not imply (conclusion) all who are laughed at are geniuses. Quoting this is not tantamount to claiming that there are people who say "anyone who is laughed at must be right."

~~ Paul
 
Sagan's quote says that (premise) some geniuses were laughed at does not imply (conclusion) all who are laughed at are geniuses. Quoting this is not tantamount to claiming that there are people who say "anyone who is laughed at must be right."

~~ Paul

Of course it is! He's arguing against the view that if people laugh at an individual, that individual must necessarily be correct. There would be no point in arguing against this view if no one actually held it . .or rather there is a point, but only in the sense of dishonestly caricaturing believers.
 
It might be that people point out one or two individuals who were laughed at and then insist this is one item of evidence in favor of their claims. I very much doubt that there are people who say that anyone who is laughed at must be right, and I doubt there are any skeptics who have claimed this.

But we digress ...

~~ Paul
 
It might be that people point out one or two individuals who were laughed at and then insist this is one item of evidence in favor of their claims.

No. People say that simply because someone is laughed at does not necessitate that this someone is wrong. I very much doubt that anyone has ever claimed that being laughed at constitutes evidence that they are right.

But feel free to prove I'm wrong.
 
Ian said:
No. People say that simply because someone is laughed at does not necessitate that this someone is wrong. I very much doubt that anyone has ever claimed that being laughed at constitutes evidence that they are right.
I'll see if I can scrounge a Web site where it's been done.

~~ Paul
 
No. People say that simply because someone is laughed at does not necessitate that this someone is wrong. I very much doubt that anyone has ever claimed that being laughed at constitutes evidence that they are right.

But feel free to prove I'm wrong.
No need to. You're correct. No one here ever said that. Next?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom