Interesting Ian
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 9, 2004
- Messages
- 7,675
Yawn. Yet another theist who thinks that by watching the Matrix he can create a rational argument in favor of God.
Seen it, done it, refuted it.
I would like to see this refutation.
Yawn. Yet another theist who thinks that by watching the Matrix he can create a rational argument in favor of God.
Seen it, done it, refuted it.
Going by your definitions, that is how it works by definition. You said science was constrained to what can be empirically demosntrated. How do you propose we demonstrate any "real" things that cannot be empirically demonstrated?
Yes, and of course rejecting science is in no way suggested.(So if you reject "science" as a method of acquiring knowledge, you are literally left with .... nothing.)
The title is "to what extent does:" ... it's not a yes/no question. You answered "science does not equal.." but I was suggesting a grey scale.Science simply relies on the same assumption that you and I have been using all day (in fact all our lives): that our observations reflect reality, and that this reality is in some way consistent.
I see no reason to abandon the assumption about the nature of reality that we make as part of our day-to-day lives simply because we're thinking about something called "science". Can you provide a compelling reason to do this?
Does science = faith? Science is based on what we can observe about the universe (although, as you have pointed out, it does rely on the assumption that our observations reflect an objective reality). On the other hand, "faith" is defined, in the context that you're using the word here, as strong belief (usually in some sort of religion) without strong observable evidence (although I think you'll find that even people of faith, in their everyday lives, rely on exactly the same assumption about the nature of the universe that I've been relying on so far today). So no, science does not equal faith.
There is no axiom about objective reality, if by that you mean an ontological axiom. We only need a definition about what is "real" (things that have affects on other things), axioms about real things behaving according to consistent logical laws, and about the ability to observe things to determine the laws. These axioms are falsifiable, in the sense that we could notice if the laws turn out to be capricious or there appear to be effects whose causes we cannot fathom.Hammegk said:What falsifiable axiom underlies your worldview? The axiom required for science is not falsifiable, but is taken on faith.
Axiom 1. Objective reality exists;
and to arrive at that point, Axiom 0. Thought exists.
But this need not be an "external, physical universe." How would we know? Science really only needs the axioms listed in my previous post.Mojo said:Science makes the basic assumption that what we observe is a reflection of an objective universe.
See now, this is a misuse of the word faith. Some scientists may assume that the universe is continuous and may turn out to be wrong in the future. But if the assumption makes no difference to their work, then what's the problem? A problem arises if the physics establishment refuses to budge in light of compelling evidence for a discrete universe, but then those old farts die and the young turks assume discreteness.Von said:My personal interests have to do with leading edge Science, of course at a superficial level. The fact that we must postulate very strange ideas, more than ever, to generate theory for gravity means we cannot hold on too tightly to old classical beliefs. For instance, apparently the belief that we live in a continuous (as in analog, or non-discrete) universe is still taken on faith by many scientists. Is that still a question? ...whether space/time and everything in it is fundamentally discrete?
When you say "we have absolutely no idea" I think you mean that we can only "have an idea" as to what is the true nature of reality. Perhaps our ideas approach a vanishingly small amount of truth, but they are non-zero.Well if it does we have absolutely no idea as to what its true nature is.
Faith is a convienient word in our language that means "belief without or with insufficient evidence. I agree we should scoff "isotropically" - which is what I am trying to balance here. You see? You perceive my pointing something out as having been aimed. Yes, aimed only to try to give fairness to the "faith accusation" argument. I have had responses to posts from certain individuals that appear to me that they think they take nothing on faith - none of us take nothing on faith.See now, this is a misuse of the word faith. Some scientists may assume that the universe is continuous and may turn out to be wrong in the future. But if the assumption makes no difference to their work, then what's the problem? A problem arises if the physics establishment refuses to budge in light of compelling evidence for a discrete universe, but then those old farts die and the young turks assume discreteness.
None of this is a reason to scoff at the close-mindedness of science any more than it is a reason to scoff at the close-mindedness of other human endeavors.
~~ Paul
~~ Paul
Von said:Faith is a convienient word in our language that means "belief without or with insufficient evidence. I agree we should scoff "isotropically" - which is what I am trying to balance here. You see? You perceive my pointing something out as having been aimed. Yes, aimed only to try to give fairness to the "faith accusation" argument. I have had responses to posts from certain individuals that appear to me that they think they take nothing on faith - none of us take nothing on faith.
Actually, it's two adjacent unbreakable spaces.*Von said:I pick DNA helices. Am I right?
Noooooo, this circularity defines inductive reasoning. It is logically valid for being what it is.
Uniformitarianism is axiomatic, sure. As Jimbo07 points out: that's a scientific axiom that differentiates itself from many religions (eg: biblical literalists revile uniformitarianism).
What other things might we want to know that the scientific method can't tell us anything about?
Why can't science tell us something about these things? After all, they are human behaviors. Perhaps science can't tell us what we wish to hear about them.Beth said:Eternal truth, justice, beauty, love. Those are the first ones that come to my mind. Science does not deal well with intangibles. But who wants to claim that such things do not exist or live in a world without them?
Why can't science tell us something about these things? After all, they are human behaviors. Perhaps science can't tell us what we wish to hear about them.
~~ Paul
Why can't science tell us something about these things? After all, they are human behaviors. Perhaps science can't tell us what we wish to hear about them.
~~ Paul