To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Going by your definitions, that is how it works by definition. You said science was constrained to what can be empirically demosntrated. How do you propose we demonstrate any "real" things that cannot be empirically demonstrated?

What about via mystical experiences?
 
Science simply relies on the same assumption that you and I have been using all day (in fact all our lives): that our observations reflect reality, and that this reality is in some way consistent.

I see no reason to abandon the assumption about the nature of reality that we make as part of our day-to-day lives simply because we're thinking about something called "science". Can you provide a compelling reason to do this?

Does science = faith? Science is based on what we can observe about the universe (although, as you have pointed out, it does rely on the assumption that our observations reflect an objective reality). On the other hand, "faith" is defined, in the context that you're using the word here, as strong belief (usually in some sort of religion) without strong observable evidence (although I think you'll find that even people of faith, in their everyday lives, rely on exactly the same assumption about the nature of the universe that I've been relying on so far today). So no, science does not equal faith.
The title is "to what extent does:" ... it's not a yes/no question. You answered "science does not equal.." but I was suggesting a grey scale.

Of course I do not propose the abandonment of science. The flippant responses you see on this thread, before this thread turned into a discussion are from those so-called-skeptics who become very nervous when fundamental questions such as those of this thread, are asked. You do not prefer my term "faith" because you believe it contributes a "religious" connotation. You may not agree, but I believe that the nervous and mean/rude reactions to perfectly good philosophical inquiry, suggests that some so-called-skeptics are very "religious" about their belief structure. Belief should be a cerebral activity yet they react from their brain stem

My personal interests have to do with leading edge Science, of course at a superficial level. The fact that we must postulate very strange ideas, more than ever, to generate theory for gravity means we cannot hold on too tightly to old classical beliefs. For instance, apparently the belief that we live in a continuous (as in analog, or non-discrete) universe is still taken on faith by many scientists. Is that still a question? ...whether space/time and everything in it is fundamentally discrete?

To scoff intensely at the idea that we live in a simulation shows religious bias, IMO. Where I believe I tinged some nerves with this proposition (on another thread) is that I suggested that a simulation reality plausibly suggests a designer :eek: . This causes the weak to have a limbic "knee jerk reaction", because they "know" that is impossible. If this comes from "knowledge" why do they use their cerebellum/medula to do the talking for them?

I have read that Lee Smolin, who is working on unifying gravity theory with QM, uses the paradigm that there is nothing outside this universe. I note that at the same time, if I begin to understand him, that there are postulated hidden things within this universe. I probably misunderstand, but it seems that hidden and within might be the semantic equivalent of outside of the universe.
 
Interesting discussion. Thanks for the food for thought. I wish I has something to bring to the table, but I'll have to content myself with feasting on your ideas.
 
Hammegk said:
What falsifiable axiom underlies your worldview? The axiom required for science is not falsifiable, but is taken on faith.

Axiom 1. Objective reality exists;

and to arrive at that point, Axiom 0. Thought exists.
There is no axiom about objective reality, if by that you mean an ontological axiom. We only need a definition about what is "real" (things that have affects on other things), axioms about real things behaving according to consistent logical laws, and about the ability to observe things to determine the laws. These axioms are falsifiable, in the sense that we could notice if the laws turn out to be capricious or there appear to be effects whose causes we cannot fathom.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Mojo said:
Science makes the basic assumption that what we observe is a reflection of an objective universe.
But this need not be an "external, physical universe." How would we know? Science really only needs the axioms listed in my previous post.

That said, most scientists certainly assume that there is an external, physical universe. When evidence arises for the Matrix, or brain in a vat, or computer simulation, or everything-is-mind, then that assumption will be shown to be incorrect. Meanwhile, the assumption doesn't really matter. If someone wants to criticize science because scientists make ontological assumptions, fine, but it's a pretty vapid criticism.

~~ Paul
 
Von said:
My personal interests have to do with leading edge Science, of course at a superficial level. The fact that we must postulate very strange ideas, more than ever, to generate theory for gravity means we cannot hold on too tightly to old classical beliefs. For instance, apparently the belief that we live in a continuous (as in analog, or non-discrete) universe is still taken on faith by many scientists. Is that still a question? ...whether space/time and everything in it is fundamentally discrete?
See now, this is a misuse of the word faith. Some scientists may assume that the universe is continuous and may turn out to be wrong in the future. But if the assumption makes no difference to their work, then what's the problem? A problem arises if the physics establishment refuses to budge in light of compelling evidence for a discrete universe, but then those old farts die and the young turks assume discreteness.

None of this is a reason to scoff at the close-mindedness of science any more than it is a reason to scoff at the close-mindedness of other human endeavors.

~~ Paul
 
Well if it does we have absolutely no idea as to what its true nature is.
When you say "we have absolutely no idea" I think you mean that we can only "have an idea" as to what is the true nature of reality. Perhaps our ideas approach a vanishingly small amount of truth, but they are non-zero.

I have written programs in ancient times for little embedded controllers, so-called Harvard machines, where the program could not be written that would do a checksum of the code space. This analogy, of a program not being able to see its own code, is something like our human condition, I think. We may see some things but not others - it may be impossible.

In the case of the microcontroller, it possessed nothing in the instruction set that would allow access to the whole code space. While the program cannot 'see' itself, it can have access to things that infer the existence of flip-flops in the ALU and various other things. There are many levels of hidden complexity it cannot see - the logic, the structure of the layers of semiconductor that make up the mechanism of the logic, the atoms in the semiconductor, etc.

I think that is our condition, that from within the system we cannot go around it and see the true system. Some things we must take on faith and some things we will never even be able to guess at. The only possibility of seeing more of 'the thing' would be through the I/O port if it were possible to find some way to poke something through it to get another aspect. Admittedly, this analogy conjecture is somewhere close to nonsense - just to stimulate some 'outside the chip' thinking.
 
See now, this is a misuse of the word faith. Some scientists may assume that the universe is continuous and may turn out to be wrong in the future. But if the assumption makes no difference to their work, then what's the problem? A problem arises if the physics establishment refuses to budge in light of compelling evidence for a discrete universe, but then those old farts die and the young turks assume discreteness.

None of this is a reason to scoff at the close-mindedness of science any more than it is a reason to scoff at the close-mindedness of other human endeavors.

~~ Paul
Faith is a convienient word in our language that means "belief without or with insufficient evidence. I agree we should scoff "isotropically" - which is what I am trying to balance here. You see? You perceive my pointing something out as having been aimed. Yes, aimed only to try to give fairness to the "faith accusation" argument. I have had responses to posts from certain individuals that appear to me that they think they take nothing on faith - none of us take nothing on faith.
 
:) I am curious what means the little tildes: "~~", when you sign?

"...very approximately" ?
"...very proportional to" ?
"...very equivalent" ?
contrails?
smoke?
not not ?
DNA helices?
spermatazoa?
nematodes?
artistic vignette?

I pick DNA helices. Am I right?
 
Last edited:
I used to love these kinds of discussions back in my undergrad days. I assume (charitably?) that Von Neumann posted his question in that dorm room bull session spirit. Now, I suspect I've lost more than a few IQ points to age, and a certain curmudgeonliness has replaced them.

As a practical person of average intellect (below average, alas, where math is concerned) I am merely content now to paraphrase Churchill: Science may be a bad method for understanding the Universe, but the others are so much worse.
 
Last edited:
The sun will not rise tomorrow , rather the Earth will rotate until the sun lights things up again .
Of course I've only got what my senses have chosen to pass on to me so it might not really happen even if I think that it does .
Doh, my brain hurts!
 
Von said:
Faith is a convienient word in our language that means "belief without or with insufficient evidence. I agree we should scoff "isotropically" - which is what I am trying to balance here. You see? You perceive my pointing something out as having been aimed. Yes, aimed only to try to give fairness to the "faith accusation" argument. I have had responses to posts from certain individuals that appear to me that they think they take nothing on faith - none of us take nothing on faith.

2 a (1) : belief and trust in and loyalty to God (2) : belief in the traditional doctrines of a religion b (1) : firm belief in something for which there is no proof (2) : complete trust
3 : something that is believed especially with strong conviction; especially : a system of religious beliefs

The only definition that applies at all is b(1), and it doesn't apply too well. There may be firm belief in a continuous universe, but there is some evidence that the universe is continuous. If that evidence is supplanted by stronger evidence that the universe is discrete, and the physics community refuses to embrace the evidence over a long period of time, then I'll be happy to entertain the idea that the physics community has an entrenched belief.

The problem with the word belief is that it usually pertains to religion, where there is no intention of abandoning entrenched beliefs regardless of the evidence. I think you are using the word carelessly.

~~ Paul
 
Noooooo, this circularity defines inductive reasoning. It is logically valid for being what it is.

Uniformitarianism is axiomatic, sure. As Jimbo07 points out: that's a scientific axiom that differentiates itself from many religions (eg: biblical literalists revile uniformitarianism).

You make a good point there, and it does make me feel a bit better about the situation (believe it or not this is the sort of thing that I lie awake worrying about at night). I suppose it's true that any system of argumentation rests on one or more fundamental principles that simply have to be accepted as primitive or self-evident, and uniformity of nature seems much more plausible to take on "faith" than does the existence of an invisible, onmipotent man in the sky.

As to the existence of external objects problem, I'm less concerned about that one though it is still important to acknowledge as defining an edge, beyond which the scientific method (bound as it is by the assumption of uniformity) can cast no light. I'm not really uncomfortable making the concession that, yes, the scientific method does assume the existence of external objects with no sufficient evidence to prove that proposition scientifically, but on the basis of that assumption it can tell us a lot about how those stipulated external objects work, and is the best tool we have for predicting how they will work in the future. That said, I suppose to answer VonNeumann's question, we might say that science is a tiny bit like religion, in that it does rest its conclusions on a couple of principles for which it can offer no rational justification, but not very much like religion at all, because 1) science acknowledges up front that its assumptions are just that, and does not insist that they are unquestionable and absolute truths, and 2) scientific inquiry rests only on a couple of foundational axiomatic principles, whereas religion builds an entire fortress out of assertions of faith.

I would be interested in working out the corollaries to the observation that the scientific method can offer no insight into the truth value of propositions that lack empirically testable content (which may, of course, nevertheless be true). The brain in a vat problem is one of these. The God of deism is another, although the God of theism, to the extent that it meddles in the material world and thus would leave empirically observable traces, is not. What other things might we want to know that the scientific method can't tell us anything about?
 
What other things might we want to know that the scientific method can't tell us anything about?

Eternal truth, justice, beauty, love. Those are the first ones that come to my mind. Science does not deal well with intangibles. But who wants to claim that such things do not exist or live in a world without them?

eta: I suppose this whole thread has been about the existence/knowledge of eternal truth, at least in one sense.
 
Beth said:
Eternal truth, justice, beauty, love. Those are the first ones that come to my mind. Science does not deal well with intangibles. But who wants to claim that such things do not exist or live in a world without them?
Why can't science tell us something about these things? After all, they are human behaviors. Perhaps science can't tell us what we wish to hear about them.

~~ Paul
 
Why can't science tell us something about these things? After all, they are human behaviors. Perhaps science can't tell us what we wish to hear about them.

~~ Paul

And that's what I was after when I first asked what form non-scientific truths might take. Math and logic are part of the scientific tool set.

Long ago (and I didn't follow up on physics at the time, much to my chagrin), a physics instructor made a joke about physics only studying measurable things, and not intangibles like love (the joke was: "She was 10 milliHelens, and he loved her 5 Megahormones :D"). I believe this was simply a conceit to get certain students off his back.

Like Paul said, it may be that science does have something to say about love. It can tell us things about hormone levels in the blood. It can tell us about the biochemical encoding of memories... in short, if we are simply machines, then it is the abstract concepts such as consciousness, love and beauty which are illusions, not physical reality.

The only failing that science has (and it's a doozy) is that it is a human endeavour. It is a human endeavour in the same way as math, dating and yes, VN, faith are. It is subject to the foibles of its participants. If humans are indeed machines, then any practice is subject to the limitations of those machines. However, it does have an impressive track record...

And VN, 14 minutes before you said, "Yes, and of course rejecting science is in no way suggested."
Ian said, "What about via mystical experiences?"

Speaking of faith...

:rolleyes:
 
Why can't science tell us something about these things? After all, they are human behaviors. Perhaps science can't tell us what we wish to hear about them.

~~ Paul

Yes, science can tell us some things about such non-tangibles. We can measure subjective perceptions of such things. We could, theoretically,measure various physical attributions, such as blood pressure, pulse, hormone levels, etc. and correlate physical states with subjective statements such as "I love A" or "I think outcome B is just", but in the end, we cannot know objectively what is beautiful or what constitutes justice. We can only know what we perceive to be beautiful or just. This seems much the same problem that VN and JD have been expounding upon.

Like objective reality, we can compare our perceptions to how others describe the same thing and try and find a consistentcy amonst our perception. We might even put together a scale and thereby 'measure' the amount of justice or beauty or love is about. But we can never know with certainty whether what we perceive of something as basic as 'red' is the same as how others perceive it. This subjective nature of the problem is simply more apparent than it is with what we term 'objective' reality.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom