To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

James said:
Hume's argument is more than that-- it's an observation that not only could we be wrong, but we have no reason to believe that we're right, even when inductive reasoning accurately predicts the outcome of an experiment.
Right and wrong about what?

~~ Paul
 
James said:
Predictions about the future based on inductive conclusions drawn from empirical observation. Take a look at post #46.
Ah, that we have no basis to believe in the uniformity and consistency of nature. Yes, true enough, we have to assume that. But at least it is a falsifiable assumption. So far, so good, apparently.

~~ Paul
 
No, I believe space is whatever the dictionary says it is.

You're asking unspecific questions. "What would happen in this situation, X or Y?" is a specific question.

What does all of this have to do with your equating Science with Faith?
Even the Britainica in the 20s or 30s had a definition of space-time authored by Einstein where he posits the idea of 'space containing nothing is nothing.'

I am speaking on the nature of what we call 'evidence'. Space is evidently like a stage, and yet, evidently is no such thing. Our perceptions are fooled. For instance, what happens in the experiment of what appears to be FTL signalling between remote particles is troubling. Was there faster than light signalling? We need a model to explain this.

On the other hand, if the 'stage' is merely our own mental construct, I can say the couch is against the East wall and the table is agains the West wall, and you construct such an image in your mind's 'stage'. The couch and the table are 8 words apart in the sentence but across the room in your mental image, and maybe microns apart in your synapses.

I can write a program where I define a graphic of a couch and display the couch image multiple places on the monitor screen. There is only one couch even though they appear in different places on the screen. I could define one couch to be on Pluto and the other on Earth. Then, if the definition of the couch graphic is changed in the program, they all change. Our perception may suggest we observe FTL signalling.

My question now to you is whether a simulation-like model as I suggested that might begin to answer the FTL problem without anything travelling FTL, is that a scientific approach?
 
If reality were a dream, then whose dream is it? Your dream? Perhaps it is my dream or drkitten’s? I know, it is God’s dream, he/she/it would be able to create the thoughts, feeling, experiences, and interactions between all 4 billion+ people here on Earth within his dream. Not to mention the interaction between all the other life on the planet.

Try thinking about how complex the interactions of life really are; try to encompass it all for any given day. How many gazelles were eaten by lions today? How many leaves on trees in Brazil were eaten by insects? How many bacteria were killed by your white blood cells today, or how about the number that were killed by every animal’s immune system today? How many fish were eaten today by people, sharks, dolphins, other fish, bears, birds, etc? Do you believe that all of this stops when you’re not thinking or are aware of it? I think it takes a particularly well trained sense of arrogance to believe that our perceptions create or change the reality we inhabit.
I do not see what is arrogant about "to believe that our perceptions create or change the reality we inhabit". It is spooky, not 'arrogant'.

Does "collapse of the wave function" mean anything to you? Do you think that the 30 years that shook physics humbled physicists or amplified their hubris.
 
First, there is no FTL information transfer, in any meaningful sense of 'information'.

Second, 'collapse of the wave function' does not have anything to do with consciousness. That is an interpretation of quantum mechanics, and an unsupported one, at that. Don't talk QM unless you can show the math, because QM is math.

When you can show the math, derived from the QM equations, to prove that consciousness has anything to do with wave function collapse, please do so.

Another point, on space without objects. If you have space with no objects, how could you tell? The entire concept of space is meaningless without objects or physical things of some nature (energy, fields, etc) in it. So yes, you must have object(s) to have space in any meaningful, useful sense of the word.
 
when we stipulate that we're believing the proposition that our observations reflect external reality without evidence for it, it seems fair to me to say that we're taking that proposition as a matter of faith..

No, we're taking that proposition as a theory that best reflects the evidence acquired so far. Humans excel at identifying patterns, and when our observations turn one up we make it a "working theory" that the observed pattern reflects reality.

the fact that nature has been uniform up to this point provides no evidence that it will continue to be uniform, because the very idea of prediction on the basis of empirical evidence rests on the assumption of the uniformity of nature, which itself cannot be proved without resort to empirical evidence. This circularity undermines the logical validity of inductive reasoning.

But does not undermine the human tendency to make that assumption anyway. Whether our observations reflect a genuine reality or a created reality that we only believe is genuine, practically speaking doesn't amount to a hill of beans. It's still the reality you are experiencing, and that you have to deal with. The philosophical question is interesting but only as an intellectual exercise: it doesn't have any real effect on your observations or on the world you observe.


Edited to fix typos
 
Last edited:
No, we're taking that proposition as a theory that best reflects the evidence acquired so far. Humans excel at identifying patterns, and when our observations turn one up we make it a "working theory" that the observed pattern reflects reality.

But I don't think it's fair to say that we have any evidence, one way or the other, regarding a proposition that is untestable by the scientific method, which is why I don't think drkitten's reliance on Occam's Razor is useful here. Our assumption of the reality of the external world really does seem to be a matter of faith.


But does not undermine the human tendency to make that assumption anyway. Whether our observations reflect a genuine reality or a created reality that we only believe is genuine, practically speaking doesn't amount to a hill of beans. It's still the reality you are experiencing, and that you have to deal with. The philosophical question is interesting but only as an intellectual exercise: it doesn't have any real effect on your observations or on the world you observe.

True enough; maybe it is only an interesting intellectual exercise. As I've said before, I'm not suggesting that we abandon the scientific method, and you're right that, in practice, we really can't do anything but continue making inductive inferences regardless of their logical foundation, or lack thereof. But I still think that these boundaries on human knowledge are worth acknowledging and contemplating from time to time.
 
Last edited:
First, there is no FTL information transfer, in any meaningful sense of 'information'.
Yes, that is my point. Some have posited a violation of SOL - I am not. I was positing that the correlation could be along the lines as I described. Would that be considered a hidden variable view?

Second, 'collapse of the wave function' does not have anything to do with consciousness. That is an interpretation of quantum mechanics, and an unsupported one, at that. Don't talk QM unless you can show the math, because QM is math.
Yes. You tell me not to talk about something? I am not arguing about the validity of the interpretation. I was addressing what the poster considered was arrogant. I think arrogance has nothing to do with these sorts of interpretations, do you?


When you can show the math, derived from the QM equations, to prove that consciousness has anything to do with wave function collapse, please do so.
You presume my purpose for discussion here is to argue against you or someone because you presume I disagree. One thing I believe is that the QM interpetation battle is not over until we get much closer to TOE.

Another point, on space without objects. If you have space with no objects, how could you tell? The entire concept of space is meaningless without objects or physical things of some nature (energy, fields, etc) in it. So yes, you must have object(s) to have space in any meaningful, useful sense of the word.
OK, good. Now, what does it mean then? Does that mean that spatial-position (like [x,y,z]) is merely information that goes with the object, and there really IS no space - no real 'stage'.
 
Science requires a few axioms of observation. We have to take those "on faith," although they are falsifiable.

~~ Paul
What falsifiable axiom underlies your worldview? The axiom required for science is not falsifiable, but is taken on faith.

Axiom 1. Objective reality exists;

and to arrive at that point, Axiom 0. Thought exists.
 
I do not see what is arrogant about "to believe that our perceptions create or change the reality we inhabit". It is spooky, not 'arrogant'.

Does "collapse of the wave function" mean anything to you? Do you think that the 30 years that shook physics humbled physicists or amplified their hubris.
Looks like you’ve scanned through some scientific papers and picked up a few new words to use.

In the sense of your reality could be a dream statement, no, “collapse of the wave function” doesn’t mean anything to me. Could you please explain this?

Now if you’d like to talk about physics, more specifically quantum mechanics, then perhaps wave function collapse might mean something. However, you should know that not all interpretations of QM include the collapse of the wave function. Perhaps you should look up quantum decoherence, or maybe Erwin Schrödinger.

I have to admit though, that I’m not a QM wiz. I’m more of an interested enthusiast with no formal schooling in the area so some of the math can go over my head at times. :)
 
MRC_Hans' practical test of Solipsism .(tm)
Disclaimer: This experiment might not only bruise your ego, but also your body, so you undertake it entirely at your own risk. I will not be held responsible for any consequences, including, but not limited to, loss of pride, peace of mind, teeth, etc.
1) Find a busy city street.
2) Wait for large aggressive looking male to walk by (generally, the more tattoos, the better).
3) Walk up behind said large aggressive looking male and direct a solid kick at the lower, rear portion of his body.
4) When he turns, tell him: "That was because you mother is so ugly".
5) Observe.
You will now have tangible evidence for the following:
a) You exist physically.
b) At least one other entity exists physically.
c) You and that other entity are in communication, both abstractly and physically.
d) The other entity probably has a mother.
You may conclude that all your observations are, after all, part of an illusion, but the experience should convince you that you had better treat the illusion as reality .
Good luck!


Don't thank me, you're welcome!

Hans :biggrin:
Why not just kick the rock if you honestly think it's that easy? Answer: because you know it isn't. BTW, kindergarten is down the hall on the left, iirc. ;)
 
Even the Britainica in the 20s or 30s had a definition of space-time authored by Einstein where he posits the idea of 'space containing nothing is nothing.'

What does this mean; what quesitons does it answer? It may be obvious to you, but it means nothing to us. You mine as well have written 'nothing is nothing'. Who can disagree with that; what are you trying to say?

You wrote a lot more, and all I can say is four thing:

1) There is no couch, only the representation of a couch on a computer screen
2) WFT is FTL? Stop acting like we're all inside your head and following along the conversation with you. You need to actually convey your thoughts and ideas with words; otherwise you look crazy.
3) What does this have to do with equating science with faith?
 
Last edited:
VonNeumann,
I'm very sorry to see the level of derision and unwarranted dismissiveness that your post has met with so far. Personally I've been struggling with this and similar issues for a while now, and while I still hold out some hope that the scientific method can ultimately be rationally justified, I haven't found the way to do it yet. To those who dismissively point out that this is an issue that has been raised before (it goes way back before The Matrix, in case some of you were unaware), that's certainly true, but it keeps arising because unfortunately no one has yet offered a satisfactory response to it. (Or maybe someone has, and I'm just unaware of it).
....
I don't see how one gets around either of these problems, and I think you're right that there does seem to be something hypocritical in the skeptical insistence that beliefs be founded on evidence rather than on faith, when belief founded on evidence still ultimately rests on faith. I'm still a skeptic, though, because it feels right, and I hope that eventually I'll come across a plausible rebuttal of the problems discussed above. For what it's worth, I agree with you that those who refuse to acknowledge those problems are acting on a quasi-religious belief of the sort they condemn in others.


Edit: Here's the link to my previous discussion of this issue. Start reading at post 15 (the opening post is really, really long, and not entirely relevant to this subject). http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=52936
Thank you for bringing dignity from the 'skeptic' community. You gave the surly posters an undeserved chance to redeem themselves a little. That's good - they needed an out - they couldn't help themselves.

I could not have had a better reaction though, to illustrate to the objective observer, that to question the fundamentals is heresy and brings out a fanatical frenzy. ...most ugly. ...walks like a duck: it's religion.

Oh, and I am only speaking of a couple or so people here - I appreciate heart felt objections. Lively is cool. Humorous sarcasm is cool. ...but name-calling to avoid the point is ... (self-explanatory).

I went to the thread you linked and see that there is a lot to read there as well as the discussion you fostered here. This sort of discussion is what I was hoping to see. The historical philosophy references are very interesting.

Material empiricism ain't what it used to be. The great minds working on quantum gravity must keep themselves much more freethinking than the suffocating constraints of view I generally see here. There is a strange safety in numbers cult here, a pack dog or bully mentality thang... Science has never moved forward well with the collective mentality - individualism reigns:) .
 
What does this mean; what quesitons does it answer? It may be obvious to you, but it means nothing to us. You mine as well have written 'nothing is nothing'. Who can disagree with that; what are you trying to say?

You wrote a lot more, and all I can say is four thing:

1) There is no couch, only the representation of a couch on a computer screen
2) WFT is FTL? Stop acting like we're all inside your head and following along the conversation with you. You need to actually convey your thoughts and ideas with words; otherwise you look crazy.
3) What does this have to do with equating science with faith?
I think you meant WTF not WFT.

FTL is Faster Than Light. Please search for Bell's Theorem/Paradox. I suggest that the quantum entanglement points toward a computer simulation reality, where what appears to be two objects in two different places is really one object with ambiguous position vectors, and dual spin attributes for instance. If one object changes the other changes instantly. In a simulation, see, the objects are in computer memory and their 'image' on the 'screen' of reality can fool you because you cannot see what is really happening in the CPU of the simulator.

While my idea sounds crazy, it is no more crazy than the types of things already posited by theorists working on quantum gravity, IMHO.

Do you see how it relates to the original post?
 
Looks like you’ve scanned through some scientific papers and picked up a few new words to use.

In the sense of your reality could be a dream statement, no, “collapse of the wave function” doesn’t mean anything to me. Could you please explain this?

Now if you’d like to talk about physics, more specifically quantum mechanics, then perhaps wave function collapse might mean something. However, you should know that not all interpretations of QM include the collapse of the wave function. Perhaps you should look up quantum decoherence, or maybe Erwin Schrödinger.

I have to admit though, that I’m not a QM wiz. I’m more of an interested enthusiast with no formal schooling in the area so some of the math can go over my head at times. :)
OK. I didn't really see your point. You thought I was making a case for solipsism. ...I wasn't in particular, but OK. Actually, that is pretty hilarious that a solipsist is arrogant - like extreeeeeeemly arrogant :) .
 
A non-scientific truth?

Math. More like "extra-scientific" or "transcendent"...

Eek!

Hoisted by my own petard... almost. I was careless to ask both "What form would it take?" and "What if you used a system of formal symbolic logic to demonstrate something untrue (such as unphysical solutions to differential equations)?" in the same post.

so... a mathematical truth without a physical consequence, or constraining mathematical truths with physical conditions?

[math junk]
Say a rod has some initial heat distribution along its length. The general solution for how that heat distribution changes over time is a linear combination of solutions. However, by defining physical constraints (boundary conditions) such as holding each end to a constant temperature, specific solutions are selected, and the rest can be tossed out. They could, in a sense, be worked out mathematically (by selecting non-physical boundary conditions), but they just don't fit the physical system.

Another example is the normalization constant, A, in the infinite square well. You're left with the equation A*A=2/L. There could be a negative root, but it has no physical implication, so it can be discarded. A negative root is algebraically, mathematically valid, it just has no physical meaning. The infinite square well, itself, is not a physical system, but serves as a mathematical stepping stone for newbies such as myself.
[/math junk]


I see math/formal symbolic logic as a tool. One has to be careful that any 'transcendent' truths don't turn out to be meaningless.

In fact, it has already been pointed out that logic/math has underlying axioms. If you think you're being logical by pointing out that science has axioms, you're illogically disregarding the need for axioms in logic! Logic runs up against the same limitation that you're trying to impose on science.

JamesD: Getting caught in a logical snarl (needing some sort of absolute proof) can obscure the relative successes that science has had in expanding human knowledge. I've already indicated my respect for true philosophers in the big bang thread, I'm just saying that you can take some comfort in not actually needing some sort of absolute proof of the validity of science.

or, forgiving my rambling... what drkitten said :D (So if you reject "science" as a method of acquiring knowledge, you are literally left with .... nothing.)
 
Sorry, that was unclear. I meant we don't have evidence for the reality of external observations, so, when we stipulate that we're believing the proposition that our observations reflect external reality without evidence for it, it seems fair to me to say that we're taking that proposition as a matter of faith.

I think you may be missing a subtlety of the problem of induction, which is most likely more a matter of my inarticulate exposition of it than your comprehension skills. But to try again: the fact that nature has been uniform up to this point provides no evidence that it will continue to be uniform, because the very idea of prediction on the basis of empirical evidence rests on the assumption of the uniformity of nature, which itself cannot be proved without resort to empirical evidence. This circularity undermines the logical validity of inductive reasoning.

Noooooo, this circularity defines inductive reasoning. It is logically valid for being what it is.

Uniformitarianism is axiomatic, sure. As Jimbo07 points out: that's a scientific axiom that differentiates itself from many religions (eg: biblical literalists revile uniformitarianism).

Certainly, this is a semantic argument: 'faith' has a lot of meanings. If you mean "is science just like a religion?" the answer is: "no, there are a lot of differences, the most important of which is that religion doesn't test its axioms."
 
Last edited:
Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?

By definition, Science is constrained in scope to that which can be empirically demonstrated. A relationship that can be demonstrated between what our senses send to our brain, our observations, and an external objective reality, must be performed via the same observation mechanism. So can we validate objectively?

We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us. So is it not an illusion or a preferred paradigm, this idea, that only those things are real which can be Scientifically proven?

If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation. I am curious what others think about this.
Science makes the basic assumption that what we observe is a reflection of an objective universe.

This is an assumption that each of us makes, and uses in our daily life. For example, earlier today I woke up. I assumed that I was observing light because the rotation of the Earth had brought the Sun above the horizon, and that it was therefore a reasonable time to get up (it's Saturday, so I didn't bother looking at the clock). I assumed that the sensation of pressure in my abdomen was caused by a full bladder, so I went to the bathroom. I assumed that the sensation of hunger I was experiencing would be alleviated by food, so I went to make breakfast. Over the next few minutes I made a wide variety of assumptions, for example that the eggs I found in the box on the kitchen counter were real, that the eggshells would contain eggs and not, for example, soap, that water would boil at a high enough temperature to cook the eggs...

All of these assumptions were based on my previous observations of the way the universe appears to work, and the assumption that these observations could be used to predict how the universe would continue to work; any other approach would be madness. I'm sure that you rely on the same basic assumptions in your day-to-day life.

Science simply relies on the same assumption that you and I have been using all day (in fact all our lives): that our observations reflect reality, and that this reality is in some way consistent.

I see no reason to abandon the assumption about the nature of reality that we make as part of our day-to-day lives simply because we're thinking about something called "science". Can you provide a compelling reason to do this?

Does science = faith? Science is based on what we can observe about the universe (although, as you have pointed out, it does rely on the assumption that our observations reflect an objective reality). On the other hand, "faith" is defined, in the context that you're using the word here, as strong belief (usually in some sort of religion) without strong observable evidence (although I think you'll find that even people of faith, in their everyday lives, rely on exactly the same assumption about the nature of the universe that I've been relying on so far today). So no, science does not equal faith.
 
Last edited:
Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?

This is a perfectly reasonable hypothesis.

We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us.

Well if it does we have absolutely no idea as to what its true nature is.


So is it not an illusion or a preferred paradigm, this idea, that only those things are real which can be Scientifically proven?

Obviously this is utterly nonsensical.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom