To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

No more so than we have to remain conscious that because my telephone only lets me talk to distant people, but doesn't make sandwiches, that is somehow a limitation on my telephone...The scientific method works great -- better than anything else we have -- for describing the visible world.

I don't disagree with that, but I think that we frequently give in to the temptation to think that the scientific method is a tool for discovering all possible truths. It isn't. (Please don't suggest that I'm about to make an argument for God or homeopathy or alien mind control. I'm an atheist and as much of a skeptic as anyone here, but I still see that there are some propositions about which the scientific method is unable to inform us.)
 
The "brain in the vat" does not know if there is a sun in the sense that we think the sun exists. Let me try something: what is your idea of 'space'? It is like a 'stage' on/in which objects have a position? If there are no objects, is there still 'space'?

If you are really a brain in a vat and unable to tell the reality you're experiencing is not real, there's no reason for you to live your live any different than a 'real' person.

I don't understand what space has to do with this. You haven't answered my questions, and I don't know why you're asking these, to me it seems like they're coming from nowhere.

And, in fact, yes, I think that if there are no objects, there is still space, since that is the definition of space:

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=space

3b. A blank or empty area: the spaces between words.

But I'm just being into words having actual meanings, so whatever floats your boat.
 
See, this is why I hate Philosophy. I don't only think the sun will come up tomorrow because I experienced that in my every day life. I have also drawn upon the lives and knowledge of others. I understand how a person could draw an incorrect conclusion from their experiences.

Well, that's an even weaker justification, isn't it? If you can't be sure of your own experiences, relying on the experiences of others just introduces more doubt into the equation, does it not?
 
Well, that's an even weaker justification, isn't it? If you can't be sure of your own experiences, relying on the experiences of others just introduces more doubt into the equation, does it not?

However, "doubt" does not eliminate justification.

See the lottery example above.
 
Or its legitimacy as a justification for belief.

A belief can be justified without being formally proven.

Can you explain to me exactly what you mean by "justification"? Does that mean probable? If it does, then it still seems like it rests on the principle of uniformity of nature, which can't be established by non-circular reasoning. If "justification" means something else, then I don't think I understand what you're saying.
 
I don't disagree with that, but I think that we frequently give in to the temptation to think that the scientific method is a tool for discovering all possible truths.

I think you're the only person here who has even suggested that it is.

The problem is one of unreasonable standards.

First, despite what you said earlier, the scientific method is justifiable. It's just not provably valid. If your standards for epistemology require that any method be provably valid, however, then you will find yourself with no methods whatsoever, because such methods are provably impossible. Any proof requires assumptions (structurally), which in turn means that those assumptions cannot be dealt with within the methodological structure your epistemology requires.

And this was known to Euclid. That's why he left some terms, notably "point" and "line," undefined -- because there are no terms to define them in. Evidently Hume wasn't a very good mathematician.

Second, the scientific method is of limited applicability. But aside from the scientific method, we have no objectively justifiable methods of acquiring knowledge at all (for the simple reason that if something were objectively justifiable as a method of acquiring knowledge, it would have been incorporated into "science" as soon as it had been identified. Scientists are pragmatic like that). So if you reject "science" as a method of acquiring knowledge, you are literally left with .... nothing.
 
But not its predictive power.

True-- and therein lies the problem, really. I can't see a way around the problem as Hume articulated it, but it does seem to be the case that inductive reasoning is a pretty consistent, reliable tool. This is why I hold out-- on nothing more than faith, really-- the hope that there is some valid response to Hume's argument. I've been told that Karl Popper made a well-regarded try at it, and someone recommended a book to me that I haven't had a chance to read yet. So in the meantime, I keep reasoning inductively while at the same time worrying about my apparent lack of justification for doing so.

Drkitten said:
Second, the scientific method is of limited applicability. But aside from the scientific method, we have no objectively justifiable methods of acquiring knowledge at all (for the simple reason that if something were objectively justifiable as a method of acquiring knowledge, it would have been incorporated into "science" as soon as it had been identified. Scientists are pragmatic like that). So if you reject "science" as a method of acquiring knowledge, you are literally left with .... nothing.

I agree-- and I'm certainly not advocating an abandonment of the scientific method. Still, I do see the problems we're discussing as limitations on it-- maybe not limitations on its proper use, but on the use to which it's frequently put. I am even less of a mathematician than Hume, but didn't Godel establish that no consistent mathmatical system is capable of proving all true statements? I've been wondering lately if the same might be said of the scientific method-- it is a consistent system for proving a number of truths, but there nevertheless exist true propositions that can't be proven by its terms? (Either the statement "Empirical observations reflect external reality" or its negation would necessarily be one of these). If it's the best we can do, then so be it-- I certainly can't offer another system of knowledge by which such propositions could be tested. But I still think that these ~limitations are important to keep in mind, and that VonNeumann has a point that those who refuse to acknowledge them are basing their beliefs on faith in much the same manner as religious fundamentalists do.
 
Last edited:
I don't disagree with that, but I think that we frequently give in to the temptation to think that the scientific method is a tool for discovering all possible truths. It isn't.

Okay, we'll go down the same road I went down with VN...

I am now assuming that a non-scientific truth exists. What form would it take? Why would it be interesting? What if you used a system of formal symbolic logic to demonstrate something untrue (such as unphysical solutions to differential equations)?

Take me from here, man! (VN couldn't...)
 
If you are really a brain in a vat and unable to tell the reality you're experiencing is not real, there's no reason for you to live your live any different than a 'real' person.

I don't understand what space has to do with this. You haven't answered my questions, and I don't know why you're asking these, to me it seems like they're coming from nowhere.

And, in fact, yes, I think that if there are no objects, there is still space, since that is the definition of space:

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=space

3b. A blank or empty area: the spaces between words.

But I'm just being into words having actual meanings, so whatever floats your boat.
I note some sarcasm. The 'brain in a vat' is merely a place to start so I can get some opinion from you.

I meant 'space' in the sense of the 'aether', or the vacuum of space - way out there somewhere. When MM experiment seemed to prove the non-existence of aether, a cascade of paradigm shifts have pervaded until now. I think you answered my question: you believe 'space' is like a stage, right?
 
Can you explain to me exactly what you mean by "justification"? Does that mean probable?

No. Justification simply means that there is reason to believe something is true. Certainly believing something is true because it is probably is a legitimate justification, absent further information. I believe that the city of Tokyo is still there [has not been eaten by Godzilla] because I find it improbable that it has disappeared.... and I have no further information at this time. If I really wanted to, I could fly to Tokyo and check, but that still wouldn't "prove" the statement.


If it does, then it still seems like it rests on the principle of uniformity of nature, which can't be established by non-circular reasoning.

So what? We have ample demonstration -- including the ability to perform new experiements -- to justify the belief in the uniformity of nature.

Basically, you're saying "but you can't PROVE that the sun will rise tomorrow!"

However, that doesn't make my belief that the sun will rise tomorrow any less justified. The question I ask you is, "do I have reason to believe that ths sun will, in fact, rise tomorrow?" If I do, then my belief is justified, despite the absence of formal proof. If I do not, then you should be willing to accept a small wager....
 
True-- and therein lies the problem, really. I can't see a way around the problem as Hume articulated it, but it does seem to be the case that it's a pretty consistent, reliable tool.

That's because the problem as Hume articulated is, simply put, not a problem.

Its an observation that we could be wrong.

To which any practicing scientist will shrug and say, "yeah."

If you press him on it, he's likely to offer you a bet and take large amounts of money from you.

Still, I do see the problems we're discussing as limitations on it-- maybe not limitations on its proper use, but on the use to which it's frequently put. I am even less of a mathematician than Hume, but didn't Godel establish that no consistent mathmatical system is capable of proving all true statements? I've been wondering lately if the same might be said of the scientific method-- it is a consistent system for proving a number of truths, but there nevertheless exist true propositions that can't be proven by its terms?

No.

Because the "scientific method" is not a "system" iin the Godelian sense, Godel's theorem does not apply to it. In practice, what usually seems to happen is that "science" appears to be inconsistant, in that there are a lot of "scientific" beliefs for which one can justify believing either the statement or its negation.

Again, to which any practicing scientist will shrug and say, "yeah, we're still working on that one."
 
Okay, we'll go down the same road I went down with VN...

I am now assuming that a non-scientific truth exists. What form would it take? Why would it be interesting? What if you used a system of formal symbolic logic to demonstrate something untrue (such as unphysical solutions to differential equations)?

Take me from here, man! (VN couldn't...)
A non-scientific truth?

Math. More like "extra-scientific" or "transcendent"...
 
No system can ever prove its own validity. That's just how it is. While we have no way of proving our observations are real, without evidence to the contrary, we must assume they are because we have nothing else to go off of.
 
I meant 'space' in the sense of the 'aether', or the vacuum of space - way out there somewhere. When MM experiment seemed to prove the non-existence of aether, a cascade of paradigm shifts have pervaded until now. I think you answered my question: you believe 'space' is like a stage, right?

No, I believe space is whatever the dictionary says it is.

You're asking unspecific questions. "What would happen in this situation, X or Y?" is a specific question.

What does all of this have to do with your equating Science with Faith?
 
Well, that's an even weaker justification, isn't it? If you can't be sure of your own experiences, relying on the experiences of others just introduces more doubt into the equation, does it not?

Uh... no. It introduces non-doubt into the equation faster that it introduces doubt. Also, other people have more/difference knowledge and I do, such as astronauts, astronomers, and physcists.
 
That's because the problem as Hume articulated is, simply put, not a problem.
Its an observation that we could be wrong.

Hume's argument is more than that-- it's an observation that not only could we be wrong, but we have no reason to believe that we're right, even when inductive reasoning accurately predicts the outcome of an experiment. Obviously this seems to contradict some deeply ingrained method of reasoning common to everyone. I suppose you're right, though, that it's not a "problem" in that we really can't help reasoning inductively, and it does seem to produce beneficial results, so we might as well keep doing it. That's pretty much the conclusion that Hume reached, as well.

No.

Because the "scientific method" is not a "system" in the Godelian sense, Godel's theorem does not apply to it.

I was making an analogy there; I realize that the scientific method is not a mathematical system. And in any case, there seems to be no alternative system for evaluating empirical questions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom