To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Evidence? What evidence?

Not that this topic has anything whatsoever to do with this thread, but why do so called skeptics continually feel compelled to lie about this issue (as well as there being no evidence for paranormal phenomena). In both cases there is a huge amount of evidence. ...

The lack of evidence is not a lie, it's a fact based upon several thousands of years of observations and failed experiments.

Could you please provide some of what you consider to be evidence?

You seem to be equating the lack of scientific understanding with evidence that something supernatural must be going on to explain that lack of understanding.

For those who suggest that paranormal evidence exists, I would like to see this evidence and expose it to competent scientific evaluation. So far, that's the point at which ALL supernatural claims fail to work. Otherwise why is the $1 million JREF prize not yet claimed by one of the 6+ billion people on Earth by now?

It's amazing how often a 'psychic' or similar nut has his/her powers fade away within the confines of properly implemented scientific controls and trained observers. These same people often work wonders in front of a gullible audience ready and willing to believe in just about anything, but their 'powers' always vanish when tested - always - no exceptions to date.

Typically a 'nonbeliever' among the observers causes so many negative 'vibrations' that said powers are negated. Apparently, all one has to do is NOT believe and magic powers fade away. At least that much is predictable.

What kind of things disappear simply because you refuse to believe in them? Things that were never real to begin with.

To all evidence, the super mind powers of a scientific skeptic are enough to negate the mighty mind powers of even the greatest world famous psychics.

I don't feel compelled to believe that because something cannot be grasped or understood by scientific study that it must therefore be the product of supernatural influence. That's the kind of rationale that brought superstitions into existence in the first place - ignorance and fear of the unknown - not logic or reasoned study.

No repeatable experiments have ever produced any consistent tangible evidence of supernatural influence. Scientific proof requires this.

I accept the limits of my intelligence and realise that nobody will ever solve every riddle of nature. However, I draw the line at assuming supernatural causes when I fail to comprehend something. That's how savages think, if you call that thinking.

One thing is quite certain. IF supernatural influences exist, their influence must be so extremely weak that they have escaped ALL efforts to scientifically prove it in the whole 5000+ years of human history. So why are paranormal forces so difficult to prove if they have such extraordinary influence in our world?

While modern science can measure the movement of a single subatomic particle, nobody with 'mind power' great enough to bend a spoon has yet demonstrated the power to influence even a single atom at will when in a laboratory. The same applies to ghostly influences too. I wonder why.

If one can bend spoons with his mind (when nobody's looking) why can't he move an atom on command when somebody is looking - or anything else when being observed?



Headlines I'd like to see:

PSYCHIC WINS BIGGEST LOTTO JACKPOT IN HISTORY

OVER A MILLION LIVES SAVED BY PSYCHIC'S EARTHQUAKE PREDICTION



In the end, the burden of proof is on the paranormal claimant, not on the skeptic.
 
"I dont give a dime on what you all say, you all are stupid and Im very intelligent. I know the real truth while you know nothing because you all like to be called skeptics and are blind and dont know nothing. The evidence is clear, countless of anecdotes represent and ultra realistic and ultra heavy evidence. Heck, they represent an evidence stronger than any hardcore fact that you present, because you all are stupid and Im intelligent and nobody understands me. Nobody has seen a consciousness without a brain? that proves nothing, because there are those anecdotes of people who state the opposite, ergo, they are ok and I want to believe them because I do not want to believe in science. Yes, I choose not to believe in science because of the compelling evidence (yes, the anecdotes, they are more important than you realice because I say so)."

Or something along those lines. Ian, you were doing ok. What happened?
 
The lack of evidence is not a lie, it's a fact based upon several thousands of years of observations and failed experiments.

Could you please provide some of what you consider to be evidence?

Sorry, we have been there before, this leads nowhere. The discussion will go in circles. We need to break that.

Forget about the evidence Ian, make something paranormal, by this day Im sure you have learned to do something, anything. Care to show us? Forget about others, forget about science, just you and us.

Prove something with your own example.
 
II
The normal definition is not physical processes happening in the brain Paul.

How many times do you need to be told this?

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
Even if consciousness is something else, neuroscience can still study it. And gee whiz, it might even come up with evidence to support your contention.

No. Unless conscious is causally efficacious, then by definition it cannot be studied by science. How can science study something which has absolutely no effect on the world whatsoever?

And you can only claim it is causally efficacious by claiming it is literally physical processes (well either that or embrace my position --i.e it is non-physical and causally efficacious).

The definition of consciousness:

1 a : the quality or state of being aware especially of something within oneself b : the state or fact of being conscious of an external object, state, or fact c : AWARENESS; especially : concern for some social or political cause
2 : the state of being characterized by sensation, emotion, volition, and thought : MIND
3 : the totality of conscious states of an individual
4 : the normal state of conscious life *regained consciousness*
5 : the upper level of mental life of which the person is aware as contrasted with unconscious processes

Now what is it about that definition that rules out physical processes in the brain, or strongly suggests something else? It even mentions processes.

What is it about that definition that rules out consciousness is a ham sandwich?

II
Yeah sure. I can also do experiments on the film showing on my TV by hitting the top of my TV very hard.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
Yes, you can. And after sufficient experiments you'll discover how your TV works and find out that it's just an electronic gadget.

That's not the point. Of course it's just an electronic gadget. What I'm asking is how do you find out the origin of the film and why the film is about what it is, by banging a TV set??

II
What's this "homunculus"? You mean a self? I don't say there has to be. But maintaining there is no self is vastly more counter-intuitional, for example, than supposing that you are the only conscious being in the Universe and everyone else are merely automatons (p-zombies).

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
Who is supposing that?

No one is as far as I am aware. But what if I were to hold that position? And that it is vastly more sensible to suppose that no-one else really exists?

II
And I've already briefly hinted at the problems in supposing selves do not exist. Do you really believe "you" are ceasing to exist every infinitesimal fraction of a second only to be replaced by an almost exact duplicate?

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
I am doing no such thing. I'm changing from moment to moment, but so is a rock.

Imagine a teletransporter where your original gets killed off and another you is created. But imagine that you are using the teletransporter every infinitesimal fraction of a second for every moment of your entire life. If you believe that the brain generates consciousness and that you are wholly dependent and your mental states follow such physical processes in the brain, then this is effectively the situation of your normal second by second existence.

II
And what about people who have very similar brains to you? Why don't you experience out of their bodies?

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
Because "I" am my body and brain. Why would I experience someone else's body?

Well you certainly would do with a teletransporter. Your body gets destroyed and another created at a remote location. So you experience your consciousness jump from one body as it gets destroyed, to the other as it gets created. How dissimilar does the brain have to be before you wouldn't experience out of it?
 
Past Experience Justifies The Request For Evidence

Sorry, we have been there before, this leads nowhere. The discussion will go in circles. We need to break that.

The circularity of the argument does NOT originate with the skeptics, but rather with those who refute science only because they want to continue to believe in something and will berate any contradictory evidence - like those ID people who think T-Rex ate daisies in the Garden of Eden with Adam and Eve.

There is nothing invalid about asking to observe the evidence when the other party claims it exists. It's like saying, "I have evidence, but I'm not going to show it to you because it will lead to debate and I don't want to hear it."

Anecdotes are scientifically worthless. Every quack has truckloads of those to prove how wonderful his new, improved Snake Oil is.

A true skeptic MUST question every extraordinary claim, especially due to the long, long history that no such claims have ever survived a scientific test yet. After all these years, that's a very important observation. How could one NOT wonder why?

I've been led to the theory that the main reason we can't prove any paranormal claims is simply because there is no valid basis for such beliefs in the first place. So far, that seems to be the most probable explanation in hindsight with respect to the thousands of years of failed attempts.

Why should I just shut up and believe a person who claims to have been abducted by aliens and taken to Venus to have tea with the Queen of the Amazons? Most paranormal claims are just as dubious and no more believable on the face of it.

I have an obligation to common sense and scientific integrity to challenge such claims in the absence of any proof because I also want to know the truth of the matter as much as anyone else. But I'm not so easy to fool with pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo as the general population disappointingly seems to be.

Whatever the truth is, it has no reason to fear inquiry that would only serve to validate it one way or another.

All paranormal claims ever argued before the 'Court of Natural Law' have been found guilty of outright fraud or gross negligence in the analytical methodology upon which they defend their arguments. The ID argument is a classic textbook example of this in its grandest glory.

Can a psychic, remote viewer, clairvoyant, prophet, spoon bender or whatever prove to a court of law that his or her powers are genuine? If not, I ask, "Why do they fail every time and get a nasty attitude when I ask for evidence?"

:)
 
There has indeed been shown to be a definite relationship between the physical structure and chemistry of the brain and emotional states and perceptions. Cerebral biochemistry seems to be one of the major controlling influences in how we perceive things and process sensory input and other information.

It makes me wonder about how a so-called soul or spirit would perceive things outside the body with no physical eyes, ears, etc., or any apparent way to tangibly interact with our physical universe.

It's never inside or outside the body. Asking the question how we perceive things makes no sense whether we are embodied or disembodied. If there is a "life after death" then the ears, eyes etc do not create our qualia. Thus asking how we perceptually perceive anything at all is no more mysterious in an unembodied state than an embodied state.

Doesn't it seem reasonable to assume that IF there were any truth to supernatural beliefs, that during the last 5000+ years, at least ONE atom of concrete evidence would have been found by now to validate at least one such belief and firmly put the question to rest in at least that one instance?

What does "concrete evidence" mean? Do personal experiences count? If so there's a huge amount of concrete evidence.

Inexplicable typically equates to supernatural in the simple minds of believers. In a truly scientific mind, it never does, by definition.

Well that's not very helpful is it. If scientists dismiss by definition the existence of supernatural phenomena, then the assertion that it does not exist (or does exist) is entirely vacuous.

At what point do we finally decide that a supernatural question no longer has any scientific merit and deserves no further waste of time and resources.

Not ever. Consciousness is supernatural. Do you think we should spend no time and resources trying to understand it??

How many times does an experiment have to return a negative result before we finally say, "Enough is enough, I don't see any point in repeating it again." ?

Just a handful of times I would imagine.

When science does prove a superstition wrong, does anyone ever believe them? Certainly not the believers.

Logic won't lead a person away from beliefs that logic didn't lead him or her to in the first place. Valid logic, that is.

One's man's logic is another man's folly. Much too often, logic is relative.


You really are completely clueless.
 
Given that there has never been evidence of consciousness without a brain, it is quite surprising!

If you are not that consciousness, and bearing in mind that, being non-physical, consciousness cannot be perceptually perceived, then how would you obtain such evidence? By using the brain consciousness can make it's presence known when embodied. But how would it make its presence known when disembodied?
 
When Ian says "no compelling reason," he means "no compelling logical reason that I've ever thought of." He is not referring to neurophysiological evidence, because he has said that such evidence is irrelevant. There can be no empirical evidence that says anything about consciousness.

The neurophysiological evidence could not possibly be a compelling logical reason. It could only possibly aspire to a compelling empirical reason.

As far as I am aware the neurophysiological evidence merely consists in correlations between brain states and mental states. How therefore can this present compelling logical reasons to suppose that the mental has its genesis in the brain? It does not logically compel one to conclude that the brain is the genesis of consciousness. It merely provides evidence.

I predict he is completely safe, because (a) evidence is irrelevant; and (b) there is no logical argument in favor of or against the ontological status of consciousness. He's in a metaphysical Faraday cage.

How can evidence possibly be irrelevant? Furthermore how is it possible to misunderstand me so much as to suppose that I think evidence is irrelevant.

Incredible.
 
Imagine a teletransporter where your original gets killed off and another you is created. But imagine that you are using the teletransporter every infinitesimal fraction of a second for every moment of your entire life. If you believe that the brain generates consciousness and that you are wholly dependent and your mental states follow such physical processes in the brain, then this is effectively the situation of your normal second by second existence.

Well you certainly would do with a teletransporter. Your body gets destroyed and another created at a remote location. So you experience your consciousness jump from one body as it gets destroyed, to the other as it gets created. How dissimilar does the brain have to be before you wouldn't experience out of it?
Could you explain how you’ve come to the conclusion that we are being completely destroyed and recreated as almost exact duplicates every fraction of a second?

When the wind weathers a rock is the rock completely destroyed only to be replaced by an almost exact replica, or do the atoms in the wind simply knock a few atoms loose from the rest of the rock?

Also, I don’t believe there is any evidence that using a teletransporter would allow the transporting of a living creature. There is a good chance, given that teletransporters are even possible, that once the body is destroyed on one end, you’d get a reassembled dead creature on the other end.
 
If you are not that consciousness, and bearing in mind that, being non-physical, consciousness cannot be perceptually perceived, then how would you obtain such evidence? By using the brain consciousness can make it's presence known when embodied. But how would it make its presence known when disembodied?

.. and another interesting quote:
How can science study something which has absolutely no effect on the world whatsoever?
If there is no effect on the world whatsoever, how can you know there is a consciousness? It is only because consciousness has an effect on the physical world that we are able to talk about it! And if we want to measure it, a simple brain scan will show activity - we can not yet, and perhaps never determine exactly what this activity is. But the activity is enough to show that there is a physical effect of consciousness, otherwise people are dead, and it is notoriously difficult to make dead people tell if they experience anything!
 
The neurophysiological evidence could not possibly be a compelling logical reason. It could only possibly aspire to a compelling empirical reason.

data trumps logic: http://geology.about.com/library/weekly/aa041199.htm

"How could Kelvin's logic outweigh the evidence of the rocks?

It turned out that Kelvin's premise was wrong."
(What wasn't Lord Kelvin wrong about? ;) )

You can maintain that your premises are correct, but without an external test, you can't know if logic is leading you down a false path.

As far as I am aware the neurophysiological evidence merely consists in correlations between brain states and mental states. How therefore can this present compelling logical reasons to suppose that the mental has its genesis in the brain? It does not logically compel one to conclude that the brain is the genesis of consciousness. It merely provides evidence.

Merely provides evidence? Is that all? :boggled:

What mere counter evidence could possibly compel us to conclude that consciousness is some disembodied entity? Hurt feelings? :rolleyes:

Edit: Nurtz! I forgot to add... mystical experiences?
 
Last edited:
The lack of evidence is not a lie, it's a fact based upon several thousands of years of observations and failed experiments.

Where are the references? You must substantiate your assertion that there is a complete lack of evidence. Don't bother. It's just something which is plainly false like saying no human being can walk. Pointing to people who have lost both their legs isn't convincing. Why am I bothering to even respond I don't know.

Could you please provide some of what you consider to be evidence?

I suspect you really wouldn't be interested in what I consider to be evidence.

I guess you mean scientific evidence with the tightest possible controls? I'm not sufficiently familiar with the research and statistics to make me qualified to do that. I'm perfectly satisfied with the fact that people have been having certain experiences of a certain character throughout history and across all cultures. That makes it prima facie likely that the paranormal occurs. The parapsychological research is merely verification of this. Some of this research reveals nothing statistically significant. Some of it does. Considering all the research as a collective whole (both successful and unsuccessful) through meta-analysis and deliberately omitting maverick results is statistical significant. But maybe some of the research is flawed. So is looking at a single positive result to be preferred?

All this completely misses the point though. And profoundly boring to boot.

Why does it completely miss the point? Well I'll start a new thread about that on Monday entitled "Fire breathing Dragons and Ice".

You seem to be equating the lack of scientific understanding with evidence that something supernatural must be going on to explain that lack of understanding.

You means it seems to you. That's because you fail to understand me.

For those who suggest that paranormal evidence exists, I would like to see this evidence and expose it to competent scientific evaluation. So far, that's the point at which ALL supernatural claims fail to work.

That's good. You can tell me what's wrong with this research then.

http://www.fourmilab.ch/rpkp/observ.html

Otherwise why is the $1 million JREF prize not yet claimed by one of the 6+ billion people on Earth by now?

Because it is not a competent scientific evaluation. What competent scientific evaluation deliberately concentrates on evaluating that which we imagine will fail to show positive results, and excluding that where conceivably there is a remote chance of obtaining positive results. And that's not a question.

It's amazing how often a 'psychic' or similar nut has his/her powers fade away within the confines of properly implemented scientific controls and trained observers.

Completely and totally irrelevant. If someone pretends to have psychic powers, and they are unable to demonstrate such powers, this gives no evidence whatsoever against the existence of the paranormal or indeed the alleged talent in question. And I say that using my definition of evidence.

I can't be bothered to read the rest of your post. It's just the same uninformed and prejudiced rant I read time after time after time on here.
 
I'm not sufficiently familiar with the research and statistics to make me qualified to do that. I'm perfectly satisfied with the fact that people have been having certain experiences of a certain character throughout history and across all cultures. That makes it prima facie likely that the paranormal occurs.

Utterly and completely absurd. The day you understand why you will realize what we have explained to you all the time.

Several people report that they have been abducted, why dont you claim that abductions are real and that there are aliens on earth?

Several people report that they have been raped in satanical rites. Why we never hear from you that this proves that satan is real?

You choose the reports that suit your beliefs, and you immediately close your mind to anything else. By this logic, every religious who believe in satan will find "the evidence" they need. What does this proves?
 
Ian said:
Imagine a teletransporter where your original gets killed off and another you is created. But imagine that you are using the teletransporter every infinitesimal fraction of a second for every moment of your entire life. If you believe that the brain generates consciousness and that you are wholly dependent and your mental states follow such physical processes in the brain, then this is effectively the situation of your normal second by second existence.
Sure, why not? The brain appears to operate on various cycles, so my awareness is probably timewise discrete.

I remember smoking some dope in college and feeling as if my internal clock had slowed down and that I could not fill in the gaps between the clock ticks with a continuous awareness. Maybe this is related somehow.

~~ Paul
 
Clueless To The Bone And Proud Of It

Since biochemistry dominates our physical perceptions, I find it difficult to see how a non-physical entity can see or hear the way we do - at least by any similar processes analogous to anything in physical human experience. Does a spirit see the same light spectrum we see, hear in the same sound spectrum we do, etc? It's not a scientific conjecture anyway, just something interesting to think about in a spare moment of philosophical play.


Inexplicable typically equates to supernatural in the simple minds of believers. In a truly scientific mind, it never does, by definition.
That's a perfectly valid statement.

A scientist is limited by what can be studied physically. That's the whole point of science. He's not supposed to allow supernatural assumptions in his reasoning, certainly not by default, no matter how inexplicable something may be at the time. History validates this approach.

Science explores the natural cause and effect relationships within nature. Not supernatural causes and effects within nature. That's the job of the churches.

When a scientist draws a blank, it is not valid science for him to conclude that something supernatural is at work which is why he can't explain it. The only logical avenue is to assume that his knowledge is insufficient at this point and to keep on probing and experimenting. He may or may not find his answer. Only time will tell.

The supernatural is outside the domain of science, since no such claims are testable and all attempts thus far have failed.


By "concrete" I mean a conclusion beyond any sensible doubt - like the Earth not being flat - that after 5000+ years shouldn't we have proved at least ONE supernatural assumption soundly and beyond refute after all that time if there was at least some kernel of substance to it? Just ONE? Is that an unreasonable request in the face of repeated failures and the time period over which such conjectures have existed?

Is there no logical stopping point before we decide that some argument is no longer worthy of further debate on the same old tired arguments ad nauseam and move on to more important considerations?


If scientists dismiss by definition the existence of supernatural phenomena, then the assertion that it does not exist (or does exist) is entirely vacuous.
They don't. That's not my intended meaning - though close. He would need a scientific reason to believe that - but then it wouldn't be supernatural anymore! My whole point there is that his ignorance is not justification to arrive at a supernatural explanation in the absence of a natural one. Primitives think like that.

It seems to me that the so-called 'evidence' of the paranormal is what is "entirely vacuous" after all these countless years.

But we must not lose sight of the important fact that it is NOT and never was the proper job of science to explore supernatural phenomena, with the only exceptions being those cases where a claim can be put to a physical test, such as a specific testable prediction of some kind, for example. Either the prediction is proved right or wrong, one way or the other. That's concrete evidence.

It's easy for one to take solace behind beliefs or claims that one knows perfectly well can't be tested by any means and sneer at those who disagree because they can't prove their position either. I think some people delight in that. People who claim to talk to the dead come to mind.

The physical sciences explore only realm of the natural. Religions explore the supernatural. When they mix - the rest is the history of the Dark Ages.

By its very nature, science can at best disprove some superstitious beliefs, not prove them. If a belief can be proved by science, then it is not supernatural.

Consciousness is supernatural
That's not quite certain. My only interest in consciousness is in the biophysiological aspects, I can't explore anything outside of that. Those aspects are worthy of study.



One's man's logic is another man's folly. Much too often, logic is relative.
What's wrong with that?

One can still be correct even if for all the wrong reasons.

The logic of a young child is somewhat foolish when compared to the logic of an adult. Unfortunately, the same relationship often exists between adults. Consider the 'logic' of many ID supporters. Most scientists see that 'logic' as absurd and directly contradictory to physical evidence and even some observed 'laws' of nature. The logic of one person can indeed be folly as viewed by another, especially if the other is an experienced, strictly factual scientist.


Do personal experiences count?
Not scientifically. If you see a ghost and nobody else sees it, you haven't actually proved anything by the claim. You shouldn't use anecdotal evidence to try and prove a claim scientifically anyway.

Ask three people about the temperature in the room. To one it could be too chilly. To another it could be perfectly comfortable. To another it could be too warm. That's why personal experiences cannot be used in defense of a scientific argument and certainly not in defense of a paranormal argument.

I apply the same rules to tests of paranormal claims as I do with physical science claims. Science requires that any experiment designed to test something be reproducible by others and consistent in the result.

Science cannot possibly prove a supernatural conjecture, but it can and has disproved some.

:)
 
Anecdotes are scientifically worthless.

I agree. But basically so what? It is not rational to disbelieve in something just because science has not vindicated it. To say the very least! A rational person looks at all the evidence and using his or her reasoning tries to judge where the truth lies.
 
I agree. But basically so what? It is not rational to disbelieve in something just because science has not vindicated it. To say the very least! A rational person looks at all the evidence and using his or her reasoning tries to judge where the truth lies.

Then you should agree in that every person has the right to believe that what he/she chooses to believe its "THE TRUTH". Fine, but then dont shout that no one understands you and the forum is full of idiots. Its lame.

BTW, what stops you to believe in abductions or satan?
 
Could you explain how you’ve come to the conclusion that we are being completely destroyed and recreated as almost exact duplicates every fraction of a second?

When the wind weathers a rock is the rock completely destroyed only to be replaced by an almost exact replica, or do the atoms in the wind simply knock a few atoms loose from the rest of the rock?

Also, I don’t believe there is any evidence that using a teletransporter would allow the transporting of a living creature. There is a good chance, given that teletransporters are even possible, that once the body is destroyed on one end, you’d get a reassembled dead creature on the other end.

If the brain generates consciousness and consciousness states are wholly dictated by physical processes in the brain, then why on earth should you get a reassembled dead creature at the other end??

If you have an absolutely physically identical copy of you, then since the original generates consciousness, then necessarily the copy must do too. And the copy must be you in the fullest sense of the word.

Of course I believe you would simply get a corpse at the other end. But that's because I recognise consciousness is non-physical. Since the transporter is only duplicating that which is physical, it would not duplicate the consciousness. But anyone who subscribes to a materialist based metaphysic cannot believe you would get a corpse.

From the materialist perspective a person is defined in terms of their psychological constitution. If this psychological constitution changes then the person literally changes. Compare what you are like now as to when you were a child. From a materialist perspective in what sense can you be said to be the same person? Your intelligence has changed, your interests have changed, your personality has totally changed. Your psychological constitution has completely and totally changed, and therefore you cannot literally be the same person. Indeed many other children are more similar to what you were like as a child than what you are now.

And what about when you get drunk? Again your personality might be totally different from your sober self. So you are not literally the same person when you are drunk (so scratch the idea of going out to get drunk and having a good time since it will not be you who experiences all this!). Indeed, someone with a personality similar to yours (when sober) has more right to be called you than when you are drunk. But because you are associated with a particular body which can be continuously traced through space and time, and whose appearance only very slowly changes, then for convenience we say that "you" is always associated with your body. But in reality your self changes all the time -- literally changes I mean.

The best way to understand this is to refer back to the teletransporter again. I originally thought that such duplication thought experiments established that materialism, and indeed any materialist based metaphysic such as property dualism, must be incorrect. However, I now acknowledge I was wrong. Why? Because I was implicitly presupposing the notion of an enduring self. In other words I was begging the question. Anyway, here is what I formerly thought of as the proof against materialism.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[original so-called "proof"]
I think I have demonstrated that should materialism be true then we need to concur that with a star trek teletransporter device, where the original person gets destroyed and a perfect duplicate gets created somewhere else, that the duplicate would be you in the absolute fullest sense of the word.

Now if we imagine a case where the original person is not destroyed and simply get duplicated, we will then have 2 streams of consciousnesses. Let's imagine that someone offers me £10,000,000 if I agree to be duplicated with the duplicate being killed after about an hour after duplication. And let's for the sake of argumentation ignore the ethical implications. Now this might seem like a good deal to me. After all, how could I lose out? A duplicate is created, lives for an hour, and then is destroyed. So after the duplicate is destroyed is exactly the same as before the duplicate was created, except I'm £10,000,000 richer!

So ok, I agree to it. Now let's suppose that the copying will take place in a room with a TV set. The copying will take place sometime whilst I am watching my favourite film of all time Groundhog Day, although precisely when duplication will take place is not specified. It could take place anytime during the duration of the film. Imagine also that the duplicate will suddenly appear in an absolute identical room with the same film playing which is also precisely synchronized to the other film.

It should be obvious that nothing untoward will happen at the precise moment of duplication. If I am the original obviously nothing will happen. I will be watching the film and will notice absolutely nothing at the precise moment of duplication. If I am the duplicate, again I will note nothing untoward. At the precise moment of duplication I will suddenly appear in the duplicate room, sitting exactly in the same relative position and posture, the film will be continuous with the film being shown in the other room, and my memories will be continuous with the original Ian just prior to duplication.

So ok, I'm sitting there watching the film, and I most probably will be thinking to myself "hmmmm, I wonder if I have been duplicated yet or not?". Because I have no way of knowing. Moreover, even if I have been duplicated, I have absolutely no way of telling whether I am the original or the duplicate. But now the end of the film arrives. I know that duplication must have taken place, but there is absolutely nothing about the character of my experiences which could enable me to determine whether I am the original or the duplicate. My consciousness has been continuous. I might feel therefore that I must be the original Ian. But of course the duplicate will be thinking exactly the same thoughts. Bearing this in mind I cannot ascribe anymore probability than I am the original than the duplicate, and the same reasoning will be gone through by the other Ian. So I will conclude that there is a 50/50 chance I am the original.

Then the door to the room opens, and the person standing there says "I regret to inform you that you are the duplicate Ian, and therefore must be immediately executed".

So we reach our paradox. I had concluded that I was just being given £10,000,000 to watch my favourite film of all time. There should have been no danger to myself at all. But yet there is. But this is clearly absurd! After all, how could it meaningfully differ from the situation where the same situation pertains yet no duplication takes place? Then, since no duplicate is created, there is absolute 100% certainty that I am the original Ian.

It might be pointed out that at least the other Ian gets the £10,000,000. But this doesn't interest me anymore than anyone else I like who receives £10,000,000.
[/original so-called "proof"]

Materialism (or any materialist based metaphysic) escapes this "paradox" by recognising there is no enduring self.
 
If you have an absolutely physically identical copy of you, then since the original generates consciousness, then necessarily the copy must do too. And the copy must be you in the fullest sense of the word.

Of course I believe you would simply get a corpse at the other end. But that's because I recognise consciousness is non-physical. Since the transporter is only duplicating that which is physical, it would not duplicate the consciousness. But anyone who subscribes to a materialist based metaphysic cannot believe you would get a corpse.

What you believe its irrelevant for the argument, if thats clear lets continue, why on earth such a mental experiment is important for you? First of all, the copy would have its own consciousness, and it will be someone with an identical body and identical memories. Whats the big deal about this?
 
Ian said:
From the materialist perspective a person is defined in terms of their psychological constitution. If this psychological constitution changes then the person literally changes. Compare what you are like now as to when you were a child. From a materialist perspective in what sense can you be said to be the same person? Your intelligence has changed, your interests have changed, your personality has totally changed. Your psychological constitution has completely and totally changed, and therefore you cannot literally be the same person. Indeed many other children are more similar to what you were like as a child than what you are now.
Well, you didn't use scare quotes, but you did use scare italics. I am the same person because I have some of the same physical body and the same memories.

In what sense are you the same person from moment to moment in your metaphysic? Please select something that you can actually point to, as opposed to some concept whose sole purpose is to be the thing that is supposedly consistent.

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom