To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Hammegk said:
You forgot the smilie to better highlight that bit of nonsense.
You mean the Metamind did it to me on purpose? Geez, the gall.

I have heard that (which I have emboldened) before from someone around this forum I think. If I understand you correctly, Paul, you are saying that a baseball bat to the head is sufficient proof that consciousness is in the head?
No, but it suggests that neuroscientists can have something to say about consciousness, whatever it is, contrary to Ian's claim.

~~ Paul
 
Then what you are calling consciousness is not what the rest of the world calls consciousness. Given the normal definition, neuroscience clearly has a lot to say about it.

The normal definition is not physical processes happening in the brain Paul.

How many times do you need to be told this?

I don't even need neuroscience. I can hit myself over the head with a bat and do an experiment with my consciousness. Surely neuroscience can do subtler experiments in a more controlled manner.

Yeah sure. I can also do experiments on the film showing on my TV by hitting the top of my TV very hard.
 
I'm awed by the squirrelyness of your wordplay.

What is this problem of grouping? Give me an alternative to the straightforward idea that one body/brain has a set of experiences while another body/brain has a distinct set. What other possibility is there?

Your complaint seems to center around your conviction that experiencer/experiences can't be a closed system. There has to be a separate homunculus to "have the experiences." Can you make us understand the source of your conviction? Can you do it without using the term "incorrigible certainty"?

~~ Paul

What's this "homunculus"? You mean a self? I don't say there has to be. But maintaining there is no self is vastly more counter-intuitional, for example, than supposing that you are the only conscious being in the Universe and everyone else are merely automatons (p-zombies). And I've already briefly hinted at the problems in supposing selves do not exist. Do you really believe "you" are ceasing to exist every infinitesimal fraction of a second only to be replaced by an almost exact duplicate? And what about people who have very similar brains to you? Why don't you experience out of their bodies? I cannot begin to articulate the problems with such a view.
 
What's this "homunculus"? You mean a self? I don't say there has to be. But maintaining there is no self is vastly more counter-intuitional, for example, than supposing that you are the only conscious being in the Universe and everyone else are merely automatons (p-zombies). And I've already briefly hinted at the problems in supposing selves do not exist. Do you really believe "you" are ceasing to exist every infinitesimal fraction of a second only to be replaced by an almost exact duplicate? And what about people who have very similar brains to you? Why don't you experience out of their bodies? I cannot begin to articulate the problems with such a view.

Maybe because they are not as big as you imagine them? Which problems do you have in mind?
 
How do you avoid "if it effects or affects reality, it's the same stuff" (i.e. a monism)? It's irrelevant whether current physics is complete.
Just because it affects our reality does not mean we have full access to it. An interpretation I have about our leading edge of physics is that it is exploring, right now, that interface into this sort of thing. Metaphor: you are reading these words, which are really lit up phosphor dots (if not LCD) which are controlled by a cascade of mechanisms; said mechanisms do not stop at the graphics electronics, but go to a deeper level - the CPU of your PC; which does not stop there but goes to a deeper level - the Internet; which goes to even a deeper level - (hey, I am composing this). The metaphor is that, I see your viewpoint similar to a hypothetical person who would argue that the words on the screen are in the 'reality' of the last shell of this cascade - and said hypothetical person believes 'that's all there is'.

Synopsis: our ostensible reality is merely a 'screen'. (but that is not all that is 'real').

Background: The above is my interpretation, but... so you do not think I am totally making this up, go look up Bekenstein. I have not read the following yet myself but it might give me a little backup:

http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=39620
 
I see. And how does any or all of that assist you in concluding some form of interactive dualism is logical? :)
 
Originally Posted by Interesting Ian :
There is no need to put it in other words. I am well aware what it means to deny the existence of a self. I would argue that materialists, or any position which holds that conscious states follow and are completely depend upon brain states, must also deny the existence of the self.

Bodhi Dharma Zen

What about the materialist theory about emergent properties?

Materialist theory of emergent properties?? :eek:

The concept of emergent properties is notoriously ambiguous. Do you mean "emergent" as in the sense that a clock's hands movements "emerge" from the cogs, wheels and springs constituting its internal mechanism? Because that's not emergent in the proper sense. Emergent means that X is generated by Y but we cannot in principle scientifically understand how X arises from Y. It's just a brute fact about the world so to speak. It is not reductive materialism, nor indeed non-reductive materialism properly speaking. Such a notion is not materialism at all. I don't have any particular problems with emergentism if you also hold that although consciousness is wholly generated by the brain, it interacts with the brain in turn. Of course we would have to waive aside all the evidence suggesting survival ("life after death"). But it has the merit of being eminently sensible.

Consciousness would be real, as long as the body lives and the brain keeps certain health. Now, what Im talking about its not related to mind/brain theories, but with a "subjective state of being" in which, somehow, the ego dilutes and all that is left is "the experience alone", but not "the experiencer".

Ego dilutes?? :confused:

This seems to be hinting more at my own view that the self will ultimately becomes submerged and melded with all others in the fullness of time rather than an explicit denial of a self. But I don't know. I frankly admit I know very little about Buddhism, or indeed any other religion. From what very little I know I feel some sympathy to the Vedanta school of thought.

This state is called "Satori" and its reachable when you practice Zen meditation. There is really not more to say about it, because you would have to experience it for yourself in order to understand it. Suffice to say that it breakes the sense of the continuity of the self that you were arguing as somekind of absolute from when it is impossible to doubt.

Psychologically impossible to doubt. Not just I but presumably everybody finds it psychologically impossible to doubt. I was talking about the rejection of the self in a straightforward sense though. Not in the sense that the self is irrelevant and in the fullness of time with sufficient wisdom ones self will become subsumed with all other selves. That is very differnent from denying the existence of the self. But I do not know what Buddhists believe. I only know that materialists claim that Buddhists believe the same as them. If this is true then I emphatically reject Buddhism. But materialists lie all the time and I need some more evidence that Buddhists literally reject the existence of the self (rather than the rejection of the ego for example which possibly suggests something very different indeed).

Originally Posted by Interesting Ian :
However it has been argued that experiences e.g the raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror, and more generally any experience whatsoever are not literally had by an experiencer (i.e a self), but rather exist in isolation. That is to say experiences exist, but without an experiencer. Thus pains etc exist, but no-one is the subject of that pain. The notion that *I* am the author of all these experiences is an illusion in other words.

Bodhi
Yes, exactly. For a Zen Buddhist the answer would be yes, there is the experience of pain, but no ego behind it and no world causing it.

Ego??? I don't know what you mean by "ego". It kinda insinuates the notion of a self cut off from others and being solely concerned with personal selfish satisfactions. I have very grave reservations that ego equates to "self".

Why don't you stop cheating and address what I was saying?????

I said consciousness most definitely exists. You've basically ignored this and then maintained that the self doesn't exist instead. Now you're once again shifting your position and saying the "ego" doesn't exist. Your position is constantly shifting. Indeed it has shifted so much it's becoming to sound more and more similar to my own position, and diametrically opposite to the materialists.

Both the world and the experiencer are two poles of the same experience. "Reality" is non dual. Again, nothing more to say, not because I dont want it, but because words start to lack the appropiate meaning.


You have a complete lack of analytical rational thought. The above is meaningless drivel.


Originally Posted by Interesting Ian :
Now apart from such a notion being staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here one iota), we have the problem of why experiences are grouped into families so that "I" appear to have some set of experiences, and "you" appear to have another set of experiences. But there is no "I" or "you".

Bodhi
It is counter intuitive, that is correct, as many other things in the world. "Intuition" is based on past experiences, and being a human the kind of experience we have are quite limited. When we take our "human way to see the world" as the factual base to create our epistemology we are doomed. We need to learn to view beyond our intuitions.

I'm talking about intuition as in the apprehension of what we presume to be truths without which we could not operate. I'm completely unconvinced that you give an accurate portrayal of what intelligent Buddhists believe.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Now apart from such a notion being staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here one iota),

Why should it ? Oh, I remember. The subjective is more important than the objective. Got it. :rolleyes:
 
Hmmm will the sun rise tomorrow? Can I be sure of it?

Well heck, either the earth stops in its spin 'n' track and/or the sun instantly disappears without a spark of trace. heh!

Science is about making the best of guesses in a sense.
 
Ian said:
The normal definition is not physical processes happening in the brain Paul.

How many times do you need to be told this?
Even if consciousness is something else, neuroscience can still study it. And gee whiz, it might even come up with evidence to support your contention.

The definition of consciousness:

1 a : the quality or state of being aware especially of something within oneself b : the state or fact of being conscious of an external object, state, or fact c : AWARENESS; especially : concern for some social or political cause
2 : the state of being characterized by sensation, emotion, volition, and thought : MIND
3 : the totality of conscious states of an individual
4 : the normal state of conscious life *regained consciousness*
5 : the upper level of mental life of which the person is aware as contrasted with unconscious processes

Now what is it about that definition that rules out physical processes in the brain, or strongly suggests something else? It even mentions processes.

Yeah sure. I can also do experiments on the film showing on my TV by hitting the top of my TV very hard.
Yes, you can. And after sufficient experiments you'll discover how your TV works and find out that it's just an electronic gadget.

What's this "homunculus"? You mean a self? I don't say there has to be. But maintaining there is no self is vastly more counter-intuitional, for example, than supposing that you are the only conscious being in the Universe and everyone else are merely automatons (p-zombies).
Who is supposing that?

And I've already briefly hinted at the problems in supposing selves do not exist. Do you really believe "you" are ceasing to exist every infinitesimal fraction of a second only to be replaced by an almost exact duplicate?
I am doing no such thing. I'm changing from moment to moment, but so is a rock.

And what about people who have very similar brains to you? Why don't you experience out of their bodies?
Because "I" am my body and brain. Why would I experience someone else's body? Is there some mechanism in the universe that coalesces similar brains? Don't you think this question is just a tad loaded by your worldview?

I cannot begin to articulate the problems with such a view.
Apparently not.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Science: It's Not Just For Geeks Anymore !

Not sure what to think.

This doesn't seem to be getting very far, but it's an interesting debate to observe.

:)

Seems more like a philosophical than a scientific discussion.

There seems to be much ado about consciousness, focusing on, but with little agreement, on what it actually is. An argument that seems almost hopeless from the start. It seems that any discussion on a topic so complex should begin with laying the defining ground rules at the start to avoid each individual using a completely different understanding of the concept. No small accomplishment, but unless everyone means the same thing when they invoke a definition, such as 'metre', then the argument is bound to take many twists and turns with no clear direction.

One thing seems certain - the definition of 'consciousness' as applied to a non-living mechanism must be clearly segregated from the concept of 'consciousness' as applied to a living organism. I've seen several definitions of 'consciousness' that can be applied to both living creatures as well as man-made technological sensing devices.

This is important because the definitions used should not be part of the argument itself, but defined before the fact, ideally with agreement among the parties.

Even if everyone does agree, it's not proof that anyone is ultimately correct in their conclusions, only that each party at least understands the basic ground rules and definitions of the topic upon which all should agree in order to understand each other more clearly.

What we call 'consciousness' is not a solid object like a fossil that can be physically examined and passed around for examination. It seems to be an abstract quality defined by abstract rules more than physical observations defending those rules.

Scientifically, one can't simply ask, "What is consciousness?", and expect a firm answer on an issue so nebulous and founded upon many equally nebulous assumptions.

How we ASK questions in science is just as important as it is how we go about attempting to answer them.

Any definition that covers all contingencies seems unrealistic. It seems that any definition of 'consciousness' must be parametric, or within certain defined limits with respect to what we wish to apply it to. I don't think that it can be defined in any other way than within certain specified limits - like the definition of 'time'.

Analytical scientific definitions are analogous to the analytical chemical reagents used by a chemist to analyse an unknown substance. The more free our definitions are of logical impurities, the more we can rely on an analysis based on them.

In the cases of debates over things abstract, like 'consciousness' or 'time', we simply can't ask the 'What is ... ?' question. That's too simplistic in this case. To do so makes the argument degenerate into a purely theoretical, philosophical argument with little hope of resolution - unless that's what's desired here - I can't stand loose ends.

At this point, it seems that 'consciousness' is more a matter of opinion without resolution in any universal context. Lots of perfectly valid inquires fall into that category.

Concrete answers generally don't apply well to abstract questions, but we all keep trying like fools anyway. I've done this too many times already.

:o)
 
If one believes that consciousness (a "soul") exists in some form outside of the brain, it would be helpful to learn what attributes one attributes to that consciousness--Memory? Without a hippocampus? Love? Anger? Knowledge? Sight? Smell? Communication apparatus? Angst? Thought? What evidence does such a believer have that supports this belief? Can souls be tested or measured in any manner? Can dead people describe their death, location of a lost body, who killed them, etc. Why or why not?

I, personally, would like to know if there is any compelling reason to believe that consciousness exists outside the brain. I have come to the conclusion that "souls" are an illusion. If someone disagrees, please illuminate your reasoning for me. I don't think the definition is really the problem--I think it's the evidence (or lack thereof).
 
I refuse to believe in death - therefore I am immortal - I rest my case.

If one believes that consciousness (a "soul") exists in some form outside of the brain, it would be helpful to learn what attributes one attributes to that consciousness--Memory? Without a hippocampus? Love? Anger? Knowledge? Sight? Smell? Communication apparatus? Angst? Thought? What evidence does such a believer have that supports this belief? Can souls be tested or measured in any manner? Can dead people describe their death, location of a lost body, who killed them, etc. Why or why not?

I, personally, would like to know if there is any compelling reason to believe that consciousness exists outside the brain. I have come to the conclusion that "souls" are an illusion. If someone disagrees, please illuminate your reasoning for me. I don't think the definition is really the problem--I think it's the evidence (or lack thereof).

The lack of evidence is stark.

I've yet to see anything supernatural proved by science. That's apparently why they call it supernatural.

There has indeed been shown to be a definite relationship between the physical structure and chemistry of the brain and emotional states and perceptions. Cerebral biochemistry seems to be one of the major controlling influences in how we perceive things and process sensory input and other information.

It makes me wonder about how a so-called soul or spirit would perceive things outside the body with no physical eyes, ears, etc., or any apparent way to tangibly interact with our physical universe.

The dynamics of 'belief' is a complex thing at best.

Doesn't it seem reasonable to assume that IF there were any truth to supernatural beliefs, that during the last 5000+ years, at least ONE atom of concrete evidence would have been found by now to validate at least one such belief and firmly put the question to rest in at least that one instance?

Inexplicable typically equates to supernatural in the simple minds of believers. In a truly scientific mind, it never does, by definition.

At what point do we finally decide that a supernatural question no longer has any scientific merit and deserves no further waste of time and resources. How many times does an experiment have to return a negative result before we finally say, "Enough is enough, I don't see any point in repeating it again." ?

When science does prove a superstition wrong, does anyone ever believe them? Certainly not the believers.

Logic won't lead a person away from beliefs that logic didn't lead him or her to in the first place. Valid logic, that is.

One's man's logic is another man's folly. Much too often, logic is relative.
 
Didn't realise there had been further responses to this thread. I failed to receive any emails notifying me.

Originally Posted by articulett :
If one believes that consciousness (a "soul") exists in some form outside of the brain, it would be helpful to learn what attributes one attributes to that consciousness--Memory? Without a hippocampus? Love? Anger? Knowledge? Sight? Smell? Communication apparatus? Angst? Thought? What evidence does such a believer have that supports this belief? Can souls be tested or measured in any manner? Can dead people describe their death, location of a lost body, who killed them, etc. Why or why not?

I, personally, would like to know if there is any compelling reason to believe that consciousness exists outside the brain. I have come to the conclusion that "souls" are an illusion. If someone disagrees, please illuminate your reasoning for me. I don't think the definition is really the problem--I think it's the evidence (or lack thereof).

JayT
The lack of evidence is stark.

Not that this topic has anything whatsoever to do with this thread, but why do so called skeptics continually feel compelled to lie about this issue (as well as there being no evidence for paranormal phenomena). In both cases there is a huge amount of evidence.

And in response to articulett it's more of a case that there is no compelling reason to suppose that consciousness is ontological dependent on the brain. That coupled with all the evidence gives good prima facie support for the survival hypothesis.
 
One thing seems certain - the definition of 'consciousness' as applied to a non-living mechanism must be clearly segregated from the concept of 'consciousness' as applied to a living organism.

What??? We should have 2 definitions of consciousness?? I think not.
 
Didn't realise there had been further responses to this thread. I failed to receive any emails notifying me.



Not that this topic has anything whatsoever to do with this thread, but why do so called skeptics continually feel compelled to lie about this issue (as well as there being no evidence for paranormal phenomena). In both cases there is a huge amount of evidence.

And in response to articulett it's more of a case that there is no compelling reason to suppose that consciousness is ontological dependent on the brain. That coupled with all the evidence gives good prima facie support for the survival hypothesis.

GOOD evidence, Ian.

Not unsubstantiated anecdotes...

People have been through this with you...
 
And in response to articulett it's more of a case that there is no compelling reason to suppose that consciousness is ontological dependent on the brain.
Given that there has never been evidence of consciousness without a brain, it is quite surprising!
 
When Ian says "no compelling reason," he means "no compelling logical reason that I've ever thought of." He is not referring to neurophysiological evidence, because he has said that such evidence is irrelevant. There can be no empirical evidence that says anything about consciousness.

I predict he is completely safe, because (a) evidence is irrelevant; and (b) there is no logical argument in favor of or against the ontological status of consciousness. He's in a metaphysical Faraday cage.

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom