Science: It's Not Just For Geeks Anymore !
Not sure what to think.
This doesn't seem to be getting very far, but it's an interesting debate to observe.
Seems more like a philosophical than a scientific discussion.
There seems to be much ado about consciousness, focusing on, but with little agreement, on what it actually is. An argument that seems almost hopeless from the start. It seems that any discussion on a topic so complex should begin with laying the defining ground rules at the start to avoid each individual using a completely different understanding of the concept. No small accomplishment, but unless everyone means the same thing when they invoke a definition, such as 'metre', then the argument is bound to take many twists and turns with no clear direction.
One thing seems certain - the definition of 'consciousness' as applied to a non-living mechanism must be clearly segregated from the concept of 'consciousness' as applied to a living organism. I've seen several definitions of 'consciousness' that can be applied to both living creatures as well as man-made technological sensing devices.
This is important because the definitions used should not be part of the argument itself, but defined before the fact, ideally with agreement among the parties.
Even if everyone does agree, it's not proof that anyone is ultimately correct in their conclusions, only that each party at least understands the basic ground rules and definitions of the topic upon which all should agree in order to understand each other more clearly.
What we call 'consciousness' is not a solid object like a fossil that can be physically examined and passed around for examination. It seems to be an abstract quality defined by abstract rules more than physical observations defending those rules.
Scientifically, one can't simply ask, "What is consciousness?", and expect a firm answer on an issue so nebulous and founded upon many equally nebulous assumptions.
How we ASK questions in science is just as important as it is how we go about attempting to answer them.
Any definition that covers all contingencies seems unrealistic. It seems that any definition of 'consciousness' must be parametric, or within certain defined limits with respect to what we wish to apply it to. I don't think that it can be defined in any other way than within certain specified limits - like the definition of 'time'.
Analytical scientific definitions are analogous to the analytical chemical reagents used by a chemist to analyse an unknown substance. The more free our definitions are of logical impurities, the more we can rely on an analysis based on them.
In the cases of debates over things abstract, like 'consciousness' or 'time', we simply can't ask the 'What is ... ?' question. That's too simplistic in this case. To do so makes the argument degenerate into a purely theoretical, philosophical argument with little hope of resolution - unless that's what's desired here - I can't stand loose ends.
At this point, it seems that 'consciousness' is more a matter of opinion without resolution in any universal context. Lots of perfectly valid inquires fall into that category.
Concrete answers generally don't apply well to abstract questions, but we all keep trying like fools anyway. I've done this too many times already.

)