What you call consciousness is yourself, and yes, selves do not exist. Your whole identity is an illusion, this is self evident as you learn to anihilate your ego. mm lets put this in other words:
There is no need to put it in other words. I am well aware what it means to deny the existence of a self. I would argue that materialists, or any position which holds that conscious states follow and are completely depend upon brain states, must also deny the existence of the self.
The first thing to note is this absolutely is not denying the existence of consciousness. For example there could be a raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror etc. Now what absolutely cannot be denied is that there
really is the taste of jelly, a toothache, the feeling of terror etc. So consciousness most definitely exists.
However it has been argued that experiences e.g the raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror, and more generally any experience whatsoever are not
literally had by an
experiencer (i.e a self), but rather exist in isolation. That is to say experiences exist, but without an
experiencer. Thus pains etc exist, but no-one is the
subject of that pain. The notion that *I* am the author of all these experiences is an illusion in other words.
Now apart from such a notion being
staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here
one iota), we have the problem of why experiences are grouped into families so that "I" appear to have some set of experiences, and "you" appear to have another set of experiences. But there is no "I" or "you".
Moreover it's all very well asserting a pain can exist all by itself without experiencer experiencing that pain, but what about intentions to behave in a given manner? Maybe you have the intention to cancel a cheque say. Now this intention of yours implies a network of other beliefs on your part -- the existence of a currency system, of banks, of the concept of promising, that failing to cancel the cheque will have undesirable consequences etc. It is incredibly difficult to suppose that all this is possible when there really is no self!
Ian is just a collection of memories and perceptions. Nothing concrete or with a clear (and independent) ontological status. Oh, and you might not be able to believe it, yet, that doesnt make it stupid.
I think that on an emotional level we certainly all find it psychologically impossible to believe. WE can intellectually believe something, yet psychologically be unable to do so. However, in the case of a denial of a self I can see no good reason to suppose it doesn't exist. Yes it cannot exist if materialism is true or any position which holds that mental states simply follow physical states of the brain. But people are aware of my arguments against such a position.
Note that I do not give a definitive statement that selves must exist. I only gave a definitive statement that "I" am conscious, not that "I" am a self. However I have no good reason to suppose I am not a self, and the notion of a proper self is basically indispensable I would say.
As for Cognitive Science, experiments with people with damaged brains points to what Buddhism has known for centuries. Your precious ego, the very same "thing" you believe its your soul... does not exist. Yep, as I said it before, its just an illusion.[/
Buddhism knows this does it? And what about all other religions which know
there is a self? I suspect that the only reason why Buddhism is so popular in the west is that it's denial of the self fits in with materialist views!
And I'm tempted to criticise Buddhism by asking what reincarnates if there is not a self. Any reincarnation will not be me, nor will that reincarnated person have any memories of me, so in what possibly sense could it be said *I* reincarnate??
And as for neuroscience. We know that the brain can prevent the feeling of a self. Just consider the state of deep sleep! But I said in my previous post that a real self plays a pivotal role in the sense of our self, not that the physical structure of the brain can never function (or rather not function) in such a manner to prohibit the apprehension of a self. The self operates and is "filtered" through the brain. Whilst it does so it is subject to the perceptions and senses which the physical processes in the brain allow. It is only when we become detached from our brains that we become immediately aware of our true selves and everything that we are (as well as apprehending all other realities).