To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Originally Posted by Interesting Ian :
Where has anyone ever argued that their own consciousness might not exist? I have never encountered any such arguments, and certainly not on this board.

If one is conscious then one knows oneself is conscious with incorrigible certainty. You cannot be conscious and suspect you might not be conscious because there is no epistemic gap between the fact of your consciousness and you knowing you are conscious. On the other hand, if you are not conscious then you know nothing whatsoever.

Bodhi Dharma Zen
Utterly naive point of view. Consciousness is NOT an entity but a process, and there are countless levels in conscious awareness. You obviously know nothing about Zen (talking about subjective states) and the research and advancements in the area of Cognitive Science.

It's neither an entity or process; but that's by the by. So is the fact that our conscious awareness level can vary.

Something which is not conscious eg a rock, cannot falsely believe it is conscious. This is because to believe in something necessitates one is indeed conscious.

Something which is conscious eg you, cannot believe you're not conscious since consciousness is immediately given.

No I know nothing about cognitive science or Mr Zen. Nor do I need to in this context. If they deny what I say, then they are wrong. It's as simple as that.
 
Ian - How do you account for the term colorblind?

It certainly suggests that color is external rather than internal?
 
That's not true. Surely, we can make a robot who truly believes he is conscious although he is not.

You have a rather optimistic view of the current state of robotics. My understanding is that we can barely make a robot that truly vacuums a room.
 
No I know nothing about cognitive science or Mr Zen. Nor do I need to in this context. If they deny what I say, then they are wrong. It's as simple as that.

LOL, why Im not surprised? You are certainly a funny character. No more to say. This little example illustrate well your personality, and the aperture of your thinking. Well done.
 
That's not true. Surely, we can make a robot who truly believes he is conscious although he is not.

You obviously have a different definition of the word "believe" than I do. "Believe" to me means to suppose something is the case. But something which is not conscious cannot suppose anything to be the case.
 
LOL, why Im not surprised? You are certainly a funny character. No more to say. This little example illustrate well your personality, and the aperture of your thinking. Well done.

Possibly you are also confused and are thinking about the possibility that selves might not exist rather than consciousness.

I believe that Buddhists deny the existence of the self, but I am not aware they dismiss the existence of consciousness. I'm sure Buddhism is not so stupid as to maintain such a patent falsehood.

Neither neuroscience, or cognitive science, or indeed science in general has anything to say about either consciousness or a self. Thus it could scarcely provide any evidence that either consciousness or a self does not exist. Neuroscience at the present time fails to give any justification for even our sense of self. Thus it is in no position to deny that our sense of self is not brought about by an actual real self (or at least plays a pivotal role). If neuroscience can give no evidence that a self does not exist then a fortiori neither does cognitive science or any other science.
 
What you call consciousness is yourself, and yes, selves do not exist. Your whole identity is an illusion, this is self evident as you learn to anihilate your ego. mm lets put this in other words:

Ian is just a collection of memories and perceptions. Nothing concrete or with a clear (and independent) ontological status. Oh, and you might not be able to believe it, yet, that doesnt make it stupid. You have to learn when to utter such emotions. ;)

As for Cognitive Science, experiments with people with damaged brains points to what Buddhism has known for centuries. Your precious ego, the very same "thing" you believe its your soul... does not exist. Yep, as I said it before, its just an illusion.
 
Last edited:
You obviously have a different definition of the word "believe" than I do. "Believe" to me means to suppose something is the case. But something which is not conscious cannot suppose anything to be the case.

Considering how little we know of consciousness, don't you think you're loading the question, somewhat ?
 
What you call consciousness is yourself, and yes, selves do not exist. Your whole identity is an illusion, this is self evident as you learn to anihilate your ego. mm lets put this in other words:

There is no need to put it in other words. I am well aware what it means to deny the existence of a self. I would argue that materialists, or any position which holds that conscious states follow and are completely depend upon brain states, must also deny the existence of the self.

The first thing to note is this absolutely is not denying the existence of consciousness. For example there could be a raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror etc. Now what absolutely cannot be denied is that there really is the taste of jelly, a toothache, the feeling of terror etc. So consciousness most definitely exists.


However it has been argued that experiences e.g the raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror, and more generally any experience whatsoever are not literally had by an experiencer (i.e a self), but rather exist in isolation. That is to say experiences exist, but without an experiencer. Thus pains etc exist, but no-one is the subject of that pain. The notion that *I* am the author of all these experiences is an illusion in other words.

Now apart from such a notion being staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here one iota), we have the problem of why experiences are grouped into families so that "I" appear to have some set of experiences, and "you" appear to have another set of experiences. But there is no "I" or "you".

Moreover it's all very well asserting a pain can exist all by itself without experiencer experiencing that pain, but what about intentions to behave in a given manner? Maybe you have the intention to cancel a cheque say. Now this intention of yours implies a network of other beliefs on your part -- the existence of a currency system, of banks, of the concept of promising, that failing to cancel the cheque will have undesirable consequences etc. It is incredibly difficult to suppose that all this is possible when there really is no self!


Ian is just a collection of memories and perceptions. Nothing concrete or with a clear (and independent) ontological status. Oh, and you might not be able to believe it, yet, that doesnt make it stupid.

I think that on an emotional level we certainly all find it psychologically impossible to believe. WE can intellectually believe something, yet psychologically be unable to do so. However, in the case of a denial of a self I can see no good reason to suppose it doesn't exist. Yes it cannot exist if materialism is true or any position which holds that mental states simply follow physical states of the brain. But people are aware of my arguments against such a position.

Note that I do not give a definitive statement that selves must exist. I only gave a definitive statement that "I" am conscious, not that "I" am a self. However I have no good reason to suppose I am not a self, and the notion of a proper self is basically indispensable I would say.

As for Cognitive Science, experiments with people with damaged brains points to what Buddhism has known for centuries. Your precious ego, the very same "thing" you believe its your soul... does not exist. Yep, as I said it before, its just an illusion.[/

Buddhism knows this does it? And what about all other religions which know there is a self? I suspect that the only reason why Buddhism is so popular in the west is that it's denial of the self fits in with materialist views!

And I'm tempted to criticise Buddhism by asking what reincarnates if there is not a self. Any reincarnation will not be me, nor will that reincarnated person have any memories of me, so in what possibly sense could it be said *I* reincarnate??

And as for neuroscience. We know that the brain can prevent the feeling of a self. Just consider the state of deep sleep! But I said in my previous post that a real self plays a pivotal role in the sense of our self, not that the physical structure of the brain can never function (or rather not function) in such a manner to prohibit the apprehension of a self. The self operates and is "filtered" through the brain. Whilst it does so it is subject to the perceptions and senses which the physical processes in the brain allow. It is only when we become detached from our brains that we become immediately aware of our true selves and everything that we are (as well as apprehending all other realities).
 
Ian said:
Neither neuroscience, or cognitive science, or indeed science in general has anything to say about either consciousness or a self.
Then what you are calling consciousness is not what the rest of the world calls consciousness. Given the normal definition, neuroscience clearly has a lot to say about it. You might argue the conclusions that can be drawn are not yet clear, but that is another matter.

I don't even need neuroscience. I can hit myself over the head with a bat and do an experiment with my consciousness. Surely neuroscience can do subtler experiments in a more controlled manner.

You are drawing conclusions about consciousness and color using definitions that you've apparently made up.

~~ Paul
 
Ian said:
However it has been argued that experiences e.g the raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror, and more generally any experience whatsoever are not literally had by an experiencer (i.e a self), but rather exist in isolation. That is to say experiences exist, but without an experiencer. Thus pains etc exist, but no-one is the subject of that pain. The notion that *I* am the author of all these experiences is an illusion in other words.

Now apart from such a notion being staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here one iota), we have the problem of why experiences are grouped into families so that "I" appear to have some set of experiences, and "you" appear to have another set of experiences. But there is no "I" or "you".
I'm awed by the squirrelyness of your wordplay.

What is this problem of grouping? Give me an alternative to the straightforward idea that one body/brain has a set of experiences while another body/brain has a distinct set. What other possibility is there?

Your complaint seems to center around your conviction that experiencer/experiences can't be a closed system. There has to be a separate homunculus to "have the experiences." Can you make us understand the source of your conviction? Can you do it without using the term "incorrigible certainty"?

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
It is possible to have pains in non-existent limbs. What does that say of the reality of consciousness?
 
Steen said:
It is possible to have pains in non-existent limbs. What does that say of the reality of consciousness?
This is explained by the idealist model of external reality. External reality is played on our senses by the Metamind, giving us the "illusion" of an external world. Sometimes, when the Metamind decides to eliminate the illusion of my left leg, say due to an accident with a chipper/shredder, it makes a mistake and only does half the job. The actual physical leg is no longer played on my senses of vision and touch, but it is played on my senses of pain and proprioception. So I don't see or touch my left leg, but I still feel pain in it.

See, no problem. It's all explained by mistakes of the Metamind.

~~ Paul
 
There is no need to put it in other words. I am well aware what it means to deny the existence of a self. I would argue that materialists, or any position which holds that conscious states follow and are completely depend upon brain states, must also deny the existence of the self.

Now we are talking. Thats refreshing. Its good to see when you state your beliefs/arguments without disruptive shouting nor the old "I am right you are wrong". Good.

What about the materialist theory about emergent properties? Consciousness would be real, as long as the body lives and the brain keeps certain health. Now, what Im talking about its not related to mind/brain theories, but with a "subjective state of being" in which, somehow, the ego dilutes and all that is left is "the experience alone", but not "the experiencer".

This state is called "Satori" and its reachable when you practice Zen meditation. There is really not more to say about it, because you would have to experience it for yourself in order to understand it. Suffice to say that it breakes the sense of the continuity of the self that you were arguing as somekind of absolute from when it is impossible to doubt.

However it has been argued that experiences e.g the raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror, and more generally any experience whatsoever are not literally had by an experiencer (i.e a self), but rather exist in isolation. That is to say experiences exist, but without an experiencer. Thus pains etc exist, but no-one is the subject of that pain. The notion that *I* am the author of all these experiences is an illusion in other words.

Yes, exactly. For a Zen Buddhist the answer would be yes, there is the experience of pain, but no ego behind it and no world causing it. Both the world and the experiencer are two poles of the same experience. "Reality" is non dual. Again, nothing more to say, not because I dont want it, but because words start to lack the appropiate meaning.

Now apart from such a notion being staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here one iota), we have the problem of why experiences are grouped into families so that "I" appear to have some set of experiences, and "you" appear to have another set of experiences. But there is no "I" or "you".

It is counter intuitive, that is correct, as many other things in the world. "Intuition" is based on past experiences, and being a human the kind of experience we have are quite limited. When we take our "human way to see the world" as the factual base to create our epistemology we are doomed. We need to learn to view beyond our intuitions.

BTW, I dont see the problem, if you change the "you" and the "I" for your body and my body there are no contradictions, eg: "This body is having this experience".

Moreover it's all very well asserting a pain can exist all by itself without experiencer experiencing that pain, but what about intentions to behave in a given manner? Maybe you have the intention to cancel a cheque say. Now this intention of yours implies a network of other beliefs on your part -- the existence of a currency system, of banks, of the concept of promising, that failing to cancel the cheque will have undesirable consequences etc. It is incredibly difficult to suppose that all this is possible when there really is no self!

There is the sensation of the self, the illusion about having a distinct ego who makes decisions. I wont argue about it right now, but I see no epistemic problems in considering that our freedom is an illusion.

I think that on an emotional level we certainly all find it psychologically impossible to believe. WE can intellectually believe something, yet psychologically be unable to do so. However, in the case of a denial of a self I can see no good reason to suppose it doesn't exist. Yes it cannot exist if materialism is true or any position which holds that mental states simply follow physical states of the brain. But people are aware of my arguments against such a position.

Yes, you have a different point of view. Just let me tell you this. If your arguments were as solid as you believe they are, more people should be convinced about that mental states are not based on brain/world states.

Note that Im not a materialist, note also that I didnt say brain states. Im a different kind of animal ;) I will add that I see no good reason to suppose that the self has any ontological state on its own, nor that the world we see have it, but thats another discussion.

Note that I do not give a definitive statement that selves must exist. I only gave a definitive statement that "I" am conscious, not that "I" am a self. However I have no good reason to suppose I am not a self, and the notion of a proper self is basically indispensable I would say.

I cant see why.

Buddhism knows this does it? And what about all other religions which know there is a self? I suspect that the only reason why Buddhism is so popular in the west is that it's denial of the self fits in with materialist views!

It might be true. However, Zen Buddhism relies on personal experience to assert it, not in "faith".

And I'm tempted to criticise Buddhism by asking what reincarnates if there is not a self. Any reincarnation will not be me, nor will that reincarnated person have any memories of me, so in what possibly sense could it be said *I* reincarnate??

I know nothing about that. Some say that it is not the self but the desires, abstract stuff. Too speculative for my tastes.

And as for neuroscience. We know that the brain can prevent the feeling of a self. Just consider the state of deep sleep! But I said in my previous post that a real self plays a pivotal role in the sense of our self, not that the physical structure of the brain can never function (or rather not function) in such a manner to prohibit the apprehension of a self. The self operates and is "filtered" through the brain. Whilst it does so it is subject to the perceptions and senses which the physical processes in the brain allow.

You said it. Everyday we go to a state in which the ego is diluted, in your view its because the brain "cancels" the sense of the self (without affecting the real self), in materialists views because the self is diluted with other brain functions. Im able to tell you more about this but we would enter in beliefs territory... and somethings are better understood if experienced.

It is only when we become detached from our brains that we become immediately aware of our true selves and everything that we are (as well as apprehending all other realities).

Unless a concrete proof (and Im not talking about anecdotal recolection) existed about this, I think is safe to take it as it is, an speculation.
 
Last edited:
I don't even need neuroscience. I can hit myself over the head with a bat and do an experiment with my consciousness. Surely neuroscience can do subtler experiments in a more controlled manner.
I have heard that (which I have emboldened) before from someone around this forum I think. If I understand you correctly, Paul, you are saying that a baseball bat to the head is sufficient proof that consciousness is in the head?

I'll try that with my radio set and expunge that stupid weather man who is nearly always wrong. Man, if Lee Harvey Oswald had thought of this, he could have stayed home, done the deed, and gotten away with it.

[...of course I do not suggest that there is an electromagnetic linkage to some remote control - it is merely metaphorical. If it were merely 'far field' EM, then we would have discovered it 75 years ago. Until physics is complete, dualism is not dead, nor does monism rule.] ...IMO.
 
LOL . . . You are certainly a funny character. . . .

BDZ, I’m shocked, yes, shocked! that you find Ignorant Ion funny. You should spread your prayer mat and bow profoundly before

A genuine, honest-to-bodhi Perfect Fool!

You know how hard it is to find perfection.
 
[...of course I do not suggest that there is an electromagnetic linkage to some remote control - it is merely metaphorical. If it were merely 'far field' EM, then we would have discovered it 75 years ago. Until physics is complete, dualism is not dead, nor does monism rule.] ...IMO.
How do you avoid "if it effects or affects reality, it's the same stuff" (i.e. a monism)? It's irrelevant whether current physics is complete.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom