To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Holy Matrix, Batman !

Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?
...

If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation. I am curious what others think about this.


Arguing over 'What is real?' is a philosophical argument, not a valid scientific question of any merit that leads to any new understanding - just endless, non-productive debate - but no answers.

Scientific 'faith' is built on well-reasoned foundations of logic and experimentation and accumulated knowledge over many years. The beliefs and books of science change as we learn more.

Superstitious or religious faith has no need of any well-reasoned foundation at all. Such beliefs do NOT change in the face of ANY evidence to the contrary because evidence had nothing to do with leading to such beliefs in the first place. The typical recourse is to attack, often murderously, anything that challenges blind, unreasoning faith.

Science is not founded on blind, unreasoning faith, but upon very careful thought and consideration of the available facts, wherever they may lead.



One of my favourite examples of this concept is the following:

"If the earth is rotating as they claim, the countries, the mountains, the trees, the rivers, and the oceans will have no bottom and the people will see the eastern countries move to the west and the western countries move to the east."

Source: From the book: "Evidence that the Earth is Standing Still.", page 23

Author: Sheikh Abdul Aziz Ben Baz, Islamic University of Medina

Published: 1395 AH (1974 CE)

Obviously, a great scientific mind at work.
Isn't faith just wonderful?



The tangible accomplishments and benefits of scientific 'faith' are too numerous to mention. No irrational faith has done as much to benefit mankind or more to inhibit and silence the growth of reasoned knowledge.
 
Last edited:
That's what I thought.
Belz, I think the transfer ratio of my information to you is only 10%. It must be my lack of ability to convey. While I said it was my assumption - you seemed to miss that it is also the new way of approaching unified theory - it is quite generally assumed now more than ever. If you want to think that: if VN thinks it is true, therefore it must be false - suit yourself.

I've read some good portions of one of the articles that claims to show "high probability" that we live in a simulation.

First off, the only thing this claims is that its assumptions, which it takes as premises, are "possible". Then goes on to base its arguments on that. By that logic, there is a high probability that the universe exists within the anus of a chicken.
I seriously doubt that someone could make a computer simulation of a universe, with all its matter and minds, without utilising a number of bits at least equal to the number of particles in that simulated universe. Which means such a simulation would TAKE UP an entire universe as a processor. That's a rather idiotic assumption.
Yes, the Bolstrom thing is NOT at all my worldview. I presented it as a philosophical-only proposition. So don't expect me to feel challenged by your comments on it.

You said you weren't an IDer, and now you claim otherwise. Did you change your mind, or were you intentionally misleading ?
If you are going to publically imply the accusation that I am being intentionally misleading, especially after I re-stated for you my stance that I DO embrace teleology and design, you need to show me what I said that you think contradicts that so I can see the context. I DID change my mind (toward design) - more than 10 years ago - did you miss that?
 
Last edited:
First off, the only thing this claims is that its assumptions, which it takes as premises, are "possible". Then goes on to base its arguments on that. By that logic, there is a high probability that the universe exists within the anus of a chicken.
This Bolstrom proposition is a good thing to look at how you react to it. I am in agreement with you generally about Bolstroms argument- it is totally alien to my own ideas about simulation. However, I wanted to point out what YOUR reaction is.

Are not Bolstrom's assumptions no better or no worse than the non-teleological conjectures about the origins of life, since both are based on assumptions that something might be "possible" instead of being based on evidence that something happened?
 
Belz, I think the transfer ratio of my information to you is only 10%. It must be my lack of ability to convey. While I said it was my assumption - you seemed to miss that it is also the new way of approaching unified theory - it is quite generally assumed now more than ever. If you want to think that: if VN thinks it is true, therefore it must be false - suit yourself.

The world does not revolve around you, Von. I'm sure you know this. I'm simply saying that, even if a theory seems unbelievable or incredible to you, it does not make it false, and the reverse is true, as well. Only evidence will show the truth. Unfortunately you have chosen to ignore evidence, or more precisely, to dwell on gaps in the evidence, to believe in unfounded theories.

Yes, the Bolstrom thing is NOT at all my worldview. I presented it as a philosophical-only proposition. So don't expect me to feel challenged by your comments on it.

If you didn't want my opinion on it, why did you present that link ?

If you are going to publically imply the accusation that I am being intentionally misleading, especially after I re-stated for you my stance that I DO embrace teleology and design, you need to show me what I said that you think contradicts that so I can see the context. I DID change my mind (toward design) - more than 10 years ago - did you miss that?

I meant, since the thread about ID and the laws of physics.

You said, http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1426369&postcount=260 :

Von said:
In my huge amount of posts in just a matter of less than two weeks, you will notice if you look, that I've NEVER said I believe in God. The subject matter here, I thought was ID and that origin of natural laws is probably a better domain for pro-ID argument.

And, http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1487908&postcount=753:

Did I say "theory"? Evolution is conjecture - so is ID, conjecture.

And finally http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1504061&postcount=972 :

For the Nth time, I am here to see what skeptics say they believe. You 'sound' angry at me Belz. I am not advancing a position. I push buttons. I get responses. ...I'm getting some good material here.

"god of the bible"? From what I can tell, this subject has been totally out of scope from anything I've ever ever ever said here. Ever. Save it for church lady (how many times do I have to remind you?).

In which you hint at your trolling, again.

So you don't believe in God, and you think ID is conjecture, and you ALWAYS refer to IDers in the third person.

I simply assumed that you weren't an IDer.
 
This Bolstrom proposition is a good thing to look at how you react to it. I am in agreement with you generally about Bolstroms argument- it is totally alien to my own ideas about simulation. However, I wanted to point out what YOUR reaction is.

Are not Bolstrom's assumptions no better or no worse than the non-teleological conjectures about the origins of life, since both are based on assumptions that something might be "possible" instead of being based on evidence that something happened?

Another "equivalence" argument. Sigh. The difference, Von, is that one is perfectly in line with what we know, is falsifiable, testable, AND can be expected to result from further science, even if it turns out false. The other is not, cannot and will not. The simulation argument is therefore NOT on an equal footing.

Also, as I said, it would take at least as many particles as there are in this universe to store THIS universe in a simulation. So, what ? Did they hijack ANOTHER universe in order to simulate this one ?
 
The world does not revolve around you, Von. I'm sure you know this. I'm simply saying that, even if a theory seems unbelievable or incredible to you, it does not make it false, and the reverse is true, as well. Only evidence will show the truth. Unfortunately you have chosen to ignore evidence, or more precisely, to dwell on gaps in the evidence, to believe in unfounded theories..
OK. I dwell on gaps and have chosen to believe in unfounded theories - is what it looks like to you. That is fair to say as I have been saying to you, the corallary about you.

If you didn't want my opinion on it, why did you present that link ?..
I did want your opinion and discovered that at least we both agree Bostrom doesn't fit either of our worldviews.

So you don't believe in God, and you think ID is conjecture, and you ALWAYS refer to IDers in the third person. I simply assumed that you weren't an IDer.
Wait a minute. You think "I never said I believe in God" is equivalent to "I said I never believe in God"? I said that because people assumed I believed in God when I was certain that I never said that I did, so I reminded them - that's all.

I think ID is conjecture? Yes. That makes me a non-IDer? No. I admitted all along that ID is an assumption. I'm not sure exactly how ontological proofs work. I am not even sure if Behe considers that his book Darwins Black Box presents an ontological proof.

I'll take your word for it that I always used third person. Maybe I do not identify myself as that close to the core of whatever the term means. I was sensitive to the ad hominem attacks and I was cautious on how I allowed myself to label myself. I think I can say that I am not an ordinary IDer - not easily pigeon-holed.

I appreciate that you went to the trouble to find those points and I can understand your assumption, now. I imagine that you agree that a simple label never completely defines someone.
 
Another "equivalence" argument. Sigh. The difference, Von, is that one is perfectly in line with what we know, is falsifiable, testable, AND can be expected to result from further science, even if it turns out false. The other is not, cannot and will not. The simulation argument is therefore NOT on an equal footing.

Also, as I said, it would take at least as many particles as there are in this universe to store THIS universe in a simulation. So, what ? Did they hijack ANOTHER universe in order to simulate this one ?
Sigh. OK.

On the Bostrom thing, I thought the assumption was that simulation was nested in an outer larger universe (but i am not going to go back and read it again and I do not have any point of contention with you on it so lets drop it, si'l vous plait.).
 
si'l vous plait.).

That's s'il vous plait.

VonNeumann said:
OK. I dwell on gaps and have chosen to believe in unfounded theories - is what it looks like to you. That is fair to say as I have been saying to you, the corallary about you.

Yes, yes. All the scientists are ignoring the real evidence and no one but the creationists is interested in the truth.

Wait a minute. You think "I never said I believe in God" is equivalent to "I said I never believe in God"?

No, but the implication seemed pretty clear.

I think ID is conjecture? Yes. That makes me a non-IDer? No. I admitted all along that ID is an assumption.

But ID is supposed to be science, right ? So if you only take it on faith, doesn't that make it a religion, now ? Doesn't that kinda defeat the entire point of ID vs evolution ?

I imagine that you agree that a simple label never completely defines someone.

We can agree on that.
 
Originally Posted by Timothy :
INTERESTING SIDE QUESTIONS
- "Brains in vats" does raise some interesting questions, though, about the true nature of reality. Suppose you are a brain in a vat being fed electrical impulses. According to the theory, you cannot prove that 2+2=4. For all you know 2+2=54,824, but the electrical impulses being fed to your brain tell you that 2+2 must equal 4. There is no way to prove otherwise. But what about the color red? One can argue the color red *must* exist in the "real" world...otherwise how could the signals being fed to your brain mimic a sensory perception that does not exist?

steenkh
Why should the colour red exist in the real world? If we are just brains in vats, we get every sensation from the electrical impulses. Colours do not need to exist at all. The impulses do not have "mimic" a sensory perception, they just have to "create" them..

Of course. Indeed according to those who suppose science describes reality
per se there are no colours in the world, no sounds, no smells -- there are merely wavelengths of light, molecules, vibrations in the air etc. Everything we ever perceptually perceive through the 5 senses is merely the minds interpretation of the electrical impulses in our brains caused by the reality as described by science. According to these people everything we ever perceptually perceive does not actually characterise reality in itself. Indeed everything we ever perceptually perceive is wholly unlike reality.

It's absolutely unbelievable what complete nonsense people believe.
 
Originally Posted by Timothy :
PHILOSOPHICAL PART
- It is impossible to prove with absolute certainty the existance of anything other than the existance of your own consciousness.


But then again, as we've argued before, are we actually certain of even that ?

Where has anyone ever argued that their own consciousness might not exist? I have never encountered any such arguments, and certainly not on this board.

If one is conscious then one knows oneself is conscious with incorrigible certainty. You cannot be conscious and suspect you might not be conscious because there is no epistemic gap between the fact of your consciousness and you knowing you are conscious. On the other hand, if you are not conscious then you know nothing whatsoever.
 
Originally Posted by Timothy :
INTERESTING SIDE QUESTIONS
- "Brains in vats" does raise some interesting questions, though, about the true nature of reality. Suppose you are a brain in a vat being fed electrical impulses. According to the theory, you cannot prove that 2+2=4.

drkitten
This is a misstatement of the theory.

Mathematical truths, like all tautologies, are probable not by observation, by by introspection and knowledge of the words mean. Even to a brain in a vat, 2+2 still equals 4 (assuming that we can come to an appropriate understanding of the symbols 2,4, +, and "equals"), in the same way that we can prove that all red things are red, that no unmarried man is married. It doesn't matter whether or not "unmarried men" exist -- the same argument proves all unicorns are unicorns, because that's what the word means.i]

Absolutely.

I was actually going to make the same point myself. Then I remembered an argument I had with people on here a couple of years ago that I could not be certain that 1 + 1 = 2, and the usual irrelevant stuff about me not knowing any mathematics. I really didn't want to get into such an asinine debate again, so I decided not to bother making the point.
 
Well, it's impossible to arrive at any useful conclusion if you don't. And, a priori, the thought that our mind doesn't really exist seems incoherent. It's not, but assuming that nothing exists, not even your "self", is not very practical.

But that's a point we can make against solipists, too. Sure enough, we're not 100% sure that the universe exists, but assuming that it doesn't is not a practical position for scientific purposes.

You really are completely confused.

Try to understand the difference between consciousness, minds, and selves.
 
Of course. Indeed according to those who suppose science describes reality per se there are no colours in the world, no sounds, no smells -- there are merely wavelengths of light, molecules, vibrations in the air etc.
Colours are the names of certain wavelengths in the electromagnetic spectrum, so of course they exist! What did you think?

But in the useless thought-experiment that we only live in a simulation or that we are brains-in-vats, we are only and perceive only what the simulation allows. Everything could be real, or nothing could be real, and there would be no way to tell. Which is why it is so useless.

Knowing you, I can only agree it's absolutely unbelievable what complete nonsense people believe!
 
Colours are the names of certain wavelengths in the electromagnetic spectrum, so of course they exist! What did you think?

I think you need to become more proficient in the English language. Scientists have tried to hijack the term (as in so many others) so as to mean this, but colour simply means what we actually experience. Green for example means what we experience. If there were no consciousness whatsoever in the Universe, then colour would not exist.
 
Where has anyone ever argued that their own consciousness might not exist? I have never encountered any such arguments, and certainly not on this board.

Then you haven't been on the right thread. At least two, in fact, if I remember correctly.

If one is conscious then one knows oneself is conscious with incorrigible certainty.

I doubt that. As I've said before, I've no way of knowing if this "self-awareness" deal is just an illusion or not. The point is that, those who say that only the self can be known are wrong. The self can indeed be deceiving; in fact there's no reason to believe it has any special status when compared to everything else.
 
I think you need to become more proficient in the English language. Scientists have tried to hijack the term (as in so many others) so as to mean this, but colour simply means what we actually experience. Green for example means what we experience. If there were no consciousness whatsoever in the Universe, then colour would not exist.
I agree with you, and I disagree with you :)

I think the colour terms cover both definitions, the scientific definition and the perception. I agree with you that if there is no one to perceive the colours, the perception definition would be meaningless. As many people have been musing, we do not even know if we perceive the colours alike: We might perceive quite different things from the same coloured object, but we agree on the name of the colour, and no confusion arises. Which brings us to the scientific definition which is fixed, and would not be invalid even when nobody were around to perceive the colours. The red pencil I have in my drawer remains red, even when the drawer is closed!
 
Where has anyone ever argued that their own consciousness might not exist? I have never encountered any such arguments, and certainly not on this board.

If one is conscious then one knows oneself is conscious with incorrigible certainty. You cannot be conscious and suspect you might not be conscious because there is no epistemic gap between the fact of your consciousness and you knowing you are conscious. On the other hand, if you are not conscious then you know nothing whatsoever.

Utterly naive point of view. Consciousness is NOT an entity but a process, and there are countless levels in conscious awareness. You obviously know nothing about Zen (talking about subjective states) and the research and advancements in the area of Cognitive Science.
 
Ian said:
I think you need to become more proficient in the English language. Scientists have tried to hijack the term (as in so many others) so as to mean this, but colour simply means what we actually experience. Green for example means what we experience. If there were no consciousness whatsoever in the Universe, then colour would not exist.
No matter how many times you say this, I will continue to present the dictionary definition of color:

1 a : a phenomenon of light (as red, brown, pink, or gray) or visual perception that enables one to differentiate otherwise identical objects b : the aspect of objects and light sources that may be described in terms of hue, lightness, and saturation for objects and hue, brightness, and saturation for light sources c : a hue as contrasted with black, white, or gray

It's both, as Steen said. No one is hijacking any definitions, but you are restricting one. Otherwise you'd have trouble with your incomprehensible model of the way things are.

If there were no consciousness at all, we wouldn't be having this conversation and the point would be moot.

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom