To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Well, that is an interesting supposition. Perhaps in a reverse way, you are right. Remember, I used to be of a different worldview that fit in well, right here. Now, by listening to many of you, I can hear myself and the types of things I used to say and think. It is an astonishing thing, Belz. This is worthwhile for me to try to explain to you. You will just have to take it at face value: when I listen to most of the things, for instance, things spoken in defense of evolution, I can swear to you that most of what I hear I have either said myself or is a paraphrase of my exact mindset. It was a very slow process for me to increase my threshold of credulity toward evolution, which just happened mostly due to the influence of a physicist friend of mine. Then, rather suddenly, my threshold of credulity reached a critical point, and it was a subtle crisis of belief. The flip-flop changes state. I don't think it is nearly the same thing as discovering evolution after having been brought up with a religious up bringing. Evolution used to be my religion - and I NEVER would have admitted it, but now I can see it. For all of you out there who I am totally irritating, never mind challenging this. It is merely a statement of my own personal observation - so what's to argue about. I'm not trying to say to anyone - you need to do this, too.

VonNeumann,

Can you elaborate on what you now believe, and your reasons for doing so? Even accepting the points in your opening post-- that scientific inquiry rests on some unprovable assumptions such as the existence of external objects and the ability of inductive reasoning to accurately explain the operations of nature-- how does that lead to a rebuttal of the theory of evolution? Maybe scientific inquiry has certain methodological difficulties that do ultimately rest on a kind of faith, but even if that's the case, do you actually reject the reality of the objective world or the predictive power of induction? If so, can you replace them with a more consistent method of seeking truth? If not, then it seems like, within the empricist paradigm, the theory of evolution has been proven with as much certainty as we can have about anything. What are your reasons for rejecting it, and what do you propose as an alternative?
 
How to disprove vat-speculation. Effect the brain of the believer with drugs or some other means. If his brain is in a vat somewhere else then he shouldn't be effected.
 
[Immunization Against Evidence]Then the evil robots that enslaved his brain would just pump appropriate amounts of said drug into the vat.[/Immunizaton Against Evidence]
 
[Immunization Against Evidence]Then the evil robots that enslaved his brain would just pump appropriate amounts of said drug into the vat.[/Immunizaton Against Evidence]

[OVERKILL - Not a Suggestion!!!!]
Then the believer should use a shotgun on his brain. In the RL he would be dead instantly, but in the vat world it might take the evil robot a few seconds to do the same. So the believer will be assured of the truth.
[/OVERKILL- Not a Suggestion!!!!]
 
Belz, go google "wierd"[sic]:) .

How witty and cunning of you. Ah! Belz... made a typo. What an opportunity!

Methinks you are waxing a little nonsense here (go read what you said "space-time can move"? Is that what you meant?).

In an expanding universe, space indeed moves! speed of light > c!

But Special T of R says it still travels v=c observed from its local frame. Of course from the photon's frame of reference, time is frozen so the photon is not moving at all! I hope I've got my relativity 101 down correctly here.

Yes. But if you add the actual expansion, it's going faster. I do think this seems to be our only way out of the speed limitation: bend space, or something.

I think the weirdest thing about relativity is that it is a 100 year old theory and it still has not been re-cast into descretized form! The reason for this, I believe is because it is very difficult, and the other reason is the whole basis of my isotropic skepticism: because it will require significant paradigm shift to create the models. For "Classical" relativity (a seeming oxymoron) we assume a continuous space-time. I believe when it is finally figured out how to do integrate STofR and QM, then the conclusions drawn from the unified gravity theory will be very strange [understatement].

I think you lost me after "descretized". What are you saying, exactly ?

I'll say that most people who have at least superficially learned of the twin paradox might say it is weird. Why would a biological organism age more slowly in an inertial frame that is either moving fast w.r.t. a reference frame or age more slowly in an inertial frame in which there is a much stronger gravitational field? I have my own way of looking at it and so it is no longer weird to me. For most people I think it begs "why?".

Just because people think it's weird does not make it so to people who understand it, not that I understand it much myself. The reason for the age difference is simply the assumption (shown empirically) that the speed of light is constant in all frames of reference.
 
Did you look at my link to the encyclopaedia? It did not reveal any bias from the IDers/creationists. I think it is a term from complexity theory.

That wasn't my point:
"Do you deny that creationists and IDers use the term "self"-organisation as a caricature ?"

I simply assumed you were using the same tactic.

I think one difference between us, and it might be our relative ages, is that I do not expect to have anyone cry uncle or concede that they are just now convinced so that they will make fundamental changes to their worldview because of something I say. That is unrealistic. Don't be annoyed, man - that's life.

Still. Evidence is evidence. The frustrating part for me is understanding how some people can not see what I see as evidence as evidence, or the reverse. In your case, that means a huge gap between our opinions that, I think, is difficult for me to explain.
 
Well, it's impossible to arrive at any useful conclusion if you don't. And, a priori, the thought that our mind doesn't really exist seems incoherent. It's not, but assuming that nothing exists, not even your "self", is not very practical.
All true. And all that is being pointed out are some of the things 'naturalists' accept on faith.

But that's a point we can make against solipists, too.
This comment makes no sense to me. Sorry.
 
In an expanding universe, space indeed moves! speed of light > c!.
Now you say 'space', before you said 'space-time'. I'm trying to understand what you mean by space-time having a velocity since by definition v=s/t for an object moving relative to some spatial frame of reference. I think you are talking about a "rate of expansion" and casting it in terms of change in space over change in time. That is not the velocity of an object, it is a change in density of the spin network, or whatever model is used for what you called "space-time". Lets see what else you say...

Yes. But if you add the actual expansion, it's going faster. I do think this seems to be our only way out of the speed limitation: bend space, or something.
"...or something." I agree with that or something part.


I think you lost me after "descretized". What are you saying, exactly ?
Whoops. "Discrete-ized" - that is to say "quantized". Space and time are surely "atomic" - the Greeks were right and we screwed up when we named elements "atoms" because we should have left the term "atom" untouched until we found the real level of "discretization" of space-time.

I'm sorry, but I think I'll just leave this alone. I tried to drop this argument with you before about whether ultimate reality is stranger than we can yet imagine. And I think we are just talking past each other - not being in the same worldview.

Just because people think it's weird does not make it so to people who understand it, not that I understand it much myself. The reason for the age difference is simply the assumption (shown empirically) that the speed of light is constant in all frames of reference.
On this thread I brought up simulation and brain-in-the-vat, but that was merely for discussion. It does not relate well to what I brought up in the other thread of our actually living in a simulation. The difference is that in the brain-in-the-vat, the brain is outside the simulation and the simulation is merely wired to the brain - so the brain is not simulated. That's not what I was talking about in the other thread. I was speaking on the idea of a sort of "digital physics" where ALL of the universe, including ourselves, are digital and metaphorically our 'reality' is a big computation, including ourselves. I do not think this is weird because I can see some qualitative correlations between that worldview and some of the unexplained mysteries of physics. I am not interested in pursuiting this discussion with you (not blaming you of course) merely because, as I have already said, we are not relating well to each other. But in closing I said all this last bit to clear up the confusion about what I was talking about w.r.t. simulation in the previous thread vs what I was saying in the OP.

I do not agree, from my admittedly small knowledge from reading, that the specialists in quantum gravity research, for instance, "understand" sufficiently the ultimate nature of gravity. So far, the string theory of gravity is very strange and yet the strings are continuous and I think they are just now starting to "discretize" the strings. The loop theory is based on Penrose's spin networks, and I was left with the feeling that it has the most promise. To close this difference we have between us about the strangeness of the ultimate reality, Belz, I think you will see that the worldviews being entertained to make these theories go forward, are IMO no more "weird" than my conjecture that this universe is a big computation - a simulation. BTW, I believed that the universe was a simulation long before I started embracing the idea of ID - I also realize that others who promote the idea of NKS (Wolfram's New Kind of Science), do it from a 'skeptics' worldview.

At the end you said something about the reason for the age difference [in the twin paradox I assume] is that the speed of light is c in all frames. OK - of course it is - but does that statement elucidate? See, I'm asking if you have a more intuitive explanation of why the relative time contraction occurs in a relatively stronger gravitational field or likewise in a fast moving frame of reference - just curious if you have a 'personal way of thinking about it'.
 
That wasn't my point:
"Do you deny that creationists and IDers use the term "self"-organisation as a caricature ?"
I simply assumed you were using the same tactic.
Still. Evidence is evidence. The frustrating part for me is understanding how some people can not see what I see as evidence as evidence, or the reverse. In your case, that means a huge gap between our opinions that, I think, is difficult for me to explain.
As many times as you have probably read my posts, I don't think you have picked up on the fact that I do not know very much about what "the IDers" or "the creationists" think. A few years ago I used to visit Dembski founded www.iscid.org. I found a wide spectrum of ideas and contra-ideas there. I have read only a couple books on ID: Dembski's Intelligent Design and Behe's Darwin's Black Box. I have read many Dawkins books, Gould, and similar stuff, however. So you presume too much that I should know what you are talking about w.r.t. some caricature thing and the creationists. You will have to be the one who 'splains it to me.

I've also read more verbage about complexity theory, non-linear dynamics, chaos etc than I have read about ID, BTW. I am surprised you associate the phrase "self-organization" with something "from the other side" - it comes from the beginning days of cybernetics probably: Ulam, von Neumann, ...then Conway, and more recently probably the big gun is Kauffman - I don't know. It makes me think you haven't read much about this fascinating field. If you haven't, I suggest you put it on your reading list.
 
VonNeumann,

Can you elaborate on what you now believe, and your reasons for doing so? Even accepting the points in your opening post-- that scientific inquiry rests on some unprovable assumptions such as the existence of external objects and the ability of inductive reasoning to accurately explain the operations of nature-- how does that lead to a rebuttal of the theory of evolution? Maybe scientific inquiry has certain methodological difficulties that do ultimately rest on a kind of faith, but even if that's the case, do you actually reject the reality of the objective world or the predictive power of induction? If so, can you replace them with a more consistent method of seeking truth? If not, then it seems like, within the empricist paradigm, the theory of evolution has been proven with as much certainty as we can have about anything. What are your reasons for rejecting it, and what do you propose as an alternative?
This OP was not posted with intention to lead to a rebuttal to evolution. Most the time, I probably have the same worldview as you or most anyone else who is steeped in science, just I have a few pet conjectures that are a bit contrarian. ...plus I am not at all enamored with the theory of evolution (anymore). I will not go into that much at all. While some are assuming that, by posting the OP, I promote "brain-in-the-vat", but I'm not - I only asked the question to stimulate discussion. However, I do believe it is plausible that the universe is a computation. I have no better term for it, but I sometimes have called it merely a simulation. ...and I am not visualizing brains in vats - just that continuous space-time is an illusion - space and time are discrete - and that the simulation is limited in capacity in several ways and those "artifacts" generate many of the unexpected manifestations that we observe. In the other thread, I unintentionally gave short preface to this idea. That is, I did not want to go into why I believed simulation is plausible, but I do have qualitative reasons. I just don't want to share them on this forum. That coyness might be why I have angered some people. So I am potentially flirting with a bunch of sarcastic comebacks again by telling you this. Also, all I am going to say about my doubting of random mutation and natural selection is that I think it is an insufficient theory for explaining the emergence of complexity at the level we observe in biological systems. The general observation on this from skeptics on this forum is: weak argument - evolution is the only thing science has - you have to believe it; strong argument - the evidence for evolution is so complete that it is as good as Newton's theory of motion [these paraphrases are my off the cuff summarizations]. But, I do not accept #1, that I am unscientific by rejecting evolution , and I do not accept #2 because I do not think it is anywhere near as good a theory as you might think it is. We went round and round on the other thread and I am not interested in doing that again because it appears futile. Besides, I was not there to try to win anybody over, I was interested in what others think. I was trying to understand my old worldview. I mean, trying to understand how I could think with that worldview in the past and then change worldviews. This is what I discovered for myself and about myself: I had to take many things on faith to interpret the 'evidence for evolution' in favor of evolution. It is as if I used to be trying to design a perpetual motion machine (without the advantage of knowing thermodynamics) only with the faith that it were possible - and then one day, I start getting a vague understanding about the second law and I abandoned pursuit of inventing a perpetual motion machine. I start to lose my faith that such a machine is possible. That is how I dropped my assumptions that random mutation and natural selection were sufficient as a creator of vast complexity. If the universe had infinite time, I would reconsider. This loss of faith in the TOEvol happened over a span of many years, but once my incredulity reached some critical point, it flip-flopped. One of the reasons I'm hanging out here is, it is like reunion day with my old self. It is strangely amusing what reactions I get as I ping and get responses. If people only knew that they are trying to get me reconvinced of what i already once embraced at least as strongly as they do .. I don't know - it seems it doesn't matter to them. But I am fine with the fact that I do not have a substitute for evolution. I can stretch my beliefs to accept quite a bit of evolution - so all the challenges of whether I agree with this or that become moot because I can say - yes, that's plausible. But the main rub is teleology. That's where my worldview pivoted.

BTW, I am not an IDer who thinks evolution should be taken out of schools or anything like that. I do not believe that anything should be changed about the way science tries to discover things w.r.t. origins. OTOH, I believe that there should be no thought police nor peer intimidation toward a researcher who has a teleological worldview. I think science proceeds best with individualistic minds and competitive spirit. If an idea or worldview is wrong, let it become extinct in the arena of ideas - not due to censorship or monopolizing dogma.
 
This comment makes no sense to me. Sorry.

Well, all I'm saying is that, if you assume that your mind exists, but that nothing else does, that's your right, but it doesn't actually serve any practical purpose: first off, it's non-falsifiable, and second, it doesn't change the fact that the universe can be observed and that laws can be used to describe it accurately.
 
Now you say 'space', before you said 'space-time'. I'm trying to understand what you mean by space-time having a velocity since by definition v=s/t for an object moving relative to some spatial frame of reference. I think you are talking about a "rate of expansion" and casting it in terms of change in space over change in time. That is not the velocity of an object, it is a change in density of the spin network, or whatever model is used for what you called "space-time". Lets see what else you say...

Perhaps the term was ill-chosen, but the fact remains: things can move faster than light when you take expansion into account. And some experiments that attempted to calculate the speed of gravity yielded interesting results in that regard.

Whoops. "Discrete-ized" - that is to say "quantized". Space and time are surely "atomic" - the Greeks were right and we screwed up when we named elements "atoms" because we should have left the term "atom" untouched until we found the real level of "discretization" of space-time.

That's your assumption. What's the "real" level of discretization of space-time ?

I'm sorry, but I think I'll just leave this alone. I tried to drop this argument with you before about whether ultimate reality is stranger than we can yet imagine. And I think we are just talking past each other - not being in the same worldview.

Well, sorry about that. I just don't find QM really that weird when you understand what the terms mean (and not what the new-agers try to make them sound like.) Relativity, on the other hand, is quite weird to me, although I know how well-supported it is.

I was speaking on the idea of a sort of "digital physics" where ALL of the universe, including ourselves, are digital and metaphorically our 'reality' is a big computation, including ourselves. I do not think this is weird because I can see some qualitative correlations between that worldview and some of the unexplained mysteries of physics.

Well, as I told Hammegk, assuming that reality is a simulation is not a very useful, thought not impossible, assumption. Thought I'd be interested to know what reasons you have for reaching this conclusion. What, in this universe, corresponds to this simulation theory ? Of course, I'm not talking about philosophy, but fact and evidence.

I am not interested in pursuiting this discussion with you (not blaming you of course) merely because, as I have already said, we are not relating well to each other.

We haven't even discussed this particular point.

So far, the string theory of gravity is very strange and yet the strings are continuous and I think they are just now starting to "discretize" the strings.

It's also unproven.

BTW, I believed that the universe was a simulation long before I started embracing the idea of ID

I thought you said you DIDN'T embrace ID ? Many times.

At the end you said something about the reason for the age difference [in the twin paradox I assume] is that the speed of light is c in all frames. OK - of course it is - but does that statement elucidate? See, I'm asking if you have a more intuitive explanation of why the relative time contraction occurs in a relatively stronger gravitational field or likewise in a fast moving frame of reference - just curious if you have a 'personal way of thinking about it'.

I just think that, even if our intuitive understanding gives us problems with a theory, that doesn't say anything about the theory itself.
 
Jesus H. Christ, is this thread still going on?

The answer: science ≠ faith, unless you wield some defintion of "faith" which bears no relation to usage in real life. For the rest of the discussion, see tghe numerous threads in which this "issue" has been thrashed out already, but which "VonNeumann" couldn't be arsed to look up because obviously his idea was so original and brilliant that nobody could possibly have had it before!
 
As many times as you have probably read my posts, I don't think you have picked up on the fact that I do not know very much about what "the IDers" or "the creationists" think. A few years ago I used to visit Dembski founded www.iscid.org. I found a wide spectrum of ideas and contra-ideas there. I have read only a couple books on ID: Dembski's Intelligent Design and Behe's Darwin's Black Box. I have read many Dawkins books, Gould, and similar stuff, however. So you presume too much that I should know what you are talking about w.r.t. some caricature thing and the creationists. You will have to be the one who 'splains it to me.

They use the "self" part of the term to imply that it organised itself, "intuitively", therefore implying that there's an intelligence at work. I've seen it done before. If that's not what you were implying, then fine.
 
They use the "self" part of the term to imply that it organised itself, "intuitively", therefore implying that there's an intelligence at work. I've seen it done before. If that's not what you were implying, then fine.
Right - NOT what I was implying (at least not then :) ). If you could point me to that ID source, I'd like to see what you are talking about.
 
Jesus H. Christ, is this thread still going on?

The answer: science ≠ faith, unless you wield some defintion of "faith" which bears no relation to usage in real life. For the rest of the discussion, see tghe numerous threads in which this "issue" has been thrashed out already, but which "VonNeumann" couldn't be arsed to look up because obviously his idea was so original and brilliant that nobody could possibly have had it before!
That's ludicrous. The idea goes back to the Greeks, if not before. Being at the core of our assumptions, it is still interesting what discussion insues from bringing it up.
 
That's your assumption. What's the "real" level of discretization of space-time ?.
My assumption is that it is as real as it gets. Continuum is a mathematical abstraction, and so continuum is something we can think about and use as a model: a la differential equations. All I can tell you is that it has long been my personal assumption and that the reason we use continuous mathematics in our models is because calculus is based on the continuous model. Mathematically, we like to avoid discontinuities. Even though the Greeks posited an atomic (not "elemental" but more fundamentally atomic) universe vis a vis Zeno's Paradox, and even though 1900 marks our step over that threshold, thanks to Max P., we still have not applied digital signal processing type maths, Z-plane stuff instead of S-plane (Laplace), into our fundamental physics. Why? Is it because the general consensus is that space-time is continuous? I don't know. I presume it has more to do with the formidable step of totally restarting from the first axiom, recasting physics in Z-plane type worldview. Ironically, our tools, our CPUs and DSPs have long been platforms on which there exists financial support for R&D in the discretized, the digital, world. We just don't think of it that way.

Yes, it is my assumption. But I see in reading about quantum gravity, that the recasting of physics from the foundation level, with discretization of the maths, is exactly what IS going on right now.

I just don't find QM really that weird when you understand what the terms mean (and not what the new-agers try to make them sound like.) Relativity, on the other hand, is quite weird to me, although I know how well-supported it is.
I read some of the new-ager stuff in early 80s. I wish I hadn't because it confused me (Alan Wolfe? Dancing Wu Li Masters? something like that). Hey, but go read J.S.Bell's book ( he ain't no new-ager) Speakable and Unspeakable in QM. He is THE Bell in the Bell experiments that tried to resolve the EPR paradox. I can't regurge here what he says cuz I don't remember exactly but if you don't think that stuff is more weird that T.O.Relativity, then I don't know what to tell you.

Well, as I told Hammegk, assuming that reality is a simulation is not a very useful, though not impossible, assumption. Though I'd be interested to know what reasons you have for reaching this conclusion. What, in this universe, corresponds to this simulation theory ? Of course, I'm not talking about philosophy, but fact and evidence.
If you want a purely philosophical position on that we almost for certain live in a simulation, go read Bostrom's paper. Read the whole thing - it is interesting. Go see: http://www.simulation-argument.com/

Disclaimer: that is not MY worldview but I thought of something similar to it to try on skeptics, before Bostrom wrote that paper. The similar thing was the transhuman evolving to be a 'creator'. Remember I tried that on chipmunk and he recanted accepting strong-transhumanism because he said he only did for sake of argument. But it works on someone who holds to strong-transhumanism that they believe in intelligent design, they just don't believe it happened yet.

So you ask whether I have "fact and evidence". It is all qualitative. If you want to see some of the stuff that others have done, go look up key words like Wolfram NKS, Fredkin, Zuse, Digital Physics. And once again, these guys are probably anti-ID.


I thought you said you DIDN'T embrace ID ? Many times.
Maybe I change my adjectives and verbs a little depending on context. Maybe it is a more subtle thing because you probably equate creationism=ID Churchlady=ID so when I have separated myself from certain icons, you thought I meant I was disclaiming the whole thing - that was not intended. Surely you know I have always always said that there is a plan and purpose - I'm pro-teleology. I have often shown how I think the evidence looks to me like design. If you feel like going back and finding something that looks like it contradicts that I'm sure I can explain it. Eek! sometimes I have read something I posted and I had an ambiguity or an odd parity of negatives when I thought it was even parity - thereby saying the opposite of what i meant.
 
My assumption is that it is as real as it gets. Continuum is a mathematical abstraction, and so continuum is something we can think about and use as a model: a la differential equations. All I can tell you is that it has long been my personal assumption and that the reason we use continuous mathematics in our models is because calculus is based on the continuous model. Mathematically, we like to avoid discontinuities. Even though the Greeks posited an atomic (not "elemental" but more fundamentally atomic) universe vis a vis Zeno's Paradox, and even though 1900 marks our step over that threshold, thanks to Max P., we still have not applied digital signal processing type maths, Z-plane stuff instead of S-plane (Laplace), into our fundamental physics. Why? Is it because the general consensus is that space-time is continuous? I don't know. I presume it has more to do with the formidable step of totally restarting from the first axiom, recasting physics in Z-plane type worldview. Ironically, our tools, our CPUs and DSPs have long been platforms on which there exists financial support for R&D in the discretized, the digital, world. We just don't think of it that way.

Yes, it is my assumption.

That's what I thought.

If you want a purely philosophical position on that we almost for certain live in a simulation, go read Bostrom's paper. Read the whole thing - it is interesting. Go see: http://www.simulation-argument.com/

I've read some good portions of one of the articles that claims to show "high probability" that we live in a simulation.

First off, the only thing this claims is that its assumptions, which it takes as premises, are "possible". Then goes on to base its arguments on that. By that logic, there is a high probability that the universe exists within the anus of a chicken.

Second, it plays a false dichotomy on us. An excerpt:

Now we get to the core of the simulation argument. This does not purport to demonstrate that you are in a simulation. Instead, it shows that we should accept as true at least one of the following three propositions:

(1) The chances that a species at our current level of development can avoid going extinct before becoming technologically mature is negligibly small

(2) Almost no technologically mature civilisations are interested in running computer simulations of minds like ours

(3) You are almost certainly in a simulation.

[...]

Therefore, if both (1) and (2) are false, there will be an astronomically huge number of simulated minds like ours.

I seriously doubt that someone could make a computer simulation of a universe, with all its matter and minds, without utilising a number of bits at least equal to the number of particles in that simulated universe. Which means such a simulation would TAKE UP an entire universe as a processor. That's a rather idiotic assumption.

Also, just because there is a googolplex of simulated minds in no way makes it probable that I'm one of them, without ASSUMING that I'm part of the simulation in the first place, which is circular.

So, basically, :words:
Maybe it is a more subtle thing because you probably equate creationism=ID Churchlady=ID so when I have separated myself from certain icons, you thought I meant I was disclaiming the whole thing - that was not intended.

You said you weren't an IDer, and now you claim otherwise. Did you change your mind, or were you intentionally misleading ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom